Anthony McIntyre 🔖 In the year that has marked the fiftieth anniversary of the onset of Argentina's Dirty War, waged by the South American country's armed forces, the dark art has again seen its dirty head rise above the parapet.


This is the outworking of a sanitising project by the conservative right, seeking to establish the perspective of the powerful and to discredit a settled and verified narrative holding the country's armed forces to account. 

March-24 is to seventy per cent of Argentina's population what 9/11 is to the United States or Chile. Masses take to the streets to invoke memoria, verdad y justicia. The current president Javier Milei has since his incumbency been seeking to subvert this memory, truth and justice narrative, disparaging the accounts of victims, minimising the number of disappeared and equating state violence with that of Peronist guerrillas and left wing allies who fought the dictatorship. The Milei administration alleges “a biased and vengeful version of history,” his Vice President, Victoria Villarruel - a niece of one of the junta colonels - dismissing as myth the official death and disappeared toll.

Jacobo Timerman was one of the disappeared who experienced a truth that Milei seeks to downplay if not disappear. Once described as "the most famous Argentine political prisoner" of the country's so-called "Dirty War," he emerged from the darkness of the torture chambers, and his account is worth reading even 45 years after its publication, particularly as a foil against Milea's regime of truth.

In the first few pages Timerman resonates deeply with those who journeyed through the squalid bowels of the H Blocks:

The floor of the cell is permanently wet. Somewhere there is a leak. The mattress is also wet. I have a blanket, and to prevent that from getting wet, I keep it on my shoulders constantly.

Jacobo Timerman was kidnapped by Argentinian security forces in April 1977, thirteen months into the reign of the military junta. At the time he was editor of La Opinión and set his mind against the fascism running rampant throughout the land. For many, that carried a death sentence. No one was safe, not even members of the country's mostly conservative clergy. Bishop Enrique Angelelli, one of the few dissenting clerical voices challenging the military died when his car mysteriously crashed. Two military officers were in 2014 found culpable for his death. 

Prior to being hauled off to meet Susan, the name given to the picana - an electric prod used to torture prisoners - Timerman had received death threats from a right wing death squad irked at his call for the right to trial for anyone arrested - rather than being disappeared. The Popular Revolutionary Army of the Left also promised to kill him for accusing them of being fascists and a lunatic left.

Each day of the thirteen months La Opinión managed to function under military rule relatives of those missing would turn up at the paper's offices seeking help to locate their loved ones. It was something also experienced by Bob Cox at the Buenos Aires Herald: the desperate seeking the disappeared. 

Timerman felt he had been kidnapped by an extremist faction within the military, one that 'was also the heart of Nazi operations in Argentina.' Videla, he felt, wanted him spared. He refers to the Nazi regalia and portraits he managed to glimpse during his incarceration when his blindfold was removed. Yet elsewhere in the book he seems to shift position. The Nazi element was no longer the fringe:

The military government that took power in Argentina in March 1976 arrived with an all embracing arsenal of Nazi ideology as part of its structure. 

For Timerman a Zionist Jew, to be in the custody of such monsters, must have been hell on earth. Jewish girls, he claims, were violated twice as often as non Jewish ones. The type of violation he speaks of is described in unspeakable detail by Andrew Graham-Yooll in his own account of the period. While undergoing torture by Susan, Timerman recounts his interrogators screaming Jew, Jew, Jew at him. 

The book is not just an account of his time in a torture centre but also offers many observations on the politics of Argentina. However, because of his misplaced belief that Jorge Videla was some sort of moderate, the narrative is arguably much more reliable when it addresses the matter of detention and torture. 

Now that much more information has come to light about the junta, it seems impossible to describe Videla as a figure who wanted to transform Argentina peacefully but was up against hardliners. That was a US spun myth which allowed Kissinger and company to cosy up to the regime. Videla was a uniformed thug, who had trained at the School of the Americas. He believed he was on a Christian mission to eradicate communism and those who espoused it - just about everybody from trade union leaders, nuns, priests, doctors, academics, journalists, school children protesting for lower bus fares and of course guerrillas.

Timerman survived whereas an estimated thirty thousand others did not. For that he can thank Jimmy Carter who as US President put the junta under considerable pressure, something the previous administration of Ford and Kissinger were averse to. 

A read that is not relaxing.

Jacobo Timerman, 2022. Prisoner Without a Name, Cell Without a Number.
Published by University of Wisconsin Press
ISBN-10: ‎0299182444
ISBN-13: 978-0299182441

⏩Follow on Bluesky

Prisoner Without A Name 📚 Cell Without A Number

Atheist Ireland ★ There have been nearly three times as many assisted dying legalisations in the past ten years as in the previous twenty.

25-September-2026

 One of the schools in that area has a Catholic ethos and the Minister for Education is Patron.

The Catholic Church is now complaining to the UN that the State did not divest that school to a multi-denominational ethos.


In other words, the Catholic Church is offering for divestment a school where the Minister is the Patron, with the legal power to change the ethos, and where the State owns and funds the school.

And they are complaining to the UN that the Irish State won’t take its own school back as part of the Divestment Process.

They told the UN:


One such example arose in 2019-2020 as part of a State-led pilot divestment project in which 60 areas were identified as requiring a primary school operating under a multi-denominational ethos. The State identified a particular area of Limerick city as a priority.
The Model School, Limerick, operating under a Catholic ethos and directly under ministerial patronage, was present in the area. Yet the State declined to consider that school for reconfiguration to a multi-denominational ethos.

So, as a Republic, we now find ourselves in the position that a religious body wants the State divest the patronage of one primary school, that the State already owns and funds and has legal control over, the State has not done this, and the Catholic Church is complaining to the UN about it.

Meanwhile the Catholic Church itself retains control of the vast majority of our just over three thousand primary schools.

You couldn’t make that up if you tried.

Keep up with Atheist Ireland.

Catholic Church Complains To UN That Irish State Is Not Divesting Schools!

Ukraine Solidarity Group ✊ A Digest of News from Ukrainian Sources ⚔ 16-November-2026.

In this week’s bulletin

⬤ Ukraine support for Palestine,
⬤ Imperialist states are predatory.
⬤ Junking Starlink is not easy.
⬤ Evidence of Russian torture.
⬤ Russia steals archaeological heritage.
⬤ Life in besieged Oleshky.
⬤ Russian attacks on railways.
⬤ Sanctions-busting computer chips.

News from the territories occupied by Russia

The occupiers sentenced Khatidzhe Buiukhchan to 17 years’ imprisonment (Crimea Human Rights Group, 14 November)

Raped, tortured and sentenced to 14 years for alleged part in attack on Russian collaborator (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 13th)

Faces of Resistance: Political Prisoner Osman Abdurazakov (Crimea Platform, November 13th)

A Lifetime Devoted to Crimea: Mustafa Dzhemilev Turns 83 (Crimea Platform, November 13)

Journalist Asan Akhmetov in poor health in prison (Crimea Human Rights Group, 12 November)

Oleh Prykhodko sentenced to die in prison for insisting that Crimea is Ukraine and opposing Russia’s occupation (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 12th)

Russia passes massive sentences for supporting Ukraine years after abducting Kherson oblast couple (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 10th)

How Russia Steals Archaeological Heritage in Occupied Territories (Tribunal for Putin, November 10)

Weekly update on the situation in occupied Crimea (Crimea Platform, November 10th)

30 years captivity for Russia’s ‘Ukrainian saboteur’ (Kharkiv Human Rights Prt’n Group, Nov 9th)

Progress of the war and peace talks

US floats NATO membership for Ukraine in exchange for Donbass withdrawal, Zelensky says (Kyiv Independent, 14 Nov)

Ukraine hits key Russian oil hub (Kyiv Independent, 14 November)

Zelensky accuses SpaceX of treating occupied territory as ‘not ours’ (Kyiv Independent, 14 Nov)

45 days in hell: Ukraine’s underground war with Putin (Telegraph, November 12th)

“We cooked over open fires but were afraid to go outside”: Evacuated residents of Oleshky describe life under siege (The Insider, November 11)

Ukraine captures Indonesian PoW as Russia foreign recruitment rises (Kyiv Independent, 11 Nov)

An atmosphere of pervasive danger (Tribunal for Putin, November 9th)

The fifth winter’s vicious circle: why Ukraine is losing energy battle with Russia (zn.ua, 9 November)

Ukraine identifies Russian bombers responsible for horrific carnage at Komyshuvakha school (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 9th)

News from Ukraine

Crime and the FSB have Ukraine’s leaders on the hook – what next? (zn.ua. 13 Nov)

Underground: Ukraine Kids Study Without Sunlight (Centre for Europ’n Policy Analysis, 12 Nov)

Russian Drone Attacks Endanger Rail Travel (Human Rights Watch, November 10th)

Carthage must be destroyed – corruption in Ukraine (Ukrainska Pravda, 9 Nov)

ROLE: Rule of Law, not Rule by Law (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 9th)

Ukraine anti-corruption court orders probe into Zelensky ally (Kyiv Independent, Nov 5)

War-related news from Russia

Politician Lev Shlosberg, sentenced to 11 years, on good and evil (Mediazona, 12 November)

Charges upgraded against human rights defenders (Mediazona, 10 November)

Prison diary of businessman accused of ‘treason’ (Mediazona, 9 November)

“Putin, help us!”: Chinese workers building Russia’s wartime economy (Translator, November 6)

Comment and analysis

Tethered to Starlink: why it's not easy for Ukraine to drop it (The Insider, 14 November)

Ukraine reaffirms support for Palestinian sovereignty (Facebook, November 14th)

European Parliament Adopts Resolution on Ukrainian Children Deported to Russia and Those Remaining under Russian Occupation (Crimea Platform, November 13th)

“It Is Indeed the Very Essence of Imperialist States to Be Predatory” (Posle, November 11th)

Russia’s Oleshky deception shows that US-brokered ‘peace’ would serve as time to prepare for further aggression (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 11th)

Oleshky: Kremlin’s Potemkin Plan Failed, will its Trojan Horse succeed? (Byline Times, Nov 10th)

The only event touching on the Russo-Ukrainian war at this year's Historical Materialism conference (Facebook, November 9th)

The weaponization of Ukrainian scandal (Radical Dumpling, November 4th)

Also not to be missed

COP31 in Turkey to Discuss the Impact of Russian Aggression on the Black Sea Environment (Crimea Platform, November 12th)

Revealed: Lembit Öpik and the 500 other westerners – including an ex-Tory MP – who helped Putin’s propaganda war on Ukraine (The Nerve, November 10th)

The Parts Keep Coming (Anti-capitalist musings, November 10th)

Putin’s daughters and regime insiders publish in western journals despite sanctions (zn.ua, 5 Nov)

Upcoming events

"Remembering the Holodomor" - an evening of reflection on the 1932–33 famine. It will include speeches from descendants of survivors and a screening of the film "Famine-33". Wednesday 18th November 2026, 18:30–20:30. Room 347, SSEES (UCL) Free tickets here.

🔴This bulletin is put together by labour movement activists in solidarity with Ukrainian resistance. More information at Ukraine Information Group.

We are also on twitter. Our aim is to circulate information in English that to the best of our knowledge is reliable. If you have something you think we should include, please send it to 2U022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com.


We are now on Facebook and Substack! Please subscribe and tell friends. Better still, people can email us at 2022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com, and we’ll send them the bulletin direct every Monday. The full-scale Russian assault on Ukraine is going into its third year: we’ll keep information and analysis coming, for as long as it takes.

The bulletin is also stored on line here.

To receive the bulletin regularly, send your email to:
2022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com.
To stop it, please reply with the word “STOP” in the subject field.

News From Ukraine 💣 Bulletin 221

Friendly Atheist ★ At a Dallas conference, speakers called for restricting women’s rights, deporting immigrants, and making Christianity the law of the land

Over the weekend, a group of roughly 500-750 Christian activists who think the problem with Republicans is that they’re not radical enough, held a conference in Dallas to celebrate their beliefs that women should be submissive, that the 19th Amendment should be repealed, that immigrants should be deported, and that their version of Christianity should be the law of the land.

What else would you expect from an event in which conspiracist Alex Jones was the headliner, Tucker Carlson’s more extreme brother Buckley Carlson was a speaker, and right-wing racist Nick Fuentes was the unannounced special guest?

The event was hosted by “theobro” Joel Webbon and his NXR Studios—NXR standing for “New Christian Right.” While the event was announced before the midterms, it was called “Christ Is King: America After Trump,” with speakers focusing on what radical Christians need to do after Donald Trump is no longer president to put themselves in power.

According to the Atlantic, Webbon was elated that Republicans were trounced in the elections because that makes it easier to take over the GOP. 

The “New Christian Right” Gathered To Plot Out A Post-Trump Political Takeover

Merrion Press 🔖 has published a new book by Stephen Davison.




THE WEE ROADS
Irish National Road Racing

Stephen Davison


Ireland has always been the spiritual home of road racing. From the North West 200 and Ulster Grand Prix to a rich calendar of National meetings, Irish roads have produced the sport’s greatest races and riders.

It was on these public roads, transformed each summer into racing circuits, that riders like Michael Dunlop and his uncle, Joey, would hone the racing skills that would see them become the most successful road racers of all time. Unlike the professionally funded circuits of MotoGP and the World Superbike paddock, Irish road racing remains a fiercely grassroots endeavour – run by volunteers, kept alive by passion, and staged in villages and towns where everyday life pauses for speed.

As a photographer who first discovered the sport as a boy in 1974, Stephen Davison has spent a lifetime documenting its beauty and danger. The images in these pages are a stirring tribute to the people, places and spirit of Irish road racing.


Hardback • €24.99|£22.99 • 160 pages • 220mm x 220mm • 9781785376146
Get your copy

About The Author


Stephen Davison, a native of Co. Antrim, grew up watching the Dunlop family in action after attending his first motorcycle road races during the 1970s. Inspired by their skill, he began photographing the sport and has been covering road racing for over twenty-five years as a photographer and journalist. The joint owner of the prestigious photographic agency Pacemaker Press, Davison works for a wide range of international publications. A contributor to the documentary films Closer to the Edge and Road, this is his tenth book on road racing.

Out Now 📚 Stephen Davison

Right Wing Watch 👀Written by Peter Montgomery.




Right Wing Watch reported earlier this week that Calvin Robinson, a denomination-hopping far-right British priest associated with White House Faith Director Paula White, recently declared that it is necessary to “drive out the Jews” from America. Robinson made his comments on a show produced by Command Media, which describes itself as a Catholic media operation for which Robinson serves as managing director.

The RWW report generated plenty of attention and criticism of Robinson’s rank antisemitism, which Robinson and his team at Command Media took as an opportunity to double down on their bigotry.

Under a teasing headline that read “A formal apology for Fr. Calvin Robinson’s comments,” a statement attributed to Command’s board of directors read, “There is none. Christ is King, you idiots.”

Robinson’s comments were not targeting “anyone with a Jewish ancestry,” the statement claimed, only “The Jews…who are dominating our culture and subjugating theological orthodoxy on Zionism and World Jewry (as nominalized by the World Jewish Congress) with a perfidious spirit of antichrist behind it.”

The statement further documents the group’s opposition to “religious pluralism,” which they say is “incompatible with Western Christian society,” which is wildly ahistorical and simply false.

Continue @ RWW.

Calvin Robinson and Christian Nationalist Pals Double Down On Antisemitism, Religious Discrimination

Lynx By Ten To The Power Of Two Thousand One Hundred And Sixty One

 

Pastords @ 72

 

A Morning Thought @ 3332

Muiris Ó Súilleabháin ✍ First, I welcome the response by Louth Forever to my earlier piece. 

It is thoughtful, generous in its treatment of my argument and, perhaps more importantly, recognises that Sinn Féin's electoral success and progress towards Irish unity are not necessarily the same thing. We agree on considerably more than we disagree.

I find the discussion about Sinn Féin gaining another four Assembly seats but securing no additional Executive ministries in 2027 rather beside the point.

Sinn Féin could become the largest party by an overwhelming margin. It could dominate the Assembly and, hypothetically, occupy every Executive ministry. None of that would, in itself, establish the conditions requiring a border poll.

The Good Friday Agreement does not make the distribution of ministries, the operation of d'Hondt or the number of Sinn Féin MLAs the determining factor in constitutional change. The relevant statutory test is whether it appears likely to the British Secretary of State that a majority voting in a border poll would support Irish unity. That is the test that Sinn Féin signed up to in 1998.

The distinction I have been making is that Sinn Féin can accumulate political power within the North without moving one inch closer to demonstrating the consent required to leave the United Kingdom.

Its success or lack thereof at administering the North cannot be mistaken for evidence that the electorate wishes to abolish it.

But the problem goes beyond ministerial arithmetic. There are three assumptions running through the argument that I think deserve closer examination, particularly if we are serious about establishing where the votes in a border poll might actually come from

The first is Alliance.

Alliance did not emerge from Irish nationalism. It emerged from moderate unionism, offering an alternative to the increasingly polarised politics of the early conflict. Its origins were firmly within the constitutional status quo, even though the party had a cross-community identity.

I accept that Alliance today presents itself as constitutionally neutral and that its electorate contains people who favour Irish unity. But I would be very careful about treating Alliance voters as a reservoir of untapped nationalist support. There is a substantial difference between abandoning the UUP and abandoning the Union.

I would contend that a considerable part of Alliance's appeal has been its ability to accommodate people who remain comfortable with the constitutional position but have become thoroughly uncomfortable with the political parties traditionally charged with either defending or deriding it.

The second weakness is the assumption that a vote for Sinn Féin or the SDLP can automatically be translated into a vote for Irish unity.

I am a republican. I believe in Irish unity. But I would not vote Yes in a border poll tomorrow.

Not because I have abandoned republicanism, but because I believe we have unfinished business in the North (First the North Must Work). We have not yet resolved the divisions that made the place a sectarian sink hole in the first instance. Changing the constitutional arrangements without addressing those divisions risks carrying them, unresolved, into whatever political entity replaces the present one.

My own reservations are primarily political and social, but there are others whose hesitation may have considerably more to do with their economic circumstances.

I am thinking particularly of the new Catholic middle class, the generation that has done rather well out of the North that emerged from the Good Friday Agreement. Civil servants, doctors, teachers, lawyers, business owners and other professionals who have acquired comfortable homes, substantial pensions, secure careers and a standard of living that previous generations could scarcely have imagined. The people once crudely described as the “new Catholic money”.

Many will have grown up in nationalist households, voted Sinn Féin or SDLP and regard Irish unity as a perfectly natural political aspiration. But they have also prospered within the Union.

How many would be prepared to put that prosperity at risk for a constitutional aspiration? The question is no longer simply one of national identity. The North now comfortably accommodates Irishness without requiring anyone to surrender their identity or their constitutional aspirations. The question then becomes a much more practical one, salaries, pensions, taxation, property values, healthcare and the future of their children's education. What, precisely, would a united Ireland offer them that they do not already enjoy, and what might they stand to lose?

There is a world of difference between wanting a united Ireland and being prepared to accept a reduction in your standard of living to achieve it. And I would be very reluctant to assume that every comfortable Catholic professional who votes Sinn Féin in an Assembly election would automatically vote Yes in a border poll.

That brings me to the third weakness, and perhaps the most significant, the people who are not voting at all.

We spend an extraordinary amount of time examining how votes move between the DUP, UUP, TUV, Alliance, Sinn Féin and the SDLP. We spend considerably less time asking why so many people have stopped participating in elections.

I have long suspected that a substantial section of middle-class unionism has simply withdrawn from electoral politics. Not because those people have become nationalists, but because they no longer recognise themselves in the vulgar politics of the parties claiming to represent them.

For many, the DUP’s and TUV’s brand of unionism has become something they want no association with. They have not necessarily changed their constitutional convictions. They have simply stopped voting for politicians they find objectionable.

That is a hypothesis rather than a measured voting bloc and it deserves further examination. But it is precisely why I would be cautious about projecting Assembly election results onto a constitutional referendum.

In 2022, Assembly election turnout was approximately 64%. In the 1998 Agreement referendum, it was approximately 81%. We cannot assume that those additional voters would divide in any particular direction, but we certainly cannot pretend they do not exist.

A border poll would not be another Assembly election. It would ask a question fundamentally different from which party should administer Stormont for the next five years.

Someone who cannot bring themselves to vote DUP/TUV might nevertheless have very definite views about remaining within the United Kingdom. Just as someone who votes Sinn Féin might have considerable reservations about the economic, political and social consequences of immediate constitutional change.

Both possibilities complicate the neat arithmetic of electoral blocs.

And this is where I think my original argument remains relevant.

Unionism has fragmented electorally, but fragmentation is not constitutional conversion. Sinn Féin has consolidated the nationalist vote, but consolidation is not the same as expansion. Alliance has attracted people from both traditions, but voting Alliance does not tell us with certainty what those people would do in a referendum.

The mistake is to assume that the votes required for Irish unity are simply sitting somewhere waiting to be harvested, whether within Alliance, among the undecided or within a nationalist electorate whose constitutional commitment is taken for granted.

And this is why the argument cannot be settled by examining where the votes currently sit. The real question is what has been done to persuade those who are not already committed to constitutional change.

There is a wider failure here, and it goes to the heart of Sinn Féin's entire border poll strategy.

The Good Friday Agreement, which Sinn Féin signed up to almost thirty years ago, made consent the determining factor in the North’s constitutional future. It did not promise Irish unity, nor did it establish some historical inevitability that would eventually deliver it. It provided a subjective mechanism through which constitutional change could occur, but only when sufficient numbers of people were persuaded to support it.

There is another misconception worth addressing. Louth Forever suggests that the Agreement permits another border poll seven years after a defeat, describing the provision as both a mercy and a trap.

But the Agreement does not say that another border poll must be held after seven years. It says that one cannot be held within seven years of the previous poll. That is a minimum interval, not a timetable, and certainly not a guarantee of another opportunity.

Scotland should provide a sobering lesson. In 2014, 44.7% of Scottish voters supported independence. More than twelve years later, despite continuing support for independence and repeated demands for another referendum, there has been no second vote.

Why should anyone imagine that a defeated border poll in the North, even by the narrowest of margins, would automatically be followed by another seven years later?

A generation could pass before the question was put again. That is not a legal certainty, but Scotland demonstrates the political difficulty of securing another referendum after defeat.

This is why I regard the enthusiasm for a border poll now with considerable caution. The Agreement provides a mechanism for constitutional change, not an endless series of opportunities to keep asking the question until the desired answer is obtained.

Those advocating for a border poll now do not seem to understand the consequences of putting the question before the electorate without first doing the difficult work of persuasion.

The Agreement made persuasion the key to Irish unity. Sinn Féin has spent the intervening years behaving as though demographics would do the persuading for them.

Rather than convincing those who do not already support Irish unity of its merits, Sinn Féin has concentrated on consolidating its own position, displacing the SDLP and celebrating the electoral fragmentation of unionism.

And that is the contradiction at the heart of the Sinn Féin border poll strategy.

You cannot sign an agreement that makes consent the foundation of constitutional change and then spend almost three decades treating the people whose consent you require as an obstacle to be overcome rather than a community to be persuaded.

The Agreement arguably re-offered constitutional nationalists a peaceful and democratic route to their constitutional objective. But that route required something more demanding than Sinn Féin’s electoral success. It required Sinn Féin to make a convincing case to people who had never shared their constitutional ambitions.

That work should have begun in earnest in 1998. It did not.

⏩Muiris Ó Súilleabháin was a member of the Republican Movement until he retired in 2006 after 20 years of service. Fiche bhliain ag fás.

The Votes That Aren't Being Counted 🪶 A Reply

The Fenian Way 🔖 Na Fianna Éireann At War 1916 – 1986.


I never had any official interaction with Na Fianna Éireann. I was well acquainted with former members, and one former Na Fianna leader; some of those members elevated to senior positions within the IRA and pursued exemplary operational records, the vast majority of which reside in the anonymity of true Fenianism.

The opening chapter in James Durney’s book leaves no doubt as to the importance of the role and contribution Na Fianna has played in the republican struggle. Its members have paid the ultimate sacrifice throughout that conflict from 1916 through to the hunger strikes of 1981.

From its founding in 1906 its potential to the revolutionary movement was quickly realised as Séan MacDiarmada sought to bring it under the control of the IRB, a critical contingent of which was plotting the ground for the 1916 Rising.

Another central premise of its founding gave it a depth of character beyond a mere transition hub from youthful training to adult militarism. Irish cultural identity was pivotal in republican thinking at the time.

As Home Rule was sending the youth of Ireland to the Somme to make itself ‘acceptable’ to an English establishment an Irish counterpoint was deemed essential in promoting a separate and sovereign identity.

The Irish language was seen as the ultimate manifestation of that Irish identity which made its learning a crucial part in the role of Na Fianna. It wasn’t simply a case of ‘Brits Out’ but the realisation and establishment of a culturally aware Republic. Small wonder it found a welcome home in Padraig Pearse’s St Endas.

With an impressive array of significant republican figures at its helm, Liam Mellows, Con Colbert, Bulmer Hobson, Constance Markievicz, Na Fianna quickly developed a national foothold and its impact on the ground was beginning to be felt.

One of its members, Patsy O’Connor, died at the hands of the RIC as it baton charged striking workers during the 1913 Lockout; Na Fianna members playing a supporting role in that bitter industrial dispute.

But perhaps the most indelible memory for most is the photograph of Na Fianna members on Howth Harbour with outstretched arms reaching for smuggled armaments aboard the Asgard; their military credentials confirmed.

But beyond the photographs and historical footnotes there are personalised accounts from those who explained their reasons for joining Na Fianna and outlining their roles in its activities which gives an essential perspective to the times and decades through which Na Fianna Éireann evolved and developed.

The period between 1916 and The War of Independence is competently covered and well researched. And what’s more insightful for the reader is the continuing use of personal narratives to convey a sense of clarity to an oft-times chaotic environment, the product of dissent, countermanding orders and personal loyalties.

But without question that tumultuous week in 1916 would read very different were it not for the involvement of Na Fianna Éireann. The book’s detailed description of their activities, and death and injuries incurred, translates that sentiment into fact.

As with the broader republican struggle it was not the rebellion that sparked growth in its aftermath but rather the British response to it. The executions of the Rising’s leaders proved a powerful fillip for still active commanders to recruit and renew in various regions throughout the country.

As ever in republican circles funerals, commemorations and agitation on prisoners issues became the stock in trade of daily activity and national focus. But there is something missing from the transition from Easter Week to the War of Independence and that is Na Fianna Éireann’s role, if any, in the 1918 General Election.

It was that election result which both democratised and gave full manifestation to the institutions of the proclaimed Republic. But it was also central to the whole question of loyalty, a benchmark of fidelity, which would be challenged when it came to the subsequent negotiations. A salient question to be asked and answered would have been where Na Fianna’s loyalties lay at the time as it applied to Dáil Eireann!

Perhaps an explanation for this apolitical interpretation of Na Fianna stems from a general attitude that IRA members had towards them. Whilst Na Fianna members were highly active in military activity both in the sectarian violence by loyalists in Belfast and from the Black & Tans in Cork and Kerry the author unearths an element of developing tension between, ostensibly, the senior and junior wings of republican armed forces.

The clear reticence of IRA commanders and volunteers to give orders to ‘youngsters’ to engage in direct military confrontation was fairly widespread even leading to a directive that all armaments held by Na Fianna should be given to local IRA Quartermasters. Did this lack of confidence in Na Fianna’s military abilities due to their youth also extend to their abilities to offer political commentary and insights that were worth listening to?

At this juncture in the text the author introduces their own take on developments concerning the Anglo – Irish Treaty which he describes as ‘the best possible compromise at the time.’ Is this the lens of reasoning through which the rest of the text was written?

For Na Fianna both the truce and the Treaty seem to have been addressed from a local perspective, or loyalty to the local IRA Command to which they were seconded. Although their Árd Fheis reiterated allegiance to ‘the Republic’ a neutral stance on emerging divisions and hostilities was adopted.

This however did not insulate them from the escalating violence particularly in Belfast where both the RUC and the Ulster Special Constabulary engaged in widespread attacks on Catholic Communities. The author duly notes that between 1916 and 1923 it was the Civil War period which claimed the higher death toll for Na Fianna members.

But also of note was the high rate of accidental deaths amongst its members from the inexperience use and handling of weapons. In a well sourced note a British officer makes this very same claim as just cause to disarm the organisation.

Nor did Na Fianna escape the bitterness of the Civil War. The text outlines several high profile killings, murders and executions with Na Fianna personnel involved on both sides. The ultimate toll of these internecine actions was the high rate of its members simply calling it a day.

One discernible pattern emerges in that the level of activity of the IRA determines subsequently the level of activity of Na Fianna. This may seem a trite and obvious point to make for although the purpose of the organisation is well established the fact that it has no collective voice of its own is overlooked.

Certainly individual members had their own personal motivations and political viewpoints which are expressed on various events like the Spanish Civil War and the Official/Provisional split, the rejection of Marxism in the latter on patriotic grounds demonstrating a dread of detachment from its proverbial umbilical cord. Prophetically this rejection of ‘new thinking’ in favour of orthodoxy would manifest itself in a future split in its parental organisations.

Fian Gerard McAuley became the first fatal republican casualty when he was shot dead by British soldiers in August 1969. He would not be the last of Na Fianna Éireann to make the ultimate sacrifice, nor indeed the last to sacrifice a future via youthful imprisonment.

As the early years of the 1970’s slowly evaporated from republican claims of being the years of victory the dark realism of attrition and an altered definition of that victory began to prevail.

The activities of Na Fianna in that phase of the struggle are well documented, as they should be, because the final word of history has yet to be written as to how that chapter in the republican struggle came to a close. And although the book terminates at 1986 it is becoming ever clearer that the machinations and infiltrations which led to the Good Friday Agreement were already well established, even in the midst of the 1981 Hunger Strikes.

Alluding to my earlier observation regarding the authors description of the Anglo-Irish Treaty as ‘the best possible compromise at the time’ that niggling suspicion, to my mind, bore fruit with the closing declaration of the book.

Quoting Pearse the author reaches a conclusion which I profoundly disagree with. And it reinforces my contention that having a voice is critical to having a purpose because all silence has to offer are the echoes of a history we profoundly disagree with. And that is the true definition of a war of attrition.

James Durney, 2026, Boyhood's Fire: Na Fianna Éireann at War 1916–1986. 
ISBN-10: 1785376012. 
ISBN-13: 978-1785376016. 
Publisher 📖 Merrion Press.

⏩ The Fenian Way was a full time activist during the IRA's war against the British.

Boyhood’s Fire