• TPQ
  • The Blanket
  • July 1981
  • Killing Joe O'Connor
  • Boston College Case

    Social Items

TPQ

TPQ

    Menu Items

    • 55 Hours
    • Brendan Hughes
    • Dolours Price
    • Anthony McIntyre
    • Donate
✖
Showing posts with label TV Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label TV Review. Show all posts
Caoimhin O’Muraile  ☭ I watched a two-part mini-series on RTÉ 1 Wednesday 9th July concluding on Wednesday 16th July focusing on the aid received by the Irish Republican Movement (Provisional) from the United States chiefly from ‘Irish Northern Aid’ – NORAID. 

RTÉ

Though the movement generally denies sending funds to arm the ‘Irish Republican Army’ NORAID was the largest contributor to the Provisional movement, giving rise to many of my early suspicions about Sinn Fein being substantiated by this mini-documentary series. I did not believe for one second the Sinn Fein claim to be fighting for a “32 County Democratic Socialist Republic” as was the boast of their paper; An Phoblacht/Republican News. There was a notion Sinn Fein had two versions of the weekly publication which I suspected to be true back in the early days and was advised by a senior Member of the IRSP this was the case - and this documentary proved that to be correct.

In the first programme Danny Morrison former editor of APRN and Director of Publicity for Sinn Fein said of the paper:

when sending An Phoblacht over to the Irish People (another Irish American newspaper based in New York) we would remove anything of a left-wing nature, anything which might cut across US foreign policy. 

Put plainly we did not want to upset the US establishment some of whom gave us money by writing anything supportive of left-wing struggles in the world like, at the time, Nicaragua. This unprincipled stance is an antithesis to revolutionary politics and upholds the advice I was given by the IRSP Ard Chomhairle Member and my own strong suspicions about Sinn Fein's duplicity. Morrison was unapologetic in his boast of having two versions of AP/RN, one which was sold in Britain and Ireland chiefly and the sanitised version for the USA. The issues sold over here would be aimed in essence at the British and Irish left-wing groups and the copies sold in the US aimed at gathering support and, above all money, from the US right-wing, the likes of Donald Trump.

There was much talk and showing of Thatcher’s response to the 1981 hunger strikes resulting in seven IRA volunteers dying and three volunteers of the Irish National Liberation Army (INLA) doing likewise. The NORAID people publicised, rightly so, the bravery and “dedication” shown by Bobby Sands and other IRA hunger strikers but not once did they mention the equally dedicated INLA prisoners who also lost their lives due to Thatcher’s intransigence. NORAID's response, again all those years ago when I once asked about the Irish Republican Socialist Movement was, “we don’t give money to commies with guns”. 

Sinn Fein shift their policies around to suit their audience, sometimes giving the appearance of perhaps being - which would alienate NORAID - ‘commies with guns’ while at other times presenting a very conservative face. In the USA a centre right position was and is taken while in Europe they sometimes pretend to show a centre to far-left political position leading to inconsistencies and lies. They are now an unprincipled parliamentary party along with the rest of the fucking liars who masquerade as politicians sitting in these various ‘Pandora’s Boxes’. They should not feel on their own though because the leader of the Scottish Labour Party, Anas Sarwar, once boasted; he did not “care about principles” they will not get me “elected”. “All I care about is getting elected, not principles”. This is pretty much what the modern variant of Sinn Fein is saying. Getting elected is all that matters. They would argue, no doubt, if they are not elected, they cannot deliver which is a fair argument if it were not so misleading. It suggests governments hold real power which is not really the case as real power is outside parliament in the coffers of the ruling classes. Private money who governments shy away from in case the owners of this money “leave the country”!

There was also much criticism of NORAID and a left-wing  leaning person  pointed out that “the Americans have enough problems in the South with the blacks and the mistreatment of these people” suggesting strongly skin colour to be a cause of discrimination. “They come over here after treating black people disgustingly to free the Leprechauns” and it just reeks of “double standards”. 

One of the better known NORAID activists of the day, Martin Galvin, back in 1984 was a guest of Sinn Fein even though he was banned from entering the Six Counties. Gerry Adams was determined the self-publicist would speak or at least make an appearance at Connolly House even though the Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC) were itching for a fight that day as were the occupying crown forces. Galvin, on behalf of NORAID, made an appearance as Gerry Adams told everybody to “sit down and stay calm”, easier said than done with the RUC opening fire with plastic bullets. The net result of this mayhem was the death of a young West Belfast man, Sean Downes, which left a young wife, Brenda, along with a young daughter Claire without a husband and father. Still, not to worry, Galvin and NORAID had their publicity and Adams and Sinn Fein took another step closer to entering the Dail, though this policy was not yet known to the wider Provisional membership.

Another former IRA Volunteer, John Crawley, an American ex-Marine and author of the book The Yank, also spoke of NORAID. “I would always try to avoid them because they were too much in the public eye”. I did not want “the publicity which they would bring”, perhaps shinning on the task he was there for. A fair position John, whatever you were doing publicity I would imagine was the last thing on the menu! John also revealed the less savoury side of Irish American aid, which appeared not to involve NORAID, and that was something he did “not feel comfortable with” in procuring arms and that was meeting gangsters. One leading gangster, James Whitey Bulger, “asked if I could teach him how to make a booby-trap car bomb.” John, as a Volunteer in the IRA, did not feel easy with this request and declined, claiming he “did not know how to make one, but would send somebody from their engineering department who may be able to help”. A wise and tactful move John! John Crawley voiced his concern about working with gangsters to Martin McGuinness who replied; “little old ladies do not buy rifles”, meaning the collections gathered by NORAID among Irish Americans many of them ‘little old ladies’ concerned about the conditions people in the occupied territories have to live and wanted their money to go to help and not, perhaps, buy weapons!

This is not to say NORAID did not involve themselves with gunrunning for the IRA. NORAID was what could be described as a broad-church membership some of whom, like Michael Flannery and George Harrison in 1981, involved themselves with the gunrunning side of things. Flannery had as a very young man fought in the Easter Rising 1916 so did not lack credibility. Although this was not official NORAID policy neither was it frowned upon. The organisation provided money for IRA prisoners' families and through their general fundraising made much for Sinn Fein probably their parliamentary election war chest. When President Bill Clinton granted a temporary visa for then Sinn Fein President, Gerry Adams (who was never in the IRA!), to enter the US he was shown at a NORAID fund raiser publicly shaking hands with a much younger multi-billionaire, Donald Trump! Now we do not get much more duplicity than that because even back then Trump was well known for his right-wing political position and sexist views of women along with anti-immigration policies.

Today NORAID are a shadow of their former selves as Sinn Fein are now a respectable political party. Perhaps they no longer wish to be associated with an organisation which was connected, as in the case of Flannery and Harrison, with IRA gunrunning. Today Sinn Fein receive funds from an organisation in the US titled ‘Friends of Sinn Fein’ and NORAID appear to be seldomly mentioned. Once again, a case of used, abused and binned like a child with a new toy at Christmas, by Saint Stephen’s day that same toy usually ends up in the rubbish bin! Friends of Sinn Fein appear to be the organisation's new toy!
 
Caoimhin O’Muraile is Independent Socialist Republican and Marxist.

NORAID – Irish America And The IRA

By AM Thursday, July 24, 2025
Only Sky ✏ A review of “Shiny Happy People: Duggar Family Secrets”, episode 4: “Arrows Activated.”
Adam Lee
The fourth and final episode of the documentary Shiny Happy People: Duggar Family Secrets begins with an audio recording of US marshals coming to arrest Josh Duggar. 

When he asks why they’re there, they say that child porn was downloaded to a computer on the premises. Josh doesn’t confess to anything, but he’s weirdly nonchalant about it. He certainly doesn’t show any of the shock or horror you might expect from an innocent person.

At the trial, the prosecution introduced the evidence of Josh’s molesting his sisters in the past, establishing a pattern of behavior. Jill Duggar says she was prepared to testify against her brother, if it came to that, but she didn’t have to. Bobye Holt, the family friend whose daughter Josh almost married, testified instead.

Josh’s father Jim Bob was also subpoenaed to testify. The prosecutor showed him the police report filed when Josh confessed the first time. Jim Bob claimed—astonishingly, and not plausibly—that he didn’t remember it. In fact, he claimed not to recall so many things that the judge got irate and kicked him out of the courtroom.

Continue Reading @ Only Sky.

‘Arrows Activated’ ➢ The Duggars And The Joshua Generation

By AM Sunday, July 16, 2023
Only Sky ✏ A review of “Shiny Happy People: Duggar Family Secrets”, episode 3: “Under Authority”
Adam Lee
If the Duggar family hadn’t been on TV, Josh Duggar would have gotten away with it.

That’s the unavoidable conclusion from episode 3 of “Shiny Happy People”. 

The ideology preached by Bill Gothard is a predator’s dream. It treats men as infallible authorities appointed by the will of God, while demanding that women live in submission and silence. It leaves no recourse for survivors of assault to speak out or seek justice. 

It’s only the media attention lavished on the Duggar family that made a path for the truth to come out. There’s no doubt that similar or worse evils are going unchecked in other IBLP families, away from the spotlight.

Sitcom dad syndrome

When the news broke in 2015 of Josh molesting his sisters, TLC canceled 19 Kids and Counting. However, they moved ahead with the spinoff show, Counting On, which focused on the two eldest daughters Jill and Jessa. This made them the breadwinners: the ones who earned the money and kept the family brand alive.

Continue reading @ Only Sky 

‘Under Authority’ ❤ The Law Of Crying Out

By AM Sunday, July 9, 2023
Only Sky ✏ A review of “Shiny Happy People: Duggar Family Secrets”, episode 1: “Meet the Duggars”
Adam Lee

Even if you don’t closely follow the religious right, you probably know who the Duggars are. They presented themselves to the world as a wholesome, devout family that also happened to have a huge number of kids. They starred in their own reality show, which was a hit. It made Christian patriarchy seem normal, relatable, even aspirational.

But beneath the surface, the Duggars were covering up an ocean of secrets and lies. Their exposure, and their downfall, is the subject of “Shiny Happy People: Duggar Family Secrets“, a four-part documentary on Amazon Prime. It blows apart the Potemkin-village façade that the Duggars presented to the world and reveals what was going on when the cameras were off.

I’ll be doing an episode-by-episode review of the series. This column will cover the first episode.

The rise and fall of the Duggars

Jim Bob Duggar grew up Baptist, but his childhood religion wasn’t as extreme as he later became. In fact, according to the documentary, both his parents and his wife Michelle’s parents disapproved of the course they took.

Continue reading @ Only Sky

Meet The Duggars ❤ The Secrets And Lies Of Christian Patriarchy

By AM Sunday, June 25, 2023
Dixie Elliot ✍ I recently came across a cracker TV series on one of those streaming sites.

I can't understand why it isn't more widely known about.

Snowfall is about the Crack Epidemic in LA in the early 1980s. The main character Franklin Saint, doesn't drink, smoke or take drugs but he goes from being small time to a major player.

The cocaine is being brought into LA from South America by a CIA operative called Teddy, who is using the money to fund the Contra War in Nicaragua.

There are no good guys in this series, except for Franklin's father, who was a former Black Panther, and maybe his mother.

The characters are likeable but gradually grow more ruthless, in particular Franklin and the CIA guy Teddy, who has no morals when it comes to destroying American lives in order to defeat Communism in South America.

Snowfall can also be viewed on BBC iPlayer.

Thomas Dixie Elliot is a Derry artist and a former H Block Blanketman.
Follow Dixie Elliot on Twitter @IsMise_Dixie

Snowfall

By AM Wednesday, June 14, 2023
Caoimhin O’Muraile 🎥 has been watching a BBC Six Part Series.


I was watching a series, six parts, on BBC1 titled The Capture which, among other things, examined the potential of artificial intelligence. The series was clearly based on the British business minister, Kwasi Kwarteng, issuing an order preventing the acquisition under the “National Security and Investment Act” of vision sensing technology from Beijing, Infinite Vision Technology Co, a Chinese company the British Government or perhaps more importantly the US Government do not trust. 

Infinite Vision Technology Co, it was argued successfully, had too many connections with the Chinese Government and could not, therefore, have anything to do with Britain’s security. The BBC series and characters were fiction even science-fiction in many respects, and told the tale of Isaac Turner, the Security-Minister for Great Britain and how he was portrayed on live television using artificial intelligence. 

In the series it is possible to interview a person, live on TV, and insert a totally different script to what they are really saying live, which is what the viewers see and hear. For example, the hapless Minister Turner, a black man, was interviewed live on the BBC and openly supported “racial profiling.” In the real interview, indeed several previous proper interviews, he had said the absolute opposite of the version some time at an earlier date, but it was the artificially modified and corrupted version which went out and went out live on air! In fact, he was not even in the studio at the time, he was in a ministry safe house, supposedly under protection from the Chinese, whose bid for a contract with the British Government he had rejected. All he could do was watch with horror what he was, to all intents and purposes, saying. 

Suddenly this minister from an ethnic minority background became a racist and the interview was all the proof anybody watching would need. Even the sympathetic person viewing this could not deny that the Security-Minister had indeed said this about supporting “racial profiling” in support of Britain’s national security. In reality he opposed this “racial profiling” but audiences are fickle at the best of times when facts are presented, let alone when untruths, which they believe to be truths are presented. All very confusing and had to be carefully followed I thought to get the head around. It became increasingly difficult to tell the genuine Isaac Turner from the synthetic one! The real Turners finger of suspicion pointed towards the Chinese for doctoring his speeches. This turned out not to be the case.

The question is, how far are the worlds technological giants from reaching this make-believe technology becoming fact? How long before elections are decided not on what the electorate hear candidates say on face-to-face debates, or in interviews, but what the electorate think they have heard the candidates say? In reality elections could be decided, theoretically, by the technology companies, or the larger and most advanced of them working on behalf of powerful states! These companies tend to be US, Russian or Chinese firms and, it would appear, are engaged in an ongoing war with each other on behalf of their respective states and governments. 

In recent years we have heard much about one country, either Russia or China usually, but more likely to be the USA, interfering with another country’s elections. We are never told how these alleged interferences occur, just that they do! Russia was supposedly behind the victory of Donald Trump in the 2016 US Presidential elections. Now, I am no lover of Trump, far from it, but judging by the technology now available, even discounting the possible exaggerations in the BBC series, could such a move have been feasible? If it was the case, then bet your last dollar the USA have been at it for years as they are so far ahead in the tech race. China may now be on their heels in this deadly game of cat and mouse but, certainly for the moment the USA are in the lead I believe. The BBC series opened up the possibilities a thousand times, people getting into lifts who were not visible on security screens and shooting an undercover policemen. Could this be possible and we have not been told, and if it is possible, or becomes a realistic proposition, will we ever be informed?

Could it become possible to interview live on RTE Mary Lou McDonald, while she is away somewhere else, miles away from the reported venue where the interview is taking place, telling us why she supports the partition of Ireland and why a border poll must never come about? Could this happen? Now, I know Sinn Fein are a shadow of their former selves but if such an interview were to be aired live on RTE, UTV or the BBC it would take a hell of a lot of disproving. People may, bewildered at first, believe such an artificial interview especially with Sinn Fein dumping so many other principles over recent years. Likewise, a similar interview with DUP leader, Jeffrey Donaldson, who, like his political foe, Mary Lou, could be elsewhere, miles away from the studio where this supposed interview takes place and certainly not in a BBC building, talking about the benefits of Irish unification and how this should come about quickly. Could such interviews become possible? Imagine the turmoil in republican and loyalist areas of the six counties if such technology were ever used in this way! Once again, if an interview like this went out, and even though Donaldson and McDonald are elsewhere, this is what the viewers, loyalist and republican, would hear and view. Perhaps we could have an artificial intelligence interview with new British Prime Minister, Liz Truss, talking about how great the “Northern Ireland” Protocol is, supported by Sammy Wilson of the DUP. Of course neither of these people would have said any such thing, but try telling the viewers that!

In the BBC series the technology was being used by a foreign power, notably the USA blaming Beijing, to cause a rift between Britain and China. A Chinese company, like Beijing Infinite Vision Technology Co, in real life, was looking for a contract in Britain. The Security Minister, Isaac Turner, obviously based on the real-life event, rejected the bid on national security grounds and as intended, led to tensions between Britain and China. This led to a series of fascinating events and, if were to happen in real life very dangerous incidents involving killings, ministers and police being watched and monitored in their own homes, ministers saying things they never did, the possibilities with such technology are endless. In many respects back in the sixties a basic variant of this Machiavellian intelligence reportedly happened. British Prime Minister, Harold Wilson’s telephones were regularly bugged by British Intelligence, so such carryings on already have allegedly occurred. But the BBC version was something else and frightening!

In the real-world, employers are already using computer technology to smash trade union disputes. When Willie Walsh was head of British Airways, he reportedly gained access to the TGWU (I think at the time before it became UNITE) emails. He therefore knew every move the union was about to make. Was this illegal? No, apparently not! Could the union have done the same thing in reverse? Again, no, apparently not! The moral to this tale is do not conduct sensitive trade union business via email.

How could such deeds as in the BBC serial be done? I am no expert on computer technology, semi-literate at best, but let us take an interview with Jeffrey Donaldson. It is irrelevant what the interview is about, all that is needed is the image of the DUP leader. Put this image on the screens and insert a totally different text, the interviewer, who would be in the loop, possibly a state employee (Sandy Gall, the former newscaster was allegedly in the pay of MI6), would be talking in the studio to nobody yet the image on the screens would be that of Donaldson saying the complete opposite of his real political position! How far-fetched are such technological developments, if indeed developments is the right description? 

Well, in many ways it has been with us in a very, very primitive way for years. Take, for example, an actor playing two different characters in the same film or series, sitcom even. On many occasions this has happened, the same actor playing two different characters in the same show, even the same scene and clip but never actually conversing face to face with each other. This is the massive leap the BBC makes in the series. It is possible to hold a conversation with nobody and it appears the interviewer is talking to somebody!! An example of the actor, and followers of the sitcom Only Fools and Horses may be familiar with the scene, was when actor David Jason played his usual role of “Del Boy Trotter” and also a Mafia boss. He even appeared as both characters in the same scene but not face to face or conversing. So, in a way and a very primitive way, this technological potential has been around for some time. Call it illusionary filming (my term) as the filming is done completely separately yet when put together it gives the impression the scene with the actor playing a dual role is taken in a single shoot.

Leaving the entertainment industry and their use of double acting aside, this technology, if it comes to pass or, even worse, is already here, poses a very dangerous threat to mankind and certainly democracy, even liberal democracy. It would be possible for the very best of the high-tech manufacturers, on behalf of their respective states, to decide what politicians, Prime Ministers, Presidents, and our own Taoiseach say or are believed to have said, thus deciding the Government of another country. The old maxim, “what can’t speak, can’t lie” would come into play and the saying the “camera never lies” would certainly not be the case here. It would be possible for powerful states, the USA, China, Russia, even Britain to a lesser extent, irrespective of what the various electorates think or are programmed to think, to decide future governments around the globe. It is bad enough now with the media telling people how to think and vote, but if this comes to pass and in the wrong hands, which would include almost everybody with access to it, then the candidates themselves will be, or perhaps will not be, telling people how to vote by way of the tech giants. Regime changes in less compliant countries may in the future not need military invasion, just one of these highly developed digital computer programmes.

I do not know or profess to know how this technology may work, just that it appears as a strong possibility that some powerful states, the US, China, Russia and perhaps the British even the Israelis in the Middle East could be in possession of such technology. What impact may that have, should it be the case with the Israelis, on the Arab world?

In the BBC series an American, a CIA operative called Frank, the ones behind this scam called “Correction” is diagnosed with terminal cancer. Suddenly the disease cures itself and that was because the man never had it. A British spook had inserted, by use of this technology, images showing cancer, which was what the doctor, as would any doctor, based his diagnosis. Is this possible? Is such dangerous material already with us? If it is not, and I believe various states may be close but not there yet, to having such advanced technology a terrifying scenario will exist. Doctors will no longer be trusted, politicians already suspect at best, could be presented as frauds but not in the way they are now, but in such a manner benefiting the states these tech companies work on behalf of. It may come to pass, they, the aggressive states, and not governments, who decide the future of countries and, indeed the planet and that is concerning to say the least. Just imagine a scenario where the US set Moscow against Beijing and they mutually destroy each other. Then, they could set Britain against the EU in a similar way, or on the other hand, Moscow could set London against Washington the possibilities are endless and maybe I am getting a little carried away, but these possibilities are real!!

Finally, a word of praise for the BBC who when they do produce a drama series, Line of Duty, Ridley Road, and now, The Capture which needed concentration with no adverts they get it right. This is the only channel such intriguing dramas could be shown because certainly in The Capture much concentration was needed. Commercial breaks would break that concentration and ruin the series. On the commercial channels, including our own Irish channels, every ten to twelve minutes a commercial break comes on, about fourteen to sixteen minuets per hour. These breaks have slowly increased over the years and shortly it could be we have a programme break in between adverts. Perhaps another subject for another day.
 
Caoimhin O’Muraile is an Independent 
Socialist Republican and Marxist

The Capture

By AM Thursday, September 22, 2022
Alex McCrory ✒ Today is my shift with mother and, as usual, I have been passing the time watching Netflix.

My first pick was a documentary about the brutal murder of a French woman just outside the small rural town of Schull in southwest Cork, a place of rugged beauty and tranquility.

Sophie: A Murder In West Cork, is a three part series that looks at the circumstances surrounding the murder and the subsequent investigation. Efforts to bring the prime suspect, Ian Bailey, to book failed miserably because of a combination of Garda incompetence and alleged corruption.

Years later, the victim’s family managed to bring Bailey before the French courts where the evidential threshold is a preponderance of evidence and not that of beyond a reasonable doubt. He was found guilty and received a life sentence in absentia. But that was not the end of it.

The Irish courts have refused to extradite the suspect on three separate occasions. We are left guessing at the reason for this strange anomaly. Ian Bailey continues to reside in Schull under a cloud of dark suspicion and intense curiosity.

My second choice was a thoroughly enjoyable drama, Official Secrets, about Kathrine Gunn, a young analyst in GCHQ who leaked a top secret document relating to American attempts to get the UN Security Council to support the war on Iraq by blackmailing the representatives of several member states using secret intelligence.

Few today will be unaware of the lies told by Bush and Blair in their efforts to overthrow Saddam Hussein, whom they supported in his aggressive war against Iran in the 1980’s.

It is shameful to think now that so many civilised countries bought into the the American adventure that cost millions of lives, mostly of Iraqi civilians, and led an entire country to waste.

Slobodan Milosevic was tried in The Hague for far less, and was found not guilty: A fact that has become a forgotten footnote in the history of the Yugoslav war. Unlike him however, Bush and Blair sailed off into the sunset; one retiring to a life of wealth and privilege, the other masquerading as an international statesman.

Why were not these two cowboys brought before The Hague for war crimes? It is a rhetorical question, of course.

Katherine Gunn was charged with treason for exposing the lies. and her was life turned upside down by a vengeful British State. Although naïve and frightened, she did not back down even when faced with a very lengthy prison sentence. Mrs Gunn was driven by conscience and humanitarianism which are foreign to governments.

As the viewer prepares for the worst possible outcome, a welcome development occurs inside the courtroom.

Alec McCrory 
is a former blanketman.

Murder & Secrets

By AM Tuesday, July 20, 2021
Jim Duffy ➤ An interesting programme on RTÉ presented by Michael McDowell called Rome V Republic, about the Catholic Church in Ireland.

Unfortunately, whether due to the superficialities of television histories where there isn't the time to go into detail, or the editorial stance of the makers, it seriously misrepresented the power of the Catholic Church in the 19th century in Ireland.

It created the impression of a passively accepting congregation doing as priests ordered. That simply is not true. Go through the archives and you find constant evidence where the church was disobeyed and mocked.

For example, one of the reasons the church was against wakes was because people at them consistently mocked the church and the sacraments - holding mock masses to the fury of the clergy. Sex outside marriage was commonplace. Illegitimacy was commonplace. In tracing ancestors in Navan parish I was shocked to find in the baptismal registers around 80% of children baptised in the town were illegitimate in the 1850s. I literally came across pages of the register that listed nothing but children with the word 'illegitimate' in a side column. I began to wonder if I had found some register of illegitimate births - but it seems to be the normal register.

In rural areas, illegitimacy was much lower, but still surprisingly common.

The Catholic Church in the 1870s tried to set up a Catholic Party - but it flopped miserably as ordinary Catholics voted for the Home Rule League under the Protestant Isaac Butt rather than Cardinal Cullen's party. The fact that his new party was created almost directly after the passage of the Secret Ballot Act added to the freedom of voters to do what they wanted, not what they were told to do.) That also contradicts the McDowell narrative.

In the 1890s the church took a strongly anti-Parnellite stance. The clear majority of the population were on that side too - but it is not clear how influential the church stance was. The party also took an overwhelmingly anti-Parnellite line. So did the main newspaper, the Freeman's Journal. Did they turn on Parnell because they were appalled at his long-time relationship with a married woman? The fact that he was the father of her children? The condemnation of the bishops? Or the fact that they resented his dismissive treatment of critics in the party? Or that the Liberals were taking a holier-than-thou stance based on their own religious base and threatening to abandon home rule? Perhaps it was a combination of some or all of them. It is way too simplistic to conclude that they simply took their instruction from the bishops. They had been frequently ignoring instructions from bishops for years on issues like the Plan of Campaign.

What is striking is how openly many people took their pro-Parnell line literally in front of their priest - again contradicting the McDowell thesis of an obedient populace. In my parish, the parish priest, Fr. Cole, was a particular hardliner. At one stage he denounced Parnellites from the altar and ordered his parishioners Not to go to a Parnellite rally in I think Kells. A brass band was assembling outside, and directly after mass a sizeable chunk of the massgoers assembled behind it, as the furious priest stared at them, and set off to march to the Parnellite rally in Kells. Again, that contradicts the image of an obedient loyal membership of the church. They openly disobeyed the priest and the bishop. (The bishop lived in Navan.)

In a court case which recounts in detail the open disobeying of priests, possibly involving Cole (I forget but have the impression it was him), a story was recounted of an angry parish priest hitting his parishioners with his blackthorn stick at a Parnellite rally. One of them took the stick off him and whacked him hard across the body with it. Another man took great pleasure in telling the court how the priest had bribed him not to attend the Parnellite rally but to go to an anti-Parnellite one instead. He took the money and went to the Parnellite rally anyway, spending the money in the pubs afterwards.

My great-grandfather, Patrick Duffy, was anti-Parnellite. Two of his closest friends and next door neighbours were Parnellites. The priest may have been calling Parnellites the devil incarnate but Patrick maintained his friendship with the Kane and Collins families, and Joseph Collins was a witness to Patrick's mother's will.

Cole banned Joseph Collins from holding the traditional station mass in the Collins home. It made no difference. Joseph Collins stuck to his guns and remained a Parnellite, while still going to mass in the local church. Eventually Cole was moved by the bishop as he was too disruptive in the parish. Again the experiences in the 1890s in my local area, and numerous other areas, contradicted the thesis of parishioners passively obeying the church. They were not the sheep McDowell seemed to think.

In the 20th century there was widespread disobeying of instructions of the priests, and open contempt shown for the Bishop of Meath. The bishop lived in Navan, though officially based in Mullingar, and the church in Navan was known informally as 'the cathedral'. The bishop stormed off to live permanently in Mullingar because locals in Navan, a Parnellite town though the Parnellite split had officially been healed, flung horse dung in on him in his carriage. Flinging horse dung in the face of a bishop again hardly supports the theory of a subservient obedient Catholic populace.

The clergy in 1916 were openly hostile to the Easter Rising. So were most people. The support for the priests and people was shown when the local priests in Navan carried the bodies of the R.I.C men killed in the so-called Battle of Ashbourne into the County Infirmary, as hundreds gathered outside in a show of support. Clerical condemnation made no difference to the Irish republican minority at the time. (Due to the chronic mishandling of the aftermath, the British managed to turn public opinion against them, allowing republicans then and since to spin the myth that the rising had popular support. It didn't.)

Church condemnation of the Plan of Campaign, of the Land League, of boycotting and other issues in the 1880s had also made no impact. In 1923 the church condemned the anti-Treaty IRA and threatened members with excommunication. It made no difference. It was lack of public support, not church condemnation that forced the anti-Treatyites to end their campaign and that lack of support long predated the condemnation by bishops. Deeply religious figures like Sean T O’Kelly and de Valera didn’t suddenly quit the anti-Treatyites the moment the excommunication threat was made. They ignored it.

In the 1930s, de Valera refused to support the Nationalists in Spain under Franco, earning a furious condemnation from the church. The Irish public were strongly pro-Nationalist but there is no clear evidence that was due to church pressure but was just the wholesale fear of communism that was a feature across Europe, with the Republicans seen as communists. Yet de Valera went on to win the general election in Ireland in 1937. He lost seats. So did the pro-Nationalist Fine Gael. Labour, which was split between pro-Nationalists and pro-Republicans, gained seats. Though priests called on people to go to Spain to defend religion by supporting the Nationalists, and support for Nationalists far outweighed support for Republicans, only a small number joined Eoin O'Duffy's Greenshirts. (No. That isn’t a typo. Contrary to myth, it was not the Blueshirts who went to Spain, not least because the Blueshirts were abolished two years before the start of the Spanish Civil War. It was O’Duffy’s new group, the Greenshirts, and his National Corporate Party, that went to Spain.)

You will probably have heard how the Catholic Church got what it wanted in the 1937 constitution. That is another myth. In fact, its key demands were all rejected. In particular, the demand from Maria Duce and Fr. John Charles McQuaid that Catholicism be made the established church was ignored (leading to a temporary rupture in the friendship of de Valera and McQuaid). McDowell made a point of how the 1922 constitution was more secularist than the 1937 one. Of course it was. All constitutions drafted in the 1920s tended to be. They were a product of the quite secularist revolutions across Europe. The only problem was that they were very much liberal elite documents wildly out of touch with public opinion – which was one of the reasons why so few constitutions of the age had public support. By the 1930s, new constitutions adopted Europewide tended to be more religious - reflecting the grassroots opinions of voters. That was not unique to Ireland. It simply reflected the fact that across Europe the revolutionary elites that took power from 1918 on tended to be much more liberal and secularist than their populations. While I may prefer the 1922 constitution’s secularism (though the 1937 one is better written), it undoubtedly wasn’t reflective of the views of the Ireland of the time, whereas the 1937 one was closer to the views of ordinary people. Indeed it does pose a rather difficult fundamental problem in democracies - what happens if the majority of the public hold views that are the antithesis of the minority elite liberal democratic fringe?

The scale of how much liberal commentators fundamentally misunderstand the church and the time period is captured in the 1937 constitution. Liberals think the “special position” of the Roman Catholic Church in the constitution reflects the church’s control over the text. They entirely misunderstand that article and Catholic teaching at the time. The church believed it was the embodiment of divine revelation and truth. Whether it had one member in a country, or 100% of citizens were members, was irrelevant. As the supposed embodiment of truth and divine revelation it had a right to superiority in law. In church teaching at the time, “error has no rights.” All other faiths had broken away from the truth church, Catholicism. Therefore they had No rights.

Yet what did the “special position” article, Article 41, say?

1. The “special position” was not based on the church being the “true church”. It was based on being “the Faith professed by the great majority of the citizens.” That was an outrageous line for a church who believed its authority came from right as the “true church” - not simply a head count.

2. The article said:

The State also recognises the Church of Ireland, the Presbyterian Church in Ireland, the Methodist Church in Ireland, the Religious Society of Friends in Ireland, as well as the Jewish Congregations and the other religious denominations existing in Ireland at the date of the coming into operation of this Constitution.

In other words, while Roman Catholicism believed all other faiths were “in error” and “error has no rights”, the article in the constitution that gave the Catholic Church a largely meaningless recognition based on a sectarian headcount, also said quite frankly that “error Has rights” by recognising all the other religions as valid.

So, the idea that the article, since amended, embodied Catholic power, is a nonsense. In almost every way it contradicted Roman Catholic teaching. As a result, yet again, what Michael McDowell and many liberals think the past was is actually based on a fundamental lack of knowledge.

Michael McDowell also suggested that Ireland in a host of ways was the odd one out in Europe, with a more powerful Catholicism ruling the roost. One of the many fundamental flaws in McDowell's thesis about the past is that it fails to grasp that society in general worldwide was quite religious in the 19th century. Ireland wasn't the odd one out, but quite typical. It was spoken of as if the grotesque Catholic idea that its canon law is superior to the law of the state was unique to Ireland. In fact, that has been the Roman Catholic Church's view in every state.

I was surprised to hear McDowell claim he only discovered this as Attorney General. Seriously? I’m not a lawyer yet I knew that decades ago. It was hardly a secret. Roman Catholicism believes that as a divine-created organisation it outranks secular organisations and states. That is why popes claimed the right to crown Holy Roman emperors centuries ago. Anyone who ever studied history or law should always have known it. It was not remotely a secret. That has been at the core of the clerical abuse scandal – the belief that Catholicism outranked all secular organisations, so it didn’t have a duty to report crimes committed by its clergy to ‘inferior’ secular states. In other words, their laws are god’s laws, and therefore outrank man’s laws. It has believed that for two thousand years and has been at the core of almost every clash between Catholicism and any state. If McDowell didn’t know that he was astonishingly ignorant about history and law, and the relationship between Catholicism and law in countries worldwide. How on earth did a senior counsel not know something like that, let alone imagine it was unique to Ireland?

McDowell also showed no understanding of why Catholicism was so important in independent Ireland. Catholicism over the centuries had become the central badge of identity to differentiate Ireland from Britain. Even if they didn’t believe in Catholicism as a religion, people used it as a badge to stress its difference to Britain: Protestant Britain, Catholic Ireland. Many independent states adopt a unique symbol - and in Ireland, the role of Catholicism as being the voice of the ordinary suppressed Irish person right through the penal laws gave it that badge of being a unified cultural symbol. Had the Irish language not largely died out in the 19th century it may well have been that badge of difference.

So, the crowds going to the Eucharistic Congress weren’t just making a religious statement, but also a political statement about their own nationhood. It was independent Ireland’s first chance to host a major world event - and Eucharistic congresses were big world events. It was, in some ways, Nationalist Ireland’s first chance to party on the world stage as an independent state. The papal legate was being welcomed by the Irish Air Corp flying overhead, the Irish flag flying, the Irish prime minister (and Irish governor-general, though de Valera tried to marginalise him). There was nothing British about it.

To caricature the 1932 Eucharistic Congress as simply about triumphalist Catholicism, and not understand that the event was as much a badge of political identity as religious identity, shows very poor historical knowledge. It was as much a celebration of independence as it was a celebration of Catholicism. That is why it was the Irish flag, and not just the papal flag, that flew everywhere. It was a symbolic assertion of independence.

A critical flaw in McDowell’s programme was that it presumed a hierarchical structure of authority from bishops and priests down to obedient Catholics. In fact that wasn’t the case. As mentioned, people regularly ignored diktats issued by those at the top if they didn’t like them. McDowell mentioned the banning of divorce, and the introduction of censorship.

Neither of those, however, were top-down diktats of the hierarchy. Far from it. They came from ordinary people. It was often grassroots demands that produced them. It wasn’t Rome being enforced on the state, but grassroots citizens, many Catholic, some of other faiths or none, who lobbied to say “we don’t want these. We want you to ban them.” In the 1925 all Ireland election for the Seanad (the only popular election for the Seanad to take place), Gaelic League founder Douglas Hyde, expected to be a shoe-in, was humiliatingly defeated by ordinary citizens because they thought he was pro-divorce. There was no instruction from Maynooth to defeat him. In fact the bishops found many ordinary Catholics reported them to Rome – accusing them of being too liberal, or “modernist” (to use the idiotic phrase so loved of Pope Pius X). It was the ordinary citizens who instead of electing Hyde, or another respected figure, chose as a poll-topper a non-entity councillor from Monaghan.

One final flaw in the McDowell thesis was the idea of not just the uniqueness of the Irish relationship with Catholicism (he obviously doesn’t know about the similar relationships in a host of countries across Europe throughout the 19th and 20th centuries. Italy only legalised divorce in the 1970s) but that Catholicism’s abuse of power was unique, as well as being unique to Ireland. The clerical abuse scandal is closely associated with Catholicism (and I am one of its victims) simply because it was the first one caught. Since then almost every other religion has been caught up in similar scandals – the most recent one being Mormonism. Indeed, strikingly, figures from John Hopkins University show that the scale of abuse in Catholicism is almost identical to every other religion. Each has a sexual abuse rate of 5% - which does disprove the theory that Roman Catholic clerical sexual abuse is linked to the male priesthood or celibacy, as the percentage remains the same whether religions have a married or unmarried clergy, whether they have a male clergy or male and female clergy. Given that sexual abuse is slightly lower in religions than in the general population, it seems to suggest that all organisations will reflect the popular prevalence of sexual abuse, with in or around 5-6% of their staff abusers.

The truth about Catholicism in Ireland is a lot more complicated than the rather clichéd, cartoonish liberal version portrayed by McDowell in his programme on RTÉ. The Irish historically were far less under the thumb of Catholicism than he seems to think. They were more than able to ignore it when it suited them – whether it be in not voting for Cardinal Cullen’s Catholic Party, ignoring papal condemnations through the 19th and 20th centuries, ignoring the Church on the Plan of Campaign, boycotting, Parnell, or their sex lives. They could blame the church where necessary to avoid personal responsibility – as when they decided to put relatives into mother and baby homes for convenience and pretended it was under duress (contemporary accounts contradict the duress claim). The image of the obedient masses doing what Father said because Father said it is wildly, almost comically, exaggerated.

Overall, while McDowell’s programme was an interesting polemic, it was dubious history. It made sweeping generalisations that simply aren’t supported by the detail. It presumed a special relationship between Catholicism and Ireland that actually occurred in many states. It presumed uniquely appalling behaviour by Catholicism in Ireland that was in fact neither unique to Ireland or indeed unique to Catholicism. It presumes a rather clichéd image of ordinary Catholics in the past as obedient sheep ready to be hunted wherever their shepherd priest or bishop wanted them to go. In that, it had no idea of just how independent ordinary Irish Catholics have tended to be throughout history, and how many times Catholics entirely ignored and often disrespected the priests and bishops (and you can hardly get any more disrespect than flinging horse dung into the face of the Bishop of Meath!)

The reality in Ireland was much more complicated, and far more independent-minded and nuanced than McDowell’s thesis allowed for. As a polemic, the programme was interesting. As an accurate understanding of the history of Ireland, it was cartoonish and superficial.

➽ Jim Duffy is a writer-historian.

Polemically Interesting But Historically Cartoonish And Superficial

By AM Saturday, July 18, 2020

Ads On The Front Line

By AM Friday, June 29, 2018

The Funeral Murders

By AM Wednesday, April 18, 2018

The Trapped

By AM Wednesday, March 2, 2016

Charlie

By AM Friday, March 6, 2015

The Good Wife

By AM Friday, March 7, 2014

Lost Girl

By AM Wednesday, March 5, 2014

Hostages

By AM Thursday, February 6, 2014

The Tomorrow People

By AM Tuesday, February 4, 2014

The Client List

By AM Saturday, January 25, 2014

Sleepy Hollow

By AM Sunday, December 22, 2013
This weekend is simply not the same, no matter how it ultimately turns out. The reason is quite simple: last week saw the finale of two great television series. We love nighttime television here, particularly when the viewing is Scandinavian crime fiction drama. What made these two non-Nordic series so potent was the quality of the female cast.

Kings, Queens and Police Detectives

By AM Saturday, August 24, 2013

Enlightened

By AM Thursday, May 17, 2012
Older Posts Home
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)
  • Home
  • The Blanket
  • July 1981
  • Killing Joe O'Connor

New to the Quill

Loading...

Recent Comments

Loading...

Popular Posts

  • Hate TV
  • A Turd In The Cake Mix
  • Mearsheimer's Explosive Revelation Sends Shockwaves Across the Globe

Subscribe

Support TPQ via monthly subscription

Help towards maintenance with a one-time donation via PayPal
Follow TPQ on Bluesky
Follow TPQ on Facebook
Search The Blanket's archives
(2001 - 2008)
A Journal of Protest and Dissent

Archive

Search TPQ

Anthony McIntyre

Former IRA volunteer and ex-prisoner, spent 18 years in Long Kesh, 4 years on the blanket and no-wash/no work protests which led to the hunger strikes of the 80s. Completed PhD at Queens upon release from prison. Left the Republican Movement at the endorsement of the Good Friday Agreement, and went on to become a journalist. Co-founder of The Blanket, an online magazine that critically analyzed the Irish peace process. Lead researcher for the Belfast Project, an oral history of the Troubles.

  • Facebook
  • Bluesky

Copyright © · TPQ · Namina - There is no coming to consciousness without pain