Irish Times 📰 Written by Fintan O’Toole.

If Israel-Palestine is, for us, a story about Ireland then it should not be a simplistic narrative of good and evil

According to Maurice Cohen, chairman of the Jewish Representative Council of Ireland, the Herbert Park Hotel in Dublin cancelled a booking for 70 delegates to last week’s international conference on combating anti-Semitism.

The conference was held here as part of Ireland’s presidency of the Council of the European Union. Some of the delegates are Jewish, some are not – Ireland’s representative, Colm O’Loughlin, is a principal officer at the Department of Justice.

According to Cohen, the hotel manager asked him whether the Israel Defense Forces would be involved. “Nothing I had said had anything whatsoever to do with the Israeli army, yet somehow that was where the conversation had gone.” The booking was subsequently cancelled without explanation.

Whatever the intentions of the hotel (and one suspects that the cancellation was motivated more by a desire to avoid the possibility of protest than by any conscious prejudice), this should be just as upsetting to Irish people as the effective cancellation of Sally Rooney in the UK over her support for Palestine Action.

Continue @ Irish Times. 

Zionism Is Not Racism, Any More Than Irish Nationalism Is Sectarianism

Irish Times 📰 Written by Fintan O’Toole.

If Israel-Palestine is, for us, a story about Ireland then it should not be a simplistic narrative of good and evil

According to Maurice Cohen, chairman of the Jewish Representative Council of Ireland, the Herbert Park Hotel in Dublin cancelled a booking for 70 delegates to last week’s international conference on combating anti-Semitism.

The conference was held here as part of Ireland’s presidency of the Council of the European Union. Some of the delegates are Jewish, some are not – Ireland’s representative, Colm O’Loughlin, is a principal officer at the Department of Justice.

According to Cohen, the hotel manager asked him whether the Israel Defense Forces would be involved. “Nothing I had said had anything whatsoever to do with the Israeli army, yet somehow that was where the conversation had gone.” The booking was subsequently cancelled without explanation.

Whatever the intentions of the hotel (and one suspects that the cancellation was motivated more by a desire to avoid the possibility of protest than by any conscious prejudice), this should be just as upsetting to Irish people as the effective cancellation of Sally Rooney in the UK over her support for Palestine Action.

Continue @ Irish Times. 

22 comments:

  1. Behind a pay wall, Anthony. Can you put it in an email to me like before? Thanks

    ReplyDelete
  2. Fintan O'Toole is always insightful even when we disagree with his take. I don't think the nationalist/sectarian - Zionism/anti sectarian analogy works. Zionism which is colonial theft seems very much to be racism.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I agree with every word that he wrote.

      Delete
    2. O'Toole is sometimes insightful but, like the rest of us, has the capacity to obfuscate too. On this occasion he pulls us yet again into the weeds.

      The Zionist project was, and continues to be, and forever will remain an ill-conceived enterprise.
      Here's to a free & secular Palestine/Israeli unitary state!

      Delete
    3. Zionism, like Nazism, is one of the few entities that can be genuinely described as evil. The lust for murdering children is appalling.

      Delete
  3. Henry/Barry,

    'Paywalls'---anytime either of you stumble across an article that you want to read but can't because of a 'paywall'---Open up any browser and search 'webpage archive '-----generally the first suggestion---and it will take you to here.

    Then simply copy the paywalled article's URL into the 'red search box' on webpage archive, press 'enter' ***and you will be able to read the blocked article----it works for most, if not all articles blocked by 'paywalls'....

    ***sometimes you are asked to click a 'captcha' to prove you are not a robot..........

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Frankie - tried it and it is like praying - doesn't work.

      It just gave me what you get this side of the paywall.

      Delete
    2. Anthony, very rarely does that happen to me---I have tested it on two different systems (windows/linux) and on several different browers, as a rule of thumb 'webpage archive' works for me ...

      Delete
    3. Frankie - I will email you a link to the piece I was referring to and you might be able to work your magic.

      Delete
    4. Hi,

      send the link or paste it here...

      Delete
    5. Frankie - just emailed it to you

      Delete
  4. Collapsing or flattening history into slogans like "Zionism is Racism" or "Antizionism is Antisemitism" is never helpful. For many Palestinian Arabs, Zionism is a racist, settler colonialist ideology; for many Jews it was a national liberation movement which sought to settle Jews on land to which they feel they have a ancient connection to. There are many layers of complexities in between and there are many shades of Zionism from liberal, and socialist versions to secular or messianic expansionist versions. It is quite possible to as indeed many Zionists do to abhor the Occupation of the West Bank and settler violence and the genocidal war in Gaza and remain Zionist. Likewise, support for Palestinian rights and condemnation of Israeli war crimes is never antisemitic. Name calling such as Zionist are child killers because of the deaths of so ,many -children are as discriminatory as calling Pakistani Muslims as paedophiles because of the horrendous activities of the grooming gangs in English cities and towns. These are points which Fintan O'Toole conveys excellently.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Zionism is racism, mush as Nazism was racism.

      Stealing land and forcing people out of their homes because of something in the bible is racism.

      Nazism had its many shades as well. SS officers on occasion committed suicide rather than murder Jews.

      Lust for child murder is real and is racist. It is carried out by Zionist child killers - prove me wrong.

      A for the piece - Sally Rooney's support for Palestine Action is of a radically different nature to a hotel refusing to facilitate a conference where the IDF might be allowed. The latter is committing genocide and is on the same moral plateau as the SS.

      Ireland should prioritise supporting Palestinians against genocide over Jews against antisemitism. Both are vile but antisemitism is not as savage as genocide. Ireland should reject both but not pretend that one is as bad as the other. Whatever type of treatment Jewish people are being subjected to worldwide it is not genocide. The Hamas 'pogroms' were a counter terrorist operation that used deplorable means. The article seems to suggest that the genocide was something kicked off by Hamas.

      His universalism is admirable but is he blind to the obvious - Israel is opposed not because it is Jewish, but because it is Zionist?

      I think he is a great writer and thinker. I happen to think he is wrong on this.

      Delete
  5. Henry Joy, what is your pathway towards a unitary state in Palestine. Not even the Palestine Authority agree with it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Barry it's the only viable way that the situation can realistically be redeemed. Will it happen in the short to medium term? Slim chance, I'd say. However, a secular unitary state, regardless of how far that lies in the future, most likely will be the final destination.

      This far out it's not about a pathway. It's about an orientation. This is a multi-generational project which inevitably will include false dawns and retrograde phases. Nevertheless a secular unitary state will emerge. Justice will eventually prevail. Collectively people will prioritise safety for themselves and their offspring. They will reject chaos and favour order.

      Delete
  6. I am not aware of any historical evidence that SS officers committed suicide rather than kill Jews. Rather they committed suicide rather than face the consequences of the end of the Third Reich. It is true that the Nazis moved from the Holocaust by bullets to the gas chambers because of emotional strain felt by some of the shooters at the shooting pits.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I believe I read it somewhere around the time I was reading Browning but could well be wrong. There is evidence that shows that individual SS men did refuse to participate and were not punished for their refusal. Steve makes a reference to Wannsee which I was not aware of.

      Delete
  7. Henry Joy, how will the State of Israel disappear?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Entropy Barry. As the power matrix shifts and becomes less stable opportunities to reorganise will emerge. The collectives' need for safety & order will in time triumph over sectional interests.

      Delete
  8. No SS officers or other ranks commit suicide rather than execute Jews.
    However, no punishment was meted out for those in the SS who refused to commit such acts. The Wannsee conference had explicitly forgiven SS members who couldn't stomach carrying out the acts of the Einsatzgruppen, but this is actually a surprise given it came from the worst Nazi of all in Heydrich. Of all the monsters in the High Command we should be eternally grateful he was taken out when he was.

    ReplyDelete