Sean Bresnahan ✒ Yahya Ibrahim Hassan Al-Sinwar was born in the Khan Yunis Refugee Camp, in the then Egyptian-controlled Gaza Strip, Palestine, on 29th October 1962.


His parents had been forcibly evicted from their homes in the since destroyed city of al-Majdal Asqualan, dispossessed of their land by Zionist forces as they rampaged through Palestine, carrying out what would become known as ‘The Nakba’. Hundreds of thousands of Palestinians endured the same fate — driven at gunpoint to the Gaza Strip as the newly-formed Israeli state cleansed the land of those who had lived on it for centuries. All would remain refugees for the rest of their lives. They would die still holding the keys to their homes.

It was there, in that deeply disturbing environment, where Yahya Al-Sinwar grew to be a man. A man of intelligence and highest principle, it could be no other way than that the desperate conditions endured all around him fostered within an unwavering desire for the freedom of his people — a want for freedom that we here in Ireland know only too well, having too been victim to the scourge of colonialism. We, too, were driven from our homesteads, only to the hills and not to the camps. We, too, were starved to our deaths by a power intent on our destruction as a nation. Like the suffering people of Palestine, we too refused to give up on our dreams.

 

‘They wanted prison to be a grave for us, a mill to grind our will, determination and bodies. But, thank God, with our belief in our cause we turned the prison into sanctuaries of worship and academies for study’ — Yahya Al-Sinwar

 

He joined the Resistance at an early age and spent several spells in prison. There he came into his own as a leader, rising to the rank of ‘emir’. He used his time well, studying many subjects including history and even Hebrew, which he used to gain an astute understanding of the workings of Zionism. He was eventually released, after 22 years in prison, as part of a 2011 prisoner swap. He went on to take up a senior role within Hamas, developing the movement’s emerging relationship with Iran. Eventually he became overall leader in Gaza, working to advance Palestinian unity.

Back in Khan Yunis he married Samar, with whom he had three children. In May 2021, long before the raid into Zionist Occupied Palestine from Gaza, on October 7th last year, their home was bombed from the air by the Israelis. Yahya refused to accept that the future for his family would be more of the same. The relentless persecution endured through the years, the denial of basic needs through from childhood, would not be the lot for them. And so, dedicated to securing for his people a future with dignity and honour, he set about planning for a different tomorrow. 

‘Israel is made up of a nation of soldiers with few civilians’ — Benjamin Netanyahu

 

When the Palestinian Resistance crossed the fences holding them in the cage the Israelis made of Gaza, they entered onto stolen lands once their own. In a dawn raid on Zionist positions, they quickly overpowered the Israeli garrison tasked with securing their perpetual imprisonment. Such was the embarrassment for this ‘nation of soldiers’ and supposed regional superpower that many lies were quickly concocted to warp what was a devastating military operation into a supposed act of wanton terrorism. In truth, however, the Al-Qassam Brigades of the Resistance achieved a stunning success, using legitimate military force and action to secure their objective of overpowering Zionist forces to then take back to Gaza as many prisoners as could possibly be attained, for the purposes of enacting a later prisoner swap. History had taught them that this was the only conceivable way to return the thousands held unduly in the Zionist’s dungeons.
 
Behind the planning for this daring operation was the strategic mind of Yahya Al-Sinwar. At its end, many hundreds of Zionist forces lay dead on the battlefield, the Israeli army proving no match for the Palestinians in the hand-to-hand combat of that morning. In the chaos ensuing, hundreds more were butchered by their own as panicked Israeli commanders implemented the ‘Hannibal Doctrine’, killing with abandon all around them. This mass killing of their own people would soon be used, duplicitously, to license the total destruction of Gaza. In the year since, the world has bore witness to a crazed unrelenting genocide.

‘It hurts to lose people, especially unique leaders like Yahya Sinwar, but we are sure we will win in the end’ — Basem Naim

 

On 16th October, Yahya Al-Sinwar died on the front lines of battle — the final chapter for this humble warrior. In the ruins of Rafah, with fellow soldiers he engaged the enemy before retreating to shelter in a nearby building. Their position was pounded by artillery. In the onslaught, three of their number fell dead. But when Israeli forces tried to move in, unexpectedly they met with grenade fire. Driven back by a lone survivor, they again pounded the building from a distance. Fearful, yet, of a further response, rather than attempt to re-enter the battlefield, they sent in a drone. What it found was a fighter in military fatigues, severely wounded to the point of death. Yet still, even then, he resisted — yes, with his dying breaths. The man was Yahya Al-Sinwar. He did not break. He fought bravely to the end.

No better-fitting figure can there be for the suffering people of Palestine and their struggle than Yahya Ibrahim Hassan Al-Sinwar. A man of tremendous courage and character — a man amongst men — you refused to go meekly into the night. A soldier to the last, history will know you as a Founding Father of the coming Free Palestine, as a man whose convictions and actions were something much more than the personal, whose achievements will stand as a universal achievement, for Palestine is the universal cause. What you begun, in course, will change our world for the good. If there is a Heaven, without doubt, you are already there.

Sean Bresnahan is an independent Republican from Co. Tyrone who 
blogs @ Claidheamh Soluis. Follow Sean Bresnahan on Twitter @bres79

If There Is A Heaven

Sean Bresnahan ✒ Yahya Ibrahim Hassan Al-Sinwar was born in the Khan Yunis Refugee Camp, in the then Egyptian-controlled Gaza Strip, Palestine, on 29th October 1962.


His parents had been forcibly evicted from their homes in the since destroyed city of al-Majdal Asqualan, dispossessed of their land by Zionist forces as they rampaged through Palestine, carrying out what would become known as ‘The Nakba’. Hundreds of thousands of Palestinians endured the same fate — driven at gunpoint to the Gaza Strip as the newly-formed Israeli state cleansed the land of those who had lived on it for centuries. All would remain refugees for the rest of their lives. They would die still holding the keys to their homes.

It was there, in that deeply disturbing environment, where Yahya Al-Sinwar grew to be a man. A man of intelligence and highest principle, it could be no other way than that the desperate conditions endured all around him fostered within an unwavering desire for the freedom of his people — a want for freedom that we here in Ireland know only too well, having too been victim to the scourge of colonialism. We, too, were driven from our homesteads, only to the hills and not to the camps. We, too, were starved to our deaths by a power intent on our destruction as a nation. Like the suffering people of Palestine, we too refused to give up on our dreams.

 

‘They wanted prison to be a grave for us, a mill to grind our will, determination and bodies. But, thank God, with our belief in our cause we turned the prison into sanctuaries of worship and academies for study’ — Yahya Al-Sinwar

 

He joined the Resistance at an early age and spent several spells in prison. There he came into his own as a leader, rising to the rank of ‘emir’. He used his time well, studying many subjects including history and even Hebrew, which he used to gain an astute understanding of the workings of Zionism. He was eventually released, after 22 years in prison, as part of a 2011 prisoner swap. He went on to take up a senior role within Hamas, developing the movement’s emerging relationship with Iran. Eventually he became overall leader in Gaza, working to advance Palestinian unity.

Back in Khan Yunis he married Samar, with whom he had three children. In May 2021, long before the raid into Zionist Occupied Palestine from Gaza, on October 7th last year, their home was bombed from the air by the Israelis. Yahya refused to accept that the future for his family would be more of the same. The relentless persecution endured through the years, the denial of basic needs through from childhood, would not be the lot for them. And so, dedicated to securing for his people a future with dignity and honour, he set about planning for a different tomorrow. 

‘Israel is made up of a nation of soldiers with few civilians’ — Benjamin Netanyahu

 

When the Palestinian Resistance crossed the fences holding them in the cage the Israelis made of Gaza, they entered onto stolen lands once their own. In a dawn raid on Zionist positions, they quickly overpowered the Israeli garrison tasked with securing their perpetual imprisonment. Such was the embarrassment for this ‘nation of soldiers’ and supposed regional superpower that many lies were quickly concocted to warp what was a devastating military operation into a supposed act of wanton terrorism. In truth, however, the Al-Qassam Brigades of the Resistance achieved a stunning success, using legitimate military force and action to secure their objective of overpowering Zionist forces to then take back to Gaza as many prisoners as could possibly be attained, for the purposes of enacting a later prisoner swap. History had taught them that this was the only conceivable way to return the thousands held unduly in the Zionist’s dungeons.
 
Behind the planning for this daring operation was the strategic mind of Yahya Al-Sinwar. At its end, many hundreds of Zionist forces lay dead on the battlefield, the Israeli army proving no match for the Palestinians in the hand-to-hand combat of that morning. In the chaos ensuing, hundreds more were butchered by their own as panicked Israeli commanders implemented the ‘Hannibal Doctrine’, killing with abandon all around them. This mass killing of their own people would soon be used, duplicitously, to license the total destruction of Gaza. In the year since, the world has bore witness to a crazed unrelenting genocide.

‘It hurts to lose people, especially unique leaders like Yahya Sinwar, but we are sure we will win in the end’ — Basem Naim

 

On 16th October, Yahya Al-Sinwar died on the front lines of battle — the final chapter for this humble warrior. In the ruins of Rafah, with fellow soldiers he engaged the enemy before retreating to shelter in a nearby building. Their position was pounded by artillery. In the onslaught, three of their number fell dead. But when Israeli forces tried to move in, unexpectedly they met with grenade fire. Driven back by a lone survivor, they again pounded the building from a distance. Fearful, yet, of a further response, rather than attempt to re-enter the battlefield, they sent in a drone. What it found was a fighter in military fatigues, severely wounded to the point of death. Yet still, even then, he resisted — yes, with his dying breaths. The man was Yahya Al-Sinwar. He did not break. He fought bravely to the end.

No better-fitting figure can there be for the suffering people of Palestine and their struggle than Yahya Ibrahim Hassan Al-Sinwar. A man of tremendous courage and character — a man amongst men — you refused to go meekly into the night. A soldier to the last, history will know you as a Founding Father of the coming Free Palestine, as a man whose convictions and actions were something much more than the personal, whose achievements will stand as a universal achievement, for Palestine is the universal cause. What you begun, in course, will change our world for the good. If there is a Heaven, without doubt, you are already there.

Sean Bresnahan is an independent Republican from Co. Tyrone who 
blogs @ Claidheamh Soluis. Follow Sean Bresnahan on Twitter @bres79

58 comments:

  1. As my atheism precludes belief in Heaven and Hell and as my humanism prevents me from celebrating the death of any human being, then for me the resting place for Sinwar should have been in the next cell to Netananyu after their convictions at the International Criminal Court for war crimes and crimes against humanity in relation to the biggest massacre of Jews since the Holocaust plus thirty odd foreign nationals on 7th October 2023 in the case of Sinwar and the appalling level of civilian deaths in the Gazacide that has followed including 16,000 children including incinerations in refugee camps, hospitals and schools in the case of Bibi (and his defence minister Gallant).

    Perhaps Sinwar can rest easily knowing that his genocidal assault on music festivals, kibbutzim and anything that moved in Southern Israel that morning (Yabba Yabba Doo Any Jew Will Do even if they were left-wing peace activists) achieved his quotidian of martyrs that he set out to achieve in the ensuing Israeli onslaught on Gaza; Bibi can rest safe knowing that he is staying out of the dock in Israel for corruption on he souls of the 42,000 Gazan dead and the 1,200 victims of 7/10 which happened partially due to the catastrophic security failures on his watch.

    If, as Sean would have us believe, 7/10 was an act of "resistance" and Bibi's response in the cataclysm that has fallen on Gaza (the worst to have befallen the Palestinians since the Nakba), is "self-defence", then, as Kenan Malik commented recently in the Guardian, we need to seriously rethink the meaning of both terms.

    Sean's account of the "legitimate military operation" that took place on 7/10 curiously ignores the fact that the IDF and Israeli police did not appear on the scene for six hours leaving the Hamas to exercise their bloodlust and rape fantasies on defenceless civilians and to record their depravities on GoPro cameras for the folks back home. (No doubt some IDF operatives have a treasure trove of similar snuff movies).

    Sean also wants us to disregard the basic and universal criminality of hostage taking. That 10,000 Palestinians currently reside in administrative detention and are being subject to a prison regime of torture presided over by far right Judeo supremacist Itamar Bin-Givr does not alter that fact that it is illegal to take hostages anywhere and at any time.

    Perhaps could define what "bravery" it took Sinwar to execute six hostages in cold blood and to personally strangle to death four alleged Palestinian collaborators? Sean waxes so lyrically about Sinwar learning Hebrew in prison so as to know the "Zionist enemy" better. What a contrast with Nelson Mandela who used his 27 year spell of incarceration to get to know his Afrikaner jailers and oppressors better so that he could forge peace and partnership with the Afrikaner nation in post Apartheid South Africa. Sadly there are no Mandela of De Klerk type figures to bridge the Israel/Palestine divide. Come to think of it, there are no John Humes, Seamus Mallons or David Trimbles there either.

    So basically this obituary to a psychopathic, Islamist inspired killer is no more suitable for this weblog than one to General Sir Mike Jackson, late of the Paras and their Derry and Ballymurphy killing streets. The blood of the innocent continue to drip from the graves of both.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think it is hard to doubt his personal courage. 22 years in jail and knowing he could be killed at any minute, he carried on. And by all accounts died fighting in circumstances where the end of his life was certain.
      The attack on October 7 was undoubtedly an act of resistance. The wrong way to resist in my view but that hardly lessens its essence. I also think it was a counter terrorism operation but one that did not manage to abjure the use of terrorism itself.
      Mandela brought an end to the Apartheid state without having to violently overthrow it. Had Sinwar been able to peacefully rid the world of the Israeli apartheid state he might have gone for that option.
      Being atheist and secularist like yourself, I hold no brief for Hamas but still think Sean wrote a very poignant piece.

      Delete
  2. Nelson Mandela was a native of the country whose monstrous apartheid system he dedicated his life to overthrowing. In post apartheid South Africa, he imbued his nation with the ethos of Ubuntu; a peculiarly African form of generosity of spirit. Equal citizenship was granted to all of South Africa's people.

    Sinwar had no such ideas. Violent opposition to the two state solution and the very existence of Jewish people in Israel/Palestine was baked into the philosophy and practice of the movement he led as a reading of the 1988 Hamas Founding Charter will make clear. Hamas along with Jewish supremacists not too distant from Bibi did their utmost to undermine the Oslo Accords. Sinwar was the most hard line of all the Hamas leadership. Don't forget that Sinwar promised that Hamas would perpetrate Al-Aqsa floods "again and again"; ISIS or Khmer Rouge types of "resistance" maybe but not those of movements seeking to bring peace and justice to oppressed people like the Sandinista movement of all.

    Sinwar had no such plan.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sinwar was left no space to pursue an alternative. It is possible that he might have been a recalcitrant ideologue or theocrat with whom no reasoning was possible but had there been space such people are most unlikely to hold sway. Mandela dismantled an apartheid regime. It is the only way to deal with them. The principle of a Jewish state for a Jewish people rules out any idea of equal citizenship for all. Colonial projects are never about equal rights for all.
      I don't thin people pay much heed to the Hamas Charter - it seems to be that Hamas have long been prepared to compromise on the issue of a two state solution despite the rhetoric.
      There is an international criminal regime holding sway in the region, held in place by a bigger power. Both have flouted the rules based order to such an extent that no such order exists. Not for the first time shall I say that Hitler's biggest success is to have created a so called Jewish state in his own image.
      The

      Delete
  3. One man's freedom fighter is another man's terrorist.
    The Zionist and US proxy colonial projects are evil and ultimately unsustainable. Though none alive today will ever see it all occupations eventually end.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Henry Joy, so what should replace these "colonial projects"? I would hope you say "two state solution" (a million miles off right now, I know), if not why not? One person's killer of innocent civilians is always one person's killer of innocent civilians or non-combatants; one person's rapist is always one person's rapist no matter how glorious the "cause". That applies across the board from Ireland to the Middle East and to any conflict zone.

    Btw, my definition of terrorism is any act of violence committed against the person, property or residence of any unarmed human being to further causes for which there are political ways available. That includes animal rights, foetal rights and antivaxxer extremists. Quillers are welcome to add to this list.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Barry, how we slice our perceptions of the world will inevitably be saturated with our values. I aspire to a rules-based order, and for the most part, Palestine's occupation runs counter to that.
      In time the Palestinians' struggle will become accepted as a just war of liberation.

      Delete
  5. Henry Joy, the word or concept of "evil" is often bandied about by people with a very Manichean view of the world. Recall George W. Bush's Axis of Evil used as a prop for the invasion of Iraq. Recall Ronald Reagan's Evil Empire description of the USSR. I recall the then Governor of Strangeways Prison saying that the prison riots of 1990 was down to the presence of "evil".

    I am not saying that you are of that cast of mind. As for myself, I have no hesitation in saying that Donald Trump is a manifestation of evil for the reasons given in this link

    https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/world/trump-and-his-friends-smiled-and-partied-at-madison-square-garden-then-they-got-mean/ar-AA1t2atZ?ocid=msedgdhp&pc=EDGEESS&cvid=a777ff14208e44c7ac450daddaaf7a4a&ei=

    Frankie might wish to click on it and spare a minute or two to find out why I (and much of the US military top brass) believe him to be a fascist.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As already stated Barry I aspire to a rules-based order. The US/Israeli pogram runs counter to any of that. It is amoral and cruel and in my lexicon therefore evil.
      The bookmakers' odds suggest that 'the Donald' is going to make it (Trump 33/50, Harris 6/4). Though it probably means a rough ride for Ireland economically (see David McWilliams, Irish Times, Saturday) there is a slight hope that Trump will behave better than Biden. That slim hope is formulated on how the Saudis & others might hold some sway resulting from the Abrahamic Accords that Trump initiated.

      Delete


  6. More elucidation on Trump as a fascist for Frankie's perusal

    https://www.pressreader.com/uk/the-guardian-e-paper-journal/20241026/281479281903059

    ReplyDelete
  7. Henry Joy, quite apart from ending democracy in the US Trump will embolden Netanayu to do even worse things. Do you not remember him in 2018 moving the US Embassy to Jerusalem to placate his Evangelical vote which sparked riots on the West Bank. Putin will also get a free hand. Frankly I am appalled at you sorry to say.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Henry Joy. Trump will trash what remains of the rules based order by withdrawing from COP, allowing Ukraine to fall to Putin who will the. move onto restablish the Russian Empire. FFS.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Trump is terrible - we all know that. And he has been no friend of the Palestinians. But he has not been responsible for nearly anywhere near the number of murders that bear Biden's fingerprints. There really is not much to choose between when it comes to the presidency. I hope Harris wins it but only because I think she will be less harsh on the more disadvantaged in US society. If she continues to arm the genocide then there is no reason to get enthused about her winning.
      Putin is a much lesser threat to humanity than the US and Israel; has committed far fewer crimes yet has an international arrest warrant out for him while Netanyahu is free to roam the globe. Thank the Democrats for that.

      Delete
  9. Sorry to be so harsh, Henry Joy but after that Nuremberg Rally style hatefest in Madison Square Gardens, I scratch my head at how an intelligent, thoughtful man can see any benefit in the reelection of that walking piece of sewage. Btw, I hope Rudi Gulliani stank the place out with his farts.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. the same question can be asked of how any intelligent person can see progress under Harris. When we opt for her it is only due to the lesser of evils Barry. I don't think Trump will improve anything, feeling he will make it worse. But let's not pretend Biden is not as fascist. The worst of fascism committed the worst of its crimes outside its own nation state: the Italians in Ethiopia and the Germans in the USSR. When looking at Biden focus on the atrocities abroad. In terms of fascism, he is a much more avowed practitioner than Trump ever was.

      Delete
    2. I'm not a Manichaeist, Barry, merely an observer.

      More like this old farmer who lives on his farm with his teenage son. He also has a beautiful stallion that he lovingly cares for. The farmer enters his stallion into the annual country fair competition. His stallion wins first prize. The farmer’s neighbours gather to congratulate him on this great win. He calmly says, “Who knows what is good and what is bad?” Puzzled by this reaction, the neighbours go away. The next week, some thieves who heard about the stallion’s increased value steal the horse. When the neighbours come to commiserate with the farmer, they find him again very calm and gathered. He says, “Who knows what is good and what is bad?” Several days later, the spirited stallion escapes from the thieves and finds his way back to the farm, bringing with him a few wild mares he has befriended along the way. To his neighbours’ excited rounds of congratulations, the old farmer once again says, “Who knows what is good and what is bad?” A few weeks later, the farmer’s son is thrown off one of these new mares as he is trying to break it in, and his leg is fractured. As the neighbours gather to commiserate with the old farmer, he once again reminds them, “Who knows what is good and what is bad?” The following week, the imperial army marches through the village, conscripting all eligible young men for the war that has just broken out. The old farmer’s son is spared due to his fractured leg. The neighbours no longer bother to come to the old farmer to congratulate him. By now they know what his response will be: “Who knows what is good and what is bad?”

      Delete
    3. Kamala Harris is not threatening to remove the guardrails of democracy in the US, Trump is. Btw on body counts Trump was guilty of 600,000 culpable homicides die to his handling of COVID. Biden may be guilty of being an accessory to 42,000 homicides in Gaza.That is for the ICC to decide. But it would be the Israeli leadership who would bear primary guilt. There are no US trips or military advisers inGaza




      Delete
    4. Donald Trump is a stinking racist, probable paedophile and morally degenerate piece of sewage. Kamala may have her faults but she is of good character. Anyone who supports Trump in any way belongs in the slurry tank. I am going on a bit but the America First tally last night with it's putrid hate does raise the blood pressure. Good night from Aquaba.

      Delete
    5. You are really stretching it now to blame all the Covid deaths on Trump just to try and put him on a par with Biden. That is as wacky a conspiracy theory as some others that have featured here. He was piss poor on Covid but the deaths caused involve much less culpability than arming genocide.
      The Israeli leadership do bear the primary guilt for genocide - who bears it for genocide enabling? As Gideon Levy asks what does Biden think the Israelis are going to do with the bombs he gives them? Do there really have to be US troops in Israel when the US arms Israel with the weapons of genocide?

      Delete
    6. He is a stinking racist and maybe the other things you throw at him but Biden is a racist too. He thinks Palestinians are so sub human that they do not deserve the same human rights as other s. Tell me how that is not racism? There is no good character that arms genocide.

      Delete
  10. If Trump becomes President then he will up his murder rate as he turns America into a fascist dictatorship and allies itself with the Putins and other far right dictatorships. Putin is guilty of the supreme war crime of invading another country with the intention of perpetrating the cultural genocide. Putin the Paedo has been indicted for the war crime of the forcible removal of children from Ukraine. His fingers drip with the blood not just of the dead of Bucha and Mariupol but tens of thousands of Syrians, Chechens and the victims of the Wagner Group in the Central African Republic, Mali and other African countries. Quite an impressive body count Just last week his proxies succeeded in rigging the outcome of the elections in Georgia having narrowly failed to do so in Moldova.

    He is the Adolf Hitler of the 21st century. All across Europe he being the spymaster that he is destabilising the democratic process; he is the lodestar for the Marine Le Pens, Gert Wilders, Victor Fat Arse Orbans, Roberto Ficos and Nigel Shitfinger Farages of Europe (have I missed anyone out, Netananyu is quite the admirer as is Supreme Ayatollah Khameini).

    Brexit and Europe refugee crisis bear his imprint. Whereas Israel's crimes are confined to a corner of the MENA region, Putin's crimes are global in nature.

    It is not the Democrats fault that Netananyu is free to walk the globe. The arrest warrants from the ICC may well be held up due to the allegations of sexual harassment being made against the Chief ICC Prosecutor which the Guardian has reported exclusively.

    Finally, I believe that MAGA should be classified as a terrorist organisation just like Hamas and Hezbollah.

    GO KAMALA - the integrity of women's bodies depend on your victory. DEFEAT THE ADOLF HITLERS OF WEST AND EAST!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Barry that sounds like you have been sniffing white lines on holiday!!!
      This was all said about Trump before he became president and never came to pass despite his dysfunctional regime and the many rightward lurches he made.
      I would be more concerned about the real present fascism of Biden in Gaza than predictions of Trump's future fascism.

      Delete
    2. Barry - seriously, Putin the Paedo is hardly any better than Kamala the Cunt.

      Trump will most likely ally himself with Putin and other authoritarian and far right elements like Netanyahu. And Putin is guilty of the supreme war crime of invading another country but the Biden administration is hardly opposed to him because of that given that it arms a genocide in the Occupied Territories.

      Putin, vile authoritarian that he is, remains less a Hitler of the 21st Century than Netanyahu. When you consider the Western armed genocide in Gaza, many countries have good reason to fear the West and its machinations. Which possibly explains the growth of BRICS. Since WW2 has any state waged more wars than the US? It is the greatest threat to world peace. It does not want world peace, hence its refusal to submit to the rules based international order.
      Like Hitler, Netanyahu is at war with how many countries? He has pursued a Hitler-like policy of lebensraum, has used his Einsatzgruppen child killing specialists to massacre tens of thousands of Palestinian kids; his police like the Gestapo torture Palestinians routinely; prisoners are raped in his SS camps. The list of Nazi-like atrocities is endless. It seems a double standard to call Putin a Nazi yet deny that Netanyahu is one. The single worst action in the Nazi playbook was the war of extermination in the East yet here we have Putin being called a Nazi when it is forbidden by the IHRA to call Netanyahu one on the grounds that it is unfair to compare any Jew with their tormentor even when the particular Jew is doing exactly the same as the Nazis did. Why is it alright to label A Russian a Nazi but not an Israeli? At heart it is racism - its logic being that the Russians were lesser victims of the Nazis than the Jews were.
      The Democrats have been putting pressure on the ICC not to issue the arrest warrant. They condemned the arrest warrant for Netanyahu as outrageous yet applauded the warrant for Putin.
      You argue that MAGA should be deemed a terrorist organisation. With or without the IDF? And by whom given that we do not have a rules based international order?
      The integrity of women's bodies is a great idea - think about it when the Democrats are arming the genocide that is literally ripping the bodily integrity of Palestinian women apart. As I said earlier, fascism does most of its dirty work outside its own borders.

      Delete
  11. Only this time he has his plans to deal with the "enemies" within be they journalists, disloyal staff or generals. Only this time he plans to deploy the military against street protestors. Only this time he plans mass deportations and to never hold elections. He had a plan. I suggest you click on the links to my Guardian pieces to get a fuller picture. Biden had made bad errors of judgment but it is an abuse of the term to call it fascist.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. and you believe him after all the lies he has told? Last time he planned to build a wall to keep the Mexicans out. Israel pursues a fascist strategy in Gaza - much like the Nazis did in the USSR and Mussolini's fascists did in Ethiopia. Biden arms that fascist strategy. It is mere semantics to say he is not guilty of fascist behaviour much more depraved than anything Trump has done. You really need to explaining away as bad errors of judgement what is in fact evil. He is not called Genocide Joe because he made a mistake. He is an absolute bastard, just like Nixon.

      Delete
  12. Fascism is an authoritarian far right nationalist philosophy which relies on physical force to pose it's will, which produces charismatic personality cults, suppresses women and ethnic minorities and smashes independent media, trade unions and abolishes elections

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fascism is an authoritarian far right nationalist philosophy which relies on physical force to pose it's will, which produces charismatic personality cults, suppresses women and ethnic minorities and smashes independent media, trade unions and abolishes elections

      Pretty much what is happening in Gaza, don't you think?

      Delete
  13. It should be perfectly obvious from this definition that Biden for all his faults does not meet that criteria. Netanayu maybe and Bin Givr and Smotrich most certainly. Why am I even having to say this?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Biden has supported and armed a fascist onslaught in Gaza. Don't absolve him of his fascist characteristics. No point in claiming to be a democrat at home while sponsoring fascism elsewhere. But there is nothing new in this - US has always sponsored fascism. People are not what they say they are. They are what they do. Biden does fascism.

      Delete
  14. 2024 and I still can't believe people think there's a "good" option between one set of corporate interests in a bought congress or another set of corporate interests.

    While the election run up may be entertaining to watch the result is always horrific. More dead foreigners for the sake of Military-Industrial complex profits.

    Footnote; all of what is slung Trump's way regards being a fascist...why didn't he pull half that shit when he was actually in power? Genuinely curious. I think he fits a lot of criteria but he didn't instigate Lawfare to try to get rid of his enemies like what the Democrats have been frothing over trying to do for years. They are just as bad.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Sorry Steve, but the "each side is as bad as each other" lazy type of sloganising just does not hold water. For starters, read the Right Wing Watch piece posted on the Quill on Sunday on the outline of a Christian Dominion nationalist programme. Then look at Ruth Eilat article in Politico where it is proposed that a Trump admin would deliberately make civil servants at work miserable . The "enemy within" will be dealt with and the military will be deployed to shoot demonstrators in the streets. There is a body of academic work on the mortal peril that Trump poses to US democracy. We have been warned.

      Delete
    2. In terms of foreign policy I think it is true that neither the Democrats nor the Republicans offer much to choose between. That said I think is the worst choice for the electorate in circumstances where there are no good choices. It is less his promises and threats that should worry people because he is such a liar. It is more the forces behind him who know he is pliable and biddable.
      Fintan O'Toole makes the point in today's Irish Times that the one solid objection against characterising Trump as fascist is that 'fascist regimes are typically geared towards war – and that Trump is not.' That can't be said of Biden.
      Yet, O'Toole warns very clearly that 'Trump 2.0 would be fascism tempered by senility, greed and nepotism.'
      He is a dangerous man whose pathway to power should be obstructed at every turn. But I think we should drop the pretence that Harris will be much better certainly in terms of promoting fascism abroad.
      We have seen it closer to home in the British Labour Party. The minute Starmer got in - and remember he supported war crimes in Gaza before he got in - he decided to shaft the most vulnerable in the UK. These people, Barry, are never on the side of the Wretched of the earth and always on the side of the Wicked of the earth. People like you might feel constrained by the art of the possible, and in a world of realpolitik that is something we all need to take account of, but there is no reason to attribute wholesome traits to such depraved people.

      Delete
    3. What lawfare are you referring to, Steve? The two Senate impeachment proceedings for two very egregious violations of his oath to uphold and defend the Constitution which the majority of Republican Senators cravenly and cowardly thwarted. Bit different from trying to violently subvert the outcome of a free and fair election.

      Delete
  15. Anthony,

    Barry that sounds like you have been sniffing white lines on holiday!!!

    Or maybe he met a good Rasta on holiday and he bought some herbs..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. worse ways to spend a holiday Frankie!!

      Delete
  16. Trump wants to use a 1798 law to deport "illegal" immigrants. So Make America Great Again means back to Slavery.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Why do you actually believe Trump when he has been found to have told somewhere in the region of 30,000 lies? I think John Bolton called it right for once - Trump can't think philosophically enough to be a fascist in any sense of the word as understood outside of the abuse armoury. It was said today that the thinness of someone's argument is measured by the speed with which they throw out the fascist label. Perhaps he is more the fuhrer of chaos than of fascism.

      Delete
  17. Ok, Trump is best described an authoritarian, nationalist .populist who takes a transactional approach to politics and who draws upon specifically American far right cultural memes than European fascist ones.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He is dangerous but not because he has any set of political ideas. He is a political moron whose brain can be filled with the fascist ideas of others. That is where the real threat comes from. If the US goes fascist at home he will have enabled it rather than caused it.

      Delete
  18. He is a post-truth politician for our times, in that way he most resembles Putin. The ideology that he draws most from is the paleoconservatism of Pat Buchanan.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. When was truth ever a political virtue with politicians that would enable us to talk about a post truth politician?

      Delete
  19. Probably the most grotesque example of the hollowing out of the definition of fascism was the GDR's description of the Berlin Wall as "the Anti Fascist Protection Barrier "

    ReplyDelete
  20. Trump would be an enabler of US fascism in that he has acting as a lightening rod for the anti-liberal and antiglobalisation (of the right wing variety} that has been building for years particularly since the 2008 crash. Post-truth refers to the growth of "alternative facts", "crisis actor" and science denying nature of conspiracism.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Have a great holiday Barry
    Do whatever makes sense to you!

    ReplyDelete
  22. Barry....

    Recently on TPQ you said---- "Anyway, I cannot be arsed to clock onto your links to shock jockey."---and yet you posted several URLs in this comment section for me to copy/paste into my browser. If you want to learn how easy it is to hyperlink a URL on TPQ --- open this link. Staying with links recently on TPQ there was a piece that was Recommended by Carrie Twomey, when I tried to open any of the links, I was either 'Paywalled' or I got the Irish Sunday Times home page----In the comment section I posted two links to a 'work-a-round'-----I have noticed that sometimes you can't open links because you are 'Paywalled' or other.

    What lawfare are you referring to, Steve?.......Bit different from trying to violently subvert the outcome of a free and fair election.

    Why don't you bring your argument to the former head of the DNC---Rossa Brooks, who wrote an article in Jan 2017 (weeks into the Donald's presidency)----called '4 ways to get rid of Trump's rule... open the link and read what the former head of the DNC said-------"The fourth possibility is one that until recently I would have said was unthinkable in the United States of America: a military coup, or at least a refusal by military leaders to obey certain orders.".


    It seems that point of view has been updated according to the Transition Integrity Project ---T.I.P. headed by Rossa Brooks and including John fuck you Podesta, Obama, and Billy Boy Clinton---held a 'war game' with various scenarios.....

    Game Three: Clear Trump Win. The third scenario started with an Electoral College victory for President Trump (286 to 252), but a popular vote win (52% to 47%) for former Vice President Biden. In this scenario, Biden refused to concede, convinced the Democratic governors of two states that Trump won to send separate slates of electors to the Electoral College, encouraged three states to threaten secession, and convinced the House of Representatives to refuse to certify the election and declare Biden the victor.

    It smacks of fascism. If you want to do a 'deep dive' Barry---- open the link and listen to Patrick Bet David interviewing Mike Benz or goto 7mins until 22mins---I have listened to the complete interview and 'Frankie Fact Checked' Benz and his facts check out...

    GO KAMALA - the integrity of women's bodies depend on your victory

    Take that argument to Kamala 'the cunt' Harris's husband Doug Emhoff and ask him why the nanny he got pregnant aborted or ask the ex he slapped in public in France because she was trying to get a taxi---you can also ask former female members of the LA law firm he headed and how he treated them---Then again it takes a cunt to know a cunt...(birds of a feather and all that)----If you look at her record when Harris as prosecutor for the blue state of California--her record smack of cuntism.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Frankie, for those of us who live in the actually existing world of verifiable claims and factuality as opposed to someone like you who wallows in the slurry tank of "influencers" like Candace Owens, Joe Rogan, Tucker Carlson, Dore and Icky David, a brief recap.

    First, Joe Biden won the 2020 Presidential Election freely and fairly. Trump then initiated the his "Stop the Steal" liefest in pursuit of which he and his mob attempted the violent overthrow of the election result on Capitol Hill on January 6 2021. Just like Generals Franco in 1936 and Pinochet in 1973. Only these bastards succeeded. Trump failed because there was sufficient support for and capacity to implement the principle of democratic transitions of power in the USA which sadly there wasn't in Spain and Chile.

    Second, Trump this week made the false claim that you made in the Quill that Joe Biden was the victim of a coup. Au contraire, Biden withdrew of his own volition (after a crescendo of wise counsel of course) as Democratic nominee for PE 2024 and was replaced by Kamala Harris in a process entirely in accordance with DNC procedures.

    Third, of course any talk of military interventions in democratic nations is worrying. But this scenario has been gamed in contexts such as a Presidential order to use the military to fire on protestors which Trump has promised, where as Commander in Chief he threatens to use the nuclear codes against the advice of the military top brass or where there is clear evidence that he is acting as the agent of a hostile foreign power (his long bromance with Russia makes that a very plausible scenario). Or it could an order to use the military to enforce mass deportations or detention of his "enemies within or to invade Mexico, Canada or Cuba or other Caribbean territories. Or it could be attempts to fire "disloyal" generals; disloyal to him that his, not to the US Constitution.

    I am quite loath to advocate for the works of spooks, but it strikes me that in the UK Trump would have been surreptitiously but successfully screened out as a security risk. It is for the US electorate to do that publicly next week even if Diaper Donald does not go quietly unless it is to flee the country and justice.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Barry,

    for those of us who live in the actually existing world of verifiable claims and factuality as opposed to someone like you who wallows in the slurry tank of "influencers"

    The influencers I mentioned have a great deal of influence in the un-Democratic party. I mentioned influencers such as Rossa Brooks, a former head of the DNC, John Podesta, a former chief of staff in the DNC, and two former un-Democratic Presidents who still have real influence in the DNC. I provided several source links for you or anyone else to open and do research what I said yourself. Why did you mention Rogan and others---Fcuk only knows.

    First, Joe Biden won the 2020 Presidential Election freely and fairly.

    This is only my opinion, I don't believe the 2020 election was free or fair...Rigging votes is very easy and I understand Penetration Testing better than you---it's been a 'hobby' of mine since 2006. Today in the blue state of California Gavin Newsom Bans California From Requiring ID to Vote--yet if Gavin Newsom whats to attended the un-Democratic party's national congress he has to show ID to get in---Do the maths yourself Barry..

    Third, of course any talk of military interventions in democratic nations is worrying.

    Isn't that exactly what Rossa Brooks said was a good idea of the Donald was President in 2020--a coup, and the influencers who today still control are of the same school of thought---all linked above---all I am guilty of is reporting what is been said and by whom.

    Au contraire, Biden withdrew of his own volition (after a crescendo of wise counsel of course) as Democratic nominee for PE 2024 and was replaced by Kamala Harris in a process entirely in accordance with DNC procedures.

    The Conversation Now that Joe Biden has dropped out of the 2024 presidential race and endorsed Vice President Kamala Harris to be the nominee, it will ultimately be up to Democratic National Convention delegates to formally select a new nominee for their party. This will mark the first time in over 50 years that a major party nominee was selected outside of the democratic process of primaries and caucuses.

    Noting Democratic on how Harris got selected----It was a bloodless coup. When you brush your hair, and teeth or shave in the morning do you look into the mirror reminding yourself?

    ReplyDelete
  25. As usual Frankie deflects from evidence and arguments by making extraneous and irrelevant points about ID having to be shown at Democratic Conventions. Every organisation requires proof of identity for admission to it's proceedings. By contrast elections to public representative bodies are entirely public affairs and ID demands are very often voter suppression mechanisms as is happening now with black electors in Republican controlled states .


    ReplyDelete
  26. There was no voter suppression or theft of ballot papers in PE 2020. End of. The Podesta emails fable has been debunked as lies and misinformation. No more going there. The media sources that Frankie has cited down the years include David Icke, Richard Allen l, Tucker Carlson, UKIP - an A-Z of conspiracist rot, often of the far right.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think that sometimes we need to look at what UKIP and others of that ilk are saying but David Icke - the second he is cited, game over. Nobody gonna pay the slightest attention after that. I remember when he came out and announced himself as the godhead - the hilarity of it. In the blocks we were fascinated by the insanity of it all. It still brings a smile to my face, any time he is mentioned. I often wonder how he withstood the public ridicule. Couldn't have been easy

      Delete
    2. What's even weirder is he still gets traction with a group of people. Maybe he's on to something with the reptilian thing, Tory bastards!

      Delete
  27. Barry...

    The more I read your comments/posts the more I am convinced that you float between the first two stages of what Schopenhauer said about truth---you either try to ridicule or insult---one day you will accept what is in front of you as self-evident...

    Every organisation requires proof of identity for admission to it's proceedings.

    No ID is required unless the organization asks you to vote in the USA. That leaves the elections in the USA open to vote rigging----not voter suppression.

    The Podesta emails fable has been debunked as lies and misinformation.

    The emails that Wikileaks released have not been 'debunked' ---didn't Podesta try to cover up for the Clinton Foundation and sex trafficking and Anthony Weiner sexting 13-15 year old girls...Why you defend Podesta is beyond me.

    The media sources that Frankie has cited down the years include....

    CNN, BBC, TF1, Al Jazerra...I've also gone into the archives and soured official documents, first-hand accounts, official autopsy reports (Geroge Floyd's)....academics, the list is endless..

    And do you do the same, Frankie?

    Look myself in the mirror and remind myself?-----I asked whether you do it, the fact you haven't said "No" leaves the question hanging---- I wake up, go to my fridge, grab a beer, roll a spliff while listening to Hank Williams---then I pick up a guitar (I'm a rockabilly)....

    ReplyDelete
  28. There was no trafficking ring at that pizza restaurant not that you would recognise the facts if they grabbed you by the goodies,

    ReplyDelete
  29. Barry....

    There was no trafficking ring at that pizza restaurant not that you would recognise the facts if they grabbed you by the goodies------Goolies I meant

    Then why don't they open the Epstein files so the world can see what did or didn't happen in a Washington Pizza Parlor or the corridors of power in the USA? We know a lot of young girls got sex trafficked by Epstein and Jean Luc Brunel yet only Maxwell is doing any prison time----maths don't add up.

    You could do yourself a favour and read One Nation Under Blackmail: The Sordid Union Between Intelligence and Crime that Gave Rise to Jeffrey Epstein

    ReplyDelete
  30. Frankie, the falsehood that Hilary Clinton and others ran an underground satanic paedophile ring in the basement on that pizza parlour is an invention of QAnon. Epstein ran an international trafficking ring, we all know that. But Pizzagate was definitely not part of it. There was nearly a murder because of that falsehood.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Barry and Frankie
    They remind me of Hinge and Bracket

    ReplyDelete