Ten links to a diverse range of opinion that might be of interest to TPQ readers. They are selected not to invite agreement but curiosity. Readers can submit links to pieces they find thought provoking.
Briefly going back to 1945 when he took the job, Matt Busby insisted he would decide on all footballing matters, who would be bought and who would be sold and they ‘would keep out of football matters’, they being the board. The Chairman, J.W. Gibson agreed to Busby’s terms though some directors were not happy. Matt Busby’s immediate success, operating from a garden shed with a bombsite as a ground he soon shut these directors up. He was never questioned again. Busby had laid the blueprint for managing Manchester United which ripped through the pre-war arrangements when the board decided who would be bought and sold, they also picked the team.
In 1977 the ‘Battle of the Giants’ played out the FA Cup Final at Wembley between Manchester United and Liverpool. United, under Tommy Docherty, hammered the scousers 2-1 ending their hopes of winning the then illusive treble. Ironically 22 years later in 1999 it would be Manchester United under the managerial stewardship of Alex Ferguson who would lift the treble consisting of the League, FA Cup, and European Cup. This treble had illuded Bill Shankly, Bob Paisley, Joe Fagan, Kenny Dalglish at Anfield but United’s second great manager, Alex Ferguson, achieved the impossible. Ferguson once vowed to ‘knock Liverpool off their fucking perch’ which in his 26 years as Man Utd Manager he did just that. Ferguson won 13 league titles, 2 European Cups, 5 FA Cups, and 4 League Cups in a total of 1,500 games.
It is not necessary to examine every Man Utd Manager/Head Coach since Fergie, there have now been 13 of them, so let me move on to the latest victim, Michael Carrick. Not so long ago, managing Manchester United was the most prestigious job probably in world football and now it has become, thanks to the Glazers and Jim Ratcliffe, a poison chalice. Michael took the reins after the dismissal of Ruben Amorim who lost his job after a 1-1 draw away at Leeds. After the match Amorim raged, rightly so in my view, he was ‘hired as the manager, not just the head coach’ and effectively demanded the scouting department and director of football, Jason Wilcox, ‘do their jobs’. Unfortunately for Ruben he was only the head coach despite his delusions. The last man to hold, at least on paper, the title of ‘Manager’ was Erik ten Hag though effectively he too was merely the head coach. Michael Carrick took the reins on a caretaker basis and the team’s fortunes improved dramatically. In fact if the league had started in January 2026, it would have been Man Utd and not Arsenal who would have won it! United’s first game under Carrick was against Man City in the derby. Against all expectations Man Utd took the spoils and bragging rights defeating the Blues 2-0 at Old Trafford. Then it was away to eventual champions Arsenal and again against the odds United came out victors by 2-3. Like all those since Ferguson who held the job as Man Utd manager or head coach Michael Carrick had none of the powers once held by managers like Matt Busby and Alex Ferguson. Busby had the ultimate power even above that enjoyed by Ferguson who did need the board’s approval regarding transfers because of the money involved, but the board invariably backed Fergie. Carrick had very little say over who the club bought and sold and was handed what Jason Wilcox, Director of Football, and Omar Berrada, Chief Executive Officer, delivered.
All the time Michael Carrick was doing his duties on the training pitch these two snakes, Wilcox and Berrada, were talking to another man about becoming the next head coach. That man now is the head coach, Mauricio Pochettino, who was in charge of the USA national men’s team. United will have to pay £7.5 million to the USA for poaching their man and also £5 million to Michael Carrick who had, and retains, the supporters' backing. The Glazers, still the majority shareholders by some distance, will take this money out of that extracted over the years by them from the club. To them this is loose change and if all goes wrong again, and all indications are not good because the same restraints will be on Pochettino as were on Carrick, they can just sack the new man. This managerial merry go round at Old Trafford has been a standing joke since Alex Ferguson retired back in 2013. Pochettino’s sanity must be called into question because he reportedly said, when offered the post, it is ‘too good an opportunity to miss’. This opportunity which in his eyes was ‘too good’ has seen 5 managers and 2 head coaches sacked in 13 years!! Is he sure?
The real problem at Old Trafford lays with the Glazers and Ratcliffe. When the INEOS boss bought a minority shareholding, 28%, he also took over the football side of the business, itself a minority piece of the overall concern. Recently Avaram Glazer removed any pretence of having the slightest interest in football when he stated; ‘clubs of United’s stature do not depend on success on the pitch to retain their commercial power’. This evidently proves football at Old Trafford is a very minor part of the business and success, once all important, is no longer the primary consideration. Glazers comments reportedly compared Manchester United with the New York Yankees and Dallas Cowboys who appear not to depend on sporting success in order to maintain commercial appeal. Man Utd are not some fucking American Wild West theme show with no other purpose than being a cash cow for the owners. It is the Glazers and Ratcliffe who have to go but how to do it? I don’t really care how they are disposed of, just when they are!!
Ten links to a diverse range of opinion that might be of interest to TPQ readers. They are selected not to invite agreement but curiosity. Readers can submit links to pieces they find thought provoking.
Before We Conform, Or Condemn, Let Us At Least Be Curious
The last two games I watched, the team failed to hit the high note and were out of tune on so many occasions. Against Fenerbahce it was Slot mark 2. Hard to watch. In the previous game against Arsenal, while denied an obvious penalty which the Premier League authorities have since acknowledged, they simply failed to create a serious goalscoring opportunity. There is a caveat but it offers little in the way of mitigation. The ineptitude of VAR officials has in large part led to me now being in agreement with Caoimhin O’Muraile on VAR. Although Ryan Gravenberch should never have been sent off in an earlier game against Manchester Cheaty courtesy of another VAR howler, which changed the direction of travel of the game and arguably the outcome, this is not a Liverpool thing.
I missed most of Sunday's game away to Crystal Palace, catching the first thirty minutes in a Dublin bar as we crawled our way pub by pub to the FAI Cup final. What I did see gave little cause for optimism. Palace aren't exactly high fliers in the English premiership just now but they were allowed to sniff out the Liverpool goal all too easily. Allison, despite some dodgy performances of his own in the other two defeats, kept the scores level. Liverpool emerged 1-3 winners so while the front line has delivered on that occasion, serious questions remain about the backline, which conceded from three set pieces. That is abysmal defending. Even Jeremy Jacquet, so reliable throughout this current campaign, had a seriously off day.
Ten links to a diverse range of opinion that might be of interest to TPQ readers. They are selected not to invite agreement but curiosity. Readers can submit links to pieces they find thought provoking.
Before We Conform, Or Condemn, Let Us At Least Be Curious
Ten links to a diverse range of opinion that might be of interest to TPQ readers. They are selected not to invite agreement but curiosity. Readers can submit links to pieces they find thought provoking.
Before We Conform, Or Condemn, Let Us At Least Be Curious
Ten links to a diverse range of opinion that might be of interest to TPQ readers. They are selected not to invite agreement but curiosity. Readers can submit links to pieces they find thought provoking.
Before We Conform, Or Condemn, Let Us At Least Be Curious
one of those high street legacy chain shops just before it collapses, piles of Quality Street by the door a rat in the lingerie department, destined to become a pop-up vape shop run by Albanian money launderers.[1]
And yet the pit of anxiety ran deep in my stomach just as it was when we were negotiating our path back to the Premier League in 2024-25 and our survival the following season. For the truth is that Leeds United v Manchester United is a bitter and toxic fixture that develop its venom in the 1960s and has persisted through eras of contrasting fortunes for both Uniteds. For 25 of the seasons since I became a Leeds supporter we were not even in the same division thanks to relegation (Manchester suffered that fate for one season only in 1974-75). Yet every home fixture of both sides was soundtracked to the chants of “We all hate Leeds scum” at Old Trafford and simply “Scum” at Elland Road. Elements of both sets of supporters descended to the level of the gutter with “tragedy chanting,” the “Munich 1958” song commemorating the destruction of the Busby Babes in the airplane crash in Munich in 1958 spewed out at Elland Road was matched by ditties such as “Always look for Turks brandishing knives” in reference to the fatal stabbing of two Leeds supporters in Istanbul in April 2000 prior to a UEFA Cup semi-final first leg contest with Galatasaray.
But why does this fixture take up so much headspace among the rival sets of fans? What is the historical and geographic logic behind it? It lacks the ethno-religious dimensions of the Old Firm derby in Glasgow (which used to characterise the Merseyside derby); the historical resonance of the El Classico fixture between Real Madrid and Barcelona. There is not the geographical proximity and the economic rivalries underpinning the Liverpool v Manchester United animus. It has none of the intimate, visceral bitterness of the Tyne-Wear derby between Newcastle United and Sunderland (which descends from the opposite sides that both towns took in the English Civil War) or the South Coast derby between Portsmouth and Southampton (which has its roots in a seamen’s strike in the 1950s). It is hardly a war of the roses either between Yorkshire and Lancashire as the location of Old Trafford gravitates more to Cheshire. It cannot be traced to one specific game such as the 1970 FA Cup Final replay between Chelsea and Leeds which bequeathed Leeds’s fans second most bitter hatred.
The answer is probably to be found in the footballing cultures of the 1960s and 1970s, on the pitch, on the terraces and in the media coverage of football. Some observers date the rivalry to the signing of midfield maestro John Giles by Don Revie from the Old Trafford club in 1963 when Leeds were still in the old Second Division. In Leeds’s first season in the top flight in 1964-65; Revie’s charges went toe-to-toe with Manchester United who were the eventual winners of the League title but gained some measure of compensation in victory over their erstwhile rivals in the FA Cup semi-final after two bruising encounters settled by a late goal by Billy Bremner in the replay.
Survivors of the Busby regime at Old Trafford such as Pat Crerand recall respect being shown to the growing force that was Leeds United but never affection as Don Revie’s earlier teams did not go out of their way to make friends and influence people because of their alleged aggression and meanness. However as Man U’s star waned after their European Cup, that of Leeds United rose with two League titles, one FA Cup, one League Cup and two Inter Cities Fairs Cup trophies plus three League runners up positions, two other Cup Final appearances, Cup Winners Cup final appearance and European Cup semi-final appearance in the period 1968-74 when the Stretford Enders were nosediving to the indignity of relegation by 1974.
With the return of Leeds United to the big time in 1990 under Howard Wilkinson, the cross-Pennines rivalry was renewed with an intensity that shook even Alex Ferguson who from his participation in Old Firm derbies as a Rangers player in the 1960s presumably would have known a thing or two about the animosity involved in club rivalries. The point of maximum ecstasy for Leeds United fans was reached in 1992 by becoming the Last Champions (the last winners of the old Football League Championship before the dawn of Planet Premier League) at the expense of Manchester United whose Devon Lock like collapse in the home strait led to us winning the title with a game to spare. A talismanic presence in that team was the enigmatic French forward Eric Cantona who Wilkinson had signed as an emergency replacement for injured forward Lee Chapman. Fully cognisant of the risks of signing a free spirit with a history of clashing with football authority figures, he looked to have signed at £1m the bargain of the season as Leeds fans formed an almost sexualised relationship with this Gallic force of nature who from the top of the open top bus proclaimed to the citizenry of Leeds during our title celebrations “I don’t know why, but I love you”.
A decade later at the turn of the millennium Leeds again looked poised to mount a serious challenge to Manchester United’s dominance with the full flowering of the crop of the 1997 FA Youth Cup winning squad who were unleashed onto the Premier League and European competition. It seemed only a matter of time before the trophy cabinet at Elland Road would be replenished season after season. However the collapse of the house of cards in the wake of two successive failures to qualify for the Champions League and the consequent ensnarement of Leeds United in a vortex of debts and unsustainable financial commitments as a result of the catastrophic management by the PLC board that ran the club led to the sale of the only assets that a club has – players. The biggest name in the Dutch auction that followed was Rio Ferdinand, signed for a club record fee for a defender at £19m from West Ham in November 2000 and then sold for another record fee for a defender £30m; this time again to our nemesis - and once again our export would be central to a third decade of Man United dominance. Our descent into relegation (and near extinction) was book ended by the sale of local lad Alan Smith who was the beating heart of the O’Leary Babes squad to, guess where, Manchester United for £7m overnight, becoming Public Enemy No. 1 in Leeds; the latest entry into the rogues gallery of defectors never mind the economic rationale behind these sales – considerations which football emotions override by default.
Now to Sunday’s proceedings. To their credit, they effectively deployed a 3-4-3 formation which largely thwarted our attack apart from one downward header by Swiss defender Nico Elvedi which was palmed away by Man U keeper Lammens. The opposition were winning two thirds of individual duels, and their quick breaks were sounding alarm bells in the home defence. It came as no surprise when after fluffing a header in acres of space near the goal, Bryan Mbeumo gave the visitors the lead in the 34th minute from a cross by the Belgian Diallo. A typically spiky encounter saw some juicy tackles which had a stricter official than Darren England been in charge could have seen two yellow cards leading to red for Leeds captain Ethan Ampadou, Swedish defender Gudmundsson, and Man United’s Santos and Baleba.
But come the second half total change as Leeds really came out of the traps. By the 53rd minute, we were level thanks to a seemingly well-rehearsed set piece moved in which Bosnian defender Muharamovic flicked on a corner to Dominic Calvert-Lewin who outmuscled Mbeumo to deftly trap the ball and pivot to score from close range. Now there was only one United in town and had Tanaka and Stach shown more composure in the penalty with their shooting boots, we would have gone ahead. Manchester did respond with some breakaway attacks but with no serious end product. Leeds kept forcing the pace of the game and almost forced a winner in stoppage time against a Man U defence lacking the composure they showed in the first half.
The general consensus is that a draw was a fair result. It is a sign of the progress that we have made since our return to the Premiership that Daniel Farke expressed some disappointment that we had not got all three points while acknowledging that one point was a satisfactory outcome. For besieged Man Utd manager Michael Carrick this result should buy some time until the next Spurs and Fulham type performance. But at the full time whistle I was still breathing heavily to relieve the tension in my system. There certainly is a market for a fan podcast run by Paul known as “Leeds Therapy.”
Marching on Together
[1] Barney Ronay Analysis Managerial magic bullet merchants are derailing the United supremacy The Guardian 19 October 2026 p.41
Ten links to a diverse range of opinion that might be of interest to TPQ readers. They are selected not to invite agreement but curiosity. Readers can submit links to pieces they find thought provoking.
Before We Conform, Or Condemn, Let Us At Least Be Curious
Ten links to a diverse range of opinion that might be of interest to TPQ readers. They are selected not to invite agreement but curiosity. Readers can submit links to pieces they find thought provoking.
Before We Conform, Or Condemn, Let Us At Least Be Curious
The ‘Blues’ have recently been found guilty of 114 out of 115 financial rule breaches which involves the government of the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and the ruling royal family. Man City are owned by billionaires from the UAE with the principal owner, Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, being a member of the ruling Al Nahyan royal family of Abu Dhabi and is also the Vice President of the UAE. Sheikh Mansour owns the club through the Abu Dhabi United Group and the City Football Group (CFG). To him Manchester City are a plaything, a toy he can discard when bored play games with. It would appear the game of Monopoly he chose to play this time with his toy has been a financial dealing too far because even by the standards of corrupt capitalism it is illegal. As the Sheikh moved round the Monopoly Board Officer Edgar Mallory said, ‘Go to Jail, Go Directly to Jail’ but the Sheikh refused telling the policeman to fuck off! He can of course say that because he’s a member of the UAE royal family who own 10-11% of the middle-east’s oil, around 113 billion barrels. Other non-oil wealth sectors include, Gold and Commodities including diamonds and precious metals, Financial Services, Real Estate and Construction are all sources of wealth for UAE and, like most businesses, are open to possible mega corruption just like their Man City venture.
City are appealing, as is their right, and the appeal was launched on 1st October 2026 and is in all probability to be heard within 12 weeks. Are there grounds for an appeal? If it were anybody else the answer would be no because the evidence they are presenting has apparently already being “branded untrue by the Premier League’s independent commission” (Irish Daily Mirror back page Friday 2nd October) therefore it is not new evidence. Manchester City were found guilty of violating Premier League spending rules using “sham arrangements to inflate figures and sponsorship deals to the tune of £900 million”. Apparently, they moved expenses around and used a “sham Fordham arrangement involving player image rights as part of a disguised funding scheme to bypass spending limits”. An independent commission found that “Fordham was funded by the club’s owner, the Abu Dhabi United Group (ADUG), making it little more than a front rather than a genuine independent third party” as City claimed, in plain language a fucking sham.
If they win on appeal the question to asked is, did they win because the law was on their side or because they have the financial clout? The latter would be most likely but under such a scenario both the Premier League and Man City, through their legal teams, are unlikely to leave any evidence of corrupt payoffs. What it will tell us though, once and for all, is the game, already corrupt, is irreparably fucked. Fans could stop attending PL games, but that would make little difference. Many of those crossing the turnstiles today aren’t proper fans of the team but tourists and different tourists every other week at that! Ask the Scousers, Liverpool that is, they carried out a survey. If Man City buy their way out of this then the Premier League will be about as credible as Infantino and FIFA!
City’s legal team are likely to argue “an Abu Dhabi government body – rather than Sheikh Mansour – provided funding at the heart of the financial dispute” (ibid). After the guilty verdict a statement from City said:
The whole Premier League case against us is based on a single false accusation – that the owner’s personal money was somehow and secretly put into the club via some sponsors from Abu Dhabi. This is just not true (Irish Daily Mirror page 40).
we concluded that was an explanation that the club concocted well after the event in an attempt to obscure and conceal the realities of the disguised funding scheme. (ibid).
Former Manager, Pep Guardiola, appears to have been very clever in all this. He resigned as City’s Manager having just secured the Premier League title at a very opportune moment! Did he expect this verdict coming? If this was the case, how did he work out when to jump ship? Either way he managed to distance himself from Man City at just the right time. City’s alleged corruption began back in 2009 when Roberto Mancini was their manager and the successful years – now at best tainted – were just beginning. The Abu Dhabi United Group bought Manchester City in 2008, a year before these corrupt transactions began. Ironic that! All the same it appears the cunning Pep knew when the time to go had arrived. It may have been helpful having his employers, the UAE royal family who were also his mates, on side. Did they give him the nod? Either way Pep Guardiola has told City fans – tourist and few proper fans left alike – he will “always be there for them”. Where exactly Pep will you be? Why did you not hang around? No doubt Pep will be watching the outcome of the appeal very closely. Should the decision go against the Blues will Pep still “always be there”? ‘There’ perhaps meaning somewhere in Saudi Arabia!
Former Manchester United boss, Alex Ferguson, said regarding Man City’s sudden rise into the big money league; “suddenly City could walk into conversations for players that previously would have been choosing between United, Chelsea, Arsenal, Madrid and Barcelona”. When Emmanuel Adebayor signed for the former Maine Road outfit his people “were still talking to Chelsea” meaning they were out of the conversation the player was having in West London.
At the time you simply accepted they had enormous financial power. You competed with it, that’s football. But if you discover years later that rules were being broken during the period you’re trying to compete with that financial power, you’re entitled to look back differently. Once you change the financial strength of one club, you don’t only change that club, you change where players go. You change title races before the first ball is kicked.
Should City lose their appeal and the charges are upheld what then for the bent champions? They could get a slap on the wrist, depending perhaps on how much the owners are prepared to fork out in bribes. Or the present owners could be barred from owning a football club, becoming deemed ‘unfit’ as happened to Roman Abramovich at Chelsea over something which had fuck-all to do with football! City’s owners may also pull billions of pounds investments out of the UK should their appeal fail and severe punishment is incurred. This would bring outside influences into play and would, no doubt, influence the Premier League when coming to a second decision.
Perhaps the worst-case scenario could be Manchester City FC are liquidated and cease to exist. They then could reconstitute themselves with different owners under their original name, St. Marks (West Gorton), or Ardwick another former name and restart life in the North-West Counties league, the strata FC United started life, forcing them to work their way back up. This is unlikely because “according to league protocols, an expelled top-flight club would have to apply to rejoin the football pyramid at the lowest tier of professional football, League Two”. This would only act as a punishment if the billions of pounds the UAE royal family put into City is denied them. Man City could not be given an unfair advantage over their peers in the lower leagues so, royal family or not, it’s time to “fold their tents like the Arabs, and as silently steal away”. It has also been touted that Arsenal, Man Utd, Liverpool and Spurs “could be in line for £200 million each” (ibid). This is a lot of money but small change to the bent owners of Man City. After all the amount of wealth they have is seldom amassed morally honestly! What about teams relegated after suffering defeat to ‘fake’ City? Will they have a claim? The possibilities are boundless! It would not be good for what’s left of football and particularly Manchester Football if City ceased to exist, Derby Day means a lot. Severely punished, yes, but do remember those passing judgement are also bent as nine bob notes themselves.
When Brian Clough took over at Leeds United from Don Revie, he accused the Leeds players of “cheating”. He suggested to players like Billy Bremner, Eddie Gray, Norman Hunter all institutional names at Elland Road, that they “throw away their medals” because they had won them “through cheating”. If ‘Old Big Ead’ were alive today, what would he have said about the goings on at Manchester City?
Another ancient terrace chant I recall: ‘We’re Manchester United and no one can deny, there’ll always be a United team in the days when City die. We’ve won the league, we’ve won the cup, we’ve conquered Europe too, and when we win the league this year, we’ll sing this song to you’ (Air, Puff the Magic Dragon). City dying seems the order and theme past and present, great days now just memories.








