Showing posts with label Irish neutrality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Irish neutrality. Show all posts
Micheál Choilm Mac Giolla Easbuig ★ Will Pat the Cope Gallagher and Charlie McConalogue face the People of Dún na nGall?


The recent vote i Teach Laighean is not a technical adjustment; it is a fundamental betrayal of what remains of Irish neutrality.

By voting to remove the triple lock, the UN requirement for deploying our soldiers to foreign wars, the political establishment has signalled its intent. But we must ask: why now, and for whom?
 
Pat 'the Cope' Gallagher and Charlie McConalogue voted for this ending of the UN requirement, effectively allowing Irish soldiers to be sent to wars not of our making.

Are they being honest and open with their electorate?

The rhetoric of "protecting Ireland" is a dangerous falsehood. By aligning them and therefore the people of Ireland, with EU militarism and NATO-adjacent structures, Ireland does not become safer; it becomes a target. We are being dragged into the warmongering nations, aligned with NATO and PESCO ambitions; supporting a 'weapons of death and destruction industry' based on manufactured Russian aggression.
 
This is not neutrality; this is submission to the imperatives of EU, Yankee, and English imperialism.

The hypocrisy is staggering. As our young people face a housing crisis, a health service crisis and the people ó Dún na nGall and elsewhere, living in collapsing dwellings, why is the money for wars and death not being spent on the living? There is no money for social justice and the material needs of the population of Ireland, but there is always money for militarism. Billions of pounds can be found for Wars. Wars that will mean death and destruction, along with food and fuel shortages; burdens that always fall heaviest on the working class people. Is this the future we want for our children and grandchildren; to fight foreign imperialist wars in foreign lands? And to main and kill the poor and working poor of those countries? Just look at Palestine, Lebanon, Yemin, Iran and the wider West Asia. That's what we are lining our youth up to do.

Furthermore, the two TDs are masters of 'clientelism' and 'slights of hand' . . . the old 'three card trick'; doing favours like getting people their passports, two minutes before they would have arrived anyway. All this to maintain a veneer of caring, while ensuring the welfare of the rich and powerful comes first. They are a full and willing part of that capitalist system.

But their pretend words cannot hide the truth. If they truly believe in the ending of our neutrality, will they hold public meetings right across the country, to ask the people's opinions on our neutrality and sovereignty? Or will they hide behind the party whip?

And what of the English occupation of the 6 counties? What do the two TDs, Charlie and Pat the Cope say about that? Is that somehow different? If so, why is it different? If they are so concerned with "defending" Ireland, why is the English imperialist presence in the North not their primary focus? Why is it acceptable to join a Western military NATO/PESCO bloc, to defend others but not to address the root cause of division on this island? Namely partition and colonial occupation?

We are witnessing the dilution of Irish sovereignty. The people ó Dún na nGall deserve answers. We demand public meetings on this. We demand that our TDs explain why they are choosing the interests of imperialist powers over the welfare of their own constituents.
 
Neutrality is not weakness; it is a shield for the the majority i Éireann , especially the working class. We must defend it with every sinew in our bodies.

#PattheCopeGallagher
#CharlieMcConalogue


Micheál Choilm Mac Giolla Easbuig 
is an 
independent councillor on Donegal County Council.

A Betrayal Of Neutrality

Jim Duffy ✍ Neale Richmond made an interesting comment on Virgin Media on defence. 

Unless he misspoke, he suggested that Ireland intends to effectively double defence spending within the next two years. If he was mistaken, I would have expected the Taoiseach or the Minister for Defence to correct him. They have not done so.
 
He suggested that in two years, Ireland's defence spending will rise from €1.65b to €3b. That would raise Irish defence spending to 0.54% of GDP - still the second lowest in Europe but off the bottom. Ultimately it needs to reach 0.85%, which is the current average spend of neutrals. That number is increasingly all the time as Austria has passed 1% of GDP and aims to reach 1.2% - funded by special VAT imposed. Switzerland is increasing year by year to reach 1% by 2030. As the others increase the spending the average will increase. Even Malta, currently second from bottom at 0.38%, is finally increasing its defence spending.
 
That would be a credible achievement. Perhaps the humiliation of realising how inadequate Ireland's defence is when planning for the EU presidency woke up the government to the need to dramatically increase defence spending. In addition, it is worth saying that the previous Minister for Defence, Simon Harris, and the current minister, Helen McEntee, are taking defence seriously - despite having a very demanding brief with Foreign Affairs, Trade and Defence. (Eamon Gilmore had Foreign Affairs and Trade and said it was too much for any minister to both together. Leo, ignoring Eamon's advice, insisted in taking Trade into the brief again.)
 
In both Britain and Ireland, a similar phenomenon has happened. The Minister for Defence or Defence Secretary was highly critical of the chronically inadequate funding given to defence, with the British Defence Secretary resigning over it. Both men, Simon Harris and John Harris, then ended up in the job that had been blocking defence spending - Harris as Minister for Finance, Healy as Chancellor of the Exchequer.
 
I will certainly applaud the government if they bring Irish defence spending to 0.54% of GDP. However that has to be just a step on the road, and not an end point. Ireland needs to have a properly funded, staffed and equipped Defence Forces with 11,000 serving in it, a navy of 12 ships including frigates and not just patrol boats, enough personnel to reverse the steep decline in patrol days, and to have the proper number of ships to patrol our EEZ, with each ship double-crewed. The air force (as the air corps is being renamed in a new bill. Most countries dropped the old name 'air corps' a century ago. The US replaced the Army Air Corps by the Army Air Force in 1941 and in 1947 a new United States Air Force (USAF) was created.) needs to reverse the decision in the 1990s and create a proper military using jet fighters. It has been nuts expecting the Air Corps to police both the Irish sovereign air space and Irish-controlled space without jet fighters when the planes entering it are jet-propelled. It is like expecting the Gardaí on bicycles to chase criminals on motorways.
 
Martin as a dithering Defence Minister was opposed to having an air force with an intercept capability, being content to let the RAF do it (despite the RAF having a severe lack of planes itself). Harris quickly realised that Ireland needed to have a proper squadron of jet fighters to do the standard air defence done in all neutrals but Malta.
 
Add to that a new bill will fundamentally reorganise the Defence Forces - with the air corps being replaced by an air force, the naval service replaced a proper navy, and the three elements, army, navy and air force each with their own head, over which there will be a Chief of Defence replacing the Chief of Staff.
 
The result will give the defence forces a proper modern structure and not one stuck in the mid-twentieth century.
 
No doubt some people with their usual paranoia will conclude that this is all about joining NATO. Neither Ireland, not Austria, nor Switzerland, nor Malta have any intention of joining NATO. Nor is NATO wanting them to join. Of the neutrals, only Cyprus wants to join NATO, but it is likely to be blocked by its old enemy Turkey. Turkey invaded Cyprus in the 1970s and occupied the north of the island, setting up an internationally unrecognised state there.
 
Countries joining NATO have to accept international borders. For Turkey, recognising Cyprus's de-jure ownership of the island would probably be unacceptable to Turkey. Accepting Cypriot membership would delegitimise its already illegitimate state on the island.
 
The issue of borders is why ultimately Ireland decided not to join NATO in 1949. Recognising international borders would have meant Ireland accepting partition on the island, and that Northern Ireland is part of the United Kingdom. Ireland had been on the brink of joining, and then External Affairs minister Sean MacBride told both the Dáil and the Seanad that Ireland fully supported the creation of NATO and its aims and made it clear that Ireland was not neutral in the rivalry between the communist world and the West. He made it clear that Ireland was on the side of the West.
 
Yet, in 1955, when Ireland finally joined the UN (Stalin had repeatedly vetoed it, but he was now dead) as it all UN members it accepted all existing international borders, including partition.
 
The reason Ireland is increasing its military spending and re-organisation of its Defence Forces is to reach the standard of other neutrals.
 
That said, Ireland, Austria, Switzerland and Malta issue on caveat on NATO. Absolutely none of them have any intention now or in the future of joining NATO. However unknown events outside their control, or NATO's, may force them to make a decision they do not want to make.

If one had asked Sweden or Finland up to the 24th February 2022 whether they would ever join NATO the answer would have been clear. "Absolutely not." That remained the case even though Putin made aggressive threats against both. Sweden was flabbergasted why he was targeting them. They had never fought a war in two hundred years. They had been neutral all that time. Putin's bizarre fixation on Sweden seemed to be linked to the fact that his hero, Peter the Great, had fought repeated wars against Sweden. But the days of Sweden as a major military power with an empire were centuries gone.
 
Finland declared its independence from Russia with the fall of the Tsars. The Soviet Union had invaded Finland twice, and taken part of its territory, but it was flabbergasted that after a hundred years of independence Putin seemed to be questioning Finland's right to exist.
 
Both countries treated Putin's threats and his 'Russkiy Mir' vision as just posing to win the support of Nationalists, but which he had no intention of acting on. Experts all over believed that - until 24th February 2022, when he did carry out one of his threats and invaded Ukraine.
 
That stunned and worried both Sweden and Finland, plus the Baltic states, and Poland (attacked by Russia 19 times in its history). Sweden and Finland were so concerned that they did the unthinkable. They decided to join NATO for protection. Public opinion swung from opposing joining NATO to demanding they join NATO faster than political opinion.
 
The one concern for Ireland, Austria, Switzerland and Malta is that specific threats against them by Putin could force them to do the one thing they didn't want to do, and join NATO for their own protection as they could not protect themselves.
 
In reality, only two of the four are under any risk: Austria and Ireland. Malta is tiny (eight times the size of the Aran Islands) and geographically irrelevant. Switzerland is as always protected by its geography with its mountains.
 
Putin's 'Russkiy Mir' (Russian world) has as one of its basics something he put this way: 'If Russian soldiers were ever on your territory, you belong to us and we are taking you back.' Unfortunately, Soviet Red Army soldiers occupied eastern Austria from 1945 to 1955 following World War II. That means that he could claim Austria according to his own warped logic. Some years ago the then Austrian Foreign Minister unilaterally proposed that Austria join NATO. The reaction was overwhelmingly "absolutely not." However Austria was shaken by the aggressive threatening Russian response that stressed the Soviet Union's presence in Austria and implied that because of that it had the 'right' to intervene. Its tone was "You are ours."
 
As a neutral, unlike Ireland and Malta, Austria is well protected. Its military 16,000 to 22,000 active-duty personnel and roughly 125,600 reservists. Austria requires all able-bodied male citizens to complete mandatory military or civilian service upon turning 18. The fear is though that Austria may face more Russian threats and bullying. Its doesn't want to left exposed as Ukraine was when Merkel with crass stupidity blocked Ukraine joining NATO.
 
The reaction is Austria is unambiguously "we have no intention of joining NATO. None whatsoever." Leaders however say "but threats by Putin may leave us with no choice."
 
Luckily, Russian soldiers never set foot in Ireland so it isn't covered by Russkiy Mir. Its problem is geography. We have created a world in the West entirely dependent on connectivity. That connectivity depends on data cables. They are Europe's and NATO's biggest weakness. Seventy-five percent of data cables every bank, every business, every citizen, every hospital, everyone, depends on are located in and beside Ireland's Exclusive Economic Zone, in the Celtic Sea.
 
Ireland militarily could never defend them even with a full strength military. We asked NATO to police them, with we aiding them. Russia has made it absolutely clear that they are arguably one of its top three targets if a war starts. Russia's spy ship the Yantar has repeatedly surveyed them for attack points. The Russian navy has repeatedly appeared around them. A Russian nuclear submarine, possibly carrying nuclear weapons, based itself in Cork harbour. We have no sonar (though some is due to arrive next year) so we had to rely on the Royal Navy to inform us on the presence of the sub, and then we had ask it to drive it out of Cork harbour.
 
Another Russian target is to destabilise the EU. One way it tried was to encourage illegal arrivals of migrants along European borders to create a public backlash. Ireland is a net contributor to the EU budget, while, along with Malta being the least protected country. It is exceptionally vulnerable in terms of electricity supply. It depends for gas for its gas-powered electricity generation on three interconnectors in the Irish Sea. Those interconnectors have been repeatedly targeted by the Yantar. On one occasion the government had to get specialists to check the interconnectors amid fears the Yantar has planted explosives. No explosives were found but that may be because its mission was interrupted when the Royal Norwegian Navy alerted Ireland to the Yantar's presence and that it was sending down underwater drones to the interconnectors.
 
Ireland did a detailed study as to what the effects would be if the interconnectors were damaged. Russia had damaged interconnectors and cables elsewhere. The result of the study, named Operation Cathal, were stark. It would take six months to repair the interconnectors. Ireland's gas-powered electricity generation accounts for 48% minimum of Ireland's electricity. Ireland would face six months of rolling blackouts all over the state. Major employers who use lots of electricity would be cut off for the period to give priority to electricity supplies to homes, hospitals, etc. The economic cost, including loss of taxes, would be colossal. Vast numbers of jobs would be lost.
 
Ireland because of its weak defence is exceptionally exposed and vulnerable.
 
Ireland has been targeted for cyber-attacks. Russia attempted to build a major spy communication headquarters at its Dublin embassy. Russia legally owns the land the embassy is on, but not the area underground. The Irish government banned it from building it. Satellite images suggest that Russia may well have built it anyway.
 
Ireland's location is problematic for another reason. The 500-mile stretch of ocean between Iceland and Scotland forms a crucial part of the GIUK Gap (Greenland-Iceland-United Kingdom), a premier strategic naval chokepoint. Russia has on a number of occasions had submarines based just off the Donegal coast for use in hostile actions in the GUIG gap. Again, Ireland's weak defence leaves an opening that Russia exploits.
 
Russia increasingly sends its so-called 'shadow fleet' through Ireland's EEZ. That is problematic in a host of ways. Many of the ships are barely seaworthy. They fly false flags, claiming the ship is registered in, and has been verified as seaworthy in, the country whose flag is flying. In reality that country has nothing to do with that ship and has never inspected it for seaworthiness.

Countries have a right to board ships in its EEZ and verify that its cargo is legal and all the required documents are possessed. Neither is the case with the shadow fleet. Nigeria finds its flag is regularly flown by the ships despite it having nothing to do with it, the ship not being registered there and never having been inspected for it.

Quite apart from the contraband cargo, the appalling state of the ships is a very real threat to Ireland. Should one sink, they would devastate Irish fishing grounds and the west coast of Ireland with oil, yet the ships are not insured, and in such a poor state that when one is seized by a state the owner never claims it, as it is not worth the effort.
 
Again, Ireland's inadequate defence means Russia knows it can use Irish waters for its unsafe unseaworthy ships carrying contraband.
 
Ireland's security has been repeatedly targeted by Russia. Between 2017 and 2020 Tupolev TU–95 bombers, nicknamed 'bear bombers', repeatedly entered Irish-controlled airspace - on one case they repeatedly entered Irish-controlled airspace each day for a number of days.
 
They did not enter Irish sovereign airspace. Irish-controlled airspace is a larger airspace than sovereign airspace. The Irish Aviation Authority has responsibility for monitoring and policing a much larger area than sovereign airspace.
 
The repeated entry of the planes was suspected of being an effort to test RAF reaction times in preparation for any war as Ireland has to ask the RAF to police its skies as it cannot itself. The behaviour of the Russian planes was deeply dangerous and irresponsible, especially when they turn off their transponders, making them effectively invisible to civil aviation surveillance systems.
 
Recklessness in the skies has long been a Putin hallmark. One place Russia no longer flies planes over is Turkey, as after repeat incursions the Turkish president told Putin that Turkey will shoot down every Russian military plane in Turkish airspace.
 
Russia has often used the Tupolev TU–95 bombers in other countries' non-sovereign airspaces as much for intimidation as anything else. However Ukraine has dealt Russia a significant blow by destroying a number of the seventy year old bombers. They are literally irreplaceable. The factory that made them closed in the 1960s and the designers are long dead, plus they require parts no longer available. Ukraine didn't have to destroy the planes, but just have a drone damage one part of the fuselage. Once that tiny spot was damaged the plane would never be stable enough to fly and that spot could never be repaired.
 
Earlier this month it was revealed that Ukraine had destroyed two Tupolev TU–95s. Putin considered his prized planes, a key part of the country's nuclear triad—safe at the Engels-2 airbase because it is so deep inside Russian territory. Ukraine reached them anyway, and they were not the first ones it destroyed. Putin had to move them again even further from Ukraine and hope Ukraine cannot destroy any more.
 
From flying Tupolev TU–95s in Irish airspace to repeatedly entering Irish waters with nuclear-powered submarines that usually carry nuclear weapons, including having one in Cork harbour, off the east coast and off the Donegal coast, having the Yantar spy ship repeatedly behaving suspiciously over Ireland's interconnectors and over the data cables, apparently building their underground spy communication centre at their embassy (despite being told not to by the Irish government), and repeated cyber-attacks, notably against the HSE, Russia is clearly very interested in focusing on Ireland - partly because of its highly sensitive location, particularly because of its chronically adequate defence that earned the waters around Ireland the nickname "the wild west!"

None of what has happened is remotely likely to lead the Irish government to change its mind and join NATO. Ireland and Austria are still rock solid in ruling out joining NATO. Both however have the unspoken fear that Russia may in the future go too far in its behaviour and leave both states reaching the same point Sweden and Finland and conclude "we don't want to join NATO but we need to. We are too exposed without it."
 
By the way it is worth nailing two myths that are inevitably repeated when the issue of NATO comes out - though I hope it doesn't.
 
1. The oft repeated claim that 'neutrals are safe. Countries don't attack neutrals.'
 
The myth comes from the Second Hague Convention Hague (Titloe V: Convention on the rights of neutral powers and persons (1907), including the inviolability of the territory of neutral powers). To give an idea of the states participating, here is the list of heads named:
 
His Majesty the German Emperor, King of Prussia; the President of the United States of America; the President of the Argentine Republic; His Majesty the Emperor of Austria, King of Bohemia, &c., and Apostolic King of Hungary; His Majesty the King of the Belgians; the President of the Republic of Bolivia; the President of the Republic of the United States of Brazil; His Royal Highness the Prince of Bulgaria; the President of the Republic of Chile; His Majesty the Emperor of China; the President of the Republic of Colombia ; the Provisional Governor of the Republic of Cuba; His Majesty the King of Denmark; the President of the Dominican Republic; the President of the Republic of Ecuador; His Majesty the King of Spain; the President of the French Republic; His Majesty the King of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland and of the British Dominions beyond the Seas, Emperor of India; His Majesty the King of the Hellenes; the President of the Republic of Guatemala; the President of the Republic of Haiti; His Majesty the King of Italy; His Majesty the Emperor of Japan; His Royal Highness the Grand Duke of Luxemburg, Duke of Nassau; the President of the United States of Mexico; His Royal Highness the Prince of Montenegro; the President of the Republic of Nicaragua; His Majesty the King of Norway; the President of the Republic of Panama; the President of the Republic of Paraguay; Her Majesty the Queen of the Netherlands; the President of the Republic of Peru; His Imperial Majesty the Shah of Persia; His Majesty the King of Portugal and of the Algarves, &c.; His Majesty the King of Roumania; His Majesty the Emperor of All the Russias; the President of the Republic of Salvador; His Majesty the King of Servia; His Majesty the King of Siam; His Majesty the King of Sweden; the Swiss Federal Council; His Majesty the Emperor of the Ottomans; the President of the Oriental Republic of Uruguay; the President of the United States of Venezuela.
Article 1 states "The territory of neutral Powers is inviolable."

On paper, or rather parchment, that seems straightforward. But there is a rather big problem. The negotiations started in 1904, signed in 1907, came into force in 1910 . . . and was broken on the 2nd of August 1914, when the country whose head of state, the German Emperor, was top of the list, invaded a neutral. In invading Luxembourg Germany broke the convention.
 
Two days later, Germany invaded another neutral, Belgium.
 
It was brazen. When the German plenipotentiary, Baron Marschall von Bieberstein, the German ambassador to Constantinople, signed the text he may not have known that Germany already had plans to invade neutrals. That is not the case with another German delegate, Major General von Gündell of the General Staff. He certainty knew that a year earlier Germany had adopted the Schlieffen Plan - with the commitment to invade Luxembourg, Belgium and the Netherlands. (A rewrite by Alfred von Schlieffen's successor, Helmuth von Moltke the Younger, changed the plan to drop the need to invade the Netherlands.)

So Germany signed the Second Hague Convention Title V already knowing that in any major European war, Germany intended to break it.
 
Those first two breaks were just the tip of the iceberg. In World War II, Nazi Germany invaded neutrals Luxembourg, Belgium, the Netherlands, Denmark and Norway. It would have invaded neutral Sweden except that Sweden broke the convention by actively aiding Nazi Germany, breaking Article 5. Neutral Finland was invaded twice by the Soviet Union, in 1939 and 1941.
 
Nor has countries breaking title V on neutrality ceased in the 20th century. Russia broke it in 2014 in invading Ukraine and taking Crimea - despite Ukraine at the time being neutral constitutionally. Modern Russia is bound by it as the successor state of the USSR, which was bound by it as a successor state of Russia under the tsars who originally signed it.
 
Ukraine signed and ratified the conventions in 2015, but it arguably was already bound as a successor state to the USSR. Its legal advice was that it was covered by it since the Russian plenipotentiary Baron Aleksandr Nelidow signed it on behalf of the Russian empire that included Ukraine. Nevertheless it signed up again in 2015.
 
As a result, for all the impressive words in Article 1, the Second Hague Convention's Title V on the protection of neutrals is worthless. It is nothing more than a gentleman's agreement that was broken within four years of coming into force and as been repeatedly broken.
 
Ireland does not appear to be a signatory to title V, on neutrality or indeed any of the titles other than Title I: the Convention for the pacific settlement of international disputes.
 
Of course it could be argued that Ireland is the successor state of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland. That state signed Title V on 18-10-1907 but according to the official website never ratified it.
 
Only 36 countries have ever signed Title V. That may be because by the mid 1940s it had been repeatedly broken so thoroughly that all the neutrals invaded bar Finland (and uninvaded Sweden) were founding members of NATO. They both joined NATO in the 2020s after Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022.
 
Its powerless can be seen in the fact that countries have the right to withdraw from it. Yet no country planning to invade a neutral ever withdrew from it. There was no point as they could break it with impunity.
 
So being a neutral does not make a country safe. If a country wants to attack a country they can - not withstanding title V of the convention.
 
By the way, for clarity the supposed protection only applies to neutrals who are signatories, and only supposedly protects those neutrals from attacks from belligerents who are signatories.
 
Another oft repeated myth is joining NATO would bring in conscription. In fact, only 29% of NATO members have conscription or national service. It is entirely a matter for each state, not NATO, whether they have it. Statistically it it is neutrals, not NATO members, that have conscription or national service, with 60% of neutrals having it.

I don't expect Ireland or Austria to join NATO unless Putin makes unexpected aggressive threats to them that they feel they need the collective protection of NATO membership. Given the reckless threatening behaviour of Putin, you can never anything out in a world dominated by madmen like Putin and Trump.

⏩ Jim Duffy is a writer-historian.

Neutrals Are Not Safe

Micheál Choilm Mac Giolla Easbuig ★ Minister Thomas Byrne, commenting on his meeting on Wednesday, 12 August . . . 

 . . . the Minister of State for Defence, (more like minister of war) said:

I welcomed the opportunity to meet with General Grynkewich in Dublin today.
Ireland’s engagement with NATO through Partnership for Peace has provided our Defences Forces with valuable opportunities since 1999 for useful and pragmatic collaboration, in our contribution to peacekeeping globally, and in adherence with our policy of military neutrality.

Thomas Byrne calls all of this ‘pragmatic collaboration’ and ‘adherence with our policy of neutrality’. It’s amazing how ‘intellectual gymnastics’ are used by the ruling class to justify anything . . . anything at all . . . and continue the ‘ruling by fooling’.
 
So, NATO and PESCO are being sold to us as a ‘Partnership for Peace’!! Just incredible. Escalating military spending, wars, genocides and their consequences for civilians, around the world, is called a ‘Partnership for Peace’!! It is hard to believe that Thomas Byrne, who also met with Europe’s war mongers, masquerading as ministers of defence, at the Gleann na Draoithe resort or any normal person, would believe that nonsense.They don’t even believe their own yarns. And we, the decent people of Ireland, don’t believe a word of it either.

Helen McEntee, ostensibly, the minister of foreign affairs, more like the minister of ‘foreign wars’, now says, that military spending is up to 43%, from a tiny figure of 2 to 5% before this. The latter figure more in keeping with what is supposed to be a neutral state. But those figures notwithstanding, Helen wants to increase the spending on military hardware and preparations for war, to an even higher percentage; to be nearer nearer 60%.

This compares with a measly 9% spending on housing by the Irish government and only 11% on public health care. Infrastructure spending is a tiny 5%. And, depending on how it’s measured, there is only a 2.8% to 5.8% spend on education. Even government spending on ‘social protection’, known as benefits, is only 22% . . .  approximately half of the present military budget. For those who are old and pension age, the government can manage only a 27% budget. For Helen McEntee and her ilk, spending on the provision of war and death, comes far ahead of spending on the provisions of life.

Here i Dún na nGall the two sitting TD’s Pat (The Cope) Gallagher and Charlie McConnelogue are totally silent on all of this spending of millions upon millions, on war preparations, weapons of death And the on-going destruction of our neutrality and sovereignty. Why? Do they not realise that hundreds upon hundreds of families i Dún na nGall need to put food on their table and warm their homes. There is a bypass needed i LeitirCeanainn. Could this money be more usefully spent on that? Could this money, that is being spent on weapons of death and wars, be spent on our destroyed fishing fleet, thanks to the EU, with the connivance of Fianna Fail et al? This money, destined for wars, should be spent on the collapsing homes, due to defective blocks, all over Dún na nGall further afield i Éireann? I call on them to answer these questions and state their position clearly on this imperialist military spending, in what is supposed to be a neutral and sovereign country.

We are not fooled by the safe sounding Words of “defence”, “security” and “peace” that are used all the time, to hide the fact that it is wars, deaths and genocides that they are talking about here . . .  nothing else. What does their talk about “defence” ,“security” and “peace” really mean? Who will profit from the manufacturing and selling of these weapons of death?

It means the spending of billions, even trillions, on weapons of death; to kill maim an injure civilians in their hundreds of thousands, around the world. It means the recruiting of our sons, daughters and grandchildren to fight and die in foreign wars; at the behest of imperialism and capitalism, no more and no less. And it means, the diversion of funding away from social issues such as housing health and even our infrastructure here; in other words the material necessities of life, necessary for people to live in comfort and happiness. Does living not count for more than dying? We need to Always remember, that, the minority who are the ruling class, care little for the majority, the poor and working poor; and they will continue to exploit them in any way they can If we continue to allow it.

It is long past the time that the people of Ireland put a stop to the moves by the ruling class, to make our country a target for war. Sionainn 'warport' should be immediately closed down. Like Countess
Markievicz did all those years ago, we must organise against the conscription of our children into the NATO/European army through the 'slight of hand' tricks of "security", "defence" and "peace". It is none of the above.


Micheál Choilm Mac Giolla Easbuig 
is an 
independent councillor on Donegal County Council.

Weapons Of War

Dr John Coulter ✍ Hopefully one of the benefits of President Donald Trump’s two-day pit stop visit to Southern Ireland over the weekend will be to finally convince the Dublin administration that Eire needs to sign up to full membership of NATO given Vladimir Putin’s desire to rebuild the Russian empire.

And before Irish nationalists start whooping with joy that Trump is also an ‘Irish republican’ as well as an American Republican because of his off the cuff comments about Irish unity, it should be remembered that The Donald is also an astute businessman.

If he needs to play the politics game when in Southern Ireland as laying the groundwork to getting Eire to join NATO, then play the united Ireland card! And who says it has to be an all-Ireland republic outside of the United Kingdom Trump is talking about?

Maybe he has embraced my concept of Revolutionary Unionism and wants to see an all-island state as part of the new Union of the British Isles as part of NATO.

Meanwhile, for generations under the Tsarist monarchy, Imperial Russia tried to dominate Europe. That collapsed with the 1917 communist revolution and the murder of Tsar Nicholas II and his family, but not before millions of Russians were killed in the Great War.

Next came several decades of communist dictatorship and Stalin’s purges which again saw millions of Russians slaughtered by the communists or died fighting in World War Two.

And now we have ex-KGB man Putin flexing his muscles militarily in Ukraine and constantly giving the diplomatic two-fingered salute politically to the UK using the Russian air force and navy to probe and test British readiness.

In spite of Eire’s Irish Defence Forces having a sterling record of service with the United Nations peace keeping forces in Lebanon and Africa, the Dail has constantly pussy-footed when it comes to joining NATO and playing a full role in the defence of Europe.

However, The Donald can be very persuasive and whether in private conversation or in diplomatic talks, he will have left Southern Ireland in no doubt that the geographical island of Ireland will have a key strategic role in any future showdown with the Russians.

And maybe The Donald could give British Prime Minister Andy Burnham a few tips on how ‘to grow a set’ militarily when it comes to dealing with the latest Argentinian threat to the British Falkland Islands.

Burnham needs to show the same patriotic spirit as one of his predecessors in Downing Street when in 1982 then Tory PM Maggie Thatcher sent a strong task force to the islands when the Argentinian military junta decided to invade the Falklands.

The Donald may have hinted that the US would remain tactically neutral in the event of the Argentinians attempting another invasion of the islands in a bid to get the UK to substantially strengthen its military capacity.

Burnham cannot afford to Irish-style pussy-foot with the hard line Argentinian government. He needs to indulge in the same fighting talk as The Donald does against Iran.

Burnham needs to tell Argentina’s ruling elite - put one toe on the Falklands and we’ll nuke your capital Buenos Aires! Israel has not messed about with the terrorists of Hamas or Hezbollah; the United States has not messed about with Iran or Venezuela; the SAS did not mess about with the IRA’s East Tyrone Brigade, so the British armed forces need to act tough with any Argentinian aggression.

Burnham needs to realise his soundbite honeymoon period as PM is over. He has also pledged to devolve more power to the United Kingdom’s regions, but with this problem of Russian aggression still on the agenda, the time has surely come to replace the 1998 Good Friday Agreement with a new Anglo-Irish Treaty which persuades Eire to abandon its traditional military neutrality.

Trump could be the political catalyst which prompts this military agenda - persuading Southern Ireland to join NATO, and persuading Burnham to radically increase military spending to make the UK on a realistic war footing.

While Burnham’s devolution strategy would probably see tax-raising powers devolved to the Northern Ireland Assembly rather than Stormont having to rely on funding from Westminster, foreign policy will rapidly move to the top of his agenda.

Perhaps, too, Trump could persuade Burnham to give even limited military powers to Stormont - provided Assembly reform could see Sinn Fein out of power and Unionism once again running the show.

Burnham has to face the military bitter medicine that Russia is intent on constantly probing NATO’s capabilities and response times. During the original Cold War in the latter half of the 20th century, the geographical island of Ireland was always viewed by the Right-wing of the Conservative Party as ‘Britain’s Cuba’ - a military backdoor, not just into the UK, but also into significant parts of mainland Europe.

Since Ireland was partitioned in the 1920s as a result of the original Anglo-Irish Treaty, the then Free State (later the Irish Republic) has always maintained a strict military neutrality, especially in terms of full participation in NATO.

Indeed, the Irish Republic has not maintained a strict 100 per cent military neutrality as it has allowed American planes in the past to refuel on its territory in terms of rendition flights.

And while Irish republicanism may wish to see a border poll on Irish unity by 2030, the bitter reality is that the West may well be at war with Russia come that date.

In such a conflict, neutrality will not be an option as the island of Ireland is ideally located for stationing, arming and servicing NATO’s planes, ships and submarines. It would also be the perfect location, too, for land-based missiles to attack Russia’s northern fleet in the Atlantic. While Russia may wish to prioritise neutralising NATO’s missile capacity on mainland Europe, the ability to strike key targets in Russia from Irish-based missile sites may give NATO a tactical advantage.

The Middle East conflict is also presenting Burnham with an additional foreign policy headache. For several years, the British establishment has been struggling to contain the so-called small boat crisis, which has seen tens of thousands of illegal migrants and asylum seekers enter the UK from France using small rubber boats to cross the English Channel.

Militarily, there is the real danger that radical Islamic groups could use the small boat route to sneak terrorist activists into the UK.

It has not gone unnoticed by the current Iranian regime, which supports the terror groups Hamas and Hezbollah, that the UK allowed British bases to be used by the Trump regime in United States to attack Iran through airborne bombing raids.

The peace process triggered by that Good Friday Agreement has resulted in a more open travel border between Northern Ireland as part of the UK, and the rest of Southern Ireland. Likewise, many illegal migrants are also using this open border to access the UK via Northern Ireland and then on to mainland Britain.

Given Russia’s clear support for the Iranian regime, it makes military sense for Moscow to support the migrant route in Ireland as a means of getting radical Islamic terror activists onto the island, and therefore, as a back door to the wider UK and Europe.

Whether it be to act as buffers to combat either Russian expansionism or radical Islamic terrorism, it makes clear military sense for Burnham to negotiate a new Anglo-Irish Treaty to replace the Good Friday Agreement to ensure that Southern Ireland gives up its current military neutrality in exchange for a future pro-active and full participation in NATO.

Certainly, knowing the strategic importance of geographical Ireland, Burnham cannot afford to wait until Russia makes its military move on mainland Europe beyond the borders of Ukraine.

While Unionists may see any new Anglo-Irish Treaty as a shift towards Irish unity, Stormont and Dublin must be prepared to work together more closely to face the threat of Russian aggression head on. The Trump visit may well signal the start of this much-needed process.
 
Follow Dr John Coulter on Twitter @JohnAHCoulter
Dr Coulter has been a journalist since 1978 and is currently a political commentator with GB News.

Trump Trip Should Persuade Eire To Join NATO

Jim Duffy ✍ The Irish have a very timid understanding of security and defence and governments are easily intimidated by fanatical devotees of neutrality and their reducing of every debate to pointless chants.


RTÉ is the same. Just look at the mass coverage the station gives to Paul Murphy when Murphy demonstrates a spectacular lack of basic understanding on the topic. In an article earlier this week RTE gave Murphy one third of the article in comments despite demonstrably not knowing what he is talking about.
 
Why is PBP given so much disproportionate coverage in general on RTÉ? It is on 3% in polls. It lost a seat on the general election, yet RTE pretty much gives it equal coverage with SF despite SF being seven times more popular than PBP. It gets more coverage than all the bigger parties in opposition. 

I know there is a history of political bias in RTÉ, as when RTÉ current affairs was basically a branch of the Workers Party. Now it appears to be a branch of PBP, with Paul Murphy and Richard Boyd Barrett pretty much having guaranteed seats in any debate, with Labour, Independent Ireland, Aontú and the Social Democrats struggling to get one invitation occasionally.

⏩ Jim Duffy is a writer-historian.

It Needs To, But Will It?

Irish Times 📰 Written by Sinéad O'Sullivan. 

Europe has stumbled into a new growth paradigm with a reliance on the permanent threat of war

At the launch of the White Paper for European Defence – Readiness 2030, Ursula von der Leyen declared the era of Europe’s peace dividend “long gone”. Peace, apparently, was a phase that we have now outgrown.

The EU’s centre of gravity has rapidly moved from a focus on trading to armament, as outlined by von der Leyen in early 2025, and this transfer of meaning is not happening through defence memorandums but through nation state treasuries. Consider the following: the European Commission is in the midst of mobilising €800 billion defence spending by 2030; more than 15 member states have activated “escape clauses” to enable an economic breach of fiscal rules to procure weapons; €150 billion of so-called “bomb bonds” has been raised for collective borrowing; a new multilateral bank – the Defence, Security and Resilience Bank – is targeting hundreds of billions of euro, with Belgium, Greece, Romania, Latvia and Ukraine among its founders; Canada has been admitted as a non-EU member state, in a leadership role, on many of these initiatives.

Continue @ Irish Times.

The Irish Government Is Helping To Usher In A New Wartime Economy In Europe

Jim Duffy ✍ In other contexts the TUPOLEV TU-95 bear bomber was used to send a message to countries that they were a target for Russia in any war. 

It repeatedly targeted Irish-controlled air space (that is, not the sovereign airspace, as that would potentially constitute an illegal act under international law, but the international airspace a country had the legal obligation to police to secure international civilian airflight) between 2017 and 2020.
 
They were no accidental arrivals. At one stage Irish-controlled airspace was targeted twice in two days. Each time, as Ireland's chronically underfunded defence means its air corps cannot intercept planes it had to call out the RAF to intercept the bears and force them out.
 
Russia was sending a deliberate message to Ireland - you are a target for Russia. This was nothing to do with Irish support for Ukraine, the standard spin of the neutrality hardliners. This was before Russia's second invasion of Ukraine. All countries are Russian targets. Every one. Neutrals and NATO alike. Every country had the bear bomber message. Russia sent the message to neutrals 'Neutrality is irrelevant. You are a target.'
 
It is well known why Irish airspace and waters are a target. Russia in any war intends to use Irish airspace and waters to launch ballistic missiles, and potentially nuclear missiles. That is why potentially nuclear-armed nuclear submarines frequently are in Irish waters, as with the submarine in Cork harbour some years ago.
 
Knowing the Irish, through chronic underfunding, is unable to do basic defence, Russia knows Ireland is dependent on the RAF and Royal Navy. However they need to be acting on an Irish request or with Irish permission. That takes time. Russia needs to know how quickly can its bear bombers or submarines intercept and evict its bear bombers and submarines. That would tell it how much time it has to launch missiles, whether ballistic or nuclear, from Ireland.
 
So, Irish negligence is not a threat to itself. It puts every potential target, including major cities in Europe, at risk.
 
People like Richard Boyd Barrett work themselves into a frenzy thinking Ireland is under pressure to join NATO. It is a figment of his paranoia and overactive imagination. I worked in politics in the area of defence. I know the private views of politicians on defence. I did not come across any TD who wants to join NATO. Not one. No party has any intention of joining NATO. Nor has NATO invited Ireland to join or even raised the issue. Neither Ireland, not Austria, not Malta nor Switzerland has any intention of joining NATO.
 
The pressure on defence is not to join NATO. It is simply "fix your goddamned defence. You are putting everyone at risk by your negligence."

They simply want Ireland to have standard defence neutrals like Austria, Cyprus and Switzerland have. Unlike Ireland they take defence as a neutral seriously. Austria has reached 1% of GDP on defence, and will reach 1.3% by 2032 - funded by an extra tax. Switzerland will reach 1% by 2030. Cyprus currently spends 1.8% on defence, excluding pensions. Even tiny Malta, more akin to the Aran Islands times six, spends 0.38% of GDP. Ireland spends a minuscule 0.27% of GDP - the third lowest in the world as a percentage of GDP. Only Mauritius and Haiti spend lower.
 
The pressure is simply on Ireland to have the sort of defence proper neutrals have. It has nothing to do with joining NATO. It is the sort of spending Ireland should be doing as a sovereign neutral state anyway. If you cannot properly secure your waters and airspace, and after one hundred years of independence still rely on your former colonial master to do your defence for you, are you really independent at all?

⏩ Jim Duffy is a writer-historian.

Defence Is Not About Joining NATO

Jim Duffy ✍ Ireland unambiguously never has been and never will be politically neutral. 

That has been made unambiguously clear by successive taoisigh, successive External/Foreign Affairs ministers and others. Sean MacBride as Minister for External Affairs made it clear in the Dáil and Seanad in February 1949 that Ireland is of The West, part of The West, and on the side of The West.

Ireland is simply militarily neutral - meaning it is not in NATO. Its decision not to join NATO was not based on some principle but on one simple fact - the existence of partition. On 23 February 1949, Minister for External Affairs Sean MacBride told the Dáil that:

Ireland as an essentially democratic and freedom-loving nation is anxious to play her full part in the protecting and preserving of Christian civilisation and the democratic way of life. With the general aim of the Atlantic Pact (setting up NATO), therefore, we are in agreement.

He told the Seanad:

We approve of the Atlantic Pact and I think that, if it were not for the fact that a portion of our country is wrongfully occupied by Britain, we would have been in the Atlantic Pact. Theoretically, its aims, its purpose are in accord with our own wishes and our own desire.

Sean Lemass in 1962 said:

NATO is necessary for the preservation of peace and the protection of the countries of western Europe, including this country. Although we are not members of NATO, we are fully in agreement with its aims.

Ireland has demonstrated unambiguously that it is on the side of the democratic West. On Sean Lemass's explicit orders, Kennedy's embargo on Cuba was enforced by Ireland in planes landing in Shannon en route to Cuba. Goods in Soviet and Eastern Bloc planes breaching the embargo were confiscated - to the fury of Khrushchev.
 
Ireland like other Western states never recognised the illegal Soviet annexation of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania and like other states recognised the governments-in-exile of those states as the legitimate government. The modern Estonian, Latvian and Lithuanian governments stress that they are the descendants of the Governments-in-Exile and not the Soviet puppet regimes Moscow installed.

Ireland is unambiguously on the side of Ukraine, not Moscow, as Russia breached the UN Charter in its invasion as an UN member we are obliged to uphold the charter. In theory under UN rules Russia could have been expelled for its invasion, just as the USSR was expelled by the League of Nations for its invasion of Finland in 1939. In practice, the existence of vetoes made the expulsion power, like a lot of UN powers, inoperable as veto powers can simply veto actions against them or their friends.
 
Russia like the USSR has always acknowledged that Ireland is not politically neutral. It regards Ireland as a de facto member of NATO. It was one of the reasons who Stalin repeatedly vetoed Ireland's efforts to join the UN. (Countries are admitted by the General Council on the recommendation of the Security Council. Stalin vetoed Ireland annually, preventing any SC recommendation to admit Ireland.) His death removed the logjam.

He also despised Irish neutrality in World War II as "cowardice" - a longstanding Soviet and Russian attitude towards the concept of neutrality in general. The former Allies like Britain and the US lobbied Stalin on Ireland's behalf, pointing out that though officially neutral Ireland had been working closely with Allies, breaking codes, spying on Axis diplomats and passing on information. Stalin simply threw his hands in the air, and spat out "cowards!"
 
He was particularly animated on the issue of de Valera's dumb decision to offer condolences to the German minister in Ireland on the death of Hitler - perhaps the biggest blunder in Irish foreign policy.

The truth is simple. Ireland is not and never has been politically neutral. It has been consistently been on the side of the west. It is simply militarily neutral, meaning it is not in NATO.

Sean MacBride was clear in the Seanad in 1949 in a speech:

based directly on the contents of the Atlantic Pact (setting up NATO), based on military considerations, based on public policy, the Atlantic Pact is heralded as the new instrument of international co-operation in the North Atlantic. It was intended to preserve if you like, the democratic way of life among the nations of the North Atlantic.
With that, we are in complete agreement. We approve of the Atlantic Pact and I think that, if it were not for the fact that a portion of our country is wrongfully occupied by Britain, we would have been in the Atlantic Pact. Theoretically, its aims, its purpose are in accord with our own wishes and our own desire.

⏩ Jim Duffy is a writer-historian.

Ireland Is Not Politically Neutral

Jim Duffy ✍ The silence of almost all the devoted pro-neutrality activists, on the issue of Aughinish Alumina actively aiding Russia's military in its war in Ukraine, is striking.

Other than Senator Tom Clonan, who repeatedly condemns it, the silence is deafening - despite it being an unambiguous breach of Irish neutrality.

Not a word from Sinn Féin. Not a word from People Before Profit. Not a word from the Peace and Neutrality Alliance. Not a word from Catherine Connolly or Michael D Higgins. Their press releases draw a complete blank.

Yet the same people are always out giving interviews about non-existent plots to get Ireland into NATO - something that has no chance of occurring.

So why then the total silence on a Real live breach of Irish neutrality by an Irish company enabling Russia's illegal war, a war that breaches the UN charter and international law? Could it be that many of the Irish neutrality devotees are simply motivated by their end hate of The West, of NATO and everything else, but couldn't care less if neutrality breaches help Russia, and anti-Western countries?

Getting them to ever criticise Russia, or the USSR, or the Warsaw Pact, is like plucking hens' teeth. They will always bend over backwards to make excuses for Putin, or Stalin.

Some even justify the USSR's illegal occupation and annexation of the independent sovereign Baltic states of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania in 1940 - an annexation that flowed from the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact between the USSR and Nazi Germany. They then say that "to secure peace" the three states should be handed back to Russian control, irrespective of the wishes of the peoples there.

The same people justify the Soviet invasion of Hungary in 1956 and Czechoslovakia in 1968, just as they will justify the Russian invasions of Ukraine in 2014 and 2022 - always of course twisting the facts to inevitably blame The West and NATO. Even when citizens stage revolutions, some Irish neutrality devotees invariably blame The West for engineering a supposed coup - as if citizens have no right to control their own destiny.

Those same Irish neutrality devotees proclaim themselves "anti-imperialists" while cheering on and excusing the most imperialist state in Europe-Asia: Russia. It is a country that has spent attacking its neighbours repeatedly. There is hardly a single one of its neighbours it has not at some stage invaded.

Finland finally declared its independent from Russia in 1917 after the fall of the Tsar - after decades of brutal Russianisation policies under Tsars Alexander III and Nicholas II. It has been recognised internationally as independent since 1918. Russia invaded it twice: in the Winter War and Continuation War. In 1948 it was forced to agree to a policy later named "Finlandization" (the process by which one powerful country makes a smaller neighbouring country refrain from opposing the former's foreign policy rules, while allowing it to keep its nominal independence and its own political system.)

Under it, the Soviet Union took effective control of its foreign and security policy - a period known in Finland as the 'period of national shame' or the 'period of national humiliation.' It finally regained its sovereignty in foreign and security policy in 1991 - and warns countries internationally never ever to repeat the mistake they made.

And yet, one hears some Irish neutrality advocates say that Russia has a "right" to enforce that again on Finland. I wonder would they say Britain has the right to take control of Irish foreign and security policy, or the US has a right to take control of Mexican and Cuban foreign and security policy, or is it only their beloved imperialist Russia that has that right?

When Putin after a century of independence asserted that Finland no right to be independent of Russia, I heard a number of Irish neutrality devotees actually justify his stance and say that the Finns had no right to their own sovereignty!!!

I have come to be cynical of so-called Irish neutrality, as so many of its most fanatical adherents are really just anti-wWestern pro-Russian apologists. I don't have a problem with real genuine neutrality, of the sort believed in by Senator Clonan - though some of the arguments he has made on the triple lock are factually wrong. He at least has a real concept of objective neutrality, not simply a neutrality that is anti-Western and pro-Russian.

That said, factually, the concept of being neutral as a means to stay out of war doesn't work. As neutrals all over found to their cost, if someone wants to attack you they will. Belgium discovered that twice, as did Luxembourg. So did the Netherlands, Denmark, Norway, Finland, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania in World War II. Sweden only avoided Nazi invasion by effectively collaborating with the Nazis and supplying them with critical minerals and a right to use its territory.

Of the other three neutrals in Europe - two, Ireland and the Vatican, were scheduled for invasion by the Nazis, but weren't invaded for reasons unconnected to their neutrality. Switzerland was protected by its geography as it was exceptionally difficult to conquer. No country in Europe avoided invasion by being neutral.

The 1907 Second Hague Convention supposedly protected neutrals who were signatories from attack by signatories in Article 1, which states "The territory of neutral Powers is inviolable." In fact it quickly turned out not to be worth the paper it was written on, and was just an unenforceable gentleman's promise. The convention was negotiated from 1904, signed in 1907, and came into force in 1910. It was broken in 1914, when one signatory, the German Second Reich, invaded two neutral signatories: Luxembourg on 2nd August 1914, and Belgium on 4th August 1914. There was no come back, other than the complaint "but you promised you wouldn't do that!" It had no enforcement mechanism.

Its weakness can be seen that countries invading neutrals have never even bothered formally leaving the convention before breaking it. It is that meaningless.

I am not arguing that Ireland should join NATO, or that it shouldn't. I am not arguing that Ireland should or should not be neutral. However it is important to know what neutrality is and what it isn't. Firstly, many of the loudest proponents of neutrality are really just the proverbial "useful idiots" who are supremely anti-West and pro-Moscow. They are not the spokespeople, much less the guardians, of real neutrality.

Secondly, history shows that neutrality is no protection from attack, as almost neutral in Europe, bar three, were attacked. Those three weren't attacked for reasons unconnected with their neutrality. All those attacked joined NATO when it was created, most at the beginning, a few later on.

Thirdly, contrary to myth, being neutral does not give a country a special independent status that makes it a centre for peace talks and negotiations. One of the most popular place for such negotiations is Norway. Norway was a founding member of NATO in 1949.

One negative with neutrality is that it gives countries a delusion of safety - where they think "we are neutral. No-one will attack us." Belgium, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Denmark, Norway, Finland, Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania all found that that is not the case. Ireland found out that it was potential target for invasion by the Nazis when it began intercepting Nazi communications in May 1940, and quickly made plans in Plan W for Britain to come to its aid if it was attacked. As soon as the Taoiseach requested aid, the British ambassador would send the code word 'pumpkins'. The Royal Navy and RAF would attack the Nazi troops landing between Wexford and Waterford by sea and air, while British troops would cross the border and travel south to attack Nazi troops on land, aiding Irish soldiers.

That delusion of safety may be why Ireland has a tiny spend on defence - despite defence being a core duty of every sovereign state. The average spend among neutrals in Europe on defence is 0.9% of GDP. Neutral Cyprus spends 1.8% of GDP. Austria aims to reach 1% of GDP by this year. Switzerland aims to reach 1% by 2030. Ireland spends a miniscule 0.2%. It isn't just the lowest among neutrals, and by far the lowest in Europe, its is third worst in the world. Only Mauritius and Haiti are lower.

Yes, GDP is an unhelpful measurement for Ireland. However, it is the standard one used internationally for defence comparisons. Even using others, Ireland is way off the minimum target it should be at, as a sovereign state.

And yes Ireland is a target. You cannot have critical underwater infrastructure that all of Europe depends on just off your coast and not be. You cannot have just three interconnectors, and face rolling nationwide power cuts if they are cut, and not be. And you cannot be a net contributor to the EU budget, where Putin has made clear the EU is a target, and you not be.

Whether it is neutral or in NATO is not the point (In reality there is no likelihood of Ireland, Austria or Switzerland joining NATO.) It is that if neutral, know what neutrality is and is not. It is not a protection from attack, as if a country wants to attack a neutral they always do. As a sovereign country you need to take your defence seriously, and you should be spending at least the average spend of neutrals on defence. Anything else is reckless.

⏩ Jim Duffy is a writer-historian.

Aughinish Alumina 🪶 Not A Word

Jim Duffy ✍ It is shameful. 


Peter Burke is holding an inquiry into it. If it is confirmed it has crippling sanctions ready to impose on it. Hopefully the report will be truthful and not a whitewash.

Well done to Senator Clonan on raising the issue. He is a campaign for neutrality. He is literally the only neutrality campaigner to condemn Ireland aiding Russia's illegal war. There was not a peep from any of the others. Not a peep from Sinn Féin, from PBP, not from PANA. They aren't anti-war at all, just anti-The West. They almost had a melt down in outrage when they found out that in keeping with with international law and conventions, the Irish military were training the Ukrainian military in de-mining, something the UN and anti-mining organisations also do and which is entirely allowed under neutrality. The Irish military are international experts on removing mines. But the neutrality activists almost freaked out at what is an entirely legal action all neutrals do.
 
Yet the same activists were entirely silent when Russian Tupolev TU-95 “Bear” bombers repeatedly breached Irish-controlled airspace, including twice in three days in March 2020. There wasn't a peep out of them when Russian spy ship Yantar repeatedly behaved illegally over Irish interconnectors and had to be ordered away by the Irish navy backed up by the Royal Navy. (It had to be backed up as due to chronic underfunding, there was only one maintenance expert left to main guns on Irish ships, and so the Irish ship didn't have working guns. So it needed armed back-up from other countries.)

The same activists didn't under a peep of criticism when Russia sent a Russian nuclear-armed nuclear submarine into Irish territorial waters and into Cork harbour on a spying mission. Not did they say a word of criticism when Russia sent a Russian nuclear-armed nuclear submarine to just off the east coast as part of its studying for Irish vulnerabilities in the event of war.
 
And they were dead silent when Russia illegally planned to hold military manoeuvres by its navy in Ireland's Exclusive Economic Zone. Ships have a right to travel through EEZs and territorial waters for "innocent" purposes. Holding military manoeuvres without the approval of the state who have exclusive economic use of an EEZ, using spy ships, or ships flying false flags, are deemed non-innocent and so illegal under the UN Convention on Law of the Seas, in force since 1994.
 
Yet they have a freak out when a US military plane, with full legal right under an agreement with Ireland dating back to World War II and constantly renewed, flies through Irish-controlled airspace. But they are silent when Soviet and now Russian planes enter Irish-controlled airspace. And they were dead silent when Russian spy planes were spotted over the Curragh, studying the headquarters of the Department of Defence, the headquarters of the Defence Forces, and Irish troops training on the Curragh.

Senator Clonan at least is consistent in his belief in neutrality. I frequently disagree with some of the things he says. His argument that authorisation of the use of the Defence Forces by Dáil Éireann and the Government would be unacceptable without UN Security Council approval, is frankly bizarre. Every other democracy on earth judges approval by the government and parliament acceptable. Not a single other country, not one, requires UN Security Council approval to use their own military. All the other neutrals judge Ireland's triple lock entirely nuts. One Swiss Foreign Minister questioned whether a country that does not give control of the use of its military to its elected government and elected parliament, but instead requires permission from other countries, is even sovereign at all. He compared Ireland's triple lock to the mindset of a colony.
 
I have challenged Tom over and over to explain why is Ireland so special that the standard requirement in every other democracy for parliamentary and executive approval is not adequate. He has never once answered. He goes on then about Ireland could be dragged into war? How, when it has just four ships functioning in its naval service, with only two used at the one time, an air corps with no fighter jets that is incapable of intercepting planes in its airspace, and a military with only 7,000? The chance of Ireland ever entering a war is Infinitesimally small. Even if wanted to, it doesn't have the means to.
 
Neutral Switzerland has not fought a war in two hundred years, and it just needs the approval of the government and parliament. Sweden was neutral from 1812 to 2024. It requires the approval of parliament and government and has fought any war since the Russo-Swedish War (1808-09). No neutral other than Finland (when like its neighbours it was continually attacked by Russia/The Soviet Union, who attacked it twice in the 20th century) and Cyprus (which was invaded by Turkey) have been a war against anyone, and both were attacked. They did not attack anyone. And they all simply require parliamentary and government approval.
 
So the idea that simply requiring government and Dáil approval would see Ireland go to war is bonkers. Even if it had the sort of defence spending normal neutrals have it would be incapable of entering a war. It would simply have the capacity to defend itself. So, the idea that the triple lock prevented Ireland going to war is laughable. It is just the mindset of a colony - that we need the approval of our betters to use our own military.
 
I have been waiting to hear of a single credible argument that justifies the triple lock. Not a single credible argument for it has been made. Tom has tried at least to make arguments, but his argument is full of holes.
 
But at least his arguments on neutrality are consistent and applied to all. Very few supporters of neutrality are consistent. They just hate The West, while grovelling towards Russia and China - are silent on their actions. They seem to ludicrously blame The West and in particular NATO for everything. 

It is a wonder they didn't blame it for Storm Eowyn too! 🤣

⏩ Jim Duffy is a writer-historian.

Not A Peep

Tommy McKearney ☭ Press headlines in Washington on Patrick’s Day 2026 were carrying the news that Joe Kent, director of the US National Counterterrorism Centre, and once a staunch MAGA supporter, had resigned.


What was really surprising, though, was his reason for quitting. Kent wrote on Twitter that he couldn’t continue because he believed Trump’s assault on Iran was unnecessary, saying that Tehran posed “… no immediate threat to our nation…” adding that the conflict was launched “… due to pressure from Israel and its powerful American lobby…”.


Not that such a trenchant criticism — and indeed exposé — of the USA’s blood-soaked campaign of conquest in the Middle East was having any impact on the Irish delegation to the White House.

While America’s imperial master was absorbing the news that a one-time devotee (along with several other leading MAGA supporters) was causing a headache for the regime, his ego was being massaged by a kowtowing Micheál Martin, sliding in to present Trump with a bowl of shamrock.

Amazingly, this crawling performance from the Taoiseach was reported by the Irish mass media as a successful day’s work. Not only had the Fianna Fáil leader apparently managed to avoid antagonising the emperor but had even contrived to speak up for Britain’s Prime Minister, Keir Starmer.

All of which missed the very real point that the photos of a simpering Martin alongside Donald Trump were effectively dismissing the murderous behaviour of US imperialism’s frontman. Ireland’s premier was greenwashing a cruel monster who had facilitated, if not actually supervised, genocide in Gaza, ordered an illegal and unprovoked attack on Iran that began with the massacre of 168 schoolgirls, and had ordered a savage blockade of the small Caribbean island that is Cuba.

In order to counter criticism of this revolting pandering in the White House, the coalition government promoted the excuse that the Republic is economically dependent on the goodwill of Trump. To antagonise the tanned autocrat, they said, would risk endangering US investment in the 26 Counties.

Notwithstanding the fact that acquiescing in this charade is morally repugnant, the reasoning underpinning the decision to “cuddle up” with the US empire is flawed — and dangerously so.

In the first instance, it is widely accepted, even by free-market economists, that the Republic’s government should be seeking to diversify the economy away from its over-dependency on a few US multinational companies. Last month a study¹ delivered by Professor Alan Ahearne of UCG stated that this degree of reliance was “… a structural vulnerability of the Irish economy which public policy should seek to address.”

The reason Micheál Martin and his coalition cronies refuse to instigate a different economic policy is not due to being unaware of the need to do so. Their motivation arises from a determination to preserve the current class structures. Not antagonising Trump also extends to endorsing the US model of capitalism with its rule by the wealthy privileged few.

By the same token, the warm words for Keir Starmer (and Winston Churchill!) were designed to embed still further the southern Irish state within the imperialist sphere. To achieve this end the old Empire, on which the sun has now set, was recently invited to send its navy back into the Republic’s territorial waters.

Last month the Financial Times reported² that during a meeting in Cork, Martin and Starmer agreed a “defence and security pact” which would, in a statement issued later from Downing Street, mean that “… both countries have … committed to completing a series of joint exercises…”. The article continued by saying that the Irish government has recently unveiled a maritime security strategy involving working closely with the UK-led Joint Expeditionary Force, composed of ten NATO members.

Taken together, we have a situation whereby the government in Dublin is seen to have a servile relationship with US imperialism and its despotic president. Any doubts about the nature of the connection are set aside by the granting of Shannon Airport for use by the American military.

When this fact is considered in tandem with the Irish state joining a NATO expeditionary force led by Britain, it is not remotely credible to claim the country is neutral. In reality it has to be accepted that the 26 Counties is a participant in the imperialist world order and is, moreover, seen to be so. The implications of such a stance are obvious. In the event of a global conflict, Ireland is a target. And all this done to maintain an economic system that preserves existing class structures and the privilege it provides for the few.

For the sake of decency and for the protection of the people it is imperative that we remove the current ruling class and its capitalist programme and, in its place, establish a Workers’ Republic.

Tommy McKearney is a left wing and trade union activist.
He is author of The Provisional IRA: From Insurrection to Parliament.
Follow on Twitter @Tommymckearney

Shamrock And Shame 🪶 Ireland’s Kowtow To Imperialism