Anthony McIntyre  Last night's savage attack in North Belfast in which a man was seriously injured has been described as an attempted beheading.


In this part of the world head chopping is viewed with visceral anathema which might go some way to explaining the revulsion that is said to be saturating Belfast at the moment. Speaking to a former republican prisoner this afternoon I learned that people from the nationalist community are furious, with some talking about joining protests this evening. He will not be turning up.

Not that he is opposed to standing with others in opposition to knife crime. He is not prepared to stand against colour and demonise people of a different skin tone from himself. He made the point that knife crime is nothing new in Belfast, reminding me that the nationalist community was terrorised for years in the 1970s by the Shankill Butchers, who came as close as is imaginable to beheading some of their victims.

On the back of that exchange, in a later conversation with a former member of Sinn Fein I caustically commented that it seemed Lenny Murphy was back in Belfast stalking the streets of North Belfast. He suggested an alternative knife man - the one who butchered Robert McCartney in a Markets bar twenty one years ago.

In recent years I have attended several protests against knife crime, only one of which involved head chopping. On that occasion the person responsible was reported to be a man by the name of Robbie Lawlor who was later murdered not far from the scene of last night's incident. The people who gathered on Drogheda's West Street appalled at the murder of Keane Mulready Woods genuinely opposed the killing. They were not on the street because they did not like the skin colour of the killer. 

The person arrested on suspicion of last night's attack is reported by the PSNI to be a Sudanese national. That has kickstarted a surge in anti-immigrant rhetoric from quarters which were much less vociferous when Ian Ogle was knifed to death in Belfast in 2019. Ogle's killers, because they identified as white and British, did not provoke the same rabid outcry that we are familiar with when the attacker is a different colour. The Irish News has reported that 'far-right activist Tommy Robinson and tech billionaire Elon Musk amplified calls for people to take to the streets in response to the incident.'

We can therefore expect the type of hatred that flowed onto the streets in Ballymena last year. We can also expect that amongst those who will block the roads to oppose colour rather than crime will be some who gathered at Scarva at the weekend in support of genocide in Gaza. Brutal murder is not something that taxes them too much. Rather than call for last night's attacker to be executed they could demand he be conscripted into the IDF - ready made, no training necessary.

Last night's attack was brutal and savage. There is no mitigation. Whatever about immigration policy, its rights and wrongs, people's concerns and fears, the policy is hardly any more responsible for last night's savagery than it is for the savagery that ended Ian Ogle's life. 

As the writer Louth For Ever commented on Bluesky:

fascists exploiting a crime are not protesters with concerns . . . They are the organised far right, and the failure to say so plainly is the failure that lets them launder street violence into legitimate grievance.

 

Follow on Bluesky.

Protesting Colour Not Crime

Anthony McIntyre  Last night's savage attack in North Belfast in which a man was seriously injured has been described as an attempted beheading.


In this part of the world head chopping is viewed with visceral anathema which might go some way to explaining the revulsion that is said to be saturating Belfast at the moment. Speaking to a former republican prisoner this afternoon I learned that people from the nationalist community are furious, with some talking about joining protests this evening. He will not be turning up.

Not that he is opposed to standing with others in opposition to knife crime. He is not prepared to stand against colour and demonise people of a different skin tone from himself. He made the point that knife crime is nothing new in Belfast, reminding me that the nationalist community was terrorised for years in the 1970s by the Shankill Butchers, who came as close as is imaginable to beheading some of their victims.

On the back of that exchange, in a later conversation with a former member of Sinn Fein I caustically commented that it seemed Lenny Murphy was back in Belfast stalking the streets of North Belfast. He suggested an alternative knife man - the one who butchered Robert McCartney in a Markets bar twenty one years ago.

In recent years I have attended several protests against knife crime, only one of which involved head chopping. On that occasion the person responsible was reported to be a man by the name of Robbie Lawlor who was later murdered not far from the scene of last night's incident. The people who gathered on Drogheda's West Street appalled at the murder of Keane Mulready Woods genuinely opposed the killing. They were not on the street because they did not like the skin colour of the killer. 

The person arrested on suspicion of last night's attack is reported by the PSNI to be a Sudanese national. That has kickstarted a surge in anti-immigrant rhetoric from quarters which were much less vociferous when Ian Ogle was knifed to death in Belfast in 2019. Ogle's killers, because they identified as white and British, did not provoke the same rabid outcry that we are familiar with when the attacker is a different colour. The Irish News has reported that 'far-right activist Tommy Robinson and tech billionaire Elon Musk amplified calls for people to take to the streets in response to the incident.'

We can therefore expect the type of hatred that flowed onto the streets in Ballymena last year. We can also expect that amongst those who will block the roads to oppose colour rather than crime will be some who gathered at Scarva at the weekend in support of genocide in Gaza. Brutal murder is not something that taxes them too much. Rather than call for last night's attacker to be executed they could demand he be conscripted into the IDF - ready made, no training necessary.

Last night's attack was brutal and savage. There is no mitigation. Whatever about immigration policy, its rights and wrongs, people's concerns and fears, the policy is hardly any more responsible for last night's savagery than it is for the savagery that ended Ian Ogle's life. 

As the writer Louth For Ever commented on Bluesky:

fascists exploiting a crime are not protesters with concerns . . . They are the organised far right, and the failure to say so plainly is the failure that lets them launder street violence into legitimate grievance.

 

Follow on Bluesky.

7 comments:

  1. Maybe I am wrong but I doubt it----Seems there is more "trouble" in Loyalist areas and Republican areas...

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anthony, I wrote this yesterday morning before reading this article

    "Watch the talking heads evoke the Shankill Butchers to show how we have always multilated eachother in Belfast, and that racists only care about getting their head cut off by a blackman, not a white Lenny Murphy type."

    I dont think you are a talking head btw, just highly predictable.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. DaithiD - funny old world.

      The former blanketman I was speaking to yesterday, referred to in the piece, made the point that, predictably, the far right would be up in arms about any mention of the Shankill Butchers.

      The nationalist cultural memory in the North will always equate head choppers with the Shankill Butchers. It is deeply rooted in the collective experience.

      Predictability is the outworking of consistency so it worthwhile to be seen as consistent. That which is predictable gels with the scientific method, something else I find beneficial.

      But in fairness to the little Englanders and their fellow bigots they too are predictable. Like filth flies they will gather around the excrement of racism. And so we saw it come to pass last night when the hate mobs, partly in response to the English criminal and racist Tommy Robinson, went on a repeat of what they did to nationalists in 1969 - burned them out. Criminals engaged in criminal activity are hardly well placed to be protesting against crime.

      Delete
  3. Simon comments

    Simon comments

    Republicans should never take the lead from these loyalist cretins.

    They would burn Nationalists out too given half a chance.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Anthony, the point is more using the murders you mentioned give an ill fitting context, you used to be fond of saying context is alibi after all.

    With the McCartney murder, the Shankill Butchers and Mulready Woods, to effectively assign those tragedies to individuals carrying out a continuation of random violence, with no interrogation of the wider structures shaping them (legacy paramilitaries/paramilitaries/gangland feuds), would miss a large part of why they occured, and crucially hinder prevention of more in the future. It seems you are unable to examine the possible common factors of this and another case in court the day after, that of the Parnell square attacker Bouchaker, because joining the dots would be racist. They must be simply random mental health cases that we have had a lot of in Ireland before after all, nothing to learn here.

    Without introspection, how would we know we are not being consistently wrong each time our idealism has a rude awakening with reality?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. DaithiD,

      Context is alibi.

      Alibi can be true or false.

      The context being presented by racists is a false alibi.

      So enlighten us as to the legacy context of the McCartney killing. A thug with a penchant for knives who went on to stab another guy a few years after he stabbed Robert McCartney.

      Enlighten us on the legacy context of the Keane Mulready Woods murder, dismemberment and decapitation. Killed and chopped up by a criminal gang with absolutely no connection to republicanism.

      Enlighten us to the legacy context of the Shankill Butcher murders. A psychotic gang of sectarian bigots whose psychopathic behaviour extended to members of their own community. And now one of them is marching in opposition to head chopping.

      Racists join dots to manufacture patterns to justify their racism. Yet they leave out more dots than they join for the purpose of making a Procrustean bed. The Bouchaker dots can be joined to Alan Hawe but you chose not to. Crime by immigrants in Ireland is no more than crime by Irish citizens.

      Last year in Ballymena there was more crime committed by racists in three days than the immigrants probably commit in a year.

      You don't want the dots joined between the Shankill Butchers and the maniac the other evening because it disrupts your racist narrative.

      So try a little introspection rather than pontificating to others about it. Here is a nudge in the right direction for you - the English criminal Tommy Robinson calls for protests. The type who respond are pigs from the same sow as those who burned the Quinn children. And they tried to do the same in Belfast last night. The protestors were not on the streets to vent their anger at the crime in Kinnaird Avenue but to vent their hatred at the colour of the thug who perpetrated that violence. The burning of homes with children in them is as bad if not worse a crime than that in Kinnaird Avenue - the protestors did not turn on those who carried it out.

      So try a little introspection. It might just help you to grasp that you have been consistently wrong in all your years of anti immigrant commentary on this blog.

      You have not been on the blog in a while and then turn up to shill for the racists. Go figure.

      Delete
  5. DaithiD,

    In a few weeks normal order will be restored and the same thugs who burnt families out of their homes last night will be burning the Irish flag and singing songs about being up to their knees in Fenian blood and walking were they aren't wanted...

    ReplyDelete