Showing posts with label Sinn Fein & Housing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sinn Fein & Housing. Show all posts
Matt Treacy ✒ last night, Dublin City Council voted by 36 to 23 to approve the building of 853 housing units at Oscar Traynor Road on the north side of Dublin.

23-November-2021

The Glenveagh development will be in the ratio of 40:40:20 – social housing: affordable housing: and cost rental – long term tenancy with a rent that covers build cost.

On the face of it that would seem to be preferable to most of the sort of housing projects current underway in the city and county which are disproportionately build-to-rent high rise apartments.

Fianna Fáil, Fine Gael, most Labour, and Green Councillors voted to approve the plan, while those from Sinn Féin, Social Democrats, People Before Profit and most independents opposed it.

The left parties had proposed that the city council be directly responsible for the entire development including the contracting of construction with a balance of 80:20 social: affordable. This was rejected by the Department of Housing on the grounds that Dublin City Council would not be capable of managing such a project within a reasonable time frame.

Glenveagh will now sell the 40% of the units to DCC to be added to its housing list and has undertaken to begin construction in 2022 with a completion date before 2026.

Sinn Féin’s complete opportunism on all of this was once again highlighted by yesterday’s vote. However, just for the record – and as we have pointed out previously – when Sinn Féin were the majority party on Dublin City Council they were perfectly happy to approve the sort of deals that involved private developers Glenveagh and Bartra – including the provision for private sales.

Indeed, when People Before Profit and others proposed in November 2018 that the Oscar Traynor and other sites be developed on the lines which Sinn Féin seems to support now – all of their councillors except one voted with Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael against the proposal that the City Council be in charge of all such developments.

So, why did Sinn Féin reject that argument three years ago, but support it now? Another mystical “journey” perhaps like the one that led them on the Yellow Brick Road to accepting Partition, EU federalism, abortion, the Special Criminal Court, lowering corporation tax? And so on and so forth….

Not a bit of it. The only thing that changed was that their incompetence on Dublin City Council saw them lose 8 of their 16 seats in the 2019 local elections. So, when the party was finished with the online abuse of voters who had had the temerity to reject them, they did as all opportunists do – they changed tack.

But hey, don’t take my word for it. Listen to what future Housing Czar Eoin Ó Broin had to say back in April 2017 when like his comrades in the north he was still perfectly happy to go along with the awfulness of public/private housing development:

Housing department’s plan to for 50,000 homes slammed by homeless charity due to privatisation (thesun.ie)

It’s evident that Sinn Féin will say whatever they think is currently popular but will do the exact opposite if that suits them. The same pattern will continue when they do get into government.

Matt Treacy has published a number of books including histories of 
the Republican Movement and of the Communist Party of Ireland. 

Sinn Féin Oppose Another Housing Plan They Once Supported

Matt Treacy ✒ Students from various third level institutions in Dublin held a protest outside City Council offices on Wednesday to call on Dublin CEO Owen Keegan to resign following his smart-ass advice that the UCD students union might become involved in the property market if they are serious about providing accommodation for their beleaguered members.

The protest was predictably attended by representatives of Sinn Féin and People Before Profit. Two parties of the same name were part of a left majority on Dublin City Council between 2014 and 2019, but they never actually got around to solving the student accommodation problem when they had the chance.

They were likely far too busy deciding where to place multi-coloured paths, which countries not to buy computers from, which cool flags to fly on public buildings, and who to name bridges for, to be wasting their time at such trivia. It is quite apt really that they have such an affinity with student unions.

It is also a fact that both parties – and the Social Democrats who sent someone along as well to regale the yoof with promises of jam tomorrow – seem to think that there is an endless supply of housing at any or no price.

For of course, the left is forever promising to ensure that not only everyone on local authority housing lists will be given a place to live, but that the same guarantee ought to apply to randomers who arrive here from around the globe to be welcomed to the bottomless trough of free stuff.

Sinn Féin housing spokesperson Eoin Ó Broin who is constantly going on about the housing crisis seems to believe that providing houses specially for people who have not even been granted proper legal status, or may not even be here yet, might be part of the solution to it. How in all seriousness is that supposed to work?

The Union of Students of Ireland, which is the umbrella body for the UCD students union at the centre of the Keegan mini-controversy, has also supported calls for asylum seekers – most of whose applications are ultimately rejected – to be provided with housing not only at the expense of the state but presumably in preference to people on the local housing waiting lists.

Well, that is not how things work. Every good has a limited supply. If there are 10 cakes and there are 13 people who want to buy a cake, not only will at least three of them not get a cake but the prices of the cakes will increase. And yet, Sinn Féin, People Before Profit and the USI are under the impression that this does not apply to houses and apartments.

Oh, but “We will build more” they cry. Fair enough, but even the pig-in-a-poke figures thrown out by Sinn Féin will not be enough to meet current or forecast housing demand. And especially not if they are proposing to welcome an unquantifiable number of people from overseas to claim dibs – first dibs in fact – on this limited supply.

There is a serious issue to be addressed if students here find that accommodation is both hard to find and expensive. The solution to that is unlikely to be found in student unions buying up apartments. Nor is it going to be made any easier by cheer leading the sort of migration policies that particularly in Dublin are a major contributor to those difficulties.

Matt Treacy has published a number of books including histories of 
the Republican Movement and of the Communist Party of Ireland. 

The Left’s Housing Promises Do Not Add Up

Matt Treacy ✒ The report in yesterday’s Sunday Business Post by Killian Woods on the leasing of homes by South Dublin County Council is yet another example of the wasteful absurdities that blight housing policy in the state.

30-August-2021
Homes that were originally built by the local authority, then leased to tenants who then defaulted and repossessed, and were then subsequently sold to institutional funds are now being leased back by SDCC. These are now being rented to tenants at around €1,500 a month but with no option to purchase.

Similar arrangements are in place in other local authority areas and will cost in the region of €1 billion over the terms of the leases for 2,400 homes which are part of the scheme in 2021. That money could build twice that many houses at current construction costs.

It further underlines that all of the promises by the state to tackle this financially preposterous finger in dam mess mean nothing. The funds continue to hoover up homes with the specific intent not only to rent rather than sell , but also to take advantage of the misnomered “social housing “ strategy which is increasingly anti social in its outcomes.

The leasing of homes under this arrangement does tick boxes under the “social housing” rubric, as it takes people off the housing list and bolsters the % of housing under the auspices of the local authority that can be thus designated.

While the main opposition party Sinn Féin is making massive political capital through its stated opposition to the current government’s strategy, it has proven itself not to be any more successful when it has some power to implement housing policy through local authorities.

That was the case in Dublin City Council when the current institutional landlord high rise boom took off. Sinn Féin and others approved this once the “social housing” allocation was boxed off, regardless of cost or indeed community cohesion.

Sinn Féin was also both the largest party and part of the governing majority on South Dublin County Council when much of its current plan was agreed to between 2014 and 2019. The party proved itself to be totally incompetent as a local authority governing party during that period which accounted for the dramatic collapse in its local election vote in 2019.

Even now, where it has a presence on local authorities, the actions of its councillors have shown anything but evidence of a coherent strategy on Sinn Féin’s part. In July, party housing spokesperson Éoin Ó Broin, whose soundbites constitute what there is of their plan, was greatly embarrassed by the Sinn Féin councillors on Wicklow County Council.

They voted against a social housing development on publicly owned land at Kilbride Lodge, Bray, something which is supposed to be at the very heart of Sinn Féin housing policy. Among the objectors was the father of Sinn Féin TD John Brady who opposed the development on the grounds that a very old tree would have to be knocked down.

The councillors who opposed were no doubt doing as councillors do from every party; opposing stuff that locals found to present a threat to the existing community. Perhaps the four storey block does. That is the nature of actual politics which trumps soi disant ideological preoccupations every time.

So there is no plausible opposition solution to all of this. That there even appears to be is due to the fact that the current ruling coalition is throwing money away to the short term benefit of reducing housing lists, but to the long term gain of the investor funds, and the long term detriment of not only those trying to get a place to live, but of Irish society in general.

Matt Treacy has published a number of books including histories of 
the Republican Movement and of the Communist Party of Ireland. 

The State Is Now Leasing Homes That It Originally Built From Investment Funds