Showing posts with label Sinn Fein & Gaza. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sinn Fein & Gaza. Show all posts
Gearóid Ó Loingsigh ☭ writing in Substack on 23-February-2025.


When the genocide in Gaza began, no one thought it would go on for so long. But it has, and along the road many challenges have come up for governments, social movements, Arab countries and political parties - and nearly all of them have been found wanting on the issue. In Ireland the annual cringe fest that is St. Patrick’s Day in Washington threw up a problem for Sinn Féin last year. Should they go or not go?

Last year the Irish Palestinian Solidarity Campaign issued a call for all political parties, including government parties, not to go. Sinn Féin broke that call for a boycott and were swiftly pardoned by the IPSC which swiftly invited them to address a Palestinian solidarity rally in Belfast one day before Mary Lou McDonald and Michelle O’Neill First Minister of Northern Ireland swanned around with Biden, imbibing of whatever liquor was on offer on the day. Supping the devil’s buttermilk as some of their unionist colleagues might put it.

At the time Sinn Féin said it was going, as it was important and that they would raise the issue of Palestine with Biden. One month before flying out to Washington a Sinn Féin spokesperson stated:

We will use every political and diplomatic opportunity and influence that we have to be a voice for Palestine, to demand an end to the occupation of the West Bank and Gaza, for Palestinian statehood and for a permanent ceasefire now.[1]

In the end they did no such thing. In fact, the then Irish Taoiseach (Prime Minister) Leo Varadkar was more forceful than Mary Lou or Michelle who made even more tepid statements and quaffed what was put in front of them and enjoyed the jollies. They could have been forgiven for thinking that it would be all over by 2025 and this situation would not arise again. Well, we should be gentle on them, many of us underestimated the Israeli bloodlust. But here we are again. Trump continues with Biden’s genocide and announces his intention to commit two war crimes e.g. the mass expulsion of Palestinians from Gaza, a war crime under Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention and profit from the looting of their assets a further war crime under Article 33 of the same convention.[2]

The SDLP was the first out of the hatches saying it would not go, reaffirming their position of the previous year. It is ironic that Sinn Féin supporters used to refer to the SDLP as the Stoops, a play on their initials, Stoop Down Low Party, which probably means Sinn Féin (SF) should now be known as the Stoop Further. As is common with the Stoop Further, they are fond of speaking out both sides of their mouths. They announced that they would not go this year, though no official invite has been issued to them, and at the same time urged the Irish government to go. A case of wanting to have their cake and eat it too.

Mary Lou McDonald stated Trump’s plan “represents a marked escalation in the very complex conflict situation for the Palestinian people.”[3] Really? Expulsion is an escalation from genocide? To be very clear, there is a specific genocide convention and genocide is a Crime Against Humanity, under that convention, and is so at all times and in all circumstances.[4] There are no ifs or buts to that. Expulsion and profiteering are war crimes. In legal terms, they are egregious crimes but less so than genocide. There is no escalation here. Both Biden and Trump have been complicit in the genocide, Trump however has put the blood-soaked icing on the cake with his proposal. Except it is not his proposal. It has been official US and Israeli policy since 2007.[5] In other words, a plan that began under Bush and continued during the eight years of Obama’s presidency when Biden was the Vice-President, Trump’s first presidency and of course Biden’s four demented years as President.

Mary Lou McDonald seeks to draw a line under her support for the US. There is some mythical line in the sand between the Democrats' support for murder, genocide, torture and Trump’s. In refusing to go to the Blood Fest in Washington she stated that Sinn Féin would not be in a position to challenge Trump’s statements at the Blood Fest (she doesn’t describe it as such, to be clear that is my accurate description). This is surprising as last year, she said that they would challenge Biden on his support for Israel. Before they went off on their junket last year, two days before the St Patrick’s Blood Fest they issued a tame communiqué asking Biden to play a more “constructive role” in Palestine,[6] whatever that is supposed to mean. In fact, part of their public rationale for going was that they could influence US government policy. So, what is different now? Have they concluded that their junket last year did not produce the results they hoped for? Well, they had no expectations that Biden would end US complicity in the genocide and as I already pointed out, when they went their statements were way weaker than the Irish government’s official statements. So, the answer is no. This year they have said they won’t go, but have said the Taoiseach should go:

We absolutely believe that he needs to go and, furthermore, when there, set out unambiguously the Irish position in respect to all of these matters and to push back directly against any threat or goal for the mass expulsion of Palestinians from the Gaza Strip, the annexation of that land.[7]

If, as last year under Biden, they believed they could influence policy in the same way they now expect the southern Irish government to do, why don’t they go? The answer is one of political expediency. They have calculated that this time round there is no political cost amongst their reactionary base in the USA to boycotting a Trump event and by calling on the Irish government to go, they continue to signal that they are a “reasonable partner” that the Irish state and Trump can do business with. Michelle O’Neill stated that she couldn’t go this year because:

I couldn't in all conscience make that trip at this time. I just think that there are times whenever we'll all reflect, and certainly whenever my grandchildren ask me, what did I do whenever the Palestinian people were suffering, I could say that I stood on the side of humanity.[8]

Except of course, she didn’t. Whilst Biden gladly and gaily supplied Israel with all the military hardware required to carry out a genocide, she did not nothing. In the waning days of Biden’s support for genocide, on January 4th of this year he notified Congress of an additional US $8 billion arms sale to Israel.[9] Yeah, Michelle can tell her grandchildren what she likes, but she supped with the Devil. She took part in a genocide through her endorsement of Biden. Her sudden hypocritical distancing from the same policies under Trump is meaningless.

It is not an ethical position; it is not one based on some internationalist concept of solidarity with the oppressed or even a liberal opposition to genocide and war crimes as they have previously shown no such solidarity or real opposition to such acts when Biden was the war criminal in charge.

No matter how low you think Sinn Féin can stoop, they will always surprise you and Stoop Further.

References

[1] The Irish News (23/02/2024) Protests at east Belfast arms manufacturer as city council’s largest parties accused of ‘vetoing’ PBP Gaza ceasefire motion. John Manley. 

[2] The Geneva Conventions can be consulted at.

[3] Irish Independent (22/02/2025) Sinn Féin may be boycotting White House for St Patrick’s Day, but Mary Lou McDonald is imploring Taoiseach to attend and confront Trump. Tabitha Monahan and Senan Molony. 

[4] To consult the Genocide Convention.

[5] Jonathan Cook (14/02/2025) Trump didn't invent the Gaza ethnic cleansing plan. It's been US policy since 2007.

[6] Sinn Féin (15/03/2024) O’Neill urges President Biden to play constructive role in securing immediate Gaza ceasefire. 

[7] Irish Independent (22/02/2025) op. cit.

[8] RTE (22/02/2025) O'Neill says 'could not live' with decision to visit White House over Gaza. 

[9] Al Jazeera (04/01/2025) Biden notifies US Congress of planned $8bn arms sales to Israel: Reports. 

⏩ Gearóid Ó Loingsigh is a political and human rights activist with extensive experience in Latin America.

The St. Patrick’s Day Blood Fest Comes Round Again

Michael O’Rourke ✍ Mary Lou McDonald is proposing to graft onto the Palestinian nation her vision of what they can achieve if they follow Sinn Féin’s “peace” formula with the Zionist enemy.

Speaking in London (of all places - ?) at the pro-Palestine protest rally last January 2024, Mary Lou McDonald suggested Palestinian freedom was possible, saying:

When I say this, standing in London, in common cause with you, (having) walked our own journey out of conflict, building peace for 25 years, this can happen.

Now, reading and listening to Mary Lou at the London pro-Palestine march makes me wonder: am I now living in dystopia? And is doublespeak the new lingua franca of the politics of Sinn Féin? I must ask these questions especially now since I am so astounded at the sheer warp-speed political gymnastics it takes to configure the genesis of Mary Lou foisting her peace message onto the masses of the pro-Palestine people in London. But moreover, in addition, the government the masses of people marching in London oppose, is one of the main supporters of the criminal Zionist regime. And apropos, isn’t it the same government with whom she has enjoyed sharing this vaunted 25 year peace process?

Anyway, if you have any difficulty understanding the advance of this new dispensation: it was begun in 1998 under the GFA, devised by the US State Department, CIA and MI6, and attended by the Irish 26 county government representatives and an assortment of bought-and-paid-for ex-republicans and British proxy, unionist paramilitary Orange death-squad individuals. Nonetheless, even though the Unionist paramilitaries no longer have much use for it nowadays since there is no change in the status quo, the GFA is still a mainstay of Sinn Féin and Mary Lou McDonald, as is evident by her appearance in London, selling it as a kind of (Doctor Good, cure all medicine) placebo to the aroused masses who rightly want to end Israeli genocide. However to fully understand Mary Lou’s speech, its essential political precepts and her appearance in London, you will need to apply a translation guide from the classic Doublespeak/Doublethink she uses, which is listed below:

To know and not to know, to be conscious of complete truthfulness while telling carefully constructed lies, to hold simultaneously two opinions which cancelled out, knowing them to be contradictory and believing in both of them, to use logic against.

Translate into the language of our political reality, then imagine, the best thing for the Palestinian people Mary Lou McDonald could do is; declare war on British imperialism. But she is not ever going to do that, because she enjoys peace with British imperialism. They are her partners in peace, even though in the interim they have made war on; Iraq, Libya, Syria and now Palestine and Yemen, and were essentially able to do so because they were freed from any possible escalation of the liberation struggle in Ireland. 

And accompanying their Middle Eastern imperialist rampages they have attempted to harden their border in Ireland with Brexit. But Mary Lou is still convinced of their trustworthiness, enough to tell the people in London and Palestine of Sinn Féin’s great successful (betrayal) journey. 

A note we might need to take from this new dispensation of a Sinn Féin leader addressing a mass movement in London is: when they fall they keep falling, and when they betray they keep betraying. Remember this too, the first words from Mary Lou on October 7 was: complete condemnation of the Hamas breakout of the Gaza concentration camp, after which she returned to a doublespeak smokescreen of criticism of the Israeli regime.

🖼 Michael O’Rourke is a former POW imprisoned on behalf of the INLA.

Mary Lou Fluent In Doublespeak

Anthony McIntyre ☠ Writing yesterday about the political perspective of Sean Lynch having evolved I was reminded of how another former prisoner had undergone an even more striking departure from the ground he had almost died on.

Pat Sheehan is an old friend who has previously featured on the pages of TPQ. I think because of our once firm friendship, but maybe not, I was sent via Facebook an audio recording of a disputatious exchange between him and pro-Palestinian activists. They were arguing over the heckling of Sinn Fein luminary Declan Kearney when he addressed a rally in support of Gaza earlier this year. Sheehan was annoyed at some in the crowd shouting 'Kearney you are a fuckin wanker.'

Sheehan also drew attention to himself being heckled: 

when I got up to speak at the City Hall, as soon as I got up to speak, as soon as it was announced that I was speaking, part of the crowd started booing.


I don't believe Declan Kearney or Pat Sheehan should have been shouted down. It was denying others their right to hear what either had to say. If people do not approve of the Kearney/Sheehan perspective, to the point that they do not want to listen to them, they can always turn their backs in silent protest. It happened to Sinn Fein speakers during the Iraq war when the party was suspected by many in the anti-war movement of trying to play it both ways. The joke then was that Mitchel McLaughlin would appear at the anti-War rally at Hillsborough while Alex Maskey would attend the war rally outside Belfast City Hall. 

People Before Profit activists, Sheehan's interlocuters, were claiming that the heckling was spontaneous, over which it had no control, whereas Sheehan contested any notion of it being random.

When it was put to Sheehan by a Palestinian woman that perhaps the hostility towards both he and his party colleagues was a result of anger at his meeting with Likud, he responded 'and what?' 

To put some context on this, imagine responding to Jewish people - who had lost friends and colleagues during the Holocaust and complained about others meeting the Nazis -  'and what?’ Is there a more appropriate word than arrogance to describe such an ill-advised rejoinder?

Meeting with Likud is like meeting with the Nazi Party. Perhaps an argument can be made for meeting with Nazis at critical junctures. Back channels are probably essential in the midst of violent political conflict. Norbert Masur and Folke Bernadotte evidently believed so, and in their defence they saved the lives of many Jewish people. But Sinn Fein would be hard pressed to show one Palestinian life saved as a result of the party meeting Likud.  There is not a scintilla of evidence to show that Likud would be swayed in the slightest by Sinn Fein, merely using the meetings to exercise bragging rights over the Palestinians - with taunts of even your allies are now high-fiving it with us. 

Arguably, there was only one reason for Sinn Fein to meet Likud. That was to demonstrate to the establishment that it is a party that has been cured of its radicalism and is now fit for government, trotters suitably attired in polished shoes as it sits at the top table snorting with Farmer Jones.

Sheehan told his detractors that to claim there was no organised heckling, 'you are pissing up my leg and telling me it is raining.' Takes some chutzpah to make that claim given his own party's history in organized lying and handing out brollies to those whose backs it just pissed down.

After listening to the audio, I asked a Belfast activist aligned neither to SF nor People Before Profit for his take. Very familiar with the rallies and protests, he stated that while People Before Profit members might have joined in, the heckling was not organised but was the result of young people in particular being abhorred by what they felt was Sinn Fen's duplicitous stance on the Gaza genocide.

From Pat Sheehan friend of Liberation to Pat Shekel friend of Likud, not the type of epitaph you would want on your headstone.   

⏩Follow on Twitter @AnthonyMcIntyre.

A Shekel For Your Thoughts

Caoimhin O’Muraile ☭ Although the Sinn Fein leadership have publicly sent messages of support to the Palestinians perhaps some of their actions on the ground may suggest the opposite. 

On Sunday 19th May Suzzanne Breen of the Belfast Telegraph on Sunday Politics ‘Northern Ireland’ was asked why the party are losing, according to polls, a few percentage points. In the 26 counties they are down from 31% to 29% and in the six counties they are still the highest supported party but again are down a couple of percentage points. Suzzanne suggested; “Sinn Fein in the north still hold a healthy position, but they have dropped percentage points”. It appears the party have dropped 2 points in the six counties and coupled with, according to the polls, they are losing some ground in the 26 counties which must be causing minor concerns. They are not down a great deal and no need to press the panic button yet but nevertheless it should be food for thought as they are losing points across Ireland as a whole. 

Has some of their actions over the Palestinians in Gaza been a factor in this minor decline? Suzanne Breen made a valid point when she pointed out:

I don’t think the party leadership realise the importance of full support for the Palestinians among the republican base (if that is what their base support any longer is). The other week Sinn Fein ejected some pro-Palestinian protestors from the Europa Hotel at a party meeting. This would not bode well among its electoral base. 

A fair point, as Sinn Fein councillors “failed to vote in favour of kicking out the Israeli Ambassador”, it was not clear whether this was in reference to the 6 or 26 counties. This again would not sit well within their support base.

Sinn Fein dropping points in each jurisdiction, albeit only a small number, is not good but they are still the largest party in the six counties and are riding high in the polls. In the 26 counties they are still the most popular party as they are across the island of Ireland. In the six counties they are down from 31 to 29 percentage points and remain the largest party in the Stormont Assembly. The Democratic Unionist Party (DUP) are down to 21 percentage points quite a large drop for them. The arrest of former DUP leader, Jefrey Donaldson over ‘historical sex abuse’ claims have helped the demise of the DUP and perhaps Sinn Fein have Donaldson to thank indirectly for them retaining a huge lead over their rivals? It should be remembered at this juncture that Donaldson has been found guilty of nothing at this time, but guilty or not the damage to the DUP has been done.

The small drop in Sinn Fein support is well within the margin of error so no great concern at the moment there. Polls are notoriously unreliable as has been the case on countless occasions in the past. They are not deciding factors, just vague indicators of any party’s fortunes at a given time. The only poll which counts for these parties is of course the election itself. Despite this drop in the polls Sinn Fein still look set to become the largest party in the Dail at the next election with Mary Lou McDonald becoming the first woman Taoiseach. 

In the ‘Legislative Assembly’ at Stormont in the north Sinn Fein look to remain the largesse party with Michelle O’Neil remaining as First Minister. I do not share Suzzanne Breen’s analysis that Sinn Fein's policy towards the Palestinians is costing them points. At the party’s last Ard Fheis Mary Lou “embraced the Palestinians while condemning Israel”. However, this did not prevent the party leadership attending the White House as guests of President Joe Biden, Israel's largest arms supplier at the time, for the Saint Patricks Day piss up! This did cause some resentment among Sinn Fein's rank and file but not mass desertions. The incident as told by Suzzanne Breen about the Europa Hotel in Belfast may also have caused some constellation but again no mass desertions. 

What may be causing the drop in percentage points is the party, like all those in Dail Eireann, with the possible exception of People Before Profit, is their, Sinn Fein's, fudging policies to suit populism within the community. For example, after Mary Lou’s hostile reception at East Wall, Dublin, by residents fuelled by the far-right over international protection applicants the party who once were in the scramble to be refugee-friendly shifted ground to the right slightly. This was in an attempt to reclaim support from far-right organisations. Sinn Fein are not alone here as all Dail Parties, government and opposition alike, are shifting from embracing asylum seekers to mild hostility. They have cut the benefits these people receive from over 200 euro per week to just 38. They promised these people protection and instead have reneged an all their promises, making them live in unsanitary conditions and cutting their incomes. Hardly welcoming is it! Sinn Fein are no exception as the governing parties have shifted from their ‘open door policy’ to one of caution. The problem with what amounted to an ‘open door policy’ is that it was ill thought out if any thought at all was given to it.

Another area which may be of concern particularly among the older members of Sinn Fein and some IRA veterans could be the apology issued by Michele O’Neil over the party leadership's attendance at veteran IRA fighter, Bobby Storey’s funeral. Yes, the funeral took place under Covid conditions but, as far as I could see, all safety precautions were taken. Was there any need to issue an apology? This could have damaged some grass roots supporters faith in the party but to what, if any, extent?

The complete shambles which the present government consisting of Fianna Fail, Fine Gael and the Green Party, have made in general not about just asylum seekers is the main reason Sinn Fein are riding so high. Sinn Fein may be down a couple of percentage points but this often happens and is not yet a matter for concern. Like all opportunist parties in all so-called parliaments if it suited their electoral needs Sinn Fein, like the rest of the parties, would move into an all-out opposition to international protection applicants if they thought such a move would get them into government. In parliamentary politics electoral success not political principles is what counts, which makes a mockery of the whole farce. 

The object of politics, particularly socialist politics, is to convince the people your point is the correct one, not fudge to suit changes of mood among elements among the population as Sinn Fein are doing. In Britain the Scottish Labour Leaders, Anas Sawar, once said; “I don’t care about principles, all I care about is getting elected”. That clap trap applies to Dail Eireann parties and Members of the Legislative Assembly, who are not a sovereign government, equally. 

James Connolly, a man Sinn Fein somewhat ridiculously claim as one of their historical icons, once celebrated coming third in an election on a socialist ticket. He came third by sticking to the socialist message and not fudging to suit what today we call populism among the electorate. He did not become an anti-Semite just because huge swathes of the population were, he continued to fight such abominations putting anti-Semitism and sectarianism in the same evil branch. He stuck to his guns and that is what it is all about. 

For years now Sinn Fein have abandoned policy after policy. What happened to the illusive “32 County Democratic Socialist Republic” once so often preached by SF? Will we get our much-needed single tiered nationalised health system? We’ll never know unless the Sinn Fein party are elected but, for fucks sake, do not hold your breath because form would suggest not. What we do know is the present gang in government will never deliver!
 
Caoimhin O’Muraile is Independent Socialist Republican and Marxist.

Is The Situation In Gaza Costing Sinn Fein Percentage Points?

Tomás Ó Flatharta ☭ Who Organised a Belfast Patrick’s Weekend Palestine March – Minus the Original Speakers? Bernadette McAliskey looks for answers

Bernadette McAliskey asks questions:

The Ireland Palestine Solidarity Campaign (IPSC) should provide answers.

Bernadette McAliskey:

Was this march organised by Belfast ISPC? On what date did the platform change from the three speakers below and become a platform of primarily spokespersons for political parties of the NI Assembly,? On what date were the political parties first invited to speak? Why was the list of political party speakers including Sinn Fein not announced prior to the March and rally itself, allowing those who didn’t want to hear from political parties whose leaders were in the White House, or those doing little or nothing for Palestine to have stayed away? Who made these decisions, the consequences of which must have obvious to them at the time, given the depth of feeling from anger to disappointment? What did they expect from an unsuspecting audience when a Sinn Fein speaker was sprung on them? Did they, through naivety, expect Sinn Fein to decline or was the reaction foreseen and thought to OK?





Without some transparency and explanation of the who, when and why, the organisers have very little credibility left with independent activists who are daily raising awareness; building support for boycott of Israeli goods on the ground; fund raising for medical aid, for children, for food aid in Gaza and helping as best they know how, Palestinians living here to cope with the pain and trauma of their fear for family and friends at home as well their exile.

Either lack of foresight and transparency, intentional deceit, or plain old-fashioned elitism needs to be owned up to, unless the organisers have a better explanation. This is no way to build any principled unity on Palestine, or anything else for that matter.

Vincent Doherty

This is a moment of decision nationally for the IPSC. Sinn Fein would prefer if we all forgot their treachery in fine wining and dining with Biden in the midst of the genocide. Just like a few years ago when they were meeting with Likud despite having signed up to the BDS campaign. It’s the elephant in the room, and one that needs to be addressed.

Keep Up With Tomás Ó Flatharta.

Answers Needed

Fra Hughes 💣I would not want to be standing in the elections as a Sinn Fein candidate when the chickens come home to roost. 

Well. well. well -  let us just take a moment of reflection to see were the parties stand on Palestine. The first word that springs to mind is hypocrisy, the second derision and the third abandonment. As someone who has been the victim of a smear campaign by some Sinn Fein party members, and the groups they manipulate for the last 14 years, I am delighted to see how they have finally outed themselves as the failed control freaks that they actually are. 

Sinn Fein has ridden so many horses since 1998 in their pursuit of power they are no longer recognisable as the revolutionary party they once were. No better than Fianna Fail and Fine Gael nor even their fellow constitutional opponents in the North, the SDLP,  SF is now a neoliberal establishment driven constitutional party Their pursuit of popularism not principle is as telling as their betrayal of everything they once stood for. 

Their representative was heckled from the stage at the rally against genocide outside the American Embassy in Belfast while their senior party members were frolicking with genocidal Joe Biden at the White House. A perfect example of betrayal of the people of Gaza and the parallel approach SF takes of fooling voters at home while sucking at the teat of American imperialism. One face for the people of Ireland and another for the capitalists and the imperialist war mongers in the EU and America.

I personally cannot wait for elections north and south to see the backlash against Sinn Fein and their betrayal of the people of Palestine and indeed the people of Ireland. One two three four open up the Gaza door, five six seven eight Sinn Fein will get bait(beat) Now there is an election slogan that would resonate with Sinn Fein's revolutionary past, and sadly it's very far in the past now. 

So, let us look at the opposition. Varadkar stood beside a genocidal maniac at the White House, as he explained why the Irish people are so in tune with the plight of the Palestinian people - a common history (one which includes military occupation, famine, colonisation, oppression, brutality and frequent massacres of the indigenous population) my words. Did he expel the Israeli Ambassador? No. Did he stop American war planes refuelling at Shannon Airport? No. Did he call on Genocide Joe to stop rearming Israel, to stop using their veto at the United Nations, to stop financing the apartheid racist state of Israel? No. He is another political chameleon, shedding skin, policies and principles when it suits. 

Shameless self-serving politicians are the same all over the world. Spineless cowardly and corrupt in many instances. Sinn Fein will cynically manipulate and try to control every narrative that comes into the public discourse and try to undermine marginalise and pillory critical thinkers, like myself, who they cannot control. Bullies and thugs - you know who you are. I have a long memory and I will not forget. We see you for what and who you really are. 

Now, who could we vote for and more importantly who should we vote for. Well the rivals to Sinn Fein, north and south are a motley collection of imperialist leftists and the remnants of the Socialist Workers Party. If candidates stood under the party banner vote for the Socialist Workers Party they would get about as many votes as the Workers Party which is a true socialist party, unlike these pseudo socialists who cheer-led the wars of intervention with chants of Gaddafi must go! Look at Libya now ? Sheep dressed as lions, champagne socialists, only interested in getting elected. 

People Before Profit, what a great name More a political slogan than a political party. They have risen on the failures of SF. They are not leading a socialist revolution at the ballot box LOL. People are simply sick and tired of the lies, duplicity and deception of the established parties, Indeed the rise of SF in the south is proportional to the failures of FF and FG in government. Leading us to a United Ireland, don't make me laugh. The people of Ireland will reunite the country, not SF.

In conclusion we are represented in government and council by self serving sell-outs, each carving a little niche for themselves in the political landscape, then waiting for the others elected to slip up so they can slide in. FF-FG-SF are one and the same. Parties for capitalists, big business and the ruling elite do not let them tell you otherwise. Their opponents, the likes of PBP are simply Sinn Fein-lite. Stepping into the space the once revolutionary SF party has abandoned, more rhetoric than substance. Their reversals in the last elections in the north goes to prove getting elected is the easiest part staying elected is harder, 

A curse on all your houses, Vote independent candidates.

Fra Hughes is a Belfast based writer and activist.

Curse Them All

Fearghal Mac Bhloscaidh ☭💣writing in BLOSC,

Last year a cavalcade of war criminals landed in Belfast to celebrate the anniversary of the Good Friday Agreement. Around that time, Brown University published a report that stated that more than 4.5 million people had died due to Washington’s wars since 9/11. Indeed, since the Second World War, the USA has carried out at least 81 overt and covert interventions to promote regime change in other people’s countries. Obviously, since the Good Friday Agreement’s 25th anniversary, the USA and its allies have notoriously given Israel carte blanche to carry out a genocide in Gaza. The United States was built on genocide and chattel slavery and act as successor to the white supremacist British Empire as current global imperial hegemon. The USA is above all the state arm of global capital. If you describe yourself as an anti-imperialist or if you want to end imperialism, then the White House is the last place you should be on St Patrick’s Day.

Yesterday, I attended a protest in Belfast which I thought was organised to criticise the Irish political establishment’s decision to attend the celebrations at the White House. Before leaving the house, I read a tweet from Tommy McKearney, which stated that the Tyrone People’s Dáil would not be attending as the event has ‘unfortunately now been turned into a party political rally’. I then found out that Bernadette McAliskey, who was set to speak, would now not be turning up for the same reason. It then became clear that Clíodhna Nic Bhranair, Belfast City Councillor and the manager of the James Connolly Centre, would be speaking on behalf of Sinn Féin. The Belfast branch of the Irish Palestine Solidarity Campaign [IPSC] operated as the most prominent of several groups on the steering committee for this demonstration. The publicity talked about Shamrocks for Palestine and the Dublin event made it clear what they were protesting: ‘As Irish political leaders prepare to celebrate St. Patrick’s Day with Joe Biden, the Gaza Genocide’s main sponsor, join us to show that the people of Ireland stand with the people of Palestine’.

It appears that Sinn Féin used their leverage with sympathisers and supporters on the Belfast IPSC group to get an invitation to a meeting organised to protest their position on the White House, along with that of the other main Irish political parties. Sinn Féin then selected a young woman to speak, knowing that she would receive a hostile reaction. I know Clíodhna, she is a highly intelligent and capable person, who surely anticipated that she would receive such a reception. Indeed, senior republican politicians like Gerry Kelly stood directly below the platform encouraging her, instead of speaking themselves. I was standing in front of the People Before Profit [PBP] group and I can confirm that not one of the many PBP members whom I know took part in the hostility directed at Clíodhna. My sense was that this emerged as a spontaneous reaction by sections of a very large crowd who thought they were attending a march protesting Sinn Féin as well as the other Irish political parties who attended the St Patrick’s Day junket. This is important because the social media response by prominent Sinn Féin supporters claimed that the booing was party political and directed by PBP. I have no doubt that, like any political organisation, PBP are using their (correct in my view) position on the White House to help generate support and mobilise, but the hostile reception emerged because of the audacity of Sinn Féin to sup with the Devil and stand with the Angels on the same day.

The reaction by leading Sinn Féin supporters was telling. I have selected one of many examples. Andrée Murphy tweeted: ‘Look at the strength of this young woman speaking truth in the face of a baying mob. They wouldn’t lace her boots – or the boots of the women who stood in her defence in front of the podium’. She then identified the women as ‘Bríd Keenan and Caral Ní Chuilín [who] were standing up for oppressed people, especially women, at home and internationally when it was dangerous & while many others chose to look the other way.’ So, the demonstrators opposing US imperialism and Israeli genocide were a ‘baying mob’ who had no revolutionary track record when the bullets were flying during the Troubles. As already noted, Bernadette McAliskey refused to speak because Sinn Féin made a mockery of the event and Tommy McKearney supported her decision. The revolutionary credentials line is a red herring. The logical conclusion would appear to be that unable to stop the protest, Sinn Féin attempted to muddy the waters and portray themselves as a victim, while promoting well-rehearsed tropes about armchair Trots versus their ‘real’ struggle.

The problem with all this is that Sinn Féin’s decision to attend the St Patrick’s Day jamboree demonstrated that when their position on Palestine conflicted with their cosy relationship with the great peace makers in the Pentagon and State Department, then the people of Gaza would understand if they supped with the devil. The issue is that Sinn Féin are running out of length on their spoon while they still pretend to be an anti-imperialist and socialist movement for many within their support base. I recently had a debate as Gaeilge with Clíodhna on the radio about this in the context of the return to Stormont. This is not an ad hominin attack on Clíodha, whom I get on well with, but an honest criticism of Sinn Féin’s position. I was not among the people who jeered, although I understood why many did. They booed because of the contradictory position adopted by Sinn Féin and the party’s chameleon like ability to run with the fox and hunt with the hounds. For example, Clíodhna, whom I am sure has all the attributes and ability to go a very long way in politics, manages the Connolly Centre. The Centre is a contradiction in terms from people who pose as inheritors to Connolly’s legacy while subverting it. Those involved would challenge this analysis, obviously, but objectively, it is a project in managing and negating the revolutionary legacy of Connolly and the Irish revolutionary tradition more generally.

When Connolly was alive, the dominant grouping in Irish nationalism similarly claimed the inheritance rights to the Fenian legacy and sought to incorporate Irish Catholic nationalism into the British Empire – the USA of its day. John Dillon, the son of the Young Irelander, led the Plan of Campaign during the Land War in the 1880s and, before 1916, he regularly mocked young radical republicans, brandishing his own prison record from a generation earlier. As deputy leader of the Irish Parliamentary Party, Dillon told all and sundry that he understood the limits of the possible, which involved reconciling Irish nationalism to imperialism and famously recruiting for the British Army in World War One [although he remained somewhat ambiguous regarding his own son’s potential enlistment]. When the British executed Connolly, Clarke, Mac Piarais, and the other anti-imperialist revolutionary leaders, Dillon lamented to the House of Commons that Asquith’s government had washed away our whole life’s work in a sea of blood. Today, Sinn Féin appear similarly torn between liberal integration and a grassroots and wider electoral base intent on real social change.

The aforementioned Andrée Murphy is on the board of Ireland’s Future, which typifies this trend. An essentially bourgeois organisation, Ireland’s Future represents a liberal push to the centre geared towards constitutional change (mostly) by Sinn Féin sympathisers who have climbed a wrung or two on the social ladder. Just this week, fellow board member Brian Feeney, my predecessor at St Mary’s, claimed that Sinn Féin were right to go to Washington as “Boycotting would be crackers.” His rationale was that there are 230 US companies in the North employing tens of thousands and that Conor Murphy and Joe Kennedy will expand that number and attract the magic “$6 billion investment here that Biden promised last April” (Irish News, 13 March 2024). Feeney is what he always has been, a constitutional nationalist, formerly on the green end of the SDLP. He hasn’t changed since the 1980s, Sinn Féin has and that is why he is now an enthusiast. Yet all we have here is a rerun of the failed economic policies hawked by Stormont since 1998. Multinational companies don’t invest because of sentiment, but to increase profit margins. Sinn Féin run the James Connolly centre while holding the begging bowl out to the global capitalist elite. The $6 billion are their thirty-two pieces of silver. Behave yourself and we will give you a neo-liberal United Ireland of sorts. We might even allow you build a couple of houses, but that socialism carry on is for the birds! Their PR wet dream would be to get Joe Kennedy to give a key note speech on the hospitality level of a revamped Casement Park.

The reason why all this matters is that, politically, the world is approaching a crisis potentially as grave as the First World War. The Good Friday Agreement operates as a fig leaf for Nancy Pelosi and Biden or Blair and his ilk to launder their own war mongering and profiteering past. The possibility of a global conflagration appears greater now than at any time in my life and I lived through the last decade of the Cold War. The GFA generation, Michelle and Emma – the sliothar sister, are miserable pawns in an imperial game. You don’t have to have any affinity for their imperial opponents to realise that the US and its allies are the greatest threat to peace and human survival in the world today. Similarly, the trajectory of western domestic politics is to the authoritarian right – across the board! The same Western liberal establishment have consistently failed to address the contradictions within global capitalism exposed since 2008. I recently watched Yanis Varoufakis’s documentary on the collapse of Syriza. The Troika essentially broke a genuine democratic movement pledged to equality and a sustainable economic future for Greece. Yet, when the liberal establishment hobbles and destroys democracy and with it the hope for a better future, the result is not stability but the empowerment of the extreme right. The contradictions in the system find new avenues for expression and faced with the challenge, the Liberal establishment typically become the handmaidens of authoritarianism and fascism.

Far worse than that, Sinn Féin are not even on Syriza’s level, they sold out before even getting into power. They’ve been operating on a post-dated check for a generation. The lesson from Europe is clear, if Sinn Féin let down the tens of thousands who view them as a vehicle for genuine change because they are in hock to the western imperial establishment in Washington and Brussels, then working-class Irish people will only have one place to go – rightwards. Ireland and the world need movements pledged to the democratic and socialist transformation of society not paddy-wackery and letters from America.

Yet, this political challenge is eclipsed by the far more fundamental environmental catastrophe that looms on the rapidly approaching historical horizon. Irish people need to oppose US imperialism as the political expression of global capitalist hegemony. Yet this is an international not a national struggle, for, if humanity cannot end capitalism, then capitalism will end human society as we know it. This will never be achieved cosying up to the attack dogs of global capital. We have left the era of liberal triangulation well behind and are entering an historical phase where issues of universality, class struggle and human survival must become the primary factors in any conscious human agent’s political mobilisation – the vista is bleak. At junctures like this, historical contradictions become exposed, and clarity emerges. There should be no place for blood-stained shamrocks for those pledged to anti-imperialist or socialist struggle. Constitutional nationalists and liberal hypocrites have never had a problem with genuflecting before the imperium, that’s why Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael didn’t send speakers to the demonstrations yesterday – why did Sinn Féin?

⏩Fearghal Mac Bhloscaidh blogs @ BLOSC.

Blood-Stained Shamrocks

Robert Emmet 1916 Society Lisnaskea ✊It was clear on Saturday 17th March, at the Palestinian solidarity demonstration in Belfast that Sinn Fein had overstepped the mark. 

Hundreds were booing and heckling the unfortunate Sinn Fein Councillor, who was set up by her 'cute hoor' leaders to take the flack, that they surely knew was coming. Do they really think that the people are complete fools?

Did they think that their last minute take over of the speaking panel was going to cover their clear endorsement of Yankee imperialism? 'O the fools the fools...' 

A once, purportedly, anti colonial and masquerading as an anti-imperialist party, has now thrown in its lot totally with all imperialisms and capitalism. At a time when the people of the world are consistently demonstrating against American and Israeli genocide in Gaza, the leaders of Sinn Fein were 'hob knobbing' with the leaders of that very genocide, Genocide Joe and friends, in Washington. Even when they come back from their 'masters den' will they (1) admit that they have 'taken the imperialist soup' and are committed to imperialism and capitalism or (2) condemn capitalism, imperialism and Zionism?

We fear there is no chance of any such thing happening any time soon. What then does that mean for the much vaunted 'Agreed Ireland ', a 'shared Island' or indeed their, ow fabled, "United Ireland "....not the 32 County Socialist Ireland you will understand? 

The basis, we were told, of the 30 year war. Of course we now know that there are serious questions over who was actually running the war for the 30 years. The recently published Kenova Report surely brings that into clearer focus. The implications of the content of the Kenova Report for what happened over the 30 years or more, also has even more profound implications for the next 30 years and potentially much longer. A case of 'do as we say' or else.

If the conclusions are that even during a, so called, secret guerilla war, that was prosecuted to destroy British colonial imperialism, the British were in control; imagine the leverage that they and their allies can impose now to maintain the capitalist/imperialist status quo? About 0.5% of what went on in the, so called, 'dirty war' has come to light. And about 0.0001% of British (and Dublin's) intelligence files have or will ever be released for scrutiny. So they still have a lot of power to coerce. 

The truth is: 'they haven't gone away you know ' and only too well Sinn Fein, et al, know it.

The Fools, The Fools

Ciaran McClean ✉ with a letter recently published in the Ulster Herald.

In January an appeal was made through the Ulster Herald for Sinn Fein members to lobby their leadership not to visit Washington on St Patrick's Day given President Biden's endorsement and enabling of the ongoing genocide in Gaza. 

As they prepare for the airport that appeal appears to have fallen on deaf ears whilst American weapons of mass destruction continue to erase all living things in the region.

Closer to home the Irish Government suffered an embarrassing referendum defeat trying to be too clever by half with it's citizens last week. SF too had urged a tá, tá vote also spectacularly misreading the mood of the country. 

Like the main opposition Party in England, SF's electoral fear of conservative middle Ireland is offending everyone aghast at the American/Israeli genocide. The referendum result showed Irish citizens want honesty from politicians, those in power and those who seek it. 

Any Government in waiting worth its salt needs clear blue water between itself and the status quo - St Patrick's Day is red letter day for SF in that context.

⏩Ciaran McClean is supporter of Palestinian rights.

Red Letter Day

Tommy McKearney ☭ It is hardly surprising that many progressive people have become increasingly uneasy about the Sinn Féin leadership’s relationship with the British establishment.  


Party vice president and Stormont First Minister, Michelle O’Neill, was recently pictured in a close embrace with British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, while only last May, along with her colleague Alex Maskey, she attended the coronation of Charles Windsor. Even more disconcerting is the party’s wholehearted endorsement of the PSNI in spite of, among other issues, that force’s well-documented foot-dragging in relation to releasing material connected to legacy inquests.

Nevertheless, and no matter how disturbing this cosying up to London may appear, it pales in comparison with the party’s obeisance to the United States’ government and administration. Nothing highlights this degree of subservience like their recent decision, indeed determination, to participate in the St Patrick’s Day festivities along with Joe Biden and his accomplices in the White House.

Although the Sinn Féin excursion to Washington has been analysed elsewhere, it is useful to remind ourselves of some key points. At a time when the death toll in Gaza was approaching 30,000 (including well over 10,000 children), the Biden-led US administration donated $14 billion to the Israeli war machine while vetoing United Nations resolutions demanding an immediate ceasefire. And these are only the latest actions in a long list of American collaboration with Netanyahu’s genocidal onslaught on the Palestinian people.

Difficult to believe then that Sinn Féin’s vice president, when questioned on a recent RTÉ programme about her intention to visit the White House, informed viewers that “the US has always been a strong partner for peace”. Elsewhere, party spokespersons have used the excuse that the upcoming visit has been endorsed by the Vichy-like Palestinian Authority’s ambassador to Ireland.

A crucial point that has to be reinforced in all of this is the fact that unlike Colum Eastwood, leader of the conservative SDLP, Mary Lou and her party have chosen to be entertained by the US administration. After all, it would have been quite easy to have met Sinn Féin’s transatlantic support base without smooching with the masters of imperialism on Capitol Hill.

It is this aspect of the visit – that is, the engagement with the American administration – which takes us to the crux of this matter. By rejecting and ignoring every call not to attend, by ignoring the possible fallout from alienating so many in Ireland, by risking lasting reputational damage through its craven commitment to the US state machine, Sinn Féin is making a statement. When boycotting the Biden “bash” may just have halted the party’s falling ratings, its leadership is, nevertheless, making clear that it wants a relationship with the White House above all other considerations. For Sinn Féin now, it’s all the way with the USA.

The implications of this move are stark. There is nothing cosmetic about it, because in a nutshell, Sinn Féin is accepting and endorsing the United States’ worldview. A capitalistic view of the world that sees global domination from Washington as the optimum, indeed the only acceptable system. Moreover, as so much of the world knows to its cost, in order to gain global hegemony, Uncle Sam intervenes politically and militarily across the five continents resulting in prolific bloodshed.

When not projecting its influence by direct military action, the US deploys debilitating economic sanctions, exemplified by the 60-year long blockade of Cuba. In fact, it is this attempt to starve the Cuban revolution that exposes the utter fallacy of the Sinn Féin claim to be able to speak truth to power. With access to every US president since Bill Clinton, they have failed to persuade Washington to lift the blockade. Perhaps the issue wasn’t raised which in itself begs the question, if not why not?

In reality, the Sinn Féin trip to join Genocide Joe for a St Patrick’s Day knees-up in the White House confirms a view expressed in an article in last month’s Socialist Voice. Sinn Féin has regrettably accepted the bourgeois consensus that takes its lead from US imperialism.

Tommy McKearney is a left wing and trade union activist. 
Follow on Twitter @Tommymckearney

St Patrick’s Day Subservience

Anthony McIntyre ☠  One of the more unpalatable aspects of Sinn Fein's decision to bestow shamrock on US president Joe Biden on Patrick's Day is former republican prisoners including hunger strikers trying to justify it.

All the H-Block fist waving against the malevolence of US imperialism has become nothing more than hot air.  

Much of this is the outworking of the success both the London and Dublin political establishments have achieved in moulding Sinn Fein in their own image, something the artist Carlos Latuff captured in his graphic mural which was obliterated before being restored to the International Wall in West Belfast. Here kneels Ireland's coalition.


Since the onset of the Israeli genocide in Gaza, and not taking account of the Patrick's Day issue, Sinn Fein on at least three occasions has been embroiled in controversy over its stance on Gaza.

  • The refusal to vote for a proposal to abstain in Belfast City Council from a motion calling for the expulsion of the Israeli ambassador from Ireland
  • the contrasting expulsion of a number of Palestinian protestors from a Sinn Fein event in Belfast
  • the blacking out of the Latuff mural.

We know for certain the party was responsible for the first two and while the evidence is inconclusive, thus not allowing us to be definitive about the culpability for the mural destruction, most observers seem to take the view that it is unlikely to have been the work of anybody else. As someone mockingly quipped on Twitter, it might have been Fine Gael's West Belfast youth wing.

I don't really expect much else from Sinn Fein, which as an institution has long since been turned by officialdom from poacher to gamekeeper. We could at the very least have expected more from former prisoners. Michelle O'Neill in the her comments following the release of the Kenova Report appeared to draw a line between the Good Friday Sinn Fein generation and that which waged the IRA's war prior to the GFA. She is not wrong to make that assertion, but is merely restating what critics of the party have been pointing out for decades. Good Friday republicanism, if it may be called that, amounts to a total resiling from Easter Sunday republicanism. Sinn Fein now more resembles not those republicans who fought the war but those whom they fought the war against. This is what makes the current shilling by former prisoners all the more lamentable. 

While not unexpected it is certainly disappointing that Sinn Fein has opted to prove its establishment credentials by agreeing to be a shamrock bearing cheer leader for the Biden White House. The real shock would have come had the party followed the example of Colm Eastwood of the SDLP who has taken up a much more radical stance than former IRA prisoners. 

Take Pat Sheehan, for example, once a close friend of mine and for whom I retain a measure of affection, bearing him no personal animosity whatsoever. At a recent rally he urged supporters not to feel beholden to the BDS campaign and cited the example of Glasgow Celtic supporters who a few years back turned up for a game against an Israeli team. He spoke glowingly of how the supporters wore their keffiyehs, waved their flags and chanted their support for Palestinians.

It is a fair point but a fake comparison. I would support Sinn Fein attending the Scandalous Shamrock Soirée if it too waved flags and thrust the images of murdered Palestinian babies in the face of Genocide Joe. Imagine the message that would transmit to the world rather than the cringeworthy image of of the party's leaders standing smiling with Biden rather than presenting him with a framed photo of a starving Palestinian child.

2023

2024

But we know that is not going to happen in a party where deference displaces defiance. Not a keffiyeh on display during the Ireland Funds national gala. It is most unlikely that the party will follow the lead of former Irish president Mary Robinson and call on Biden to his face while it is in Washington to prohibit all weapons sales and funds to Israel.

Later today the weekly vigil for Gaza will take place in Drogheda's West Street. I will not be there as I have an early train to Sligo where the Drogs will take on the home side later this evening. At one of the previous gatherings, I met a friend who I had not seen in a while. He shook his head in despair, observing to me that whatever Sinn Fein has done in the past, shafting everybody for a piece of power pie, abandoning the Palestinians was an all time low.  

I have no doubt that Sinn Fein is strongly opposed to genocide and does not approve of Biden' role in it. But unless the party seizes the opportunities that present themselves, it will find itself on the receiving end of the accusation that it never misses an opportunity to miss an opportunity. Ireland's situation does matter and Sinn Fein is right to raise it. But when a genocide is occurring those on the receiving end must take priority. The victim not the perpetrator should be made to matter most in Washington.

Hand Biden a wreath on Patrick's Day not a shamrock.

⏩Follow on Twitter @AnthonyMcIntyre.

Junket For Genocide

David Cronin ✒ writing in Europe Solidaire Sans Frontières.

I am old enough to remember a time when Sinn Féin was kept off the airwaves.

A broadcasting ban targeting its representatives was introduced by the Dublin government in 1976 and not lifted until 1994. Britain imposed a similar one in 1988.

The bans encouraged ignorance about the conflict in Ireland and its root cause – the brutality of the British state.

It is disappointing – to put it mildly – that having been subjected to censorship and exclusion, Sinn Féin is now resorting to censorship and exclusion itself.

A new video uploaded to Sinn Féin’s channel on YouTube gives a misleading flavor of a public meeting it organized in Belfast last week.

The main speaker at the event was Jilan Wahba Abdalmajid, the Palestinian Authority’s envoy to Ireland.

She was interrupted by several Palestinians, one of whom described the PA as a “corrupt dictatorship.” Before they were removed from the event, the protesters also voiced their disgust at plans by Sinn Féin to attend a Saint Patrick’s Day celebration hosted by Joe Biden, the chief enabler of the Gaza genocide.


The video of the event uploaded by Sinn Féin omits the interruptions.

Sinn Féin has a better record of speaking out against Israel’s crimes than most other political parties in Ireland. That does not excuse it for silencing ordinary Palestinians as it did in Belfast last week.

“Occasional scraps”

Sinn Féin used to demonstrate a far clearer understanding of the situation than it now does.

Back in 1998, An Phoblacht – Sinn Féin’s newspaper – published a critique of the Oslo accords reached between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization a few years earlier.

The article commented on how “having signed up to the ‘peace deal’,” the PLO’s then leader Yasser Arafat “now finds it empowers Israel in direct proportion to its disempowerment of the Palestinians.”

“He signed up to a deal supposedly based on the premise of land for peace,” the article adds.

“In a perverse sense, the Israelis have adhered to the central tenets of that deal. They continue to enjoy the peace that military, economic and political superiority confers. Meanwhile, they continue with the process of land confiscation and settlement building. Israel enjoys both land and peace. The Palestinians feed on occasional scraps.”

Continue reading @ ESSF.

Why Is Sinn Féin In Love With The Palestinian Authority?

Gearóid Ó Loingsigh ☭ writing in Socialist Democracy discusses the obliteration of a wall mural in West Belfast in support of the victims of Israeli genocide in Gaza. 
Once upon a time, Belfast was famed for its murals, so much so that even now a part of the tourist industry depends on a plastic paddy tour of the current murals on display in nationalist areas of Belfast.

Original Latuff cartoon. West Belfast mural.
Mural blacked out.
It was the 1981 hunger strike and its aftermath that saw an explosion in political murals in nationalist areas. As the 1980s went on, the technical and artistic quality of them improved dramatically and the politics they sought to represent expanded. Some of them were very militaristic, others much more political in content. On international issues, murals sprang up on South Africa, Palestine and figures from revolutionary struggles around the world were to be found on gable ends all over the city and indeed in other cities throughout the North. Nelson Mandela, Steve Biko, Camilo Torres, Che amongst others looked down at the wandering revolutionary tourists who would come over in August. The message was clear: Ireland was part of an international struggle against imperialism.(1)

After the peace process the quality continued to improve, but the politics went for a walk. Twee Celtic murals abounded, young girls dancing a jig displaced images of women holding an armalite aloft for International Women’s Day. Messages about Imperialism were softened, when not blunted entirely or removed. So, it comes as no surprise to see what has happened to recent murals.

Sinn Féin supporters recently unveiled murals in solidarity with Palestine. They are of good quality and try to capture the suffering of the Palestinians through the images and poignant quotes. However, they say nothing about who is causing the suffering: the US and Israel, though there are silhouette ghostly like images of soldiers standing over dead children. There was once a mural on the White Rock Road which pictured a US Indian superimposed over a US flag saying Your struggle, Our struggle. No references are to be made now to the US role in exterminating a people. That is strictly Verboten.

However, someone decided to reproduce a cartoon from the artist Carlos Latuff in mural form in Belfast. It depicts Joe Biden, standing with bloodied hands in front of Mary Lou, who is clearly identifiable in the image, and the leaders of FG and FF, who can be identified from the initials FG and FF on their backs. The British Army and the RUC used to deface republican murals, not any more. Very quickly, Sinn Féin, officially or unofficially (no pun intended, though it is apt) painted over the mural. It was quickly restored by others, who the artist Latuff described as real republicans.(2)

Sinn Féin are clearly uncomfortable about the issue in the run up their fest in Washington with Biden and not only are they content to throw Palestinians out of public meetings, they will now supress any public artistic attempts to draw people’s attention to the Slaughter Soirée they will have in the White House.

Many Palestinian voices such as the Electronic Intifada have called on Sinn Féin not to go to Washington, the calls in Ireland have been much more muted and tamer on the issue. However, it is a clear issue, what is colloquially called a no-brainer. You don’t have to think very deeply to understand that Sinn Féin shouldn’t go to Washington DC, that they should tell Genocide Joe they don’t want to meet him. They will go and they will say nothing about Palestine. Their erasure of a mural criticising them, tells you everything you need to know about their real attitude to Palestine: Whatever you say, say nothing, used to be a catchphrase about loose talk and informers, now it means never mention Joe Biden and the Palestinians in the same breath, unless you are green washing genocide. Meanwhile Sinn Féin does its part, emulating the British army and vandalising political murals.

Notes

(1) A selection of images can be seen on Bill Rolston’s website. Rolston has chronicled and photographed murals going right back to the 1970s.

(2) See.

⏩ Gearóid Ó Loingsigh is a political and human rights activist with extensive experience in Latin America.

Erasing Murals And Erasing Gaza

Fearghal Mac Bhloscaidh ☭ writing in Tomás Ó Flatharta.

Fearghal Mac Bhloscaidh is one of the most interesting political writers in Ireland. The article below is a detailed analysis of Ireland’s peace process, which begins with a speech delivered by Bernadette McAliskey the year before the Good Friday Agreement was signed in 1998. I remember it well. (*) - John Meehan



As a young man, I listened to a speech by Bernadette McAliskey the year before the signing of the Good Friday Agreement – the pinnacle of what became known as the ‘peace process’. McAliskey did not object to peace, she had notoriously been subtitled by the BBC in a 1992 interview, when she said: ‘No sane human being supports violence. We are often inevitably cornered into it by powerlessness, by lack of democracy, by lack of willingness of people to listen to our problems. We don’t choose political violence, the powerful force it on us.’ (quoted in Curtis, 1998:297) By the time I heard her speak in 1997, the powerful had arrested her pregnant daughter, Róisín, with the intent to extradite her to Germany. By 2000, the powerful admitted that Róisín, who had never been charged, had no case to answer as there was ‘not a realistic prospect of convicting Miss McAliskey for any offence.’ (Guardian, 20 July 2000). What struck me at the time, was that the powerful had a vendetta against a woman and her family because she had stood up for socialist republican principles for thirty years at that stage. Last month, fifty-five years after the Burntollet march and her subsequent election as the then youngest female Westminster MP ever, McAliskey gave the main oration at the solidarity march in Dublin, where she told the crowd that ‘Palestine is the litmus test of our humanity’ and then urged those present not to vote for any politician who would legitimise the Biden administration, which was ‘enabling genocide’, by attending the St Patrick’s Day events in the White House (Irish News, 14 January 2024).

McAliskey’s speech from all those years ago stuck in my mind because in the questions afterwards she was asked about the peace process and used a powerful analogy that I hadn’t heard before at that stage, but I have heard and used myself on numerous occasions since. She welcomed an end to violence but warned that the provisional movement appeared to be going down a well-worn reformist path that would eventually denude it of any revolutionary potential. She compared the republican movement to a frog, which if placed in a pot of boiling water, will immediately sense the danger, and jump out to save itself, but, if immersed in tepid water brought slowly to the boil so that the change in temperature remains gradual, the frog does not realise it’s boiling to death. In line with their – soon to be – new mates in New Labour, Sinn Féin had swallowed TINA – there is no alternative. Plan A – armed struggle has failed, now we try Plan B. In Sinn Fein’s case, this meant the long march through the institutions, acceptance of the principle of consent and parliamentary reformism on the classical constitutional nationalist model. McAliskey had the temerity to ask for a Plan C, which might mean retaining socialist republican principles and challenging the powerful rather than getting into bed with them.

The curious thing is that almost at the very same time, the powerful used a similar analogy and proposed the peace process as a way of luring Sinn Féin like lobsters into a pot during negotiations for the second ceasefire. Recently released papers acknowledged that Sinn Fein would have to bring the movement with them by remaining ‘faithful to the republican myth’. Quentin Thomas, linkman for the powerful, compiled a 1996 confidential report entitled: ‘The Next Ceasefire: Toasted Feet, the Lobster Pot and Parity of Esteem’, which sought to ‘defeat terrorism’ and ‘co-opt’ Sinn Fein. Thomas viewed Sinn Féin as ‘authoritarian, absolutist, conspiratorial and intransigent’ and recognised that it must ‘maintain fidelity to its past’ and to the ‘republican myth, of which it claims guardianship in this and future generations.’ Thomas concluded that ‘nobody volunteers to have his feet held to the fire… but lobsters can be lured into the pot’ (Belfast Telegraph, 26 January 2024).

Thomas spoke about the ‘peace process’ or as republicans in the 1990s came to know it the ‘strategy’ as an ‘orderly retreat’ by a movement which accepted that it could not achieve its objectives militarily. We might reflect on a near parallel acceptance by the ANC in South Africa and the PLO in Palestine that with the ‘end of history’ came the realisation that peace would be sought and achieved on the terms of the global hegemon – the USA. In South Africa, this led to the end of political apartheid but the entrenchment of racial inequality and neo-liberal capital. In Palestine, it led to the Versailles of Oslo and Arafat’s death in a bunker in Ramallah and, ultimately, today’s genocide in Gaza. In Ireland, it heralded a generation of political stasis, where the working-class community that backboned the republican struggle could arguably to be said to be in a worse position today than twenty years ago.

The ‘strategy’s’ apparent high point arrived last week, the election of a woman who calls herself a republican to the joint-equal leadership of a glorified county council, with no discernible power. Indeed, a dark shadow was cast on the recent proceedings at Stormont by the news that our monarch is suffering for cancer – thankfully it was caught early by excellent highly-paid private doctors while NHS cancer waiting times here break new records each quarter. The typical SF response is that it is better to be inside Stormont helping to solve these problems than outside shouting in. Yet, this ignores that the ‘powerful’ twenty-five years ago, still hold all the power today. We are still under British rule and the ‘strategy’ is to beg the British for more money to pay for services in an economy ravaged by British austerity that our glorious institutions administered on Britain’s behalf. The border poll will be called at the whim of the British Secretary of State since the conditions have never been nailed down. A procession of unaccountable secretaries of state has unilaterally broken elements of the Good Friday Agreement since Peter Mandelson’s tenure twenty years ago – and Jeff Epstein’s buddy will have a big say in the next British government if the polls are to be believed.

There are several reasons why Sinn Féin more than any other party should be taken to task for this. The first is that attacking the SDLP would be like harpooning a corpse. Sinn Féin, to all intents and purposes, cannibalised the SDLP – they are a northern constitutional nationalist party with pretensions to government in the South. This reflects the second reason, Sinn Fein’s, currently waning, popularity in the Free State is not based on the 1990’s ‘strategy’ but represents the political outworking of the 2008 financial crash and the popular outrage at the resuscitated broken social model that the political establishment reassembled after the 60 billion+ bank bail outs. Sinn Féin’s support emerges from a sizeable section of society locked out of the Celtic Tiger’s irretrievable social contract which is demanding an overhaul of Irish society based on social equality and democratic accountability. Great say my friends in Sinn Féin, and I do have some, we will fix this as we govern north and south as part of the transition to a New Ireland. This represents the third reason for taking Sinn Fein to task – their modus operandi or Third Way triangulation, opportunism and real politick is incapable of delivering the necessary transformation because the are beholden to the ‘powerful’.

When Gerry Adams recently claimed that Sinn Fein must go the White House and that anyone ever engaged in real serious struggle would understand why, he was claiming ‘guardianship’ of the republican struggle. Other Sinn Fein members called those who opposed their decision Trots. Indeed, the unequal political rivalry between Sinn Fein and People Before Profit often serves as a stick to beat anyone who questions SF’s position on Palestine or indeed the economy or Stormont. Yet, Sinn Féin have performed several volte face in the recent past, such as the decision before Christmas to call for the expulsion of the Israeli ambassador. I have no doubt PBP are using Palestine and other matters as wedge issues to generate support, but they only tend to gain any traction if PBP’s position resonates with wider left-wing sentiment.

In October, when PBP and others called Sinn Fein out on the Israeli ambassador’s expulsion, Pat Sheehan sardonically tweeted ‘I stand in absolute awe of their revolutionary credentials’ (Twitter, 28 October 2023). Pat courageously took part in the 1981 hungerstrike, forty-three years ago. More recently, last summer in fact, he put down three rental properties on Stormont’s register of member’s interests. In the intervening period, Pat has transformed from IRA hunger striker to revolutionary private landlord. But this is not a personal attack on Pat, whom I do not know, or his colleague Colm Gildernew who three days ago tweeted a picture of his mother participating in the 1968 Caledon squat which led to the first ever Civil Rights march from Coalisland to Dungannon. To be fair to Colm he only receives rental income on one property. The point is that a party which brandishes revolutionary credentials and claims guardianship over the republican legacy can’t have elected members as landlords and then claim that it seeks to overturn the inequitable property system in Ireland. It can’t pretend to be a socialist party and then stand up for the interests of private property – although to be fair to SF they’re not on their own there!

Sinn Fein are going to Washington to raise funds amongst wealthy Irish Americans who are fully ensconced in the global hegemon’s empire. They are happy to validate Joe Biden because they sense that US support will facilitate their border poll – they might be less fortunate if Trump wins in the autumn, which looks increasingly likely. In 2015, the then Prince Charles visited St Patrick’s chapel in Belfast, outside of which Orange thugs routinely played the Famine Song and similar sectarian thrash. Martin McGuinness was inside as Deputy-First Minister while Gerry Kelly stood outside supporting the families of the Ballymurphy Massacre victims. Sinn Fein wants to be inside and outside the tent at once, but as one of my favourite radical humanists of all time once said: No one can serve two masters. Either you will hate the one and love the other, or you will be devoted to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve both the Irish working class and their exploiters – the powerful. You cannot build a society based on republican ethics like, civic virtue, democracy and accountability on hypocrisy, double speak and backroom deals with the powerful. I’d say that when they land for the Paddy’s Day party the menu will have a distinctly French theme – frogs’ legs and Lobster Thermidor!

While operating as an emissary for the Irish Republic after the Easter Rising, Liam Mellows quickly identified the USA as an unworthy ally for Irish republicanism, since it ‘has been the grave of the Irish race’, where journalism had descended to accounts of fiction and English airgead ran like water. In November 1917, he wrote to his brother that ‘the sooner the people of Ireland turn their eyes away from and give up hope of securing their independence through this tír the better. It is all cant, hypocrisy and big talk–bluff from start to finish and can at present be only compared to Russia previous to Revolution.’ Mellows identified the domination of ‘Trusts and capitalists who have through their large English interests bulldozed this tír into the War. The trusts and capitalists run politics here. The whole system – commercial, financial, legal and social is built on graft [corruption]. Honesty is an unknown quantity. The bigger the bluff, the greater the man. The greater the rogue, the wealthier respected and protected’(Liam Mellows to Barney Mellows, 4 Nov. 1917).

I know a lot of people involved in Sinn Féin and they are sincere and genuine republicans and mostly socialists. I am delighted that a working-class woman from East Tyrone has achieved the highest electoral office, even if I would take greater delight in converting that monolith to Orange supremacy into carpark or better still free-at-the -point-of-care a nursing home. Mine is a structural argument that ironically (given SF’s discourse) partially mirrors Trotsky’s criticism of Stalinism to portray Sinn Fein as a bureaucracy, unresponsive to internal democracy which deploys former revolutionary prestige as an ideological stick to beat dissent from the left. A prominent SF politician once whispered to me excitedly that Sinn Fein isn’t a party it’s like an army – that’s the problem.

We have been here before. Fianna Fail emerged from an army that realised that it could not be militarily successful and then pursued the constitutional road carrying much of the Irish working class in its populist train. After the Great Depression, Dev came to power on a radical manifesto and attempted to develop a domestic market to sustain the workforce and small farmers, without harming the larger farmers and Seoinín interest – an impossibility. All of this was based on de Valera’s cross-class nationalism, and we should be mindful that Sinn Féin will not do the same when Mary Lou is Taoiseach. Without class struggle, Dev’s finance minister, Belfast man and renowned misogynist, Sean McEntee left credit and investment under the auspices of private banks ensuring that they invested in London’s financial market rather than at home. Both Irish banks and the Department of Finance vigorously opposed the alternative – affordable credit to boost indigenous growth but a weaker Irish pound. (McCabe, 2014: 142). Fianna Fail did, however, build houses and in the process ensured their dynasty. Between 1932-9, Dublin Corporation built 6,019 cottages, half of them in Crumlin. In total, local councils built 100,000 homes in Ireland between 1898 and 1948, and 80,000 were built privately with the help of the state – 65% under the Dev regime (McCabe, 2014:26). After meeting with Eoin Ó Broin, Sinn Fein’s potential minister for housing last year, one of the biggest private construction firms in the South told the media:

I don’t believe Sinn Féin have this magic wand that homes are going to become affordable if they get into power. They will potentially increase the state’s resources in housing, But again, if you look at the Housing for All strategy by the government, that’s what they’re trying to do…If Sinn Féin get into power, there will be more state involvement in housing investment. We’re a delivery vehicle for homes. If Sinn Féin’s policy is that we want to bring more affordable homes, we’re happy to play our part in that.” (Business Post, 2 July 2023)

Fianna Fail did not tackle vested interests but rather Lemass, another misogynist of note, found a way to increase the South’s industrial base without increasing the tax base through foreign direct investment (FDI). Yet FDI did not return wealth to the country’s economy, rather the banks and property developers made their profits from servicing those FDI companies (McCabe, 2014:99). In addition, under Lemass, Irish people paid twice for the same house, once with the grants and exemption to make private housing “affordable” and then the taxpayer had to get a mortgage priced higher because of government support for the developer! (McCabe, 2014:33). The Southern economy is still based on the servicing of FDI and building property.

The PAYE system, which was first introduced in the late 1950s, became a cash flow for the government. The income generated by the direct taxation of ordinary workers was syphoned to speculators and foreign investors through tax havens. Construction, finance, land and law stood as the four pillars of Lemass’s economy and the tide was certainly high if you sat on any of these boats (McCabe, 2014:248) The two largest Irish companies (both linked to construction) merged in 1970 under the chairmanship – believe it or not – of Seán Lemass. Desmond Traynor (Charlie Haughey’s banker) was one of the directors. (McCabe, 2014:109) In February 1967, Charlie Haughey established Taca in Dublin as a Fianna Fáil funding group whose offices were on Amiens Street, in the same building as Charlies’ accountancy firm. Desmond Traynor joined them afterwards. For Fianna Fail to criticise Sinn Fein for its funding model is a bit rich from the party which forged the Golden Circle out of vice and naked self-interest (McCabe, 2014: 113). Yet , this is where Plan B invariably takes populist nationalist movements.

As a result, Ireland has suffered a series of speculative property bubbles since, but, in the late 1980s, Haughey also opened the doors to an international Tax Haven along the Docks in Dublin. The Finance, Insurance and Real Estate jobs created to service these tax dodgers and the expansion of the pre-2008 property boom did mean that ‘a real economic miracle occurred in Ireland, with very rapid employment and productivity growth during the years 1984 to 2000 (McCann, 2011:197) In the second phase of the Tiger, however, a quarter of the southern Irish economy was made up of a baseless property market that relied on debt. Inflation under Charlie McCreevy rose at twice the rate of Ireland’s European partners. Prices in Ireland in 2004 were 28% higher than they were when McCreevy took office in 1997; corresponding figure for the EU stood at 14% (McCann, 2011: 205-6). In 2002, the 400 southerners with the highest incomes [not the greatest amount of wealth] were surveyed. Six of them managed not to pay a penny of tax at all. 43 owed less than 5%. 79 paid less than 15%. Conversely, only 83 paid more than 40%, indeed no one paid more than 45%. The largest rate of tax for PAYE workers in the same year was 42% (McCann, 2011: 209). There is no indication that Sinn Fein intends to systematically overhaul the tax system, properly regulate the property market or close tax loopholes. After their surprise success in the 2020 election, Pearse Doherty, the prospective Finance Minister, publicly stated that ‘Big business and investors know Sinn Féin won’t go after them’ (Irish Independent, 10 October 2021).

Sinn Fein appears to be triangulating towards a position of tinkering with welfare provision and using the process of reunification to rule from the centre, while maintaining its base. In autumn 2008, the FF/Green coalition pledged all the state’s resources as collateral to 6 private banks. The country was now liable for approximately €400 billion in loans, amid a recession in the aftermath of the property bubble explosion (McCabe, 2014: 194) The Irish government then committed €64.1 billion to the banks and a further €31.6 billion on bad loans in NAMA. A year later, the state had to take a €67.5 billion “bailout” from the Troika because of fears in Brussels and Berlin that the Irish economic disease would spread through the entire European Union (McCabe, 2014:215). Fine Gael who has always stood up for wealth have no issue with this. Fianna Fáil’s position appears less secure, however. A populist party with a strong grassroots labour vote, but one funded by banking interests and property developers. FF could not rescue its financial supporters while retaining its working-class vote. After several punts on Labour, and the Greens the working class appears to have settled on Sinn Féin. This explains Micheal Martin’s hatred for the Shinners. He describes this as the contrast between his own party and Sinn Féin’s socialism which challenges the entrepreneurial basis of the Irish economy. But there is no such system, the economic elite in the South are as grey and boring as their professions: stockbrokers, accountants, bankers and lawyers (Irish Times, 11 September 2023). Yet, there does not appear to any such socialist threat either.

Sinn Féin’s modus operandi claims that they can build a new Ireland without a class struggle. Yet, they owe their political position to working class discontent. In the North, their strategy appears to be to boost the subvention from Westminster and use access to the EU single market to generate growth, specifically in FDI. Few now remember Peter Robinson, perhaps his title in the Lords will have something to do with the Isle of Mann, and Martin McGuinness petitioning George Osborne, the creature who imposed austerity, for a reduction in the North’s corporation tax rate in 2011. Osborne agreed if he could cut the block grant by £385 million a year (Belfast Telegraph, 17 June 2011). The Stormont parties are now entering negotiations with Whitehall to raise the fiscal floor, i.e. increase the ratio of government spending per head in the North due to the area’s location as the most deprived part of the UK. The British are talking about £124 while the Stormont parties are pushing for between £127-130 compared to every £100 spent in England. We can anticipate pay rises from the £3 billion bribe that brought the executive back and then, hopefully, the announcement of a long-term budget in health and education on the transitional models outlined in the now decade old Bengoa report and the more recent apocalyptic educational report which came out before Christmas. Only a fully funded transition will mean that these reforms can be achieved without exacerbating the existing social crisis.

The observant reader will note that the Stormont executive returned in large part due to pressure from trade unions, both in 2024 and 2020. They might also note that issues such as the Irish Language Act and other equality issues were forced through in large part because of popular democratic pressure. Added to this, as the prospective party of government North and South, we can see that across a range of issues, from Palestine to the Irish Language, to Water Charges and even their initial abstentions on the bank bailouts, Sinn Fein, while not internally democratic, is amenable to democratic pressure. The reality of politics in a liberal democratic framework is that there is a massive democratic deficit. Vested class interests occupy the high political ground and dictate the course of policy – the banking crisis made this clear to all. Yet, anyone who considers themselves a socialist or even a republican for that matter realises that only radical change and real democracy can address the underlying causes of social problems – all inextricably linked to Capital. For all the grovelling to monarchs or partying with imperialists, this democratic reality persists – as Mellows stated, the Republic ‘stands not for an Ireland within the British Empire, not for the acceptance of doles from the British government, not for a so-called freedom tied up in Imperial swaddling clothes, but it does stand for an Ireland free and independent from sea to sea, unshackled, unfettered, as the good God made it… The Irish people are a force in the world today, a force for good, a force for democracy, for Ireland at this moment presents the spectacle of being one of the most democratic countries in the world’.

This is the Plan C – popular democratic struggle as witnessed across the North and indeed Britain since this cost-of-living crisis kicked in. Every political party operates some form of democratic centralism, Sinn Fein or PBP get hammered for it because of their left-wing orientation. What matters is who controls the purse strings and who calls the shots. The Plan A of impotent militarism cannot create a democratic future, although the powerful have forced it on the Irish people across our history. The Plan B of constitutional reformism resembles the hamster on the historical wheel, turning but making little forward progress. Plan C opens a democratic path of mobilisation and participation, building political consciousness across solid democratic, republican and socialist principles in co-operation where possible but in conflict where necessary with vested interests represented by the state. The nature of this island is changing and the powerful wish to manage the project. History suggests that Sinn Fein will perform the function of elite proxy, but the contradictions in their own position and the genuine socialism and anti-imperialism of their own members leaves room for manoeuvre. For socialists and republicans in the tradition of Liam Mellows, the path is clear : any New Ireland must tackle the capitalist class interests that dominate our own country and wreak imperial havoc across the globe.

Conor McCabe, Money, Cork University Press, 2018.

Conor McCabe, Sins of the Father: Tracing the Decisions that Shaped the Irish Economy, Cheltenham, The History Press, 2014.

Curtis, Liz, Ireland: The Propaganda War – The British Media and the Battle for Hearts and Minds, London, Pluto, 1984

Gerard McCann, Ireland’s Economic History: Crisis and Development in the North and South, London, Pluto, 2011.

Denis O’Hearn, Inside the Celtic Tiger, London, Pluto, 1998.

⏩Fearghal Mac Bhloscaidh is a Belfast-based historian and the author of a number of important books, including Tyrone: the Irish Revolution, 1912-1923 (Four Courts Press, 2014).

“Frogs’ Legs And Lobster Thermidor – Or The ABC Of Republican Strategy”