Showing posts with label Sarah Kay. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sarah Kay. Show all posts
Sarah Kay ✊ In 1985, at the height of the Cold War, British singer Sting wrote a protest song against mutual nuclear deterrence. 

Calling upon reason, which was scarce at the time, he pleaded to understand that no one is above another – that we all fear death, violence, that we all want the same thing for our children. We all, supposedly, do. We all, supposedly, work toward a society in which they would grow up free and happy.

The Belfast pogroms have tested that theory in two different ways. The non-issue of asylum has been fascinating the United Kingdom, and Ireland, in the most negative way possible. A population ranking under 2%, asylum-seekers have become targets of the most violent of acts, including burning people alive. The Belfast attacker was a 30 year old from Sudan. This was a call to review immigration and our role toward those under international protection. It’s in the name: asylum is not regulated domestically as much as it is the product of a post-war treaty that was meant to address the consequences of the 1936 Nüremberg laws – statelessnesss - and provide for the millions of displaced in Europe: refuge, the right to seek safety and protection.

The current genocide in Sudan should horrify us all. A consequence of the 1994 Rwanda genocide and the 2003 genocide in Darfur, Sudan is suffering unprecedented levels of conflict-related sexual violence. In 2024, Volker Türk, the High Commissioner for Human Rights, commented that:

(The RSF) have killed thousands, seemingly without remorse. They have manufactured a climate of sheer terror, forcing millions to flee. They have let the people who could not - or would not - escape, suffer, destroying medical services and blocking humanitarian aid. 

Ignoring that Sudanese people should indeed be under international protection is dehumanisation on a state scale.

But there are other genocides – in Palestine, in Congo, in Armenia – where the horror continues to unfold; sometimes live streamed into our phones, sometimes spoken about at the tail end of news reports. In 2025, the Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights announced:

In other areas under M23 control in South Kivu, such as Minova, M23 has occupied schools and hospitals, forced IDPs out of camps and subjected the civilian population to forced conscription and forced labour. Additionally, DRC officials report that at least 165 women were raped by male inmates during the prison break by more than 4,000 inmates from Goma’s Muzenze prison on 27 January, as M23 began its assault on the town.

 As Sting then said, “there’s no such thing as a winnable war, it’s a lie we don’t believe anymore.”

But migration isn’t only about seeking asylum; it is the oldest, and most important, human behaviour. Since the beginning of human civilisation, we have migrated: to find food, to find land, to find water. We have migrated, even more importantly, to find shelter. Through this migration, Darwin’s theory of evolution brought us here, to the point where Jim Crow laws on segregation, a source of nostalgy in many European countries, can become a biological issue. Migration isn’t and will never be a crime, because we have all migrated one way or another in our lives: we studied abroad; we did a work away visa; we visited a friend and overstayed our welcome; we decided to check out a new city because Belfast felt too small. All of this is migration. Moving back with your parents in Dundalk because you couldn’t find a job in the city is a micro form of migration; you wouldn’t have it removed from you. Migration is not the issue; racism is. Only one category of people is allowed to migrate and doing so on the assumption that their chosen form of immigration is the only valid one. Ending immigration has never helped any public deficit or crumbling institutions, in fact, it’s been demonstrated time and time again that immigration has immense economic benefits.

As Sting said again, here’s no monopoly on common sense on either side of the political fence. We believe that those seeking asylum made a choice. We believe that migrants all inherently are bad faith actors in an otherwise open and thriving community. We deny the simple fact of genocide and the direct consequences of global exploitation leading to global inequality. We have no moral or ethical right to denounce what we would continue doing to ourselves: criminal exploitation. Paramilitary recruitment, drug trade, all of which show cruel child neglect in the name of scoring political points. Wouldn’t we want a different future for them, too?

⏩ Sarah Kay is an international human rights lawyer now described as “an unusual and extraordinary threat to the national security and foreign policy of the United States” . . . again.

Do We Love Our Children Too?

Sarah Kay ✊ Several months ago, my phone vibrated against the marble countertops of my kitchen, with several Signal notifications appearing on the lock screen. 

“Am I okay?” my friend and colleague MP texted. “Where should I go? Am I going to end up on a list?” I sighed, grabbed my phone and texted back, “you’re fine. I don’t think you need to go anywhere.” I hesitantly put the phone down, thinking I probably sounded overly dismissive, and texted again. “Plus if you were to be on a list, I’m sure you already are anyway. So keep on doing your thing!” Somehow, it didn’t reassure MP as much as it should have.

On Thursday, an oversensitive and emotional rich white man penned an irrational and disorganised Executive Order, the only actions he seems able to take, not being fully cognisant of what governance requires. The long text, penned without Microsoft Word’s grammatical assistance, is a monumental brick aimed at the glass windows of the International Criminal Court. A full 6,159km (I googled it) from the site of this Executive Order, issued by a country not a member of the governing treaty, the Court is not particularly impressed. It did not stop its work in 2020, and it will not in 2025. However, the language is much broader than the previous sanctions issued back then, which “only” targeted the General Prosecutor and the Office of the Tribunal Prosecutor (OTP).

This time, under the watchful eye of alleged war criminal and genocidaire Benyamin Netanyahu, Trump decided to declare the Court - that, again, the US is not even a part of - “illegitimate”. Seeing that this poor judgement call had little to no effect on a profession that does not recognise the legitimacy of Donald Trump, the only escalation possible was the use of force now targeting international law as a whole. Note that, at no point, in this Order, is Trump asserting the ICC did not have a legal basis to claim territorial jurisdiction over Palestine, or had no legal basis to issue arrest warrants against Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Gallant. It just spat out “legitimacy” as a supremely subjective concept. But of course, the eyebrows were raised over the “dangerous precedent” Trump claims the ICC attempts to set.

As usual, the far right is engulfed with rage over the most basic display of accountability. The precedent is one of possible oversight, and provided us with this Napoleon-esque decision-making: “The United States will impose tangible and significant consequences on those responsible for the ICC’s transgressions” (of what?) ranging from asset seizures to travel bans. Section I (ii) A-C clearly extends to any international lawyer, not a US resident, having participated in any of the investigations, evidence gathering missions, and analysis conducted by the ICC against Israel and against the United States (in case anyone forgot about the Afghanistan investigation). This Order targets not just a few, but hundreds of legal professionals and scholars. It places particular stress on those of us who have worked for, in, or around commissions of inquiry and reside all over the United States.

For the avoidance of doubt, let me make very clear that this will not impact the work of the Court; it never did. It will not affect the work of the General Prosecutor; it never did. It will never lead to a withdrawal of those arrest warrants; this won’t even be considered. In his rush to flex his non-existent muscles against what causes him a slight inconvenience, Trump forgot that not everyone is watching, or is interested in watching. Stating elsewhere in the document that “the United States remains committed to accountability and the peaceful cultivation (sic) of international order” is only worth the quality of the whitehouse dot gov website this was published in. “The ICC and parties to the Rome Statute must respect the decisions of the United States” is risible, “and not subject their personnel to the ICC’s jurisdiction” makes me wonder if the Attorney General has indeed even read the Order. Trump seems to confuse “sovereign prerogative” with “royal prerogative”, demonstrated by his unilateral dismantlement of a Republic he wants to turn into a nuclear wasteland.

From Thursday, we are all under a 60-day notice waiting on a decision regarding who will be directly named by the Treasury, and how section I will apply to our collective visas. For those residing within the United States, this may mean contingency plans, preservation of assets, international protection; this will inevitably result in a paralysis of legal action within the United States. It will deprive the country of its best and brightest, will dim the influence of the United States on the world stage, and continue to enshrine it as a threat to the global rule of law. Trump’s quest for absolute isolationism will sicken, starve, and endanger the country. If any of those preliminary statements about the ICC’s role, jurisdiction, and scope were true, nothing is stopping the US from joining the Rome Statute and taking part in the Assembly of State Parties (ASPs), saying what it needs to say where and when it matters. Alas, this would require some introspection, and probably some legal advice on the risks of accepting territorial jurisdiction.

It seems that, for an illegitimate body, the ICC is terrifying this administration. I, for one, am grateful that it is now acknowledged by Executive Order that our collective legal work, worldwide, has irritated a despot. It is the reason why people like MP and myself have become lawyers: to be witnesses of violence, but with the capacity to act against it. Thanks for the ammunition, Donald.

⏩ Sarah Kay is an international human rights lawyer now described as “an unusual and extraordinary threat to the national security and foreign policy of the United States” . . . again

Sanctioned

Sarah Kay ✊ The first thing I want to say is that I don’t even know where to start.


Somewhere near Bastille, off Boulevard Richard-Lenoir, is a small street without any pretension or, until then, historical significance. Mere walking minutes from the beating, pulsating heart of French identity, stand beige buildings, post-war architecture, with unadorned windows and empty balconies. The traffic of the boulevard is heard faintly during rush hour, but after shops close, it returns to an almost suburban quietness. The backstreets of the 11th district have a lot to share. Rue Nicolas-Appert, ten years ago, was temporarily renamed Rue de La Liberté d’Expression (Freedom of Expression Street).

I grew up with Charlie Hebdo. I grew up with Le Canard Enchaîné. I grew up with old school, sometimes crass, often biting, satirical press. From them I learned critical thought, and the stubborn refusal to yield to power, no matter how democratic. I learned that what happens in the hallowed halls of said power is not necessarily more important or more solemn than fundamental freedoms, including that of opinion, expression, and information. I learned that dissent can be funny; that pompous ceremony is hardly a celebration; and that we should all, if we believe in said freedoms, always remain vigilant. No matter how stable the nation, no matter how safeguarded the human rights, nothing, or no one, is ever safe.

The second thing I want to say is that my memories of ten years ago have no sound.

History came to Charlie Hebdo, and I have never stopped thinking Charb would have hated it. He hated it in 2011, when the firebombing of 2011 forced him under police protection. In 2012, someone called for Charb’s beheading online. In 2013, Al-Qaeda put Charb on its “most wanted” list. The constant reminder of violence and the presence of uniforms in a magazine’s editorial office ring odd, uncomfortable, because unnatural. Can the press truly be free under the watchful eye of its detractors and of the state? Some had then argued, cynically, that liberty has a price, but the cost is unaffordable. If this means leaving behind Charb, Cabu, Tignous, and others, it is unacceptable. This isn’t a contract through which any of us can willingly engage. It is not a debate. It is not a disagreement, it is not even a conflict. It is silence. Silence that has enveloped the district in diffused pain, almost ashamed of its gaping wound: the pens that were now lying on the floor of the magazine offices, covered in blood, next to those who had huddled under desks for the longest ten minutes of their existence.


We know the story. A tragic two-day manhunt resulting in a hostage crisis and the trial by bullet of the gunmen, two brothers who claimed to have killed in the name of Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula (AQAP) with weapons supplied from Belgium. France will then plunge into deep counter-terrorism waters, yet barely had 10 months’ reprieve before the next terror attack that would then change the country forever, and for the worse. In this interim, the legislation stopped solely relying on the 1905 principle of laïcité, a French exemption to the typical understanding of freedom of religion, which imposes state secularity. It created the criminalisation of what it called “apology for terrorism”, ie. its support or endorsement; it limited reporting on national security and defense matters; it demanded complete and total subjugation to a new order, in which prevention of radicalisation and extremism would exceed its constitutional ambitions to preserve speech and opinion at all costs. What Charlie fought for seems to have vanished with them, somewhere, indeed, between Bastille and République.

We should never forget them, and never forget that Charlie Hebdo’s refusal to bend the knee wasn’t reactionary, or disrespectful. It was foreshadowing what the world had become, and would continue to cement: a timid, non-confrontational analysis of world events. I often ponder what Charb would think of France today, under Le Pen’s spell, causing chaos in the Assemblée, unable to find its place in an increasingly polarised world. The silence is deafening.

A week after the shooting, on the 14th of January, Charlie Hebdo rose again in an act of defiance. The Prophet Muhammad is depicted on a green background, holding a pen, and shedding a tear. “Tout est pardonné”, “All is forgiven”, the front page read. It ran almost 8 million copies worldwide.

Pour Cabu, Elsa Cayat, Wolinski, Charb, Philippe Honoré, Bernard Maris, Mustapha Ourrad, and Tignous.

⏩ Sarah Kay is a human rights lawyer.

Catharsis

Sarah Kay ✊ once ran into Manuel Valls in a shopping centre in Evry-Courcouronnes in 2008. She’s been struggling ever since

2024 challenged democracy and modern institutional status quo like very few years did before. Some would show you the responsible planets for it, others would refer to the inevitable and cyclical nature of extremist politics. What France brings to the table is stereotypical but always gravity-defying political spectacle.

Unseen under the Fifth Republic, the vote of no-confidence (motion de censure) in the Michel Barnier government feels like a brick thrown at a window. It is not just a reflection on Barnier himself but very specifically of President Macron, delegitimised since his anticipated dissolution of the Assembly earlier this year, but seemingly delegitimising himself. This vote was a long time in the making, but it was clearly aimed at the President. Unfortunately, the Constitution only allows for the use of this parliamentary procedure to target the Prime Minister. And so Macron remains, a much hated figure that now clearly rang the death bells of the Fifth Republic.

The Centre-right struggled to emerge from this spring’s elections. Little to sell, with a lot of pre-existing baggage from Macron’s chaotic and controversial first mandate, they only took leadership out of principle. But familiarity brings contempt, and constant flirting with the demands of an empowered far right was never going to yield stability. One thing always leads to another, and unacceptable compromises reached their apex. The reactionary challenge to an indifferent government is one that will burn more than bad lawmaking. On the day of the vote, led by Le Pen’s formerly-known-as-the-National Front RN party and drafted by whatever is La France Insoumise (far-left pre-Potemkin? Nationalist socio-anarchism? Loud noises?) unions and collectives asked parties to vote against axing the government, insisting on the need for political stability for the purposes of negotiations and planned reforms. So, what now?

Well, France has made its constitutional bed and is very likely to keep Michel Barnier. Macron has already exhausted his get-out-of-this-government dissolution free card and would now have to wait two more years to announce parliamentary elections. As of Macron himself, he is extremely unlikely to go. Nevertheless, he persisted with his (ab)use of executive powers, such as the very Gaullist 49 (3), allowing for the President to force legislation through both Chambers. Austerity politics announced with very little mitigating measures as well as constant nods to Le Pen on immigration, borders and EU foreign support was never going to be the thriving pluralistic influence Macron begged for with his dissolution gamble. The truth is, there is no turning around that ship. Macron is headed for the iceberg but pretends he can outrun it.

Le Pen herself is in a predicament. Facing several counts of corruption and embezzlement, she could face 5 years’ imprisonment if found guilty in an ongoing trial. She could also be hit with an electoral ban, meaning she would not be allowed to run in the upcoming parliamentary elections. Her absence would be a breath of fresh air, but it is a medium term goal. As of today, France is heading toward the inevitable end of the road crash, a test of institutional resilience I am not sure it is quite ready for.

Growth is always uncomfortable, but the country does not know government suspensions the way we do here in Northern Ireland, and it might have to find a quick solution to this perennial problem of political legitimacy: do people get the government they deserve?

➽ Sarah Kay is a human rights lawyer.

Tout Est Chaos, À Côté

Sarah Kay 🔖 Erasure takes so, so many forms.


We talk of erasure when talking about censorship; silencing; oppression, suppression, and the annihilation in its absolute form, genocide. In an era of rampant state violence, from police brutality to wars of expansion, the chant remains the same: say their names. But how do we pass on this knowledge? Above all, what does bearing witness mean?

Erasure is an odd term. It can be active or passive. It doesn’t, in itself, indicate violence. If nothing else, it is about the passing of time. Remnants of past civilisations – Pompeii, Athens, Jerusalem, Homs, Bamiyan – those places were erased, but not for the same ggkreasons. The elements do not have criminal liability. Survivors are not carrying the same burden.

In Against Erasure, we catch a glimpse at life in Palestine before the 1948 Nakba. A Palestine that rises from the ashes of military destruction. We see multigenerational families tending to olive groves; we see patriarchs with long white beards reading to young grandchildren; we see women in colourful dresses, resting on a thick, rich rug, sharing tea and wisdom amongst themselves. We see lives, intertwined and interdependent, living peacefully, including the presence of other ethnicities: an Armenian family; a Bedouin tent; a group of Coptic monks. Musicians, artists – singers, oud players, trumpetists – adorn the pages of this book, full of life, full of history, heavy with millennia-old knowledge.

Erasure, in a genocidal context, is not simply about human extinction. It is about annihilation of culture, of tradition, but most importantly, of memory. We see the same dynamics at play on a lesser level but with the same intent elsewhere: book bans, historical revisionism, passive voice in news coverage. By erasing suffering, we erase victimhood. By erasing victimhood, we erase its cause. We erase culpability, and root causes. We then all become unwilling participants in the process of destruction.

Bearing witness is not about the reckless consumption of graphic horror on the daily basis. Bearing witness Is knowing what is in front of us – erasure – and refusing it. We say names, but we also know the faces. We talk about places, but we also know what they looked like before walls, checkpoints, and military patrols. Candlelit processions to mosques, parades, murals on the walls of schools and processions in Gaza, the times of the British mandate however must not be seen through positive nostalgia. It was colonisation still, and state control pouring out of every frame. But the aspiration for a different and better future was still there.

Against Erasure affirms that Palestinians have the right to exist; the right to live free from violence; the right to their language, their history, their culture and their land, a fertile one stretching from the river to the sea. Our duty is never to forget.

Teresa Aranguren and Sandra Barrilaro, 2024, Against Erasure: A Photographic Memory of Palestine Before the Nakba. Translated from the Spanish edition by Róisín Davis with Hugo Rayón Aranguren. Haymarket Books.ISBN-13: ‎978-1642599800.

⏩ Sarah Kay is a human rights lawyer.

Against Erasure

Sarah Kay 🔖 My memory is faint, and I hold onto it like a child with a blanket. I worry it might disappear.

I remember the feeling of warm sand under my feet, my shoes in my right hand. It was a pair of beaten up Dr Martens, the same boots I had worn since I was a kid that had followed me around the world, in all those places where human life is cheapened and reduced to survival.

The sun was setting, but the warmth remained. The gentle clapping of the waves somehow absorbed every sound around. There were families behind me, with children running, laughing, parents calling them home, as it would be time for dinner. All I could hear was the rush of the Mediterranean, a vast body of water that had calmly surrounded so many places I should be able to call home. Palestinians cannot call Haifa home. My feet have known Haifa, but so many indigenous to this place never have.

I have talked about home, not just the physical element, but the idea and ideal of home, with Mx Yaffa for years. I have approached Blood Orange with that knowledge of the extreme privilege I have held, being able to return to Belfast safely, on my own terms, on my own time, and without any obstacle. Home is not a privilege. Home is a right. Home is an entitlement. Colonialism, occupation, and genocide are weapons forged in the fire of controlling, destructive, and bloodthirsty power. Resistance to this absolute desire for annihilation has always floored me, like a flower blooming from beneath the concrete. A flower that smells like orange blossom.

In Blood Orange, Yaffa asserts, declares, cherishes, and opposes. It is an ode to the sense of self; to the knowledge of identity; to reverence to our ancestors; to claiming, and reclaiming, a language, an appropriation of the land, an understanding of the elements, and the acute pain of displacement. In “I Am”, perhaps its most powerful core, Yaffa fearlessly and powerfully declares,

I am not

A Palestine you

Can erase

I am

Indigenous sovereignty

You can't wipe out

I am

Palestine

Indigenously sovereign

A movement

A thought

A voice

I am inevitable

This inevitability is what has powered independence movements since the dawn of our belligerent humanity. We are told the arc of history always bends towards justice, but justice’s arm is not even-handed, to say the least. This inevitability transcends man-made structures, the pathetic fragility of the nation-state, the inherently unsustainable idea of supremacy. It is inevitable that Palestine will be free. It is inevitable that we, as a collective, will one day be free. Our lifetimes are just that; short, ephemeral, insignificant. The intimacy we feel towards our own idea of freedom and liberation is what endures. It is okay to feel small in the face of a grand revolution, and this is how Blood Orange made me feel: I was dwarfed by the luminous revelation of this inescapable future.

With the simple question, So / Where do / The motherless / Go? Yaffa forces us to face our idea of displacement. In a world full of foaming-at-the-mouth screams for blood and soil, have we forgotten about Palestinian, with no right of return? Have we forgotten about Armenians, chased from Turkey to the Caucasus? Have we forgotten that the celebration of a diaspora, regardless of its ethnic origins, is one always borne out of atrocities? In this same blog, I had talked before about the end of legal sovereignty, this idea that our norms could be the way out, a hopeful and inclusive vision for an utopic future. In this constant struggle between the advocate and the legal professional, between the prosecutor and the activist, I have found a narrow, dry and somewhat loveless place in which to stretch my legs.

Blood Orange challenges those narrow, occidental world views. It shatters those pre-conditioned ideologies by not just expecting, but demanding, a genuine, true way out. A way out for all the oppressed. No longer containing classifications of skin colours, no longer expecting compliance with half-baked democracies, seeing beyond all of this, all of this noise, this undignified fist fight for power. A utopia.

All that is left for us, the readers, is this:

Our blood filling

Trees and canyons

Turning the

Sea a blood orange

Like an eclipse that

Forgot to

Subside

May we see an end to this blood shed in the name of control, and may all see the waves in Haifa. May we all be freed from a seemingly unstoppable appetite for hate. As Stefan Zweig once wrote, may we all see a dawn to this long, cold night. Mx. Yaffa gave us one. Least we can do is listen.

Yaffa As, 2023, Blood Orange. Meraj Publishing. ISBN: 9798223130505. Buy from Rainy Day Books.

➽ Sarah Kay is a human rights lawyer.

Blood Orange

Sarah Kay ✊ Sometime near 60 BC, the Roman scholar and lawyer Marcus Tullius Cicero advised his friend Titus Annius Milo, accused of murdering a third person, resulting in a speech during which the now infamous phrase originated. 

Several times modified, the original idiom goes silent enim leges inter arma, which translates into, “in times of war, the law falls silent.” This was meant to explain his murder will go unnoticed, because larger issues kept the world occupied. And ever since, taken in much more gruesome contexts, the maxim is invoked to claim that atrocities are committed in the name of war. As John Kirby, the White House Press Secretary, noted on the 25th of October, “war is messy, war is gory, and civilians are gonna die.”

Since hearing those words, I have tried to sit with those words, and what those words mean for someone like me, whose job rests on the premise of being loud, extremely loud, in time of war. Sixteen centuries later, Hugo Grotius, residing in The Hague, worked against Cicero in De jure belli ac pacis, published for the first time in 1625 and intended as a gift to Louis XIII of France. This was not the first time “law” and “war” found themselves in the same sentence, but it cemented the belief that even one of the great plagues can’t silence those of us who regulate, determinate, and adjudicate.

I could continue to cover three more centuries of words in Latin then in English that would tell you about war, and the regulation of conduct of and in war. I could tell you about the League of Nations and I could tell you about court referrals. One thing I can not tell you is why the law is painfully silent on the day I am writing this, and the 28 days prior. In response to a horrific, mass scale terror attack committed by the terror group Hamas, the state of Israel has decided to continue - and promises, this time, to finish - its genocide of the Gaza Strip. I am mentioning another loaded word, this time not Latin, but Greek: genocide, the destruction of an entire population.

We have language for the unspeakable. We have collated seemingly opposite civilisations to create a common memory cataloguing horror. We have then drawn, designed and implemented the aforementioned laws and regulations that speak of those horrors with the reverence of those who remember, but the arrogance of those who think they can stop this from happening, by sheer will, not even commitment. I learned from the books, tediously. I nearly crushed under the weight of self-discipline, but the belief carried me.

I didn’t find law silent in time of war. I stood with a stained jacket on the Whiterock Road in Belfast. I tiptoed along abandoned railway lines in Kosovo, mere years later. I found those, blue helmets and blue jackets and blue pants and blue armbands, full of rage, full of despair. They weren’t silent. They were loud, but it wasn’t enough: genocide was louder. After Rwanda, East Timor, Myanmar, China, and the atrocities in Afghanistan, Yemen, Syria, and Libya, who is louder? Are we just building more and more bombs to drown the screams?

We are taught accountability at a very young age. We know actions have consequences. And yet millions are dying in Gaza due to a near absolute absence of consequences. Millions are already dead in the Democratic Republic of Congo, sacrificed at the altar of neocolonial policies that seem to escape the accountability that true universality requires. In 2017, Prof. Anthea Roberts wrote the critical yet controversial Is International Law International? - wondering if the Global North continues to exert judicial dominance over the South. But as we are witnessing yet another genocide, waged in the Occupied Palestinian Territories and on everyone’s social media account, we are now told to once again relegate human rights and humanitarian imperatives to secondary or tertiary concerns, as there is some eradicating, annihilating, and cleansing to do.

We are not silent, and we have never been. What we need is the political courage to support accountability, regardless of who the perpetrator is. What we need is to restore what was at the heart of regulating war in the first place: to limit the constant letting of civilian blood that has never fertilised any ground or bred any trees, of freedom or prosperity. What we need is the courage to end it, and the screaming will cease.

➽ Sarah Kay is a human rights lawyer.

Inter Arma Silent Leges?

Sarah Kay ✊ Yes, and there are ICC fact finders there now. 

Designated starvation and collective punishment is what characterises specifically the treatment in Gaza, in addition to the conditions of detention: it can cross the threshold into genocide.

It took 60 years to take it to the ICC. I don’t want to die before hostilities cease and I see the case. Palestinians deserve a state, deserve peace, deserve safety, and deserve self-determination. Most importantly, they are entitled to all of these things. Let me repeat. Entitled.

Israeli civilians and foreign nationals currently being detained, injured and killed are damage caused by Netanyahu’s lifelong commitment to eradicate the Palestinian cause and its survivors. His government has, just like Russia before it in the face of the Ukraine invasion, criminalised protest, imprisoned dissent, and ripped out the courts. Consolidating power, he triggers Hamas’ violence and traps his own citizens under their guns.
 
Hamas does not represent Palestine, but Palestine has no way to obtain representatives. Palestinians can’t go back home, they do not have a right of return. Palestinians can flee, but they’re already the largest refugee population in the world, making up a two digit percentage of the populations of both Lebanon and Jordan. Palestinians were in the largest Syrian refugee camp, Yarmouk, before the Syrian uprising. Yarmouk, since 2015, is the definition of hell on earth. I’ve been there. Hell. Hell you can’t comprehend. Hell I hope you never can.

Mandatory drafts, denial of access to civil rights for the non-Jews, refusal of mixed marriages, and forced religious education makes Israel an oppressive theocracy. I am urging everyone on the Palestinian cause to reach out to Jewish voices for peace and Israeli activists fighting against the occupation of the Palestinian Territories, which, I have to remind everyone, have borders fixed in 1967. Anything else is a crime of aggression. Israelis are scared because they have no say in how their government treats Palestinians; and how they will be made guilty.

Politics are too complex for war, and that has always been the case. The law is not silence in time of war, this idiom no longer exists and in fact, ignores just how old the regulation of conflict is. Politics are silent, because politics is about dialogue, debate, and discourse. War doesn’t just suspend those, it destroys them. You can only argue with the living; and those who made it back have lost the capacity to do so. Trauma, once inflicted on that scale, also defines the political silence of future generations, for whom opposition will be the only way to create identity and community.

There can be no peace without justice, and justice would demand that the current US budget of military assistance to the IDF - $3.9 billion as of 2019 - is suspended. Justice would mean treating Israel the way we would treat any other state that would commit such crimes, for so long. Justice would be granting Palestine statehood. But statehood demands three criteria. One of them is territorial definition.

And Palestine’s borders already exist. They were drawn. They’re drawn on the UN HQ walls, where every year, we have a reminder of how much we fucked up in handling the end of British colonialism of the area mixed with the aftermath of the Holocaust.
 
  • The Nakba compounding existing trauma.
  • A genocide to respond to a genocide.
  • A crime against humanity to balance a crime against humanity.
  • Programmed dehumanisation to face annihilation.

This conflict proves humanity at its worst. It illustrates how little we invest in the principles we claim to uphold because everything becomes an ideological fervor to end all the previous worships. Israel and Palestine, the most fertile and holy ground of our entire civilization, are now where such lofty ideas of development and morality die in abject circumstances.

We are all responsible for this conflict. And we are all responsible for calling an end to it and demand action. Without Islamophobia, without antisemitism. Because we must. Because the Palestinian cause is everyone’s cause. Its asks are everyone’s asks. Its resistance is everyone’s hope. Its endurance is everyone’s perseverance. And Israel’s fascism should be everyone’s anxiety. Because its self preservation at all costs is our isolation. Because its hunger for control is our submission. Because its manipulative foreign policy becomes our burden of arms trade.

It’s about and for all of us.

➽ Sarah Kay is a human rights lawyer.

Israel’s Fascism Should Be Everyone’s Anxiety