Showing posts with label Irish housing crisis. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Irish housing crisis. Show all posts
Pádraig Drummond  ✊
 "There’s no “emergency” when the same conditions repeat every month for a decade; that’s policy."

The October 2025 homelessness figures land like a brick through the window of Ireland’s so-called social conscience. Sixteen thousand seven hundred and sixty-six human beings, living, breathing, thinking citizens and children, boxed into “emergency accommodation” that resembles a stopgap solution only if you squint hard enough and ignore the smell of systemic failure rising from the numbers. Eleven and a half thousand adults, over five thousand children, a whole small town’s worth of kids growing up in hotels and hostels, and the government has the gall to present this as a monthly report instead of a national indictment.

In a normal society, these numbers would be a siren from the watchtower. But in Ireland’s mad bureaucracy, they're just another spreadsheet cell. Every statistic in this report reads like a casualty figure from a war that shouldn’t exist, a war waged quietly, efficiently, against the poor. Families make up a quarter of the homeless households, and single adults nearly three-quarters. That’s not just a housing crisis; that’s a generational collapse. Almost six thousand children under eighteen caught in the gears of a system built to grind the vulnerable into administrative dust.

You can practically hear the bureaucrats patting themselves on the back as they churn out percentages about gender and age distributions, as if the tragedy becomes easier to swallow once you convert it into pie charts and percentages. Nearly 60% of adults are men, sure, that tracks, men always get hit first and worst when the floor collapses, but the real horror is in the age bands. Over half the homeless adults are between 25 and 44, prime working and living years, the years society claims it rewards. A quarter more are middle-aged, staring down the barrel of a future that’s shrinking by the day. Two hundred and sixty-seven people over 65, elderly people, shoved into emergency accommodation like some kind of grim retirement plan for a country that forgot how to care.

And Dublin, the gleaming jewel of Irish capitalism, hoards more than 70% of all homeless adults, like some monstrous magnet for misery. Eight thousand one hundred and forty-one adults, enough to fill a small stadium, shuffled between PEA, STA, TEA, and other alphabet soup euphemisms for “we don’t have real housing, so here’s a stopgap.” The fact that the majority of accommodation is still Private Emergency Accommodation, hotels and B&Bs, is a quiet confession that private profit has long since eaten the state alive. There’s no “emergency” when the same conditions repeat every month for a decade; that’s policy.

The report’s self-congratulation about “preventions” and “exits to secure tenancies” reads like something cooked up by a PR team rather than public servants. One thousand six hundred prevented from entering homelessness and 1,234 moved out sounds impressive until you view it through the proper social lens: these are crumbs dropped from the banquet table of a housing system engineered to fail. Tenancies created through Housing First barely hit double digits in multiple regions. Meanwhile, thousands more fall in the front door of emergency accommodation every quarter. You don’t need chemicals to see the hallucination here, it’s all right there in the numbers: the exits are dwarfed by the scale of the problem.

The citizenship breakdown adds another layer of quiet cruelty. Half Irish, half non-Irish, a reflection that capitalism’s failures don’t discriminate, but its apologists will. You can almost predict the cynical debates this will fuel, the narratives that whisper the problem away by blaming migrants instead of the decades-long political decision to outsource the housing system to developers, landlords, and “the market,” as though the market ever cared whether a child sleeps in a bed or on a floor.

Let's call it what it is: state-sanctioned neglect dressed up as progress, a bureaucratic fever dream where human beings become inputs and outputs, and the state issues monthly newsletters instead of solutions. A social analysis doesn’t have to look far, the very structure of the report betrays the ideology behind it. Everything measured, nothing solved. Everything counted, nothing changed.

This isn’t a homelessness report. It’s a confession note slipped under the public’s door. A society that tolerates nearly 17,000 people in emergency accommodation, including more than 5,000 children, is not malfunctioning. It is functioning exactly as designed: protecting property over people, private interest over public need, profit over humanity. And until that design is smashed, these monthly reports will read less like statistics and more like obituaries for the social contract.


⏩Pádraig Drummond is an anti-racism activist.

Hotel Ireland 🏠 Vacancy For The Damned

Hedley Lamarr ✍ It is with deep disappointment and embarrassment to read that the so-called Republicans Against Anti-Fascists have spray-painted a Housing Executive van in West Belfast with a threatening racist message.

We are all astute enough to know that being against anti-fascists does not necessarily make you a fascist but writing such nasty, racist threats on the side of a van of an organisation in charge of local housing certainly does.

Of course, there is pressure on housing. It's not due to immigration though. It's due to a lack of regulation; little if any protection for tenants; rampant speculation on the housing market where corporations and businesses buy up houses and drive up prices out of reach of families.

There are no rent controls, no limits on how many houses a person/business can buy, no security of tenure.

The unregulated market coupled with the governments, North and South missing their targets of new-builds causes the shortage. Many houses lie empty all over the island. There were 163,000 empty houses (excluding holiday homes) in the Republic of Ireland in 2022. The Irish government missed the target of new-build social housing in 2025 by 15%. In Northern Ireland the new-build target has recently dropped from 3,000 per annum to 2,300.

Google, for example, owns a portfolio of properties that includes Boland's Quay. 37,000 square metres of office, residential and retail space. Don't forget NAMA and the numerous vulture funds ripping the heart out of local communities.

They call themselves Republicans. I'm sure you have Republican racists just as you have Republican drug dealers or Republican sex offenders or Republican touts. Every demographic, including Republicanism, has it's repugnant element. It's how we deal with that element that counts.

Republicanism has a long proud history of internationalism, as far back as the very first Irish Republicans, the United Irishmen. Don't forget Mary-Ann McCracken worked her entire life to help women and the downtrodden. She campaigned tirelessly against slavery. The racists are happy to have cheap goods from all over the planet but wince if a person comes over. The racists value commodities over people.

I'm not going to turn this into a history lesson but would like to remind the racists that the seven signatories to the Proclamation were human rights driven. Way ahead of their time. Cherishing all children of the nation equally. It's doesn't mean children literally but citizens. Equal rights for all. The leaders of the Rising were to the forefront when it came to fighting for women's rights.

Roger Casement was a beacon of human rights and an exemplary Republican.

James Connolly was a firm internationalist, driven by socialism. The fascists on the other hand are driven by hate and ignorance.

Bobby Sands spoke up for many anti-colonial fights in his poem Rhythm of Time.

"It is found in every light of hope,

It knows no bounds nor space

It has risen in red and black and white,

It is there in every race.

 ♜ ♞ ♟

It lies in the hearts of heroes dead,

It screams in tyrants’ eyes,

It has reached the peak of mountains high,

It comes searing ‘cross the skies.

 ♜ ♞ ♟

It lights the dark of this prison cell,

It thunders forth its might,

It is ‘the undauntable thought’, my friend,

That thought that says ‘I’m right!’"

The Irish far-right invited a loyalist bank robber to speak outside the GPO, a member of the UVF, an organisation which took up arms to murder fellow Irish people purely because they were Catholics. An organisation which bombed Dublin and Monaghan. The loyalist in question describes the Irish language as a foreign language. Amadán gan mhaith mar a deirtear.

No demographic can be held to impossibly high standards. No demographic can possibly be immune from criminality. Let the punishment fit the crime. Let perpetrators be held accountable and not the communities from which they come.

There were riots in Ballymena directly after the arrests of two Romanian teenagers accused of rape. I can't remember any riots when a certain unionist politician was accused of rape. This was never about protecting women. It's pure bigotry.

⏩ Hedley Lamarr is a student of the conflict out of which has developed his strong interest in justice.

Pure Bigotry

Guardian ✏ Decades of skewed policy have led to one of Europe’s worst shortages of affordable homes. Now it is being weaponised against refugees.


11-December-2023

Ireland is in a dark place. Riots in Dublin last month exposed to the world the presence of a small, nascent but emboldened far right. 

A complex range of factors underlie this: social media conspiracy theories, toxic masculinity, an ugly underbelly of racism and persistent social and economic inequalities. But the far right is also weaponising a decade-long housing and homelessness crisis that afflicts the entire country and has placed thousands of people in a state of chronic housing stress, anxiety and fear.

The riots did not surprise those of us who have been warning about the rise of racism directed at immigrants. We have seen how the housing crisis is used to whip up hate against newly arriving asylum seekers. It doesn’t much matter to those who attack temporary accommodation centres for refugees that such buildings would never become private homes. Their message is that Ireland is “full” and we should house “our own” first.

The truth, however, is that Ireland’s shortage of affordable housing has not been caused by an increase in numbers of immigrants or refugees, but by 30 years of policies that have left delivery to the property market while decimating social housing. My phone pings daily with messages on social media from people who are losing their home. In the past few days, a disabled woman asked me to share her plea for “immediate accommodation”, as she is being evicted. A worker for Dublin city council is being evicted, but he and his family can’t afford any of the rents on flats they have viewed. He told me: “I clean our streets every day, and I haven’t even a home I can clean for myself.”

Continue reading @ Guardian.

Ireland’s Housing Crisis Is A Disaster For Its People 🔨 And A Gift To Far-Right Fearmongers

Caoimhin O’Muraile ☭ As the 26 County administration continues with its apparent open-door policy towards allowing limitless asylum seekers refuge in Ireland and leave to seek refugee status, matters are beginning to unravel into chaos. 
 

Asylum seekers alongside our own indigenous homeless are finding there is no room in Ireland as they sleep rough on the streets of the Emerald Isle in tents, sleeping bags and, in some cases, just plastic bags. Our own homeless are sleeping in similar conditions. In fact it is probably they who educated the new arrivals in the art of survival as they have been forced to live rough for many years by different governments in the Dail. Various Fianna Fail, Fine Gael and coalition partners have turned their backs on Ireland's homeless many years ago, now they are inviting asylum seekers fleeing war torn countries, particularly Ukraine, as part of the 26 counties “hate the Russians” campaign, with, to a far lesser extent, those from Syria, a few from Yemen, Afghanistan and other troubled regions around the globe only to tell them on arrival, there is no room, find a park bench. 

This is as cruel as it is well intended, you cannot invite a person round for drinks and on their arrival serve up water! If there is no room for any more arrivals, would it not be better to say so rather than fill hearts with false hope, leaving them open to racial attacks, the drug barons, and the elements? The only difference sleeping rough in Ireland to their lands of origins is there are no bombs going off here. The accommodation offered is very similar of late, the street. This open-door policy resulting in more and more bodies sleeping rough on the streets will give the far-right a launching pad which has already happened at places like East Wall in Dublin, turning genuine concerns into racial hate, something the residents never had in mind at the outset. 

The far-right have been to a limited extent successful in their attempts to turn people against the fleeing asylum seekers particularly if they happen to be single males from the African continent. What happens if these disciples of Hitler latch on to “our streets being littered with refugees”, which most are not, they are asylum seekers aiming for refugee status, how long before the fascists capitalise on this tragic situation?

Back in 2015 Angela Merkel in Germany decided to allow in “over one million refugees” from Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan into Germany as part of her “open door policy” which caused a backlash from the neo-Nazi Alternative For Deutschland (AFD) party. Many of those who initially welcomed the newcomers to Germany turned violently against them after hearing the hate mongering AFD speeches. Could the same happen here, on top of what has already happened at places like East Wall? Should the government change policy? Should they abandon the “open door” stance and begin limiting or stopping any more asylum seekers entering their jurisdiction? Is it perhaps time to start housing or at least accommodating those already here before inviting any more in? Would bringing in any more desperate people only be cruelly giving them false hope?

When the 26 County administration first set about its laudable acts of charity in line with “Cead Mile Failte” (a hundred thousand welcomes) it was a great act of kindness, admittedly for the government with an ulterior motive, but for the asylum seekers it was heaven. Now, it is turning into a kind of hell, as they jump from the frying pan of their country of origin into the fire of the 26 counties! If the government closes the door they will be accused of racism. If they close the door to all but Ukrainian asylum seekers they will, rightly, be accused of favouritism. If they continue down the present trajectory, they will fill the streets, along with our own unfortunate homeless people, with “foreigners” which will fuel the far-right organisations arguments. A tricky situation, what is the answer?

Well, if the government is really interested in finding a solution to this conundrum they could look back in history to 1919 and the “Democratic Programme of the First Dail” paragraph one. This states unambiguously “we affirm that the right to private property must be subordinated to the public right and welfare”, such an occasion has arisen to “affirm” that right, to make private property ownership “subordinated to the public right and welfare”. If you look around Dublin and other towns and cities the amount of “private property” sitting vacant is phenomenal. Some have been vacant for months, even years so why not take these shops that were, public houses that were, ghost housing estates and take them into public ownership for the “public right and welfare.” It would provide employment for many shopfitters, carpenters, electricians, plasterers, brickies and general labourers in renovating these premises. Some do not need renovation such as the ghost housing estates which are ready for accommodation. I know the present owners will not like this suggestion but they are not really supposed to. What comes first, private ownership of property and the rights which accompany this ownership, or, the rights of people to have somewhere to live both indigenous and newcomer alike? I think it was Thomas Drummond who once said; property ownership has its “obligations as well as its privileges,” as true today as it was then.

All the government has to do is place a “compulsory purchasing order” on all property left idle for three months or more. Start work, where necessary, on renovating using the labour outlined above. Many homeless people both indigenous and asylum seeker are tradesmen themselves and could start helping in this renovation work, earning a living wage, where one day they themselves might live. What a great prospect for somebody who, through no fault of their own, have become homeless either through reasons of war in their lands of origins or sheer bad luck at home here in Ireland, to have the opportunity of developing premises for themselves and those in similar positions to live.

The question is, will the government have the backbone to take this decision? Will they have the balls to take on the property owners through legislation? Or, on the other hand, will they go belly up the moment the rich man frowns in an aggressive manner? They could do it if they wanted to: the question is, do they? The 26 County administration are often boasting their pride, rightly so, in Irish history and fight against oppression so now why not put some of that revolutionary past into modern day practice? I suggest they read and digest the contents of the “Democratic Programme of the First Dail” and think about enacting some of it today, otherwise I see a disaster waiting to happen!

🖼 Caoimhin O’Muraile is Independent Socialist Republican and Marxist.

Open Doors Policy 🚪 Could It Be Time For A Policy Change?

Anthony McIntyre ☠ When Sinn Fein TD Pearse Doherty accused the Taoiseach of making a 'cruel, heartless and calculated decision' to disappear people . . . which of course he didn't because Leo Varadkar hasn't disappeared anybody and Doherty was referring to something entirely different.

I just could not help but think what the Sinn Fein response might be if the same type of question in relation to the Disappeared were to be asked of a potential candidate in the next Presidential election; if the eagerness to call out the cruel, heartless and calculated will vaporise in the rush for political advantage. I think I know the answer. 

What Pearse Doherty was objecting to with every justification in language echoed by Brid Smith of People Before Profit -"dangerous, sad and brutal" - was the Varadkar-led government's decision to side with the landlords against the dispossessed by not extending the eviction ban, thus leaving people traumatised and terrified at the prospect of homelessness.

The charge against the Taoiseach came during a Dail debate on a Sinn Fein motion to halt the slide towards the abyss of homelessness by having the ban extended. Unfortunately the motion failed, leaving us to conclude that for now a majority of TDs still value profiteers over people.

Surprisingly Sinn Fein did not get a bounce in the latest Red C opinion poll. While Fianna Fail and the Greens slipped, Fine Gael increased its rating while Sinn Fein remained steady. This was the moment when the party could have expected to soar ahead but for some reason has not. And with Labour leader Ivana Bacik calling for a “left-led green-red government”, the voter might be left wondering where the green is going to come from. The Greens under Ryan seem destined to repeat their 2011 fall from grace and power.

With that in mind I was quite glad to see Eamon Ryan being given the what for when last Thursday he turned up at an event in Trinity College. Ryan's Green Party with the arrogance of the damned had suspended the one TD who displayed a flash of compassion on the eviction ban and he was not going to be allowed to forget it.  

Ryan faced a barrage of highly charged political accusations in what my wife described as a wackamole strategy - as soon as one young person was pushed down another popped up - by protestors who included members of the Connolly Youth Movement which had previously faced their own eviction from a university campus for having challenged Bertie Ahern.

These young protestors are not blocking roads, or disrupting people's lives. They are not even denying others the right to hear people like Ryan or Ahern: they turn up, make their point and leave. They are risking their current education and future careers in a bid to stop others losing their homes. 

Politically and socially embarrassing for the agents of austerity, the young protestors can expect to find themselves subject to increased surveillance from people they consider foes and insidious endeavours from people they consider friends.   

⏩ Follow on Twitter @AnthonyMcIntyre.

Eviscerating The Evictors

Anthony McIntyre ☠ Last evening's televised exchange between Louise O’Reilly of Sinn Fein and Minister of State Kieran O’Donnell of Fine Gael served up more anger than answers. 

The minister was a wooden one who it seems ended up on Prime Time as a result of a short straw. No one else in government wanted to do it.

O’Reilly was good up to a point, which was when she was asked why her party opposed certain house building projects. There was nothing wrong with her answer – her party objected to public land being handed over to private developers. Anybody who has ever worked for one will realise what drives them – unbridled greed. O’Reilly’s problem is that house building, even by private developers on public land, seems such a good idea in the midst of a chronic housing shortage that few are going to row away from any port in a storm on some ideological ground. People in need prioritise practical homes over an ideological dislike for who builds them.

O’Reilly seemed uncomfortable when answering the question, not because her answer was wrong, but because in today’s climate the public ear is not receptive to what she was saying. When a party fails to raise the level of public consciousness to its own ideational plateau it risks being dragged under by the drowning person it is trying to save.

Sinn Fein might yet come to consider that it is best to park its opposition to private developers building on public land, work on it later when the problems posed by private developers look more stark to the public, and get more people into homes now. In Gramscian terms, the common sense at present is that homes are to be welcomed from wherever they come. Realistically, there is little else Sinn Fein can do given its all consuming desire for office and willingness to jettison all ideological baggage in order to get there. It is simply unwilling to think outside of a framework where capital might be brought under democratic control. 

The threat posed by the current Coalition government and their allies in the landlord class grows by the day. 

Neary 5,000 eviction notices were served on tenants between July and September last summer, new figures from the Residential Tenancies Board have shown.

This means a lot of people facing homelessness, beginning at the start of next month. The cruel irony of wakening up on the first day of April to the government shouting April Fool for trusting us; the landlord is kicking you out with our blessing. 

Citizens in this society should not be exposed by the government they place in office to the voracious appetites of unscrupulous rentiers and landlords determined to put profit before people. A government, whatever its composition, that will stand up to the profiteers rather than evict people at their behest is the bottom line for a just society. 

Our government is not that. The limits of its imagination will not stretch much further than sending Eamon Ryan out to promise new green benches in public parks (not on private land) for the homeless to sleep on. And just to ensure equality before the law the rich will not be arrested for sleeping on them as well.

⏩ Follow on Twitter @AnthonyMcIntyre.

Coalition Deserves Eviction

Anthony McIntyre ☠ It is hard to frame the Coalition government’s decision not to extend the eviction ban as something other than a grievous act of class cruelty.

This is not some crackpot idea floated by Eamon Ryan, but is the agreed policy position of all three party leaders currently leading the government. It is a crass decision, a class decision.

In a society purporting to be democratic, the state should stand up for its citizens. Here the state stood up for the profiteers. Placing – and that is just a start - 2,700 families or residents in the direct line of fire from the modern equivalent of the Pinkerton Agency, acting as the licenced goondas of landlordism, is a substantial assault on citizens. It also contains within it the potential to risk squandering what confidence capital the Coalition has accumulated; a deposit that does not merit the description 'astronomical'. Dr Rory Hearne asks:

How could an Irish Government make this decision knowing the direct impacts on the most vulnerable in our society? I have been highly critical of policy decisions that have prioritised property interests, but this decision is really shocking. Nothing has changed since the moratorium was introduced last October. The housing crisis has actually worsened.

The callous decision comes hard on the heels of a withering critique of government strategy by Social Justice Ireland director, Sean Healy who labelled poverty policy a disgrace.

In recent months, the Coalition has quietly watched as the opinion polls have continued to show a small but steady decline in the popularity of its main rival, Sinn Fein. The distance between the combined strength of the government parties and its populist opposition has been incrementally narrowing. Perhaps the government read too much into this and, emboldened, thought best to strike while the iron was hot and shove the poker up the backside of those most at risk, least able to fight back from tents or homeless shelters, their likely destination if the government gets its way.

It is a strategy fraught with perils. Sinn Fein might not benefit from the kickback due to its own Victory to the Landlords position adopted in Belfast City Council where the party joined ranks with the right wing DUP to block a People Before Profit motion to impose a rent cap.

There is a very real danger that the far right who have been vocal on the housing crisis - seeing in it a blackthorn stick with which to beat refugees and immigrants - will emerge the beneficiaries of Coalition callousness.

When a state robs Poor Peter to pay Plutocratic Paul it is guaranteed the support of the plutocrat. One hand of Irish society has clapped for this proposal - the landlords. We now have a MRI image of the Coalition heart that shows the greed of capital pulsating through the veins and arteries of government. The Coalition, dictated to by the structural logic of capital, could not envisage a way forward that would not leave society and its most vulnerable at the mercy of profiteers and the threat of homelessness.

The problem, an ideological dependency on a historical scourge of the country, landlordism, can be read into the analysis of Sean Healy:

Ireland won’t solve this housing crisis until it increases the provision of social housing in particular on a much larger scale than is currently planned. We have the resources to tackle housing, to tackle healthcare, and to tackle poverty and to do that effectively and within a relatively short timeframe. But the resources are not being committed in that direction.

Informing society that evicting people from their homes is necessary to secure the retention of landlords has all the merits of lowering the age of consent in order to have enough priests able to perform mass.

A scandalous act by a landlord oriented Coalition determined to assuage the greedy and screw the needy.

⏩ Follow on Twitter @AnthonyMcIntyre.

Victory To The Landords

Matt Treacy ✒ The news that An Bord Pleanála has now changed its previous decision so that the 524 private homes to be built on the O’Devaney Gardens site can be sold to institutional investors, commonly referred to as “vulture funds,” is a further indication of the growing power of those funds within the housing sector.


It is also, by the way, an illustration of a combination of incompetency, irrelevance and studied contempt on the part of central government for local authorities such as Dublin City Council which negotiated the deal with Bartra, the development company who successfully challenged the ban on the sale to a “corporate entity” which had been affirmed by Bord Pleanála in September 2021 – but who have now reversed that decision.

The original deal to develop the site was with Bernard McNamara for 100% public and mixed income housing but that collapsed with the financial crisis. Dublin City Council, at a time when SF was the largest party, then negotiated an agreement with Bartra for a mixed private, social housing and affordable housing scenario.

Bartra cleverly played on the state’s unwillingness to commit to buy the 524 units which the developers said they could sell privately, presumably to one of the investment funds. Why Bartra could not have built them and then sold them individually as was first proposed would seem not to have been challenged by Bord Pleanála in its volte face.

We raised this in the context of the increasing role being played by Chinese and other investment funds in the housing sector here. It seemed, and still seems, incredibly naïve that any politicians thought they could prevent that by council motions.

The consequences of builds being sold en masse to investment funds is severe for ordinary families who have now become increasingly desperate – being outbid by vulture funds who are chasing the large profits gained from renting out the houses now placed out of reach of families by the purchasing muscle of institutional investors.

Recent figures from BNP Paribas showed that these cuckoo funds are able to outbid families by a massive premium – by as much as 32% according to the report. pushing families even further away from home ownership, according to a report. Why the government doesn’t act to prevent this remains the unanswered question.

It’s almost a year since Micheál Martin told the Dáil it was “unacceptable” that investment funds were buying up entire housing estates, and the government vowed to take action to prevent this happening. That has come to naught, it seems.

That is of course not to detract from the contemptuous manner in which the state itself through its planning and regulatory structures is ignoring almost all local democratic decisions on these matters if and when they come into conflict with the interests of the major corporate players who are indeed using their financial power to dictate terms regarding the current and future shape of the Irish housing market.

Any state with a genuine commitment to not only putting people into apartments, but in ensuring that housing is part of something more than a “market” with little reference to the society it has responsibility for, would not allow such a crucial sector to be dictated by entities like Bartra. It speaks of a state that couldn’t care less what this place is going to look like in 30 or 50 years time. This we already know.

The obsession with “social housing” on the part of others has meant that the chances of working families being able to buy their own homes was always a minor consideration, including for the parties on Dublin City Council. The one thing the left and the likes of Bartra do share is their contempt for private home ownership. You will be either a tenant of the state or some faceless investment fund.

So, we are now left with a situation where – if the ongoing legal consideration confirms the Bord Pleanála amendment – the 524 units that were supposed to be sold to individual private purchasers will now almost certainly mean that all of those apartments end up in the rental sector – a sector increasingly dominated by the investor/vulture funds.

All of this portends ill for the city and people of Dublin. Even the late Pete St. John would be challenged to find a fitting update for the “grey unyielding concrete” that 40 years ago he saw turning Dublin from a town into a city. Now from a city in any sense of what that ought to be mean as an organic urban community into some dystopian high rise mess.

Matt Treacy has published a number of books including histories of 
the Republican Movement and of the Communist Party of Ireland. 

O’Devaney Gardens ✑ Why Haven’t The Government Acted To Stop Another Victory For Vulture Funds?

Anthony McIntyre ✒ A long time in the making, Prime Time's debate between Darragh O'Brien and Eoin O Broin had been billed as "the Housing Showdown the country was waiting for." 

For those with an eye for the gladiatorial, this massive housing debate had the promise of a night to remember, one of Madison Square proportion. With a long suffering audience primed for fight night the big beasts from the Bruiserweight division who had for long eyed each other to the din of hype, would at last step into the ring and slug it out. 

The problem, if not the solution, was at least crystal clear: 

Over the past two decades, Ireland’s population has increased from 3.6 million to over 5 million. In that time, the number of people living in each household has also decreased – from 4 people in every home to just 2.7 – that means as households have fewer people, we need more homes.

O’Brien held the belt but the pretender to the throne, O Broin, seemed odds-on to strip him of it. Only one outcome seemed possible: with the housing crisis so bad on the holder's watch, the challenger merely had to turn up to claim at least ninety percent of the success. The Sinn Fein housing spokesperson had thrown down the gauntlet on many occasions. Now it was the Toichfaidh Ar La moment - his time had come. The penalty kick awarded by Prime Time need merely be stroked home. The Fianna Fail Housing Minister was supposedly in nets with arms much too short to deal with a well placed shot from the Sinn Fein front bencher. 

It wasn’t to be. If anything the Dublin West TD came off second best. This will have disappointed those desperate for homes and eager to see the government flayed with a Sinn Fein whip. The party had rode to success in the opinion polls in no small part because of its very vocal critique of what it had adroitly and persuasively framed as government inaction. 

It is not that O Broin does not have the arguments. As well briefed on the housing crisis as anyone, with a number of books on the topic to his name, he was more than equipped to tackle what is a gaping deficit in public policy. Yet he seemed way off his game, at times hesitatingly uncertain during the exchange. While his adversary never laid him out on the canvas, O'Brien had O Broin on the ropes often enough to cause jitters in the Sinn Fein corner.

To be sure, it was not the mauling that former party leader Gerry Adams underwent at the hands of  Michael McDowell in a 2007 televised debate. There is a poverty of words to positively describe Adams' understanding of economics, whereas McDowell fired salvo after salvo of dictionaries in the direction of his bleating opponent. O Broin, unlike his former leader, is not ignorant of the subject matter. On the night his was a failing of application which resulted in a points victory for Darragh O’Brien which given the pervasiveness of the housing crisis, he had no right to achieve.

To be fair to O Broin, Professor Tony Fahy in a 2019 review of his book Home: Why Public Housing Is the Answer, observed that. 'Ó Broin comes to the question with policy experience and a left-wing perspective but with no simple solutions.' It is admirable that O Broin sought not to resort to the simple soundbite to explain what is a highly complex problem. Still, it did not see him spared from the merciless use of the same from his Fianna Fail adversary. 

Although O Broin is an impressive performer, and he will surely come again, this was not his night. I headed for bed, feeling that while there is a desire for change within society, it is not a yearning for Tweedleduh to join the circus of Tweedledee and Tweedledum.

⏩ Follow on Twitter @AnthonyMcIntyre.

More Slowdown Than Showdown

Matt Treacy ✒ Students from various third level institutions in Dublin held a protest outside City Council offices on Wednesday to call on Dublin CEO Owen Keegan to resign following his smart-ass advice that the UCD students union might become involved in the property market if they are serious about providing accommodation for their beleaguered members.

The protest was predictably attended by representatives of Sinn Féin and People Before Profit. Two parties of the same name were part of a left majority on Dublin City Council between 2014 and 2019, but they never actually got around to solving the student accommodation problem when they had the chance.

They were likely far too busy deciding where to place multi-coloured paths, which countries not to buy computers from, which cool flags to fly on public buildings, and who to name bridges for, to be wasting their time at such trivia. It is quite apt really that they have such an affinity with student unions.

It is also a fact that both parties – and the Social Democrats who sent someone along as well to regale the yoof with promises of jam tomorrow – seem to think that there is an endless supply of housing at any or no price.

For of course, the left is forever promising to ensure that not only everyone on local authority housing lists will be given a place to live, but that the same guarantee ought to apply to randomers who arrive here from around the globe to be welcomed to the bottomless trough of free stuff.

Sinn Féin housing spokesperson Eoin Ó Broin who is constantly going on about the housing crisis seems to believe that providing houses specially for people who have not even been granted proper legal status, or may not even be here yet, might be part of the solution to it. How in all seriousness is that supposed to work?

The Union of Students of Ireland, which is the umbrella body for the UCD students union at the centre of the Keegan mini-controversy, has also supported calls for asylum seekers – most of whose applications are ultimately rejected – to be provided with housing not only at the expense of the state but presumably in preference to people on the local housing waiting lists.

Well, that is not how things work. Every good has a limited supply. If there are 10 cakes and there are 13 people who want to buy a cake, not only will at least three of them not get a cake but the prices of the cakes will increase. And yet, Sinn Féin, People Before Profit and the USI are under the impression that this does not apply to houses and apartments.

Oh, but “We will build more” they cry. Fair enough, but even the pig-in-a-poke figures thrown out by Sinn Féin will not be enough to meet current or forecast housing demand. And especially not if they are proposing to welcome an unquantifiable number of people from overseas to claim dibs – first dibs in fact – on this limited supply.

There is a serious issue to be addressed if students here find that accommodation is both hard to find and expensive. The solution to that is unlikely to be found in student unions buying up apartments. Nor is it going to be made any easier by cheer leading the sort of migration policies that particularly in Dublin are a major contributor to those difficulties.

Matt Treacy has published a number of books including histories of 
the Republican Movement and of the Communist Party of Ireland. 

The Left’s Housing Promises Do Not Add Up

Matt Treacy ✒ The report in yesterday’s Sunday Business Post by Killian Woods on the leasing of homes by South Dublin County Council is yet another example of the wasteful absurdities that blight housing policy in the state.

30-August-2021
Homes that were originally built by the local authority, then leased to tenants who then defaulted and repossessed, and were then subsequently sold to institutional funds are now being leased back by SDCC. These are now being rented to tenants at around €1,500 a month but with no option to purchase.

Similar arrangements are in place in other local authority areas and will cost in the region of €1 billion over the terms of the leases for 2,400 homes which are part of the scheme in 2021. That money could build twice that many houses at current construction costs.

It further underlines that all of the promises by the state to tackle this financially preposterous finger in dam mess mean nothing. The funds continue to hoover up homes with the specific intent not only to rent rather than sell , but also to take advantage of the misnomered “social housing “ strategy which is increasingly anti social in its outcomes.

The leasing of homes under this arrangement does tick boxes under the “social housing” rubric, as it takes people off the housing list and bolsters the % of housing under the auspices of the local authority that can be thus designated.

While the main opposition party Sinn Féin is making massive political capital through its stated opposition to the current government’s strategy, it has proven itself not to be any more successful when it has some power to implement housing policy through local authorities.

That was the case in Dublin City Council when the current institutional landlord high rise boom took off. Sinn Féin and others approved this once the “social housing” allocation was boxed off, regardless of cost or indeed community cohesion.

Sinn Féin was also both the largest party and part of the governing majority on South Dublin County Council when much of its current plan was agreed to between 2014 and 2019. The party proved itself to be totally incompetent as a local authority governing party during that period which accounted for the dramatic collapse in its local election vote in 2019.

Even now, where it has a presence on local authorities, the actions of its councillors have shown anything but evidence of a coherent strategy on Sinn Féin’s part. In July, party housing spokesperson Éoin Ó Broin, whose soundbites constitute what there is of their plan, was greatly embarrassed by the Sinn Féin councillors on Wicklow County Council.

They voted against a social housing development on publicly owned land at Kilbride Lodge, Bray, something which is supposed to be at the very heart of Sinn Féin housing policy. Among the objectors was the father of Sinn Féin TD John Brady who opposed the development on the grounds that a very old tree would have to be knocked down.

The councillors who opposed were no doubt doing as councillors do from every party; opposing stuff that locals found to present a threat to the existing community. Perhaps the four storey block does. That is the nature of actual politics which trumps soi disant ideological preoccupations every time.

So there is no plausible opposition solution to all of this. That there even appears to be is due to the fact that the current ruling coalition is throwing money away to the short term benefit of reducing housing lists, but to the long term gain of the investor funds, and the long term detriment of not only those trying to get a place to live, but of Irish society in general.

Matt Treacy has published a number of books including histories of 
the Republican Movement and of the Communist Party of Ireland. 

The State Is Now Leasing Homes That It Originally Built From Investment Funds

Fra Hughes ✒ calls for a systemic overhaul of the Irish housing market and the structures that support it. 


Vulture funds.

In Ireland today in the South and increasingly now in the North the cost of renting a place to live is becoming prohibitive.

In an unregulated, market led, free for all housing sector, the price of owning your own home is sky rocketing in parallel with the cost of renting somewhere to live from private landlords.

The value of property is increasing alongside the cost of living yet wages in many cases remain stagnant or in real terms are decreasing.

Are we witnessing the perfect storm for Vulture fund speculators and private landlords?

As properties values go up, deterring first time buyers from accessing the housing ladder, this facilitates Vulture funds and billionaire landlords to buy up new and existing housing stock in order to create a generation of renters in perpetuity.

If young people cannot afford to buy a home then they must rent, become homeless or stay living with their parents.

The traditional pattern for those who wanted independence and freedom as adults, was to leave the family home, rent for a few years, save up a deposit, staying in permanent employment, pick an area to live in and buy a home.

Start a family and have security of tenure going forward. Perhaps moving to a larger home as the family grows, and hopefully before retirement be mortgage free with a reasonable disposable income in order to live comfortably in retirement.

For those who could not afford to buy a home based on income or unemployment the government provided state housing with security of tenure and fixed affordable rents.

After 50 years of neo liberal successive governmental policies, the housing market had seen a drastic reduction in the building and procurement of social housing with a dramatic increase in housing construction by private companies, when there is profit to be made.

The old economic equation of supply and demand dictates property prices and house rents.

On average only 20% of all homes built in new housing development schemes are set aside for affordable or social housing that means 80% of all new private housing stock is generated by market value.

With very few social housing units being built more and more people are being forced to rent.

Exorbitant rents decrease the likely hood of young people being able to save towards a mortgage deposit, when such a huge proportion of their salary goes into, simply paying the rent.

While the bank of mum and dad may be an option for some the reality is young people must rent for longer and longer periods before even attempting to buy.

If the Vulture funds are allowed to continue to buy up to 80% of new housing developments, then our young citizens will not be able to purchase a home, regardless of cost because the Vulture funds will not be selling their assets.

The government in the Republic of Ireland are complicit in allowing this to happen. They refuse to protect our housing stock from the rapine of capitalism.

Many European cities have rent caps to prevent excessive profiteering by landlords.

The response in Ireland to house price inflation is not to restrict rents but to offer 40 or 50 year mortgages. This may become the only way young people can afford the monthly repayments.

To work for 50 years, to pay for your own home and potentially pass that mortgage debt onto your children who cannot afford to buy simply takes my breath away.

The financial system endorsed and overseen by government is allowed to make massive profits off the backs of its citizens.

Unregulated markets led to the financial crash of 2007/2008.

The boom bust biblical cycle of 7 years of lean followed by 7 years of fat is repeated in the capitalist economic cycle of ten years of boom and ten years of bust.

While people look at short term governmental policy of 4/5 years, they miss essentially the long term failures of the capitalist system.

If Vulture funds and private billionaire landlords some of them in government continue to buy up as much of the available housing stock as they possibly can, rents will be continue to rise.
 
  • People will not be able to buy a home of their own.
  • A renter economy will become entrenched in society.
  • Can you imaging working all your life to pay rent?
  • Then retiring on a state pension and perhaps a small private pension and still be forced to pay huge rents until you die?

What kind of a soulless life in retirement are government creating for those who produce the wealth in society, that us the working man and woman? If they cannot pay the rent from their meagre savings are they to then live in homeless shelters?

If you think this is far fetched, just ask yourself why billionaires and Vulture funds are buying property in Ireland, North and South.

It’s simple. They are buying homes so they can rent them out and create huge profits from the extortionately high rents.

It’s a racket endorsed by government.

If you want a roof over your head you must pay the prices they demand.

They are not in this for ten years or twenty years or thirty years. This is all pure profit. They are in it for a lifetime, your lifetime and for lifetime of your children and grand children.

Venture capitalists would love nothing more than owning all the property in Ireland and forcing people to rent for life.

That’s a capitalist landlords dream. Profit in perpetuity.
 
It’s a racket to be sure.

One that that Irish government in the South and increasingly in the North appear happy to see develop.

I fear the present systems of government extols the excesses of the private sector, over the health and wealth of the common people.

That’s you, me, our children, and grand children.

It’s not time to change those running the system.

Its time to change the system!

Fra Hughes is a Freelance journalist-author-commentator-political activist.
He blogs @ The North Belfast Journal: A View From Napoleon's Nose.
Follow on Twitter @electfrahughes

Ireland Home Of The Renter

Matt Treacy ✒ If the truth be told, housing projections for Ireland make the form book for virtual racing seem reliable.


What is pretty conclusive is that the estimates for new builds that form the basis of Project 2040, which is the synthesis of the National Planning Framework and National Development Plan, are way off.

The great “vision” that is supposed to be guiding where the state is going, and which barring a few quibbles here and there, is shared by the main opposition parties, is based on a forecasted population increase of somewhere in the region of “roughly a million” by 2040. Which on the basis of the population at the time the “plan” was drawn up, would mean a population of around of 5.8million.

We shall return to that, but even if that turns out to be accurate, then it would require 550,000 new housing units to be completed by that time. That would require an average annual new build of 25,000. The plan itself refers to a target of 25,000 to 2020, rising to 30/35,000 between 2021 and 2026, and a total of 112,000 social housing units by 2027.

It does not take a genius to realise that none of those targets have been met, nor are likely to be met. The number of house completions in 2018, the first year of the Great 22 Year Plan, was 18,000, with 21,241 in 2019 and less than 21,000 in 2020.

That, and rather different population projections, have led to others significantly upping the targets that need to be met if the demand for housing is to be met. In December 2020, the Economic and Social Research Institute published an estimate of between 26,000 and 33,000 new builds over the next number of years.

The difference depends on the level of net migration. This was 33,700 in the year up to April 2019. That fell to 28,900 in the following 12 months, as the Covid crisis made an impact, but will most likely increase significantly if and when restrictions ae lifted, and in the light of continued large movements of illegal immigrants into Europe this year. The ESRI estimates depend on whether there is high or low net migration.

Others, looking at the issue from the perspective of those with a direct involvement in the housing sector obviously believe that Ireland will continue to experience a high level of immigration. A report from Davy’s which we referred to in June, bases its projection on there having been an increase of 240,000 in population in the past five years. That will require 200,000 new builds over the next three years, an average of 66,600 each year.

The latest report to basically dismiss the Project 2040 forecast is one published last week by the Irish Institutional Property group. They have skin in the game of course, more of which anon, but that probably makes their predictions a bit more on the money, because money is their primary interest in housing.

It is written by Dr. Ronan Lyons an assistant Professor of Economics at Trinity College, Dublin. Unlike either the state or the ESRI, Lyons does not pussy foot around the issue of mass immigration, which he regards as a “positive.” Every 10,000 migrants require an average of 4,000 new dwellings.

So, if net migration returns to even pre Covid levels, immigration alone will add 450,000 new builds required between now and 2050. That’s of a total of 1,450,000 – an average of 50,000 new builds every year – which is close to what Lyons believes will be necessary to meet overall demand.

Another dimension to the housing market, and the reason that developers and indeed the state is looking more towards one and two bedroom dwellings is the radical change in household composition. Between the 1996 and 2016 Census, 66% of new households were one and two person households, which now constitute over 50% of all households.

Another significant statistic is that 40,000 new households are what are described as “crammers,” that is households made up of people who are not related to one another. That cohort constituted 35% of the overall increase in all households between 2011 and 2016. They are of great interest of course to buy and build to rent developers, and account for much of the dynamic including the upward pressure on rents that is evident in the housing market.

Dublin, like other European cities, is particularly impacted by the dissolution of older traditional social norms, with an estimated 360,000 one and two person households which is already responsible, according to Lyons research for a latent demand for 125,000 “multi family apartments.”

Shorn of the politically motivated platitudes and nods of the head towards “balanced regional development” favoured by all of the main parties who worship at the altar of globalised capital, Lyons report makes no pretence of the fantasy that Ireland is going to be able to control those forces in the direction of sustainable communities. Rather, he forecasts that urbanisation will rise from a current level of 64% to at least 80% over the next 50 years.

That is backed by the fact that 83% of work locations are currently located in the 20 Census districts with the highest population. Nothing in Project 2040 or the even more dystopian “vision” of the open borders multi cultural “post nationalist” left will alter that trend.

On the basis of all that. Lyons contrasts the predictions of Project 2040 starkly with what he believes will be the actual outcome based on his analysis of current and likely future demographic and economic trends. He states that demand for housing up to 2025 will require an annual build of 47,000 not 25,000. And even that is based on demand created by net migration of just 20,000 whereas if the pre Covid pattern remerges, and global trends suggest that it will, then immigration is likely to be higher than that, of at least 33,000 every year.

Project 2040 is basically more of a public relations exercise than a serious national plan. It is clear that it completely ignored some of the projections made by the Central Statistics Office in a 2013 report on Population and Labour Force Projections, 2016 – 2046. The CSO forecast a net migration of 10,000 by 2021, which is already a gross under-estimate of almost 280%, and of 30,000 between 2026 and 2046.

The CSO predicted that in a high migration/high fertility scenario that the population of the Irish state will reach 6,727,000. And bear in mind too, that given the falling native birth rate, much of any increased fertility would be among immigrant communities.

The purpose of IIP, who commissioned the report, is of course to influence policy in the direction which best suits their members who include Cairn Homes, formerly owned by George Soros, the Ronan Group whose founder was one of the stars of the financial debacle, and the state’s largest landlord Ires Reit. The thrust of the report is that housing strategy should be based around high rise one and two bed apartments, to be rented not owned. Lyons points to the fact that Ireland is way below the European average of apartment dwellings.

The fact that the formerly Soros owned Cairn is one of those pushing housing policy in line with mass immigration, complements perfectly the Soros Open Society funding of NGO “social justice” advocates of mass immigration, including the acceptance of illegal immigration from countries that are not even considered to be unsafe under international refugee criteria. These ensure more people to be housed, often at public expense, and more upward pressure on rents.

In common with other European cities, Dublin has already experienced a significant movement of Dublin born people moving to other pasts of the country, mostly to counties of east Leinster. That is increasing as more people are displaced, and as working people from Dublin move to other counties to commute for a combination of affordability and increasing discomfort in their native place.

That pattern is common across all European cities in which mass immigration and the radical changes in demographics and community have taken hold. Those changes also bring with them increased social dysfunction which is the product of social welfare dependent natives being stuck in parts of the city where there is a high proportion of immigrants, many of whom are also state dependents. It is not a healthy recipe, nor one that could not have been foreseen in the light of the experience of English and other European cities.

Meanwhile, the high rise blight continues to afflict Dublin, and rents continued to increase. Ires Reit made a profit of €27.4 million to June this year, with its rental income growing by 5.9% to €31.3 million over the previous 12 months. The average monthly rent in Dublin is currently €1,641. Interestingly, from a policy perspective, the Lyons report recommends that state land be made available to build upon, and that shared ownership and shared equity be encouraged by the state.

They are policies that on the face of it are appealing, but the fact that they are apparently favoured by institutional landlords might cause one to pause. It is also the plain truth, that unless the Irish people elect people who are not prepared to go along blindly with global forces outside of their control, that domestic housing strategy is never going to be more than moving the deck chairs around.

More than that perhaps, it requires the Irish people themselves to look at where we are headed as a community. The dominant narrative, as reflected in elections and referendums and the blithe acceptance of the most pernicious aspects of Woke anti-culture would not give rise to optimism on that score. If a people believes in nothing, then it will accept anything. And then wonder at the consequences.

Matt Treacy has published a number of books including histories of 
the Republican Movement and of the Communist Party of Ireland. 

Project 2040 ➖ The Fantasy Numbers Behind Ireland’s Housing Policy

Matt Treacy ✒ A report on housing published this morning by Davy’s estimates that 200,000 new houses will have to be built over the next three years. That will require an average annual new build of 66,600.


Less than 21,000 were built in 2020, with an even smaller number of completions projected for 2021.

This will be to meet a latent demand estimated by Davy’s to have been 106,000 last year, in addition to a further 30,000 new houses every year to meet new demand.
 
Housing estate in Drogheda Photo Credit:
MacMcCarron on Geograph under CC licence

The bad news for those seeking a home is that a combination of demand and under supply will lead to significant inflation in house prices and construction costs. The report implies that, far from representing a solution, the current proposals by both the government and the opposition to stimulate demand in the absence of realistic proposals to meet that demand will exacerbate the problem.


Davy’s housing projection takes into account an increase in population of 240,000 in the past five years. Much of that of course has been due to immigration, and we have looked previously at how that will continue to be a key factor in the housing market over the next 20 years.

All of the main political parties not only accept this but, as we have seen, have both consistently under-estimated the actual level of inward migration, and are basing their future projections on factors completely outside of the control of the Irish state.

An indication as to how random population estimates are is the discrepancy between different models. The ESRI, as we have reported previously, estimates a population in the state of 5.66 million by 2040, but closer to 6 million in a “high migration scenario.”

The United Nations estimate, based on likely trends, was for 5.49 million in 2040. That is a difference of between 170,000 and over 400,000. (It should be noted too that the UN projection for 2016 was 66,000 lower than the Census.) Not small beans at all when this will be the main factor in not only future housing demand, but in public provision in education, health, policing, and so on.

Perhaps, amid all the promises and plans for housing, someone might consider actually looking seriously at how to cope with the main driver of population growth over the next decades?

The elephant standing in the corner might make the proverbial horse in the Ballymun elevator look like a minor conundrum.

Matt Treacy has published a number of books including histories of 
the Republican Movement and of the Communist Party of Ireland.  

Davy Says Housing Policies Will Push Up Prices And Build Costs