Showing posts with label Sinn Fein delivery failure. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sinn Fein delivery failure. Show all posts
The Fenian Way ✍ Muiris Ó Súilleabháin's insightful article,The Provo Paradox, opens up an accessible path of clarity that can rely on straightforward observations to assess events both pre and post ceasefires in the mid-nineties and beyond. 

In the midst of a revisionist onslaught such a path is an indispensable guide to pragmatic engagement.

Analysis at this remove, if to be valid, must first recognise that its primary function is to educate, and not form some semblance of identity comfort to anyone attempting to recreate the past in the here and now.

Nor should it be guided to a given end point, vindicating or repudiating any stances taken within republicanism at the time because to the British, ostensibly, all republican points of view are now dead. What’s done is done, which is all the more remarkable given the loud logic of history imploring us that it should have been done a different way.

The two principle points I would like to address in the article concerns the circumstances surrounding the ceasefires and the politics it conferred on the Six Counties and Provisional Sinn Féin, however strenuously denied or parried by that grouping.

I completely agree with Muiris that anybody who joined the Republican Movement did so with a basic understanding that their involvement was to secure fundamental change to the status quo and that that change had to surpass any previous arrangements put forward as settlements.

There were/are many different view points as to what a ‘United Ireland’ should look like; a Marxist classless society, comely maidens at the crossroads, broad indifference once the Irish people were free to choose. The common denominator however was, and remains, sovereignty, the securing of which was a prerequisite to allow any of the above, or other, to be pursued.

When the first ceasefire was called the joyous cavalcade which streamed down the Falls Road was a clear expression of an expectation that the ceasefire secured terms that were worthy of the struggle which preceded it. Forearmed with the historical experiences of Collins and Sunningdale, and emboldened with the sacrifices of struggle, that expectation was wholly justified.

Muiris argues that the ceasefires were necessary, that the abandonment of armed struggle was right. The true paradox however is that the terms upon which the former was called guaranteed the defeat, not the abandonment, of the latter because the ceasefire was called on British terms.

Robert Barton, one of the plenipotentiaries during the Treaty Negotiations in 1922 observed on the outcome; ‘Once we conceded we were not representatives of the Irish Republic we were on the road to disaster.’ In other words, once they allowed the British to determine their status within the negotiations they did, by default, allow them to determine the parameters of any settlement reached.

And this is precisely what the Provisional leadership allowed to happen in the negotiations which led to Good Friday. Gone was the position of the IRA representing the defence and demand for national sovereignty, replaced by Provisional Sinn Féin demands based on their electoral mandate in the Six Counties.

In other words, the British were dealing with a regional political party who had political gripes within part of the United Kingdom and that’s precisely how they were dealt with. Thus were the parameters of the Good Friday Agreement secured.

And because the issue of sovereignty was not a term for securing the ceasefire it could never be broken on that issue either. The PIRA, now reduced to the role of a militia, truly became what the British, unionists, constitutional nationalists and Irish governments always referred to them as, the armed wing of Provisional Sinn Féin.

The irony of the politics which Provisional Sinn Féin subsequently adopted for electoral gain is cogently mapped out in the article. Muiris makes the following (and widely accepted) observation:

The Provisionals did not defeat constitutional nationalism by demonstrating that it was wrong. They replaced constitutional nationalism and then, gradually, became it.

But they didn’t, they became something much worse. To its credit constitutional nationalism recognised that the issue of sovereignty had to be addressed in any credible settlement with the British. In the New Ireland Forum Report in 1984 three proposals were put forward; a Unitary State, a Confederation/Federal State or Joint Authority.

These were dismissed by Margaret Thatcher in her infamous Out, Out, Out declaration because each option represented a derogation of British sovereignty over the Six Counties. For Thatcher sovereignty was non-negotiable. For their part Provisional Sinn Féin equally rejected the reports proposals because they fell short of a clear call for a complete British withdrawal from Ireland.

The grievous irony is that Provisional Sinn Féin adopted Thatcher’s position in subsequent negotiations because the entry fee into those negotiations was not simply the calling of a ceasefire but a ceasefire on terms that accepted that the issue of sovereignty continued to be non-negotiable.

The obvious follow on question is: where did this place the issue of sovereignty within the so called pan nationalist front, the new alternative strategy? Having rejected the findings of the New Ireland Forum how could Provisional Sinn Féin, credibly, return to constitutional nationalism on the sovereignty question?

The equally obvious answer is in the observable facts of the agreement reached. Articles 2 & 3 gone. Stand Alone All Ireland Bodies rejected. A Triple Lock guaranteeing a Unionist Veto agreed to. British Sovereign Authority explicitly recognised in the Good Friday Agreement.

Here now we see the correlation between the terms upon which the IRA ceasefire was based and the counter republican politics which it inevitably spawned. Constitutional nationalism was now off the sovereignty hook. Constitutional imperatives were replaced with fuzzy aspirations. And as our host observed in a commentary on the original article politics was now centred on the manner of British occupation and not the fact of it.

The only obligation on any party to the talks initiated by the ceasefire was to ensure that a prolonged ceasefire would have a withering effect on any leverage that resumption of armed struggle could yield (by anyone). And the net effect of that strategy, once armed struggle as a tactic was neutralised, was the retrospective criminalisation of armed struggle itself. The differences between Sunningdale and Good Friday did not necessitate the taking of one human life to resolve. Paradox and irony combined as one.

Which leads us to addressing the shameful but predictable revisionism from Declan Kearney. Muiris correctly identifies the glaring contradiction in Kearney’s call for a second pan nationalist front as a tacit admission that the first such entity failed to remotely deliver what republicans were promised it would achieve.

But the key point that he observes is that the pan nationalist front did not fail constitutional nationalism nor British strategic interests in Ireland (all of it). Not one single republican demand was secured. Howling in an echo chamber for a border poll only serves to distract internal chin stroking as to the precise nature of the current strategy to move Provisional Sinn Féin forward: Stormont working? Stormont not working? Stormont not existing? Are they flying or falling with style?

Oddly I think this current revisionist thrust is best addressed by the revisionism of Martin McGuinness; “I would gladly give my life for peace.” The paradigm shift.

Gerry Adams once told us that the Good Friday Agreement was not a republican document, the obvious observable conclusion to be drawn is: that’s because republicans didn’t negotiate it! Revisionists abhor simplicity and clarity.

I agree with the conclusion that Muiris reaches:

The less speculative reality may simply be that, after nearly three decades with their snouts in the Stormont trough, the patronage, salaries, status and political infrastructure that come with government have become indispensable to the party itself!

Probably their only remaining All Ireland conviction!

⏩ The Fenian Way was a full time activist during the IRA's war against the British. 

Pernicious Paradox & Perfidious Irony

Finnian O Domhnaill ✒ When republican Phoneyism comes to government in Ireland, it will be wrapped in a hunger striker’s blanket.

Sinn Fein look well fed and warm now after a long time coming in from the cold. After supporting the non-jury courts, even Fianna Fail are cracking jokes at their selling out before an election instead of waiting until they are in government. Ah but isn’t that what mates do? A wee piss take at each other? Once they skip into Leinster House hand in hand like best friends at baby infants, leaving Fine Gael behind at the school gates crying, all will be forgiven, and they will get down to carrying out the same old Capitalist neo liberal system. While Fianna Fail won’t have too much problem with their voter base siding with Sinn Fein, even the robotic of Shinner bots will have a cognitive dissonance major malfunction.

This of course, will require a strategic, modernised and highly intelligent strategy to win back those angry at Sinn Fein for siding with Fianna Fail. Roll out the ‘’what’s the alternative’’ line. From dropping abstentionism in 86 to today’s support of non-jury courts, Sinn Fein have a long history of this famous slogan. They seem to dismiss the fact the alternative would be the extremely obvious decision to vote no on non-jury courts.

Perhaps it was so obvious that they missed the point altogether and will fix all that once they bring in the socialist republic? Even when they literally signed in welfare reform themselves and had the choice to say no and reject it, their answer was "what’s the alternative?" When they agreed to be junior partners to Fianna Fail or Fine Gael, and had the choice to say no, their response was, well, I think we are getting the pattern here.

When this lie fails. When a politically aware socialist questions the policies of Sinn Fein, you attack and instantly accuse them of wanting to blow up fish and chips shops and go back to the 70s and 80s. Throw in words like equality and integrity. That always goes down well. Begin speaking of the Good Friday Agreement and how amazing it is, even if it has absolutely nothing to do with what the topic on point is. Talk about Sinn Fein as if they wrote, composed, and done everything about the GFA and no one else. If they mention Sunningdale, quickly change the subject or immediately leave the area.

The truth is, that the IRA brought the British Army to a stalemate and there was always going to be a continuous war that would lead to nowhere. So naturally you would cause a truce, sit down, and have some: we won’t shoot you if you don’t shoot us peace talks. What Sinn Fein thought it meant was you don’t shoot us; we won’t shoot you, we will play by your rules, we will abandon our principles, we will administer British rule. You can end a military armed campaign, but you don’t have to end your political campaign along with it. In fact, you ramp up and put all your efforts into that. But alas it was less a case of Brits go home, more Brits go home, we got you covered.

And finally, if all else fails, if you are in a corner slowly having a mental breakdown and close to going into a full-blown epileptic fit due to the realisation that Sinn Fein might not be the party you think it is, reach deep into your denial and pluck out the good old "you have to compromise" line. Yes, compromise. Or what I like to call, "the slow and subtle erosion of your principles". 

What Sinn Fein have taught us about compromising is that it absolutely and ultimately does not work. Just look at the 100 years of Irish political history. When the Sinn Fein of 1921 decided to compromise on the treaty, leaving behind their principles and abandoning the republic, accepting partition, and resulted in civil war, it didn’t work. When Fianna Fail compromised in 1927 and entered Leinster House, came to power, abandoned their principles, executed republicans by hanging, and handed any power over to the church, it didn’t work. The Sinn Fein of 1998 compromised and entered Stormont, administer British rule, joined the policing board, shook hands with royals, agreed to be junior partners with Fianna Fail and Fine Gael, and now supports the non-jury courts, their compromise didn’t work.

History and Specifically Sinn Fein themselves, have shown us that compromise does not work. You may think it’s a fine idea to only chip the pillars that hold up the party. However, the next group that hold the reigns will do the same. And so and so, until the whole thing falls down around you and all you are left with is Mary Lou Mc Donald, standing in the rubble, smiling, with a hunger striker’s blanket wrapped around her.

When all of the above fails, Blame the Brits and shout up the Ra.

Finnian O Domhnaill is a Donegal
political and community activist. 

What's The Alternative? You Have To Compromise. Why?

Dixie Elliot ✒ In the 2006 Saint Andrew’s Agreement talks the British government promised to pass an Irish Language Act at Westminster.

Sinn Féin wanted it to be devolved to Stormont.

The following year in 2007, Edwin Poots told the Sinn Féiners up in Stormont that it wasn't getting past him.
 
Ten years pass and there's barely a mention of the Irish Language Act from Sinn Féin.

January 2017 and Sinn Féin demands that Arlene Foster steps aside as First Minister until after the RHI Inquiry.

Arlene Foster refuses to step aside so Martin McGuinness is forced to resign as Deputy First Minister.

Sinn Féin announced that there would be no return to the status quo without an Irish Language Act.

A three year stand off ensued before Sinn Féin were forced to crawl back into the status quo empty-handed.

June 2021: Sinn Féin calls the Tories... "Er Boris, could you legislate for that Irish Language Act at Westminster?"


"We said we'd legislate for an Irish Language Act in Westminster back in 2006... where have you been since then?"

"Tied up in Stormont but that doesn't include the three years we weren't in Stormont because of the Irish Language Act."

"OK then, you did help us out with Welfare Reform."

"Could you consider a border poll sometime soon as well?"

"You Want More!"



Thomas Dixie Elliot is a Derry artist and a former H Block Blanketman.
Follow Dixie Elliot on Twitter @IsMise_Dixie

Sinn Féin Are Hailing This As A Victory

Irish Times ✒‘Adams and McGuinness betrayed everyone’: A former IRA prisoner reflects on Troubles. Dixie Elliot was interviewed recently by Kitty Holland for the Irish Times. He was joined by Don Browne, a former INLA activist.

A former IRA prisoner, who shared cells in the late 1970s and early ‘80s with H-Block hunger strikers Bobby Sands and Thomas McElwee, says the killings and mayhem inflicted by paramilitaries during the Troubles were “for nothing”.

Thomas ‘Dixie’ Elliott (63) from Derry, reflecting on the 30-year ‘armed struggle’ as Northern Ireland marks its centenary, says the IRA leadership should have been ended the violence 1987. Instead, he says, they allowed it continue for more than a decade longer while planning to “sell-out” the socialist republican ideals for which he and hundreds of working class Catholics got involved.

While welcoming peace, he says the 23 year-old peace process is a “scam” that made some former IRA members “very wealthy”, while failing to deliver a fairer, less sectarian society.

Sitting in ExPop (Ex prisoners’ outreach programme), a drop-in support centre for “former combatants” in Derry city-centre, Elliott tells he was 19 in 1977 when sentenced to twelve years for hijacking, attempted murder and membership of a prescribed organisation.

Late into the conversation he is joined briefly by Don Browne, former member of the INLA and now yoga-teacher, who echoes many of Elliott’s observations.

Like a surprising number who joined the IRA in the early 1970s Elliot had links to the Protestant community. “My father was Presbyterian. My grandfather was wounded in WW1 in France. My mother was Catholic so I was brought up Catholic.” He grew up initially in Rosemount, a mixed area in the 1960s, before moving to the predominantly Catholic Shantallow in the early 1970s .

In Rosemount we were running around with Protestants, playing football together. There was never no problems. The Protestant and Catholic working classes lived in the same conditions. OK some Protestants might have better conditions but there were Catholics who were well off too.
The problem was the businessmen, the politicians kept us divided. They kept the Catholics down and treated us like second class citizens, while telling the Protestants they were better off, better people. My father always says, ’Everything was alright until Paisley came along’.

Asked how he got involved with the IRA he says: “Same thing as happened a lot of young people”. From about 13 he used to “sneak up to the Creggan to fire stones” and “to riots…It was the excitement.”

He wasn’t allowed to attend the anti-internment march on January 31st 1972, during which 13 civilians were shot dead by the British army on Bloody Sunday, but remembers the "stunned silence” across the Bogside the following day. And though he felt no sectarian animosity to his working-class Protestant neighbours, he remembers the horror at the British army “pointing their guns at us [Catholics]”.

He felt “great” when asked by the IRA to join the Fianna - the youth wing of the IRA – convinced by the leadership of the justice of the ‘war’.

We were running around, scouting, watching, carrying out small operations. Then you moved on to the IRA at age 16. We were taken over the border [to Donegal] and trained - shown how to fire armalites, how to make bombs. It was sleeping in tents, making your own food. It was like the scouts with real guns.

He recalls friends ‘killed in action’. In June 1974, David Russell (18), a Protestant, and Gerard Craig (17), also from Shantallow, died while carrying a bomb in a supermarket carpark. In October that year Michael Meenan (16), from Shantallow, was killed when a bomb he was carrying on his lap exploded. “They’re examples of how young some of the people involved were.” Asked what he thought of their dying at the time, he says: “We thought it was all part of the war. Oh aye we believed in the war and the struggle.”

His parents didn’t know until his father caught him painting over the windows of army Saracen jeep, to prevent soldiers seeing out. 

He brought me in home and gave me a lecture, said: ‘You are going to either end up in jail or dead and Martin McGuinness will end up in a big house.’ When I was sentenced my father wept.

So many young working-class Catholics were being sentenced to prison:

it was like a conveyor belt…You were in jail with your mates. They wiped out Shantallow. One day you were running about, living normal lives. We watched music, we watched glam rock, supporting English football teams. Next day you were in the Crum [Crumlin Road prison, Belfast, on remand]. That’s where I met Michael Devine [member of the INLA and the tenth man to die in the 1981 hunger-strike], from Derry as well. He introduced me to socialism. I never saw Micky again even though we were on the blanket together.

He went “immediately on the blanket [protest]” at the Maze prison – also known as the H Blocks - against the removal of political status from IRA and INLA prisoners and at the authorities’ insistence they wear prison uniforms. 

I went on it because I was a republican. I wasn’t going to be criminalised with the prison uniform. I was on it from June 1977 until the protest ended in October 1981.
How was it? It was bad. At the start we were in clean cells, a bed and a table. Nothing was happening, we were getting beatings. So we wrecked the cells, smashed the windows, smashed the furniture and put our excrement on the walls. The worst of all was the winter of ’78. The snow was coming in the window.
Coming up to Christmas ’78 there was forced washing, with scrubbing brushes…The screws would storm into the cells and dragged us down the wings. There were unmerciful beatings...You have to remember we were naked.

He recalls the “punishment block” with concrete beds, no heating and “the number one diet” of dry bread, black tea and “watery soup.”

In H-Block 6 fellow prisoners included senior members of the IRA including Sands, Brendan Hughes, Larry Marley and Seanna Walsh. In 1979, moved to H-3, he shared a cell with Sands.

Bobby kept morale very high. He was an amazing man, a fantastic singer – I actually thought he sang a bit like Bono though I don’t like Bono much. He was an amazing song-writer, poet, Gaeilgor. One of his favourite books was Trinity by Leon Uris. He’d tell it to us in instalments, through the cell-door at night. 

He says Sands wrote poetry and songs for anyone he shared a cell with, composing I Wish I Was Back Home in Derry – sung famously by Christy Moore – for him.

Recalling the ill-fated first hunger strikes between October and December 1980, which marked the escalation of the blanket and dirty protest, and the subsequent strikes between February and October 1981 in which ten men died, he disputes Sinn Fein’s account as to how the former ended, and remains “angry” that the deaths of “brave men” like Sands, were capitalised on for ends they had not died for. “They were on hunger strike for political status, not to win elections.”

Had he considered joining the strike? 

I couldn’t, I wouldn’t put my family through it, and thank God because it would have been for nothing.
Those years were really hard. It was all hell but we believed we had to keep going on. We couldn’t break or let anyone down. It was for the war, for a 32-county socialist republic. We believed that.

Released in 1985 he got involved in Sinn Féin in Derry and “probably” would have remained in the IRA but could see, “it wasn’t getting anywhere”.

We know now the war was being wound down. We know now [Gerry Adams and Martin McGuinness] were meeting the Irish Government, the British government. But instead of sitting the boys down and saying, ‘Look we can’t win this, we need to take a different direction and put the guns down, they went behind these men’s backs.
“While they were seeking peace, they were still encouraging war. Their peace process was a bloody peace process, and we haven’t seen a victory yet.

By “victory” he means a fairer, less sectarian society he says;

Our children have less opportunities now than even we had during the conflict…We could just go down to the signing centre and say we wanted to learn a trade. Now they have to go through hoops, the jobs are temporary, low paid. It’s shocking.

An anguished sense regret and betrayal runs deep in many former IRA members. “I never killed anybody but I know people who have and who have been broken, become alcoholics trying to drink it away,” he says.

Nodding, Browne says his brother Tony, a former IRA member, died in 2018 of cancer. Though never charged he was suspected of involvement in a number of murders. “I remember when he was dying,” says Browne, “when he was lying in his bed talking, he said: ‘I left behind widows and orphans’ and he says, ‘For what?’”.

Asked whether they regret the things they did, Browne says:

My true answer, none of it was worth it. But if you are asking the 15 year-old me who got his first gun, he would disagree totally with the 62 year-old here.
Was it the right thing to do? At this time yes, of course. You have to believe it was right or you wouldn’t do it.

Both welcome the peace. “My son and daughter have never been involved in republicanism,” says Elliott. “That is a good. But the peace process is going on almost as long as the conflict and it’s a scam. You have to be serious and stand up and ask, who is benefiting?”

The power-sharing system of Government in Northern Ireland, according to which unionists and nationalists must be represented in the Stormont executive, institutionalises sectarianism he says.

“You see both sides whipping it up to get the vote. The unionists is scared a republican, and on the republican side they’re scared a unionist, will get the seat.” This distracts public scrutiny not only from issues like housing, employment and education, but also from nepotism and cronyism within the main political parties, he says.

Sinn Féin provides a lot of people with political careers, jobs in the community sector, so they’re loyal to Sinn Féin. If you criticise Sinn Fein in Derry you’re cut out of those jobs. I know people who say, ‘Dixie, you’re right but I have a mortgage to pay. I just keep the head down and keep going.’

"The only place in the North the nationalists haven’t the worry about a unionist taking a seat is Derry, and you can see how they hammered Sinn Féin,” he says referring to the massive 17,000-vote victory by the SDLP’s Colum Eastwood over the Sinn Féin’s Elisha McCallion in the 2019 Westminster election.

This happened “first because of what [Sinn Féin] were doing with welfare-reform and then all the other stuff that was going on in the party.”

Republicans like him, he says, find Sinn Féin today:

hard to stomach… They have no more in common with the ideals of Bobby Sands than the modern Labour Party has with the ideals of James Connolly.
When we were on the blanket, if you had have even suggested Sinn Féin would be shaking hands with the Queen, sending sympathies for [Prince] Philip’s death, especially the year of the 40th anniversary of the hunger strikes, it’s unimaginable.

He says:

You have got people who are broken by it, who can’t accept this, think ‘There must be a plan for something more’. I am angry and am entitled to be angry. I saw brave men like Bobby Sands and Thomas McElwee walking from my wing for the last time; young guys like Michael Meenan getting blown to pieces … From 1987 [Gerry] Adams and [Martin] McGuinness, they should have told us, told the IRA it wasn’t working and stopped the killing. They betrayed everyone.

He hopes sectarianism is fraying in Northern Ireland as both Sinn Féin and the DUP appear to be in crisis, especially among younger voters.

“In the end,” he says, “Brexit might achieve what the IRA never could.”

Thomas Dixie Elliot is a Derry artist and a former H Block Blanketman.
Follow Dixie Elliot on Twitter @IsMise_Dixie

Brexit Might Achieve What The IRA Never Could

Thomas Dixie Elliot
believes Sinn Fein inhabit a weird kaleidoscopic world.

In a tweet, which she later deleted, regarding victims' pensions, Martina Anderson referred to those who fought Britain's dirty war in Ireland, those involved in collusion and British troops like the Paras who murdered people on Bloody Sunday and Ballymurphy. 

 

Did she forget that her party colleague, Declan Kearney apologised to those to whom she referred; the British military forces and the RUC, for the hurt and pain they experienced during the war?

 

Has it totally slipped her mind that the Colonel-in-Chief of the Paras can't set foot in Ireland these days but members of Sinn Féin are there to meet and greet him? 

 

Lest we also forget, Raymond McCartney was deputy chair & Jennifer McCann sat on the committee which gave screws with 40 years 'service' a payout of £120,000 or more. (Let that sink in ). In doing so he used words like 'rehabilitation' in saying that he thought, "It's accepted that over many, many years customs and practices have led to the 'prison service' not being run in the most efficient way."
  
 
McCartney effectively criminalised those Republicans still enduring incarceration in the British penal system.

It's as if, from time to time, that someone in Sinn Féin leaves a gate open and one of their members gets out to run wild before being pulled back in and the gate is closed again.

How can Republicans, or anyone for that matter, trust a party which changes like the Irish weather?


Thomas Dixie Elliot is a Derry artist and a former H Block Blanketman.

Follow Dixie Elliot on Twitter @IsMise_Dixie    

Sinn Fein's Weird Kaleidoscopic World

Padraic Mac Coitir thinks Sinn Fein has a lot to answer for when it comes to the creeping impoverization in the North.

Sinn Fein Delivery Failure

Pauline Mellon with a piece on a Sinn Fein failure to deliver.  Pauline Mellon is a blogger, rights campaigner and community activist in her native Derry. This piece initially featured on her blog Diary of a Derry Mother on 22 February 2014.

Belfast Comedian Jake O'Kane Speaketh the truth!
 
Today began just like any other Saturday morning with the exception of my latest attempt at a diet which normally occurs on a Monday morning. There I was laid out in mismatched pyjamas struggling to eat a poached egg and at the same time trying to forget my usual Saturday morning iced turnover (cake) when I heard the letter box rattle. What I found lying in the hall was the distraction I needed ... political propaganda entitled Glor Dhoire (Derry Voice) courtesy of Sinn Fein. If ever there was literature to distract you!

However in all fairness to Sinn Fein when it comes to propaganda they are the masters, as they claim credit for everything but the virgin birth.

Dun do bheal (Shut your Mouth)