Showing posts with label Afghanistan. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Afghanistan. Show all posts
Atheist Alliance International ✏Written by Petros Tatsopoulos.

We have news from Afghanistan. No, it’s not good news. This is no surprise – it would be a surprise if we had good news. 

For decades, Afghanistan has been an experimental laboratory of dystopia. Compared to what takes place in Afghanistan, the dark visions of George Orwell, Aldous Huxley or Philip Dick look like amusement parks for slightly perverted adults. 

When we say that nothing worse can happen in that ill-fated place, more, new records of paranoid authoritarianism are being constantly broken, and the bar of social insanity is being raised higher and higher.

These days the Taliban are celebrating the third anniversary of their seizure of power. Since the mood is celebratory, they thought to have a feast with a bill, based on an earlier decree of 2022 – a “social traffic code” so repugnant as to scandalize even the United Nations field mission (the UN missions, as you understand, are not easily triggered). So under this new “code”, Afghan women, with threatened penalties ranging from warning to confiscation of property and imprisonment, will not only have to continue to have their faces and the rest of their bodies fully covered when they are out of the house . . . 

Continue reading @ AAI.

Not Even Their Voices!

A Lawyer Writes ✒ Inquiry says ministry has allocated insufficient resources to evidence disclosure. Written by Joshua Rozenberg. Recommended by Christy Walsh. 

The independent judicial inquiry into alleged unlawful killings by UK special forces in Afghanistan has run into delays because the Ministry of Defence (MoD) has not put enough resources into meeting the inquiry’s deadlines.

The inquiry is now examining what were called deliberate detention operations. It says the MoD has known of the inquiry’s timings “for some considerable time”.

A spokesperson for the inquiry said it had set out a phased approach to its work and told the MoD at various times last year how it wanted to proceed with its evidential timetable.

“The MoD do not have enough resources allocated to meet those deadlines for the disclosure of evidence,” the spokesperson added. The government’s suggested timeline would substantially delay the inquiry’s work.

Sir Charles Haddon-Cave, the appeal judge appointed by the MoD to chair the inquiry, had wanted to deliver his report without delay. “However,” said the spokesperson, “this issue makes it clear that the chair’s original timetable may now not be possible.”

Continue reading @ A Lawyer Writes.

MoD Accused Of SAS Inquiry Delays

Only Sky ✏ When the US pulled out of Afghanistan, you might have assumed that was the end of the story.

Adam Lee

The Taliban swiftly retook control of the country—and everyone expected that they would reimpose their brutal theocracy. 

They’d ban all heretical pursuits like books, music, sports and education. They’d return Afghanistan to a medieval stasis. Innovation and change would cease, and life would contract to the endless echoing of Qur’anic verses. The ease of their victory over the US-backed government made it seem that they’d achieve all their goals without facing any serious resistance.

However, that proved to be false. It turns out, not even the Taliban can control Afghanistan. A new enemy has arisen to threaten their grasp on power.

The Taliban face an insurgency of their own

In the nearly two years since the Taliban seized control of Afghanistan, ISIS-K has scaled up the volume and complexity of attacks across the country, putting pressure on the new government and raising concerns in the West about the possible regeneration of a group that could once again pose a serious threat internationally.

…ISIS-K’s recent attacks have largely been aimed at the Taliban . . . 

Continue reading @ Only Sky.

Taliban Vs. ISIS 💣 The Endless Wars Of Religious Fundamentalism

Richard Norton Taylor - writing in Declassified UK. Recommended by Christy Walsh.

12-October-2023

An independent inquiry has heard shocking allegations of how SAS soldiers engaged in a “widespread and systematic pattern of unlawful extrajudicial killings” - which were known at the highest levels of the UK government, even in Downing St, but covered up for years.

The judge-led inquiry was forced on a reluctant Ministry of Defence (MoD) after allegations surfaced repeatedly in the media before families of Afghans killed by SAS troops, including the execution of Afghan males of “fighting age” between 2010 and 2013, took the claims to the high court.

The inquiry has heard devastating allegations, some of them privately backed at the time by serving SAS troops, that were persistently ignored. Commanders attempted to block investigations by the military police, according to detailed claims backed up by witnesses.

Computer records of SAS activities are reported to have been permanently and deliberately wiped before they could be shown to military investigators.

The inquiry is particularly significant with the combination of a catalogue of allegations backed up by detailed evidence shedding unprecedented light on the SAS, the least accountable of organs of the British state.

Continue reading @ Declassified UK.

Whitehall’s Cover-Up Of SAS Killings In Afghanistan

Maryam Namazie ✊An Open Letter From Iranian And Afghan Women, International Lawyers And Global Women Leaders Urging Countries To Recognize The Crime Of Gender Apartheid.



One Law for All Spokesperson Maryam Namazie joins a coalition of female lawyers, judges, activists and other global leaders to name the atrocities against the women and girls of Iran and Afghanistan for what they are: Gender Apartheid. 

This effort is being led by legal experts who are pursuing a path to have Gender Apartheid recognised as a crime against humanity in international law in the same way that Racial Apartheid has been recognised. You can learn more and sign onto the campaign here.

As a diverse coalition of Iranian and Afghan women leaders, international legal practitioners, activists and other stakeholders, we are calling on states to recognize the crime of gender apartheid to counteract and eventually end the systems of gender apartheid currently in place in the Islamic Republic of Iran, and in Afghanistan under the Taliban.

The Islamic Republic of Iran and the Taliban in Afghanistan are often described as “gender apartheid” regimes for their treatment of women as second-class citizens under law and policy. However, apartheid standards in international law, developed primarily in the 20th century, were designed to address racial apartheid.

Apartheid comes from the Afrikaans word for “apart.” The term was born out of apartheid South Africa, and its system of institutionalized racial segregation and discrimination, which sought to establish and maintain dominance by white South Africans over black South Africans. That system eventually came to an end, in part because of decades of pressure and isolation from international actors through shaming and severing diplomatic and economic relations.

While representing a distinct form of apartheid from that in South Africa, the components of systematic segregation and subjugation that make up apartheid are also present in Afghanistan and Iran today.

Under the Taliban, women in Afghanistan are banned from education, employment in NGOs and in government, and from traveling long distances without a male guardian, all while having to abide by a severe dress code. 

In the Islamic Republic of Iran, women are banned from many fields of study, sporting events, and from obtaining a passport and traveling outside the country without their husband’s permission. Women’s lives and their testimony are worth half a man under the law and they are forced to wear compulsory hijab. These bans, and the broader legal systems they belong to, seek to establish and maintain women’s subjugation to men, and the State. Violation of these laws can lead to violence, imprisonment, and death.

Looking to the example of the international community’s condemnation of apartheid South Africa, women living in Iran and Afghanistan are requesting similarly internationalized responses to end the gender apartheid regimes they are subject to. In order to fully realize the goals of the woman-led revolution in Iran and to support the courageous defiance of Afghan women who have had their rights brutally stripped away, the international community must properly recognize the harms of a legally enshrined system in which women are treated as second-class citizens and acknowledge this not only through condemnation but through effective, concerted action.

The situations in the Islamic Republic of Iran and under the Taliban in Afghanistan are not simply cases of gender discrimination. Rather, these systems are perpetuating a more extreme, systematic and structural war against women designed to dehumanize and repress them for purposes of entrenching power.

Our chief demands to governments:

  1. amplify and center the experiences of women in Iran and Afghanistan living under gender apartheid,
  2. make statements, issue resolutions and shape other policy responses to condemn the gender apartheid regimes in Iran and Afghanistan, and
  3. interpret and/or expand the legal definition of apartheid under international and national laws to include severe forms of institutionalized gender-based discrimination.

Maryam Namazie is an Iranian-born activist and Spokesperson of the
Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain and One Law for All.

Crime Of Gender Apartheid

Fra Hughes ✒ How is the US deliberately attempting to provoke civil wars in Iraq, Afghanistan, and Lebanon?

First Published In
Al Mayadeen English.

Iraq

When America, Britain, and the coalition of the greedy decided to crush Iraq under a barrage of bombs, cruise missiles, and multiple munitions, in its campaign of Shock and Awe to destroy Iraq, it was only the beginning.


With claims that Iraqi Generals had been corrupted in advance and the much-celebrated Republican guard would collapse, the western imperialist destruction of another sovereign state was only in its embryonic stage.

Crushing the Iraqi military was not a complicated matter. The overwhelming superiority of western military technology and firepower left the outcome of the war in little doubt, but like all wars winning was only beginning. It was the following occupation that would lead to brutal repression coupled with a hearts and minds propaganda blitz on the Iraqi people.

The real threat to western financial gain in Iraq through its programs of resource theft would be a united Iraqi resistant axis, utilizing all of the Iraqi territories, all of its resistance networks, and all those willing to play a part in a national war of liberation against the illegal occupying forces mainly British and American.

In order to prevent the Iraqi resistance from resisting the invaders, a way was to be found to weaken the resistance and have the Iraqi people fight each other and not the Anglo-American invaders.

Sectarian murder was not a feature of daily life in Iraq prior to the 2003 invasion.

Then one Friday afternoon as people knelt in prayer in a Mosque probably praying for peace and an end to the violence and death brought to them at the hands of the invaders, a bomb shattered those prayers for peace along with the bodies of those saying those prayers and a new horror was visited upon the Iraqi people.

An attack on the Imam Ali Mosque in Najaf on 29 August 2003 left 95 Shia worshippers dead including Ayatollah Mohammed Bakir al-Hakim the spiritual leader of the Islamic revolution in Iraq.

This monstrous event occurred just five months after the invasion of Iraq on March 20, 2003.

Who was behind this hideous heinous act may never really be known. Al-Qaeda militants later claimed responsibility but that was in 2007.

Many wonder was this a deliberate attempt to provoke a civil war in Iraq?

Was it American or British special forces?

Was it others acting on behalf of, or directed by, western imperialists or Zionists interested in further destabilizing Iraq?

The result was a protracted campaign targeting Mosques, targeting the most vulnerable in society, people at prayer, and the resistance against the foreign occupation crumbled as the country fell into ethnic pseudo-religious sectarian strife. A Shia- Sunni civil war was instigated.

The losers were all those who died, all those who were injured, all those who grieved at the loss of loved ones, and a society that lost security as it became a victim of a senseless indiscriminate campaign of random civilian murders.

The winners were the West and its illegal occupation of Iraq, who were then given a freer hand to rob and plunder at will with little coordinated opposition.

In September 2005 in Basra, two undercover British soldiers disguised as Iraqi civilians shot and killed two Iraqi police officers who had tried to question them. The two SAS officers, Special Air Service soldiers were later detained and their car was found to contain explosives.

They were subsequently freed when the British army using tanks and a SAS assault team stormed the place where they were legally detained and illegally snatched them from lawful custody.

You can make up your own mind on why they were disguised as Iraqi nationals, why they murdered two friendly Iraqi police officers and why they had explosives in their car?

They divided the Iraqi people and the Iraqi resistance and they conquered Iraq for two decades.

Afghanistan

America has made a tactical withdrawal from Afghanistan.

Many claim it is a humiliating defeat for America which it is, but America left voluntarily.

There was no Taliban army at the gates of Kabul. The reality is the Taliban controlled the countryside and the invaders, Britain and America, had the cities.

That was the trade-off, that was the stand-off.

Biden, corporate America, and their hangers-on in the United Kingdom establishment along with the military-industrial complex have robbed Afghanistan as much as they can.

They have used British and American taxpayers' monies to destroy Afghanistan and pay for its continued occupation with trillions of dollars being paid out to private contractors and weapons manufacturers.

America, Britain and now bizarrely Australia are looking to project their power into the South China Sea in an attempt to retain their first world dominance of global commerce, finance, and technology.

A battle they have already lost.

In leaving Afghanistan they appear determined to destabilize the incoming victorious Taliban Afghan government.

They want to keep Afghanistan impoverished at war and away from the influence of China, Russia, and Iran.

To that end, we have now witnessed bombs exploding outside Shia mosques in Afghanistan, killing many, just like we saw in Iraq.

The seeds of civil war and war by proxies of the Afghan ISIS-K who are being reinforced by ISIS elements brought in from Iraq and Syria, armed and financed by the usual suspects from Turkey, EU America, and the Gulf states will only exacerbate the situation.

As relative peace was finally dawning on Afghanistan after another two decades of foreign interference in the internal politics of Afghanistan by western imperialist military and financial adventurism, we now witness the bombs of hate deployed once again.

If they can divide Afghan society through another western-inspired Shia-Sunny civil war, then politically for a time at least they will reconquer Afghanistan.

Lebanon

The tragic events surrounding the Port of Beirut explosion that killed and maimed so many, which left total destruction to hundreds of private homes, apartments blocks, and businesses, the cause of which is being investigated by a Lebanese judicial inquiry.

The inquiry is meant to apportion blame on those who are directly or indirectly responsible for the storage of dangerous nitrates in huge concentrations in the heart of a busy Mediterranean port.

The judge is being accused by many of playing a part on behalf of the enemies of Lebanon in trying to scapegoat Hezbollah for being complicit in the explosion.

As victims and survivors of the bomb blast joined Hezbollah and Amal supporters in a peaceful demonstration at the judiciary offices in downtown Beirut, calling for the judge, Tarek Bitar to be removed, accusing him of being an American stooge trying to divide the Lebanese people, gunmen from the Christian Lebanese Forces opened fire on these unarmed protestors killing 8 and wounding nearly 35 others, some of whom are in critical condition and the death total may very much rise.

For decades, Lebanon -a confessional state- has been at war with itself on behalf of foreign powers like its former colonial occupier France, and more recently "Israel."

From the Sabra and Shatila massacres in September 1982, where as many as 3000 Palestinian and Lebanese unarmed civilians, old men, women, and children were systematically and brutally murdered, after the Palestine Liberation Organisation left Beirut, to the events on October 14, 2021. In order to impoverish and enslave Lebanon, the West and "Israel" use the right-wing Christian Phalange, their political representatives and now the Lebanese Forces to do their killing.

Collectively they are all working against the sovereign interests of Lebanon and are in the pay of foreign nations alien to Lebanon. as Victoria Nuland, American Under Secretary of State for Political Affairs, who it is claimed by many, was instrumental in the events leading up to the Maidan Square massacre of February 20, 2014, in Kiev, Ukraine, resulting in the following coup, suddenly appeared in Beirut on the same day fundamentalist right-wing Christians murdered the victims and survivors of the Beirut port blast alongside peaceful unarmed Hezbollah and Amal supporters.

What is Victoria Nuland doing in Beirut?

Well, she was defending the judge Tarek Bitar whom many Lebanese want to see step down, while simultaneously meeting the generals of the Lebanese army confirming America will give the Lebanese army a further 67 million dollars in military aid.

What has America, Britain, and "Israel" got planned for Lebanon?

It looks like America is buying Lebanese army loyalty with 67 million dollars while Britain already stands accused of running spy networks from inside the military intelligence corps of the Lebanese army through a British company.

Is another debilitating bloody civil war the desired outcome of western and Israeli imperialist adventures in Lebanon?

Dividing Lebanon, so the imperialists and colonial "Israel" can conquer the country.

Divide and conquer? Well after all it's the imperialist way.

𒍨The opinions mentioned in this article do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Al Mayadeen, but rather express the opinion of its writer exclusively.

Fra Hughes is a columnist with Al Mayadeen.

Divide And Conquer ➖ It's the Imperialist Way

Pete Trumbore ✒ The military-focused website Task & Purpose brings us a new chapter in the never-ending saga of apparently indestructible Toyota trucks on the world’s dusty battlefields.


I first wrote about this exactly six years ago when it became clear to US anti-terrorism officials that ISIS was really fond of Toyota pickups. They just couldn’t figure out how they got their hands on them. Apparently, with ISIS monopolizing the supply of Toyotas, other jihadist groups in Syria had to look elsewhere for their war wagon needs, like scoring a used Ford F-250 traded in at a dealership in Houston.

When tricked-out Toyotas showed up on both sides of the Yemeni civil war in 2018, I wrote about that too. As I noted in 2015, the Toyota Hilux and Toyota Land Cruisers have long enjoyed devoted fan bases across the rebel-jihadist-insurgent-revolutionary-guerrilla spectrum, not to mention cash-strapped militaries.

So it shouldn’t be much of a surprise to find this new story, which unfolds at Hamid Karzai International Airport in Kabul during August’s hurried evacuation of Americans and allies from Afghanistan.

Here’s the details, as reported by T&P:

Most of the security posts around the perimeter of the airport had been abandoned, said Lt. Col. Andy Harris, commander of the 1st Battalion, 504th Parachute Infantry Regiment. Soldiers with the battalion quickly set about bolstering the airport’s defenses, yet the situation remained volatile — Taliban fighters were just meters away, outside the airport’s gates — and much of the equipment they’d typically use, like heavy vehicles and machine guns, had yet to arrive at the airport.

What they did have, however, was a green pickup truck outfitted with an anti-aircraft gun.

The obvious question, of course, is how American paratroopers managed to get their hands on a fully tricked out Toyota technical. Well, apparently, they traded for it. Two cans of “dip,” i.e. smokeless tobacco, to be exact. Skoal, brother!

Task & Purpose continues the story:


Because Harris and his soldiers were some of the first to arrive in Kabul, they were light on equipment. The focus was getting troops into Kabul, he said, which meant there wasn’t much room for “our heavy equipment or vehicles with our heavy machine guns.”
“We just had our basic weapons, we didn’t have any heavy machine guns, any gun trucks or anything,” said [Iraqi-born] Pfc. [Alsajjad] Al Lami.
But the Afghan forces had their own gear, including an olive green Afghan National Army truck mounted with a Russian-made 14.5mm ZPU-2 anti-aircraft gun. On Aug. 17, when the Afghan troops informed Bravo Company that they were moving to another area of the airport, the paratroopers asked if they wouldn’t mind handing over the keys.
“There were two guys standing by the truck, and we asked them if they had the keys,” Al Lami said. “They were like, ‘Yeah we do have the keys.’ And they gave us the keys for two cans of dip.”

This whole episode may end up memorialized at the 82nd Airborne Division Museum at Fort Bragg in North Carolina. If the unit gets permission to bring it into the United States, that is.

⏭Professor Peter Trumbore blogs @ Observations/Research/Diversions.

Toyota War Wagons ➖ Take 3!

Pete Trumbore ✒ The Taliban announced the makeup of an interim government the other day.


And what should have been to no-one’s surprise, it is made up of figures notable for their close ties to the movement’s late founder, holdovers from the last time the Taliban held power, and a host of hardliners who made their reputations during the last 20 years of insurgency.

In that mix are terrorists.


For example, Sirajuddin Haqqani is the new interim interior minister. He is the head of the Haqqani network (a US-designated terrorist organization), which has been carrying out brutal terrorist attacks across Afghanistan for the last two decades, including a 2017 truck bomb in Kabul that killed and injured hundreds of Afghan civilians. The FBI has a $10 million bounty on his head for information leading to his arrest.

Khalil Haqqani, Sirajuddin’s uncle, is acting minister for refugees. Another leader of the Haqqani network, the FBI has a $5 million bounty on him because of his past ties to al Qaeda. Four former Guantanamo Bay detainees have landed senior government positions as well. These all had been mid- to high-level officials in the old Taliban regime who were captured early in the US war. They were released in a 2014 prisoner exchange.

Interim Prime Minister Mohammad Hasan Akhund is under United Nations and European Union sanctions for his close ties to the Taliban’s founders and his role as a military commander. Interim Deputy Prime Minister Abdul Ghani Baradar, in addition to serving as a key diplomat, was also a senior military leader coordinating attacks on US and coalition forces during the war.

So yes, the Taliban’s new acting government includes terrorists. But let’s not kid ourselves that this is somehow unprecedented. Let’s look at some examples.

Israel is perhaps the quintessential example of terrorists turned government leaders, at the highest levels. Menachem Begin, who became Israel’s sixth prime minister in 1977, assumed leadership of the Zionist terrorist organization Irgun in 1944 and was the architect of its violent campaign against British occupation of Palestine. Under Begin’s leadership, Irgun was responsible for an escalating series of attacks on government offices and police stations. The most infamous of those attacks was a direct strike against Britain’s administrative and military establishment which was based at Jerusalem’s King David Hotel. Begin ordered the bombing of the King David, which resulted in the destruction of a wing of the building and the killing of 91 people, mostly British, Arabs, and Jews.

In 1983 Begin was succeeded as prime minister by Yitzhak Shamir, who was himself a former terrorist, a leader of Lehi, also called the Stern Gang, a more militant offshoot of Irgun. Under Shamir’s leadership, Lehi carried out a series of assassinations including that of Lord Moyne, the British Minister for Middle East Affairs. Shamir also ordered the assassination of one of his fellow terrorist leaders, Eliyahu Giladi, the culmination of an internal dispute over strategy.

In January 1947, members of Lehi drove a truck loaded with explosives into a British police station in Haifa, killing four and wounding 140. It is thought to be the first truck bomb in the history of terrorism. A little more than a year later, in a combined operation, Irgun and Lehi terrorists staged an attack on the Palestinian Arab village of Deir Yassin. The resulting massacre left more than 100 Palestinian civilians dead, including women and children.

Northern Ireland provides yet another example of terrorists moving into the halls of government, and at the highest levels. Provisional Irish Republican Army terrorist Martin McGuinness, served from 2007 to 2017 as deputy first minister of Northern Ireland. But before he moved into politics, in the 1970s he led the PIRA in his home city of Derry, later rising to head the PIRA’s Northern Command in the 1980s and a seat on the organization’s seven-member Army Council. And in another piece of delicious irony, former PIRA member ... having moved into electoral politics in the early 1980s, found himself some 20 years later with a seat on Northern Ireland’s Policing Board. A former terrorist overseeing the police.

And let’s not exclude ourselves from this discussion. By today’s definitions, the violent revolutionary movement that we remember as the Sons of Liberty was an anti-British terrorist organization that in the 1760s and 1770s carried out attacks against representatives of the Crown, destroyed Crown property, and assaulted and assassinated prominent loyalists in the American colonies. Many of its most notable members went on to play prominent roles in the American War of Independence and the subsequent government of the new United States.

Our patriots of the founding era, familiar names such as Samuel Adams, John Hancock, Samuel Chase, Christopher Gadsden, and Patrick Henry, got their start as members of or leaders in a terrorist group.

So yes, the new government of Afghanistan is loaded with terrorists. But the Taliban are far from the first to make the leap from terrorist to politician to government. As history shows, they’re just a recent example of a pattern in which we ourselves are a part.

⏭Professor Peter Trumbore blogs @ Observations/Research/Diversions.

Yes, The Taliban Has Terrorists In Its Government (But That’s Not Unusual)

Fra Hughes ✒ So where do we go from here? Better still where do we even begin to unravel the pain sorrow and hardships Afghans have endured for decades?


Do we start with the American invasion twenty years ago? Its objective was to end terrorism as part of the ‘War on Terror’ after the 9-11 attacks the anniversary of which occurs shortly?
 
Can we usefully employ this timescale of American and NATO interference in the internal affairs of the Afghan people? A prelude to war on Iraq? Should we start a timeline from 2001? If we cannot ignore the transgressions of the Taliban while in power surely we cannot ignore how they came to power in the first place?

Should the timeline begin with the Taliban gaining control in Kabul or must we delve back even further to the government that ruled Afghanistan prior to the rise of the Taliban?

Now I am not a historian and the situation has been complex for a very long time but let’s just simplify things a little bit.

After three Anglo-Afghan wars, a monarchy continued to rule Afghanistan until a bloodless coup was led by General and former Prime minister Mohammed Daoud Khan on July 17, 1973.

Born into the royal family he deposed the King and inaugurated a one-party-style political system installing himself a supreme leader as President of the Republic of Afghanistan.

Economic reforms were promised but failed to materialise as events on the ground became unstable. As President, he led a purge of the soviet aligned Peoples Democratic Party of Afghanistan. One of its leaders was assassinated and several of its officials; arrested. Many went into hiding and led a military coup on April 28, 1978, deposing Daoud Khan. He and his family were killed and a secular communist government was then established.

With Afghanistan now led by a secular, pro soviet government at the height of the cold war between American capitalism and Soviet communist ideologies, the stage was being set for a proxy war financed by America to destabilise the country and trap Soviet troops in a Vietnam type quagmire of military entanglement.

Many analysts and historians have claimed that the Central Intelligence Agency set out to recruit arm finance and train Islamic fundamentalists? People who through their religious outlook and practices similar to the type of Islam practiced by Saudi Arabia could be radicalised in order to incentivise an armed opposition to the government of Afghanistan. While opposition to the communist government was already established it was about to be fully financed by America, Saudi Arabia, and others. Pakistan was already a haven for the Afghan opposition.

Under Operation Cyclone the Central Intelligence Agency of America financed and armed the Afghan opposition between 1979 and 1989.

A civil war erupted between ‘the Mujahideen’ who were led by among others, Ahmad Shah Massoud joined later by Saudi Arabian, Osama Bin Laden, and the secular government of Afghanistan who had invited the Soviet Army into Afghanistan to help restore order.

The protagonists were ready. The stage was set the actors employed armed and financed and the war began in earnest.The Mujahideen trained and financed by the American government and others succeeded in destroying the secular government.

The Taliban took control of Kabul.

Human rights were repressed and women especially were forced to conform to Islamic law.

America won the proxy war. Their surrogate army which repressed women and arguably de-evolved human rights by 100 years seized power and the American administration was full of self-congratulatory smugness.

Then began the systemic misrule of Afghanistan by the reactionary forces of Islam, the Taliban

The Mujahideen, a collection of opposition forces then began an internal struggle between the Northern Alliance forces and the Taliban in 1996. This struggle ended with the American-led invasion of 2001.

Pakistan and its Inter-Services Intelligence agency ISI played a major role on behalf of America during the Mujahideen revolt and harbored its leaders.

Many of those who fought on the side of the Afghan Mujahideen were not even Afghans but Islamic extremists from many other Arab countries.

With claims of Al Qaeda Islamic militants now training in Afghanistan, and the country a hotbed for fundamental Islamists, America blamed Bin Laden and others for the 9-11 attacks on the twin towers. Although nearly all those accused of perpetrating this atrocity were Saudi Arabian and the only planes allowed to leave America in the immediate aftermath of the attacks were Osama bin Laden’s family. America duly attacked Afghanistan. This was despite claims the Taliban had offered to help America hold those responsible to account!
 
The Taliban had been part of the Mujahideen front which took control of Afghanistan. The Taliban now controlled 90% of the country while various warlords and drugs gangs involved in the Northern Alliance controlled the countries northeast corner.

The puppets of American imperialism the Mujahideen, now the Taliban, went from Washington’s brave fighters for freedom to the terrorists who needed to be rooted out and destroyed when America and its allies bombed parts of Afghanistan back to the stone age.

A twenty-year invasion and occupation costing an estimated 2 trillion dollars alongside countless allied and Afghan deaths have finally ended.

American troops withdrew in a negotiated humiliating retreat on August 31 2021.

I asked at the beginning of this piece, What next for Afghanistan?

Well, I fear more violence destabilisation death, and destruction.

With the Taliban are now back in charge of affairs in Afghanistan amid claims that they want to pursue national reconciliation with the Northern Alliance who would benefit from the disruption of this initiative?

The new Sino -Soviet cooperation in rebuilding an economic supply line into a revitalised economic Eurasia will be a focal point of American and European sanctions and destruction.

American troops may well have left Afghanistan. No more NATO boots on the ground but the economic cooperation policies pursued by China and Russia to include vast investment in infrastructure projects throughout Eurasia to include Afghanistan may yet see a new proxy war aimed at the Taliban government but in reality, it will be yet another war against Russian and now Chinese economic cooperation in the region.

While Nato and America pursue a military dominance in a hegemonic new unipolar world order, Russia, China, and increasingly many others from Iran to Venezuela pursue a cooperative multipolar mutually benefitting economic strategy. America will use every vestige of influence along with the EU to destroy destabilise and attack the new Belt and Road initiative led by China and supported by most Eurasian and African countries.

The war on terror is nothing more than a capitalist-imperialist attack on democracy and the freedom of sovereign nations led by those who claim to cherish democracy and freedom yet they continually bomb invade sanction murder displace and maim millions all in the name of humanitarian intervention.

I fear Afghanistan will not see peace and stability. I fully expect the Northern Alliance and now Al Qaeda in Afghanistan ISIS-K - to give it its American name - to be used and directed by America to disrupt the Belt and Road initiative and have continued war in the region.

Fra Hughes is a Freelance journalist-author-commentator-political activist.
He blogs @ The North Belfast Journal: A View From Napoleon's Nose.
Follow on Twitter @electfrahughes

Afghanistan ➖ What Next?

Pete Trumbore ✒ According to billionaire mercenary kingpin Erik Prince, it’s $6,500, plus expenses. That’s what he’s charging for a seat on one of his chartered flights out of the chaos that is Kabul Airport.


(The situation may be becoming even more dire for those trying to flee Kabul following an apparent suicide bombing attack this morning at one of the entry gates to the airport. The ISIS-affiliated Islamic State of Greater Khorasan claimed responsibility. More than a dozen were reported killed with many more wounded. Update — Apparently there are a number of US service personnel among the dead and injured.)

Credit: US Marine Corps/Reuters via BBC
Of course this is far from the first time Prince has tried to profit from America’s failing military adventure in Afghanistan. Four years ago this Michigan native son, and brother of former Education Secretary Betsy DeVoss, proposed a scheme to the Trump Administration in which the Blackwater founder would hire a mercenary army to conquer and pacify Afghanistan on behalf of the United States.

Prince, naturally, would set himself up as Viceroy of Afghanistan, ruling the country in the manner of Britain’s storied East India Company. In fact, this was precisely the model Prince had in mind, a private corporation whose private army would conquer and exploit a country on behalf of the crown. Of course he’d line his own pockets in the process.

As I wrote about in December 2017, one of the ways that Prince sought to profit from his gracious offer to liberate Afghanistan from the burdensome yoke of American bureaucracy was by stealing the mineral wealth of the territories his mercenary army would pacify. According to the pitch he made to the Trump Administration, Prince estimated the value of strategically important minerals at $1 trillion in Helmand Province alone.

It’s a long way from a possible $1 trillion in stolen loot to a measly $6,500 each extorted from people desperate to flee a nightmare, but to Prince’s credit, the vulturine grift goes on. Never say the man stops hustling.

Given this sorry record, it looks like White House press secretary Jen Psaki has captured Prince perfectly:

I don’t think any human being who has a heart and soul would support efforts to profit off of people’s agony and pain if they’re trying to depart a country and fearing for their lives.

As pointed out in The Independent, Prince’s companies made billions of dollars off of America’s wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. Is it any surprise he’s found a way to profit from America’s most recent defeat?

⏭Professor Peter Trumbore blogs @ Observations/Research/Diversions.

What’s A Life Worth?

US President Joe Biden’s disastrous strategy in Afghanistan could well be the trigger which results in Donald Trump - or a Right-wing Republican Party candidate - being handed the keys to the White House, again. Political commentator Dr John Coulter examines how foreign policy for the Democratic Party has gone ‘down the tubes’.

You would think given the strategic disaster which the Viet Cong and North Vietnamese Army inflicted on the mighty American forces in Vietnam, not to mention Laos and Cambodia, that the United States would implement a workable strategy for handing over power to the Afghan army and government.

But then again, this is a Democratic administration in the White House, not a strong-arm Republican Party regime, so what did we expect from a ‘Sleepy Joe’ Biden Washington clique.

Whilst many of the scenes in Kabul in Afghanistan are reminiscent of the mad rush to evacuate Saigon in Vietnam in 1975, the long-term political implications for the Democratic Party could be even more catastrophic, namely The Donald back in the White House after the next Presidential Election in a couple of years’ time.

Don’t be daft Coulter, I hear the skeptics and critics moan - it’ll never happen. Let’s not forget the uniqueness of American politics. Initially, the pundits thought Hillary Clinton would stroll into the White House ahead of Donald Trump. She didn’t!

Then The Donald was predicting victory over the ageing ‘Sleepy Joe’ Biden. The former lost!

Presumably, the aim of the Democratic Party was that ‘Sleepy Joe’ would keep the Oval Office seat politically warm until it could prepare a liberal African American female for the post in 2024.

But that was before Biden had overseen the greatest military disaster in American history since the surprise Japanese attack on Pearl Harbour in December 1941 which rapidly ushered a supposedly politically neutral US into World War Two.

It should be noted that the Americans did not accept the unconditional surrender of Japan in 1945 until Japanese forces had been utterly crushed. In 2021, the United States has militarily pulled out of Afghanistan before the Afghan government and army were ready to effectively deal with any resurgent Taliban activity.

Is the Biden administration about to sit back and watch a potential genocide unfold in Afghanistan against anyone and everyone who does not adhere to the Taliban’s unique and theologically warped version of Islam?

Put bluntly, how many Muslims will be butchered by the Taliban for not observing ultra strict Sharia law?

And it’s not just moderate Muslims and those who helped the Coalition forces who have to fear the ‘Tally Terror’ - the country’s extensive Christian population would be well advised to get across the border, any border.

Are we about to see another genocide in Afghanistan akin to the slaughter unleashed by the notorious Khmer Rouge in the late 1970s in Cambodia?

Worse still, did the Biden administration do a deal with the Taliban in exchange for America quitting Afghanistan? Given the crisis caused by the Covid pandemic, the last thing the United States would want would be another 9/11 terror attack on American soil.

And given the fluffy bunny weakness and liberal policies of a Biden government, it should come as no surprise to the Western administrations that America would ‘turn tail and run’ regarding Afghanistan.

Publicly, the Republican Party - and especially its Hard Right - must be appalled at the Biden capitulation. Privately, every Republican activist must be rubbing their hands with glee, chomping at the bit for the next Presidential election when The Donald could very possible be back in the Oval Office. 

Follow Dr John Coulter on Twitter @JohnAHCoulter
Listen to commentator Dr John Coulter’s programme, Call In Coulter, every Saturday morning around 10.15 am on Belfast’s Christian radio station, Sunshine 1049 FM. Listen online. 

Has Sleepy Joe Allowed The Donald Back In The White House?

Anthony McIntyre ✒ shares a mish mash of thoughts on Taliban rule. 

Since I first read her book Kingdom Coming: The Rise of Christian Nationalism I have always appreciated the writing of Michelle Goldberg. Like Katherine Stewart, currently a prominent author on the religious right in the US,  Goldberg provides powerful insight into a range of Christian fundamentalist beliefs and practices much wider than the usual whack jobs that TPQ covers in its pieces from Right Wing Watch each Sunday morning.

In a piece for the New York Times titled "The Right-Wingers Who Admire the Taliban", Goldberg flags up “the open admiration for the Taliban that’s developed within parts of the American right.”

Powered by outrage at secularism, combined with a deep animosity towards the Democrats, the pro-Taliban sentiment is transparent. Nor is it something that should be casually dismissed as being on a par with Calvin the Calvinist fulminating on his laptop in Aghadowey, having just been told at Sunday Service that there are sinners out there who hold to the heretical belief that the earth is not 6000 years old. The type of people who espouse admiration for the Taliban are not on the margins where they should be but have influence and access to those in power.

The influential young white supremacist Nick Fuentes — an ally of the Arizona Republican congressman Paul Gosar and the anti-immigrant pundit Michelle Malkin — wrote on the encrypted app Telegram: “The Taliban is a conservative, religious force, the U.S. is godless and liberal. The defeat of the U.S. government in Afghanistan is unequivocally a positive development.”

An account linked to the far right misogynistic Proud Boys expressed similar sentiments. 

Goldberg makes the point about the toxic influence that the Taliban kindred spirit has acquired since 9/11:

the distance between the sort of right-wingers who cheer for the Taliban and conservative power centers has shrunk ... The tragic journey of the last two decades began with the loudest voices on the right braying for war with Islamism and ended with a right-wing vanguard envying it.

For someone like myself with something of a passing interest in US evangelicalism, this is not too wieldy to swallow in one go. Since first reading Kingdom Coming, I have been struck by the points of comparison between the Taliban and the US evangelical right. Take away the Afghan fundamentalists' garb, and the ideas have a lot in common.   

Fortunately for US women the US Taliban cheerleaders are not in power unlike in Afghanistan where the theocrats have set up the “Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan.” Nevertheless, it is instructive that women are to the fore in offering discerning analysis of the dynamics within the US Christian Right. Religious fundamentalists of all hues display a visceral loathing of women and incessantly endeavour to curb their rights and freedoms. 

Now we have a situation in Afghanistan where “puritan barbarism” is the hegemonic force. An Afghan activist succinctly grasped the essence of the Taliban: they only have horns (guns), they have no head (ideas). If they give up their horns (barbarity), they will dissolve.

Despite all the posturing and defence of liberal values the US administration is hardly blameless for the beast being in heat again. The Taliban ruled Afghanistan from 1996 to 2001 when the US reined in what it had breathed life into through CIA covert involvement in the anti-Soviet War which:

fueled Islamic militancy and inadvertently helped organize and orchestrate a resistance movement mostly composed of ardent religious fighters.

Patrick Cockburn listened to the reminiscences of a friend who remembers an era replete with theocrats, neither literate or enlightened.

She recalled Taliban leaders prior to 2001 who could not read or write and, at first, employed somebody to write their signature on official documents. “Later they had their signatures inscribed on a ring they would press down on an inkpad and then on a document,” she said.

The Taliban has its theological origins in India’s Deobandi Islam which:

adheres to orthodox Islamism insisting that the adherence to Sunni Islamic law, or sharia, is the path of salvation. It insists on the revival of Islamic practices that go back to the seventh century – the time of the Prophet Muhammad. It upholds the notion of global jihad as a sacred duty to protect Muslims across the world, and is opposed to any non-Islamic ideas.

Upon seizing power in 1996 the Taliban:
 
instituted a system of gender apartheid effectively thrusting the women of Afghanistan into a state of virtual house arrest. Under Taliban rule women were stripped of all human rights – their work, visibility, opportunity for education, voice, healthcare, and mobility.

Small wonder that in the wake of the latest rise to power by the Taliban it fell to women to challenge the theocrats and their warped Weltanschauung. A day after Kabul fell, and the US sponsored leader of a kleptocracy fled to safety leaving the hindmost to the devil, five young Afghan women gathered outside his abandoned palace. “Small in size but Himalayan in courage” they put it up to the armed thugs of the Taliban. 

Despite their courage the future looks likely to be blacked out by a niqāb. Much depends on whether the regions can force the Taliban to devolve power. But their Sunni "visceral hatred of the Shia as heretics" might well prove an immovable force.

Life no doubt was bad under the US occupation. Taliban suicide missions further compounded the misery bombed onto Afghan villages by the US war jets. The latter claimed more civilian lives. However, under the Taliban it will go from bad to worse. Once consolidated, Taliban will start deploying their horns more ruthlessly. 

 

⏩ Follow on Twitter @AnthonyMcIntyre.

All Horns, No Head

Pete Trumbore ✒ I certainly didn’t think that this would be the topic that got me back to the blog, but here we are.


Let me caveat this by acknowledging that I’m no expert on Afghanistan, and looking back over the archives here, I see I’ve not written much about it, beyond noting some of the more recent absurdities, like dropping a $16 million “mother of all bombs” on a cave to target a few dozen ISIS-affiliated fighters, or mercenary Erik Prince’s proposal to privatize the war and pay for it by stealing Afghanistan’s mineral wealth.

Taliban in the presidential palace, Kabul (AP photo)

Almost exactly three years ago, in August 2017, I noted that President Trump, with his first policy speech on Afghanistan, was taking ownership of a foreign policy failure that was at that point three presidencies in the making. A year later, his administration entered into peace negotiations with the Taliban (tellingly, the actual Afghan government was not included in the talks), which culminated in a Feb. 2020 agreement in which Trump pledged to remove all US troops by the end of May 2021. In return the Taliban agreed to play nice.

This April President Biden announced that the withdrawal would be carried out in full, but pushed the timeline to the end of this month. We know the rest of the story.

Unlike me, actual experts have had some smart things to say. For example, my friend and fellow academic Steve Saideman, who has written books about the NATO mission in Afghanistan and Canada’s experience there, has two new posts over at his blog where he looks at some of the big questions emerging from the Taliban’s victory.

Another academic blogger, Dan Drezner, is well worth reading on the international relations and US foreign policy implications of the fall of Afghanistan. His big takeaways, that the damage to the US here is not in terms of raising doubts about American resolve but rather policy competence, are ones that fully agree with.

I was on the radio less than a week ago repeating what was then the conventional wisdom, that the Afghan government would likely only be able to hold off the Taliban for 90 days or so once the US withdrawal was complete. Turns out it only took six days, with our withdrawal still in process.

What has perhaps been the most shocking to observers, pundits, and policymakers alike is the stunning collapse of the Afghan National Army, one we spent 20 years and hundreds of billions of dollars training and equipping.

The explanation for the largely bloodless conquest of the country over the last several days may lie less in American or Western failures of training or equipping than in a collective failure to understand Afghan society. As Anatol Lieven writes in Politico, the pattern witnessed over the last several weeks, in which Afghan government security forces surrender to Taliban units, often without firing a shot, is one that has persisted since the Soviet occupation and the decades of civil war that followed:

I remembered this episode three years later, when the Communist state eventually fell to the mujahedeen; six years later, as the Taliban swept across much of Afghanistan; and again this week, as the country collapses in the face of another Taliban assault. Such “arrangements” — in which opposing factions agree not to fight, or even to trade soldiers in exchange for safe passage — are critical to understanding why the Afghan army today has collapsed so quickly (and, for the most part, without violence). The same was true when the Communist state collapsed in 1992, and the practice persisted in many places as the Taliban advanced later in the 1990s.

This dense web of relationships and negotiated arrangements between forces on opposite sides is often opaque to outsiders. Over the past 20 years, U.S. military and intelligence services have generally either not understood or chosen to ignore this dynamic as they sought to paint an optimistic picture of American efforts to build a strong, loyal Afghan army. Hence the Biden administration’s expectation that there would be what during the Vietnam War was called a “decent interval” between U.S. departure and the state’s collapse.

While the coming months and years will reveal what the U.S. government did and didn’t know about the state of Afghan security forces prior to U.S. withdrawal, the speed of the collapse was predictable. That the U.S. government could not foresee — or, perhaps, refused to admit — that beleaguered Afghan forces would continue a long-standing practice of cutting deals with the Taliban illustrates precisely the same naivete with which America has prosecuted the Afghanistan war for years.

A lot of smart (and not so smart) people are now going to pivot to the “lessons learned” portion of the American adventure in Afghanistan. Lieven, I think, has the most important part figured out:

The point is that America’s commanders and officials either completely failed to understand these aspects of Afghan reality or failed to report them honestly to U.S. administrations, Congress and the general public.

We can draw a clear line between this lack of understanding and the horrible degree of surprise at the events of the past several days. America didn’t predict this sudden collapse, but it could have and should have — an unfortunately fitting coda to a war effort that has been undermined from the start by a failure to study Afghan realities. 


⏭Professor Peter Trumbore blogs @ Observations/Research/Diversions.

The Afghan Debacle

With the Taliban now firming back in control of Afghanistan and Coalition leaders licking their political wounds, contentious commentator Dr John Coulter puts forward his own solution to defeating the Taliban.

Taliban tales that women’s rights and Afghan citizens who assisted the Coalition forces are safe from radical Islamic reprisals are about as daft as Sinn Fein spin that Unionists will have their culture fully recognised in a Shinner-run United Ireland. ‘It ain’t gonna happen!’

The people I really feel sorry for are the relatives of Coalition forces killed during the decade-long war in Afghanistan as well as the veterans of that campaign who were wounded and maimed both physically and emotionally.

And whilst the Coalition is organising Saigon-style evacuation flights out of Afghanistan, there will still be thousands of Afghan citizens and supporters of the Coalition left behind to face the Taliban’s eventual wrath.

Oh yes, the Taliban in the immediate future is portraying itself as a moderate Muslim movement which will fully respect the rights of those who do not strictly adhere to the Taliban’s warped interpretation of the Quran and especially Sharia law.

This tactic was only to prevent a full-scale invasion again of Afghanistan by the Coalition forces as the Taliban has not yet fully asserted its authority in every hamlet, village, town and city in the country.

In hard military terms, the Afghan government and army - much like the South Vietnamese government and army in the 1960s and 1970s - do not have the will or the capacity to combat Taliban terrorism.

The Americans, as part of the Coalition forces, tried to fight the Viet Cong and North Vietnamese army for over a decade in Vietnam using conventional military tactics deployed in Korea and World War Two. In 1975, the Americans left Saigon with their military tails between their legs.

What did all those - mainly young - Americans die for in Vietnam? You need only visit the memorial wall to the dead from Vietnam to appreciate the suffering and sacrifice which the American forces endured.

Now to Afghanistan. What must the loved ones left behind of those killed and wounded among the Coalition forces be thinking as Coalition political leaders scramble to find excuses to leaving the country.

The Coalition should never have left Afghanistan without first 100 per cent guaranteeing that the Afghan army and government was capable and competent enough to keep the lid firmly on any Taliban activity.

The decision of the ‘Sleepy Joe’ Biden administration in Washington to totally pull out of Afghanistan at this point must rank as one of the most idiotic of any American Presidency in the history of the United States.

Moscow tried the strong arm approach in Afghanistan and the Russians eventually left with their tails between their legs. The Taliban are spinning its takeover of the country as ‘victory’ over the Coalition forces.

By this Christmas, the Taliban will have ensured that its militant version of the Islamic faith and laws will be enforced on the country.

A number of years ago, I got into a lot of hot water for a satirical piece I published on using nuclear, chemical and biological weaponry to defeat ISIS terrorists.

The point being, given the vast arsenals which the Coalition countries possess, conventionally armed Taliban terrorists sent the Coalition political leadership (not the Coalition personnel on the ground) packing.

The big worry for Western nations, indeed for any nation which has a democratic government, freedom of worship for faith communities and a free press, is whether the Taliban ‘victory’ in Afghanistan will spark fundamentalist Islamic groups to start similar terrorist revolutions in other states.

There’s no use indulging in the blame game over the Coalition’s ‘defeat’ in Afghanistan. We can all moan until the cows come home that the Coalition left the country well before the Afghan government and army was fully equipped to deal with a resurgent Taliban.

The key question still remains - how can we now defeat the Taliban? The answer is brutally simple; use the same tactics which the British forces used to defeat the Mau Mau rebellion in Kenya in the 1950s and the Provos during the Troubles.

The British identified those within both the Mau Mau and republican movement ranks that they could ‘turn’ as informers, agents to manipulate a ceasefire.

In terms of Ireland, north and south, you need only read the many books which have been penned about the intelligence war - or dirty war - by ex-soldiers or agents to appreciate the value of ‘turning’ republican activists into effective agents of the state.

And for those who cannot be ‘turned’, the special forces can always ensure they are eliminated in a ‘convenient’ ambush. Take the Loughgall ambush in May 1987 when the SAS wiped out the once-feared East Tyrone Brigade of the Provisional IRA. An innocent civilian also died in that ambush.

Would the Adams-McGuinness peace agenda for Sinn Fein have become a reality if Jim Lynagh, one of the East Tyrone Brigade’s leaders, not died in that ambush? Lynagh - even though he was a Sinn Fein councillor at the time of his death - did not agree with the political wing’s peace strategy and was planning to form a breakaway dissident terror gang.

Would there have been a Good Friday Agreement if Lynagh had been still alive and an active terrorist in 1998, implementing his Maoist ‘liberated zones’ strategy of murder and mayhem?

On the loyalist side, Billy Wright, the founder of the breakaway Loyalist Volunteer Force, was ‘conveniently’ murdered inside the Maze prison by INLA inmates. Had Wright lived, would the Combined Loyalist Military Command ceasefire of 1994 survived?

The Coalition must now adopt the same tactics in Afghanistan against the Taliban as the British forces have perfected in Ireland.

In the past 40 years, Sinn Fein has evolved from being an apologist for the Provisional IRA to operating a power-sharing partitionist parliament with the DUP at Stormont.

Given the number of agents operating within the republican movement, the question still remains - how many people needlessly died to implement this strategy?

Focusing back on Afghanistan - how many Taliban leaders either need to be ‘turned’ or eliminated before the country can be classified as a moderate Islamic democracy? Will it take another 40 years as in Ireland’s case? How many people will needlessly die before this strategy can be implemented?

Time is not on the side of the Coalition political leadership. It does not have the luxury of waiting years until agents are firmly in place within influential sections of the Taliban leadership.

What will befall the Afghan people and the Western powers if the Taliban’s versions of Jim Lynagh tighten their grip on the movement and and the nation?

Follow Dr John Coulter on Twitter @JohnAHCoulter
Listen to commentator Dr John Coulter’s programme, Call In Coulter, every Saturday morning around 10.15 am on Belfast’s Christian radio station, Sunshine 1049 FM. Listen online. 

Taliban Tales And Shinner Spin ➖ What’s The Difference?

Anthony McIntyre ✒ shares his thoughts on the West's failure in Afghanistan.

The blanket protest was settling down for another Christmas banged up behind the doors, where one day seamlessly and monotonously flowed into the next. The news filtered through that the Soviet Union had invaded Afghanistan. I do not recall anybody claiming to know what or where Afghanistan was. There seemed to be a greater buzz around the subsequent Western led boycott of the Moscow Olympics in response to the Soviet invasion.

If few of us had ever heard of Afghanistan, we all knew of the Soviets, some of us even believing they stood for a type of progressiveness, including those of us who had read Orwell. I recall telling Pinta McKnight during one of those black-is-white debates the protest was fond of hosting that there might not be any prostitutes in the Soviet Union. He promptly laughed at me, commenting that perhaps there were no sailors either. The silly trivial things long since lost to memory are suddenly triggered back into being by this week's news that the US and NATO had lost their war of terror in the country.

Fast forward twenty years from the blanket protest and there was a fear that the US might nuke Afghanistan out of sheer fury that someone had the temerity to return the war crime serve on the volley. In West Belfast we tried to put together an anti-war group, but the Left were more enamored to the notion of going to war with each other. Ultimately, that particular group's lifespan was unusually short even for the fractious Left. What you learn with the Left, to borrow a quip, is that when all is said and done, more will be said than done. Oblivious to what was going on in West Belfast, The West attacked but stopped short of the nuclear option, opting for torture and murder instead.

Fast forward another twenty years and we find ourselves the grateful recipients of the most biting and incisive comment about the current state of affairs in Afghanistan. It was attributed to Norman Finkelstein: If you ever feel useless, remember it took twenty years, trillions of dollars and 4 US Presidents to replace the Taliban with the Taliban.

That's about the sum of it. There is little room for doubt: it would take the mind of a Young Earth Creationist to pass this off as anything other than a humiliating defeat for the US and NATO. No going down with the ship for President Ashraf Ghani. He abandoned everybody he had asked to stand and fight and duly took himself off to Oman. The US might have got away with its belligerence had it been capable of better strategic management and foresight. Its highpoint came in 2002. With the Taliban in disarray and Pakistan forced to side with the invaders, the time to get out was then.

The scene was set for America to maintain the momentum of its success, install and bankroll a Karzai-led government, hand over aid, development and security responsibility to the United Nations et al, walk away and accept the laurels of victory.

But no. Its militaristic instinct combined with its urge to be daddy on the global block led it to settle in for the planned long haul and the unplanned swift exit. Biden’s credibility fell on the sword of style. He was merely fulfilling an undertaking already put in place by the execrable Trump. Like Lebanon, Somalia and Vietnam there was nothing neat about the exit strategy.

Tariq Ali summed up a tale foretold. 

In a period when the US has wrecked one Arab country after another, no resistance that could challenge the occupiers ever emerged. This defeat may well be a turning point. That is why European politicians are whinging. They backed the US unconditionally in Afghanistan, and they too have suffered a humiliation – none more so than Britain.

Western state building was an abject failure. Afghanistan was a kleptocracy supported by another, Pakistan. The speed of the collapse alone clearly indicates that the Afghan government was an artificial puppet state wholly dependent on external support to survive. It was on an life support machine, all its internal organs failing to function on their own steam. Once the plug was pulled, life was extinct. 

State building amounted to this: 

In one of the poorest countries of the world, billions were spent annually on air-conditioning the barracks that housed US soldiers and officers, while food and clothing were regularly flown in from bases in Qatar, Saudi Arabia and Kuwait. It was hardly a surprise that a huge slum grew on the fringes of Kabul, as the poor assembled to search for pickings in dustbins.

Sounds like every other country the US has either invaded, subverted or brought regime change to.

Nick Timothy asks of both NATO and the US: Why were we ever there? It certainly was not for the women they promised to free and have now betrayed. 

⏩ Follow on Twitter @AnthonyMcIntyre.

Replacing The Taliban With The Taliban