Tinfoil Tuesday 🧪 Sci Man Dan having the craic ridiculing yet another YEC idiot.
Whatever women wear, wherever they go, indeed whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and to demand justice from the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Russell Brand, act without their consent.
But not even the conviction of the man with the Charles Manson visage and follicles based on over a thousand evidential items has led to a humble acceptance of his guilt. No, he posted a message on his You Tube channel Sunday Service pleading his innocence through the words of his wife Laura. Bad enough, that the Christ-like demon was able to broadcast a running commentary on this crypto-spiritual channel to his US followers on the trial but to continue to protest his innocence outside of normal legal channels is utterly preposterous and is certainly contrary to prison regulations where such messages cause serious distress to victims. The London Victims Commissioner has stated that such comments would retraumatise his victims As I write this, 10 Downing Street has described this message as “appalling” and is looking at appropriate responses.
It is important to discuss what some commentators hope is Britain’s #MeToo moment[1] as, hot on the heels of Brand conviction, last week the London Metropolitan Police launched investigations into “non-recent” allegations of sexual misconduct by comedian, children’s author, and Britain’s Got Talent (BGT\) judge David Walliams after a three year joint investigation by ITV and the Guardian newspaper into his alleged grooming and sexual assault of teenage girls including at least one 15 year-old who had contacted him for advice as to how to enter the world of comedy. Online speculation has also mushroomed around another prominent entertainer of the noughties era alleged to be guilty of the same sexually predatory crimes as Brand and Walliams and likely a close colleague of both. The laws of libel and the reputation of the TPQ weblog prevent me from naming my suspect candidate, but it is to be hoped that justice will catch up with this generation of celebrity sex offenders as it didn’t with Jimmy Saville or late in life as with Rolf Harris, Stuart Hall and Gary Glitter.
Brand and others were not ensnared by peak #MeToo as, like other cultural phenomena like Black Lives Movement, just did not transfer seamlessly from across the Atlantic to Britain. At Brand’s trial, his defence barrister Ian Winter QC, sought to use #MeToo against the complainants. He questioned why they had not come forward in 2017, the year of the downfall of Harvey Weinstein, when in his lyrical formulation, ‘every woman in the world was examining whether they’d been sexually assaulted by a famous person.”[2] However that line of argument does not take into account what Rosamund Unwin calls the “half-baked” nature of Britain Me Too. Some brave women did come forward but it was politicians who were the main focus – Michael Fallon had resigned as defence secretary after admitting to his behaviour towards female journalists and colleagues had “fallen short” of the required standards, and the late Anthony Lester resigned from the House of Lords following sexual harassment allegations that he denied. The MP for Dover Charlie Elphicke went to prison. Businessmen behaving inappropriately towards staff in public were brought to book. There were also a slew of complaints made against politicians from all the major parties around “touching” and “handsy” behaviour which didn’t lead to high-profile resignations apart from Chris Pincher during the dog days of the Boris Johnson administration. However there has been discussion about toxic working cultures within the Parliamentary estate.[3]
By contrast in the US, the downfall of film mogul Harvey Weinstein triggered full fat #MeToo which swept away Les Moonves, the head of CBS; Matt Lauer, the presenter of NBC’s Today show; the comedian Louis CK; and Charlie Ross, the veteran television interviewer, fired by CBS and PBS. A particularly deserving case was that of the conservative broadcaster the late Roger Ailes, forced to resign from Fox News after multiple allegations of sexual harassment. The case against Bill Cosby, the subject of complaints for years by women, went to trial in 2018 although his conviction was overturned by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in 2021. The convictions of Puff Diddy and RB Kelly are arguably the outcomes of the culture shift set in motion by #MeToo.
Another issue that has to be revisited in the wake of the Brand (and likely other scandals) is the age of consent with calls for a staggered age of consent which would make sexual relationships between adults and teenagers when there are decades in age between then statutory rape while no longer criminalising consensual sex between teenagers even if under the statutory age of 16 as in the UK; 17 in the Republic of Ireland. Such legal flexibility would have definitively placed Russell Brand on the wrong side of the law in relation to the allegation of rape of a 16-year-old when he was 30 and would do for David Walliams should he be charged with the offences he has allegedly carried out against young women. It would legally enshrine Andrew Mountbatten Windsor as the “sweaty nonce” who committed statutory rape against the late Virginia Guiffre in both London and the State of Florida and possibly other minors. Perhaps such a law could be named “Virginia’s Law” but there would have to be the widest possible consultative process before and during a putative legislative process to put in place the appropriate guardrails.
Britain’s notoriously strict libel laws have historically acted as a major deterrent to whistleblowers and investigative journalism in the area of celebrity sexual crime. In 1968, the Sunday Express was poised to publish an expose of the offending record of Jimmy Saville but baulked at it due to the advice of their libel lawyers and so and opportunity to identify of Britain’s most prolific sex offender was missed. It should at least be possible to amend the libel laws to ensure that in the cases of failed attempts at suing newspapers by Walliams, Elphicke et al, the costs are awarded entirely against the complainant.
Lastly on the ‘lad’ culture of the time that Russell Brand operated in. My fellow TPQ columnist Christopher Owens points out rightfully that prevailing cultural maxims and assumptions do not rob people of agency. Yes, it was an era when young women in public spaces like pubs would take no “shit” from leery blokes and would respond to unwanted advances from them with throwing beer at them or maybe even a kick in the nuts (my words). There are anecdotes of how women operating in male dominated environments would display a pair like Karen Brady who as Managing Director of Birmingham City became the first woman ever to hold such a position in professional football and later, on the club’s flotation became the youngest such appointee in the sport, would riposte to players on the team choice who said “I can see your tits” that “Well you won’t see them from Crewe when I have transferred you there!” All fine but hardly, I would suggest, that these vignettes chime with the lived experiences of many, if not most, women. For, in the words of Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett, “the noughties told girls like me was that abuse was normal.”[4]
Rhiannon paints vivid and shocking scenes from the ‘lad culture’ era; personal, such as reading as a 17-year-old a tabloid newspaper column arguing that girls who wore short skirts essentially deserved to be raped, to being attacked by a stranger while walking home after a night out when a common rape myth at the time had it that “I was a car who had left her doors unlocked. She knew girls who met rock stars more than twice their age at festivals who targeted them when they were still in their teens. Girls who were groomed and abused by teachers or preyed upon by older men with a preference for girls still doing their GCSEs. Girls whose boyfriends locked them in their flats. Girls who were assaulted or anally raped like Brand’s victim.[5]
She recalls the prevailing media landscape at the time that she co-authored with Holly Baxter in 2014 a book called The Vagenda which contained a section on rape culture and rape myths and aimed at teenage girls. The gang rape jokes by Jimmy Carr (who I have always found obnoxious). The London Evening Standard having a strip club correspondent. The Daily Telegraph reporting that Gymbox ran a Playboy “bunny bootcamp.” Teenage magazines having a section for readers’ photos entitled “How Sexy Am I?”[6]
The book was trashed by older male reviews and by the women who took money from the women’s magazines it criticised (where was the sisterhood when it was needed again?) To question the post- modern culture in which idea of meta narratives were for the birds; in which everything “went;” in which women were supposedly “liberated” and so feminism was redundant was to invite criticisms for being “uncool,” “prudish,” “neurotic” or, heaven forbid, “politically correct” or what would now be called “woke.” That world may have passed but its legacy is, in the words of Rhiannon, the divided self of women who came of age; “the half that knows it has been violated, and the half walking around in a world that refused to listen.”[7]
[1] Rosamund Urwin. Our #MeToo moment? Let us hope that Russell Brand’s conviction marks a watershed for Britain. New Statesman 13-19 November 2026 pp.18-19
[2] Ibid, p.19
[3] Ibid
[4] Rhiannon Lucy Cossldett. The noughties told girls like me that abuse was normal. The Guardian Journal. 12 November 2026 pp.1-2
[5] Ibid
[6] Ibid
[7] Ibid, p.2
Ten links to a diverse range of opinion that might be of interest to TPQ readers. They are selected not to invite agreement but curiosity. Readers can submit links to pieces they find thought provoking.
Before We Conform, Or Condemn, Let Us At Least Be Curious
This is not the first time the Democrats have held a majority in Congress. During the Obama era, the Democrats found themselves in a situation similar to the present, with the key difference that the President was also a Democrat. In other words, even in the best-case scenario, the outcome of these elections will not reach the level of the Obama era. One might argue: Conditions were far better back then, so a return to—or even an approach toward—that period should be considered a major victory. If so, one must acknowledge that the situation has become truly dire, given that some on the Left and among socialists are now longing for the Obama years.
Does Trump represent a distinct form of fascism?
All attention has been fixated on Trump—on his narcissistic drivel and psychopathic ravings. This propaganda has created an atmosphere that has stripped many of their capacity for sound political judgment and logical analysis. Trump is a fascist, a paedophile, a criminal, a thief and corrupt in every sense of the word. This is an accurate assessment. But are the Democrats any different in this regard?
It is undeniably true that conditions in the United States have become far more repressive and fascist; the dimensions of state-sanctioned, police-enforced racism have grown significantly more brutal. The ruling establishment no longer resorts to diplomacy or smooth talk; it expresses its intentions bluntly, explicitly, and in the ugliest possible manner. This approach is reminiscent of fascism. However, it must be noted that times have changed; global conditions are different.
The emergence of such circumstances has led some to an erroneous analysis. Trump is a fascist—there is no doubt about that. But the reality is that Western society as a whole now finds itself under the jackboot of fascism—from the Labour government in Britain and the Social Democrats in Denmark to Macron’s right-wing administration in France and the fascist Giorgia Meloni in Italy. While the names and outward appearances of these parties may differ, they all pursue the same policy.
The issue is not about Trump, Biden, Obama, or Clinton; we are living in an era where the bourgeoisie has drawn its sword. An economic crisis has gripped the world, NATO is aggressively broadcasting war propaganda, and we stand on the precipice of a Third World War. A handful of billionaires own nearly all mainstream media outlets and social media platforms, propagating racism, anti-Muslim sentiment, and xenophobia throughout society.
A militant and radical protest movement has emerged in Europe, declaring war against these conditions. For weeks, it has been locked in a fierce struggle against the police. A broad, international strike by port workers has been organised against war and Israel, and in defence of Palestine. Class struggle has emerged into the open. Under such conditions, the bourgeoisie turns toward fascism. This is precisely what has occurred in the United States, and what is taking shape in Europe as well. In the United States, this is embodied by a madman named Trump.
Consequently, analysing and evaluating Trump as a unique, singular phenomenon leads us to erroneous conclusions—which is exactly what the ruling establishment desires. If the Democrats secure more votes, we might interpret this as Trump’s defeat and breathe a sigh of relief, thinking, "Thank God, the danger has passed!"—believing we can simply carry on with our lives. While one might argue that Trump’s personality is unique, his politics are rooted firmly within the context of prevailing fascism.
Why, then, is this clarification necessary? Because the mainstream media, political commentators, and even segments of the Left and communist forces are all breathing this sigh of relief. Although they may offer warnings that the struggle continues, by exaggerating the significance and impact of this election—by overstating the defeat of Trump and the "victory of the people"—and by offering a false sense of reassurance, they are, in effect, fostering passivity.
Democrats and Republicans: Two Names for the Same Phenomenon
A brief look at history is instructive. The Vietnam War was vastly expanded by two Democratic presidents—John F. Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson—who were responsible for the massacre of millions in Vietnam. The regime change in Iran in 1979, which rode the wave of a popular revolution, was orchestrated by Jimmy Carter, a Democrat. Belgrade, the capital of the former Yugoslavia and Serbia, was bombed with depleted uranium under the administration of Bill Clinton. The killing of millions in the Middle East, the total destruction of Libya and Syria, and the orchestration of regime change in Syria were carried out under Barack Obama—touted as the "most liberal and progressive" Democratic president. Every single president has staunchly defended Israel’s crimes, genocides, and the ethnic cleansing of its native population since the state’s inception.
The domestic track record is similarly bleak. During his presidency, Bill Clinton launched one of the most severe assaults on the working class and the poor, dismantling numerous social welfare programs. As a senator in the 1980s and 1990s, Joe Biden played a pivotal role in crafting draconian drug laws that mandated long prison sentences—disproportionately affecting young Black men from impoverished and marginalised backgrounds. These laws effectively served to supply the slave labour in prisons who create millions of dollars profits for private enterprise.
As for criminal records, the names of a significant number of these figures appear on the "Epstein list," accompanied by sufficient evidence for prosecution and conviction; yet, the "elite"—those who consider themselves "better than the rest of us"—manage to shield themselves. The names of George Bush, Bill and Hillary Clinton, Barack and Michelle Obama, as well as Trump and a large portion of his administration, are all present on this list.
Furthermore, the U.S. President wields vast powers—effectively acting like a dictator. The President can unilaterally declare war, deploy nuclear weapons, occupy a foreign nation, and grant pardons to any criminal of his choosing. Through "governing by executive order," the President can bypass both Congress and the Senate; moreover, he retains the authority to veto legislation passed by these bodies. Consequently, the election loses even the marginal influence it might otherwise have held.
Some point to this shift in public sentiment—manifested as a rejection of Trump and the election of six left-leaning representatives who identify as socialists—as having symbolic significance. While this public turn against Trump is noteworthy, it was entirely predictable. Poverty has become widespread, and nearly all commentators attribute this to the (U.S.-led) assault on Iran. This is the primary source of the public's anger. Yet, pinning one's hopes on elections within these existing "democracies" is a pure delusion—a desperate act born of sheer helplessness. While one might expect the general public to fall prey to illusions—given the desperation that has gripped society—it is truly lamentable for leftist and socialist forces, who envision themselves as leaders, to harbour such delusions.
Furthermore, regarding these six so-called "socialists"—even assuming they are radical—one must acknowledge that the role eight individuals (two of whom are already aligned with the Democratic Socialists) could play in Congress is negligible. Moreover, their policies differ little from those of the British Labour Party. They are cut from the same cloth as Alexandria Ocasio-Cortes (AOC), who continues to vote for measures authorising the shipment of arms to Israel. We are well aware of the role played by these so-called socialists or "progressives"—figures like Bernie Sanders: they steer the discontented masses—whom they have attracted through left-leaning rhetoric—straight into the arms of the Democratic Party leadership. They act as a "safety valve," preventing unrest and pacifying the dissatisfied public.
An anecdote might help clarify the issue. Recently, a video circulated featuring Norman Finkelstein—a leftist activist, commentator, and staunch defender of the Palestinian people—criticising Mamdani. Finkelstein recounted how he had personally and actively campaigned for Mamdani, only to become deeply disillusioned with him. He noted that Mamdani had disregarded many of the promises he had made. Is this surprising? What is truly astonishing is not Mamdani’s conduct, but rather Finkelstein’s illusions.
Midterm Elections in the U.S. and Brazil
These elections are sometimes compared to the elections in Brazil; both are described as having positive and promising outcomes. But were these two elections similar? Both yes and no. On the surface, they appear alike; however, in reality, there are significant differences between the two events. As noted above, the U.S. elections have had no impact on the situation of the American people, the international landscape, or U.S. warmongering. Consequently, the only "benefit" of these elections is a fleeting sense of joy over the "defeat" of Trump—they will have no tangible effect on people's lives.
In Brazil, by contrast, the choice was effectively between a leftist reformist and an overt fascist. Therefore, the election result has a very real, perceptible impact on the lives of the people. The election of Bolsonaro would have imposed a dark nightmare upon a vast segment of the population.
Exaggerating the significance of a political development—labelling it a "victory" or a "defeat"—is a misguided approach that ultimately harms the people and society. Genuine, grounded socialists and communists must analyse and present reality as it truly is, and chart a path forward based on that assessment. Sloganeering is easy; effecting real change is difficult and complex.
So when I learned that Maurice Morrow had lost his wife Jennifer Morrow and daughter Rachel Burrows to illness within hours of each other, I could only feel empathy. The words of Wallace Thompson, who knew the DUP Chairman for decades, chimed with my own sentiment, that there are times when:
politics and political differences seem irrelevant. . . . . Yesterday, he lost his daughter to cancer and his wife also passed away last night. Words are inadequate in such tragic circumstances.
It has been one of the very few occasions in my 48 years in journalism that I have been physically ill doing the story. However, what helped me recover from witnessing the horrors of that camp, were the gentle danders I took around the tranquil streets of Krakow.
So I was also truly horrified to hear about the mass shooting in the city which claimed the lives of six people with the gunman later dying in hospital.
The shooter supposedly had access to Far Right material and one theory is that he became radicalised by that online material before carrying out his murder spree.
This poses a key question - is the Far Right now going to resort to terrorism to push its radical agenda, or was this a one-off massacre? The use of the so-called ‘lone wolf’ tactic - where one person organises and carries out the attack - is a favourite method of the Far Right.
In 1995, American Timothy McVeigh carried out the Oklahoma City bombing which killed 167 people. He was executed in 2001.
In 2011, Anders Brevik carried out gun and bomb attacks in Norway leaving 77 people dead. He is presently in jail.
However, there has been an attack by a Far Right terrorist group in the past. In 1980, the Armed Revolutionary Nuclei terror gang killed 85 people in the Bologna railway station bombing in Italy.
Given the rioting which has erupted in France and Spain in recent weeks, much of it attributed to Hard Left activists, the question must also be posed - has the Far Right now decided to copy the Hard Left in gaining global attention for its own extremist agendas?
The problem posed by the Far Right has come much closer to home. In early November, the PSNI announced that an investigation into explosive devices found in Belfast was linked “to extreme Right-wing terrorism”.
In an earlier column I wrote, I noted that this year was the 40th anniversary of an interview with the late Rev Ian Paisley in which he told me about the formation of a new loyalist paramilitary group. Days after the interview was published in the Belfast News Letter, the Ulster Resistance movement was officially launched.
The group was known for its distinctive red berets, but was also one of the groups which benefited from a massive shipment of loyalist weapons which were smuggled into Northern Ireland from South Africa. The haul was divided among the UDA, UVF and Ulster Resistance.
Whilst much of the UDA and UVF consignments have been found, it is believed much of the Ulster Resistance batch is still held in concealed arms dumps.
There is no known record of Ulster Resistance decommissioning its arsenal and while the theory is that they are being kept as part of a ‘doomsday’ plot in the event of Unionism losing a border poll, there is also the possibility the weapons could be ‘loaned’ to Far Right activists to carry out attacks on Northern Ireland’s migrant and ethnic minority communities.
Northern Ireland has already witnessed quite a number of racially-motivated hate crimes since the signing of the Good Friday Agreement in 1998 which supposedly heralded in the peace process, prompting the question - has racism become the new sectarianism?
During my time at the Irish Daily Star, I wrote a story of how Ku Klux Klan activists from the Knights of the Invisible Empire faction were trying to form an umbrella organisation to carry out co-ordinated attacks against the ethnic communities.
Politically, both the Far Right National Front and British National Party have made unsuccessful attempts to organise in Northern Ireland.
Whilst attacks by the Far Right must be condemned, the crucial question remains - how can they be realistically combated and prevented?
Primarily, many of these so-called Far Right ‘lone wolves’ become radicalised through the internet and especially the dark web. In this respect, there needs to be more cash investment by Westminster and Stormont in intelligence gathering on the digital footprints of people to alert the authorities to potential attackers.
There has been much talk since the outbreak of the Ukraine war for the need for the UK to increase the cash flow to the Armed forces. Cyber security must be given a dedicated budget to give the intelligence community the human and physical resources to monitor who is accessing Far Right material on the web.
From this, an in-depth data base can be compiled of potential Far Right activists who can be interviewed by the police about their interest in Far Right ideologies and material.
Indeed, if necessary, there should be a round-up of suspected Far Right activists before attacks, such as Krakow, Norway and Oklahoma, can be initiated.
There must also be much tougher fines and jail terms for people convicted by the courts of possessing, distributing or even accessing Far Right material on the web.
Whilst human rights campaigners will be screaming to high heaven about such draconian measures, there is an equal need to consider the human rights of the victims of Far Right actions.
In the past, moves to have individual identity cards have been shelved. However, if Far Right extremism becomes a reality in the UK, it will be necessary to introduce such measures to closely monitor suspected activists.
It would be much better for the sake of society to root out such activists at the point of their initial interest rather than wait for them to become radicalised and carry out a terrorist atrocity.
No doubt, the woke community will be up in arms about the concept of the state’s ‘Big Brother is watching you’. But if the increased surveillance of people’s digital footprints saves the lives of innocent civilians, then such a measure must be on the table. We cannot wait as a society until a mass shooting takes place in the UK before action is taken.
Ten links to a diverse range of opinion that might be of interest to TPQ readers. They are selected not to invite agreement but curiosity. Readers can submit links to pieces they find thought provoking.
Before We Conform, Or Condemn, Let Us At Least Be Curious
With my wife, and about to avail of the rail service to a destination I no longer remember, the title seemed apt: Night Train. I had set out forgetfully without my constant travelling companion, Kindle, and being the type of traveller who can't while an hour wasting an hour, I looked for something light. At about 150 pages, it seemed one I could get through pretty quickly. Martin Amis, I had read before. Experience, forget the pun, was a pleasurable reading experience of which I had fond memories, and Koba The Dread was on a bookshelf at home. So I guessed I wouldn't be bored by Night Train.
I am a Police is a colloquialism peculiar to the unidentifiedl US city in which Detective Mike Hoolihan plies their police trade. Mike is also a woman who had worked over a hundred of the city's murders, filtered down from the thousand suspicious deaths she had a role investigating. She brings a sardonic candour via her claim that 'all police are racist. It's part of our job . . . you're a member of a race called police, which is obliged to hate every other race.'
With fifteen years in Homicide notched up, Jennifer Rockwell's death stretched her, taking her outside her comfort zone. The victim's body was found in her apartment, undressed and little left of her head, the cerebral grey that had navigated her course in the world of astrophysics destroyed. The father of the deceased is Tom Rockwell, known to Mike as Colonel Tom, the former head of CID but now a politician. He was insistent that his daughter's death be investigated beyond the initial assumption that it was suicide. For Rockwell senior the perp is his daughter's former boyfriend, Trader Faulkner, a luminary in the world of academia.
Like Harry Hole, her Norwegian counterpart, Mike also carries an alcohol addiction which has seen her dried out on occasion. The problem could no longer be concealed once colleagues noticed Mike blowing on her dessert to cool it . . . her dessert was ice cream. During a convalescence she stayed at the Rockwell home. So there's familiarity.
Her other addiction is to bad guys. 'But I cannot get the good guys. I just cannot get the good guys.' Jennifer Rockwell from the age of eight had seen Mike 'hanging n the arms of woman-haters and woman-hitters.'
Suicide is 'the night train, speeding your way to darkness.' That made me think of my sister Rebecca, but not in a melancholic way, who took her own life a few years back. I will probably never know what train Rebecca was on.
When I next use the train in a day or two, Night Train will be placed in the station waiting room for somebody who might have forgotten to put a book or Kindle in their bag before leaving home for the commute. My contribution to the battle against boredom, a quest I have been on since the tedium saturated years of the blanket protest. Where it might travel to is . . . but the words of Arlow Guthrie about the train they call they city of New Orleans, when tweaked, seem to work. Good Morning Drogheda, how are you . . .
![]() |
| ⏩Follow on Bluesky |
British attitudes relating to Jewish people and Israel show two broad trends. Anti-Jewish attitudes are typically less prevalent and have remained more stable, whereas anti-Israel sentiments are more prevalent and have been increasing.
![]() |
| 23-September-2026 |
Assisted dying has been legalised, either by statute or courts, in 28 places in the past decade. This includes ten countries (Canada, Italy, Germany, New Zealand, Austria, Spain, Colombia, Ecuador, Uruguay, and France), Jersey, plus ten regional jurisdictions within USA and seven within Australia.
In the previous twenty years, it was legalised in ten places. This included three places in the 1990s (briefly in Australia’s Northern Territory, partially in Colombia, and in Oregon, USA), five in the 2000s (Netherlands, Belgium, Washington State, Luxembourg, and Montana), and two in the early 2010s (Vermont and Quebec).
Fifty years earlier, it was legalised in Switzerland in 1942.
Courts tend to focus more directly on whether the state should be allowed to interfere with the rights of dying people, while parliaments focus more on the balance between choice, compassion, criteria, safeguards, and palliative care.
Four common persuasive arguments in recent laws have been:
- The case for personal autonomy is more persuasive when the person is already dying, though the German Court in 2020 did not confine the right to terminal illness. And people empathise more with specific cases of personal suffering than with the principle alone.
- There is a move towards addressing vulnerability by regulating safeguards, rather than by simply denying people the right to choose. The Canadian law in 2016 followed this distinction which was made by the Supreme Court’s Carter judgment.
- There is a move against framing assisted dying and palliative care as mutually exclusive alternatives. France in 2026 explicitly strengthened palliative care while also allowing assisted dying for those with serious, incurable, life-threatening conditions.
- As more laws are passed, there is more experience elsewhere to examine and learn from. This does not resolve every dispute, but it shifts the debate from unquantifiable fears to seeing how regulations work in practice.
With that in mind, here are some lessons from legalisation during the past decade, ranging from Courts that focus more on individual rights to parliaments that focus on balancing rights with safeguards.
National Jurisdictions, 2016-2026
Canada 2016: The Supreme Court in 2015 struck down a blanket ban as it violated the rights to life, liberty and security. It found careful regulation could address the problems of vulnerability. Parliament passed the law in 2016.
Italy 2019: The Constitutional Court created a narrow exemption for assisted suicide. One argument was that Italian law already allowed dying people to refuse life-sustaining treatment and thus suffer a slower death.
Germany 2020: The Federal Constitutional Court struck down a ban on assisted suicide. It ruled this right came under the right to personality and human dignity, and that it was not confined to people with terminal illnesses.
New Zealand 2019-21: Parliament passed the End of Life Choice Act in 2019, a referendum endorsed it by 65% in 2020, and it was enacted in 2021. The people’s vote was on a specific narrow law, not on the principle of assisted dying.
Austria 2020-21: The Constitutional Court struck down a blanket ban in 2020 as depriving a person from carrying out a freely made decision. Parliament passed the law in 2021, not creating euthanasia but regulating assisted suicide.
Spain 2021: Parliament passed a law permitting both assisted suicide and euthanasia in specified circumstances. Spain’s statutory preamble says life and physical integrity must be reconciled with dignity, freedom and personal autonomy.
Colombia 2022: Colombia already allowed euthanasia, and this Constitutional Court judgment decriminalised doctors who assisted competent people to commit suicide. It ruled that the criminal sanction on doctors was disproportionate.
Ecuador 2024: As in Colombia, the Constitutional Court removed criminal liability for a doctor carrying out euthanasia under specified conditions following a competent patient’s request. This was based on dignity, autonomy, and proportionality.
Uruguay 2025: Parliament passed a law to allow dying with dignity, connecting assisted dying with autonomous choice in the face of terminal or irreversible conditions, unbearable suffering and serious deterioration in quality of life.
France 2026: Parliament passed two laws, one that explicitly strengthened palliative care, and another that allowed people to self-administer assisted dying for incurable, life-threatening conditions. This was preceded by a citizens’ convention and upheld by the Constitutional Council.
Jersey 2026: The States Assembly passed a law following a Citizens’ Jury. It confined assisted dying to people with terminal illness, and committed to end-of-life and palliative care. It is due to commence in late 2027.
USA Regions, 2016-2026
Assisted dying was first legalised in Oregon in 1997. It has become the blueprint for assisted dying laws in USA. It has never been expanded beyond terminal illness. Palliative care has continued alongside access to assisted dying.
Four more US States allowed assisted dying before 2016. These were Washington in 2008, Montana in 2009, Vermont in 2013, and California in 2015. In the past ten years, another nine States and District of Columbia have joined the list.
In the second half of the 2010s, five States and DC legalised assisted dying. California in 2016 largely followed the Oregon model, Colorado in 2016 built in safeguards that reassured voters, the District of Colombia Act in 2017 explicitly excluded euthanasia, Hawai’i in 2018 and New Jersey in 2019 required multiple healthcare providers, and Maine in 2019 required monitoring of how the law operated.
So far in the 2020s, four more US States have legalised assisted dying. New Mexico in 2021 emphasised dignity, free will, suffering and peace of mind, Delaware in 2025 focused on a regulated end-of-life option, Illinois in 2025 said assisted dying complements, rather than displaces palliative care, and New York in 2026 said the law allowed people to shorten not their lives, but their deaths.
Australian Regions, 2017-2024
Legalisation in Australia all happened through regional parliaments, starting with Victoria in 2017 and ending with the Australian Capital Territory in 2024. This meant later laws could follow earlier Australian laws rather than rely on international examples.
Victoria in 2017 followed a major parliamentary inquiry and an expert panel, which reassured wavering legislators. It focused on autonomy, relief of suffering, and safeguards.
Western Australia in 2019 began with an inquiry themed My Life, My Choice. It also explicitly recommended improving palliative care. In 2021, Tasmania, South Australia, and Queensland broadly followed the Victorian model.
New South Wales passed a law in 2022, allowing choice for competent people who are dying, with safeguards for vulnerable people, and backed by the evidence of assisted dying already operating elsewhere in Australia.
The Australian Capital Territory passed a law in 2024. It was based on dignity, human rights, community consultation, and people make choices consistent with their values.
Conclusion
There have been twice as many assisted dying legalisations in the past ten years as in the previous twenty. So what arguments have proved most persuasive in the past decade?
- The case for personal autonomy is strongest when the person is already dying.
- There is a move towards addressing vulnerability by regulating safeguards.
- There is a move against framing assisted dying and palliative care as mutually exclusive.
- As more laws are passed, there is more experience elsewhere to examine and learn from.
Hopefully parliamentarians will take these lessons on board as campaigns continue to legalise assisted dying in other jurisdictions.
Atheist Ireland supports the right to live well while dying. People who want to live as long as they can should get the best medical resources. And people who want to die peacefully at a time of their choosing should be able to do so.
When laws recognise this balance, fewer people will suffer needlessly, more people will have a greater quality of life while dying, and everybody will have their personal conscience respected with safeguards to protect the rights of others.
In this week’s bulletin
⬤ More evidence of Russian torture.
News from the territories occupied by Russia
Russia causes the death of Kharkiv teacher illegally held in solitary confinement in Crimea (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 6th)
54-year-old Serhiy Diachuk has multiple rib fractures after two years in secret Russian FSB captivity (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 6th)
The Face of Resistance: The Story of Political Prisoner Eldar Yakubov (Crimea Platform, November 6th)
Called up for Russian army service and forced to sing Russian national anthem: 13 children and teenagers rescued from occupation (Ukrainska Pravda, November 6th)
Weekly update on the situation in occupied Crimea (Crimea Platform, November 3rd)
Crimean Tatar mother of three sentenced to 12.5 years for a donation to Ukraine’s Armed Forces (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 2nd)
News from Ukraine
Kyiv faces extremely difficult situation with electricity, heating and water (Ukrainska Pravda, November 7th)
Suspects in high-profile case discussed acid attack on Ukraine's top investigative journalist (Kyiv Independent, November 6th)
How Ukraine’s security service sought access to the Anti-Corruption Court’s restricted database (Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, November 6th)
Khinprom drug cartel planned to bribe former minister Klymenko through his associates – Ukraine’s anti-corruption bureau (Ukrainska Pravda, November 6th)
Ukraine’s anti-corruption court orders probe into prominent Zelensky ally (Kyiv Independent, November 5th)
Here’s what we know three days after the clash at a temporary base for the National Guard’s Azov Corps outside Kyiv (Meduza, November 5th)
Forty people confirmed killed in Russian aerial bomb attack on school in Komyshuvakha – photos, video (Ukrainska Pravda, November 4th)
Crowd gathers outside house near Kyiv where mobilized troops and AWOL soldiers were being held. Clashes erupt, shots are fired, and Zelensky’s chief of staff intervenes (Meduza, November 3rd)
Russia bombs humanitarian aid distribution site in Southern Ukraine, killing 31. More than 40 people remain missing (Meduza, November 3rd)
War-related news from Russia
Russian regions have slashed payments to families of soldiers killed in Ukraine by up to 20 times (Ukrainska Pravda, November 6th)
A foreigner is arrested in Moscow on charges of mercenarism. His namesake served in the Armed Forces of Ukraine (Mediazona, November 6th)
At least 350 Russian conscripts have been killed in the war with Ukraine. Here is the list of their names (Mediazona, November 6th)
Russian losses in the war with Ukraine. Mediazona count, updated (Mediazona, November 6th)
Investigation finds Russia's billboards featuring troops fighting in Ukraine include men with criminal convictions and soldiers accused of war crimes (Meduza, November 6th)
Russia’s economy is suffering under the weight of war and sanctions. So why is the ruble still one of the world’s strongest currencies? (Meduza, November 6th)
Comment and analysis
Stephen Kinzer’s Boiling Point: How America Brought War to Ukraine – a critical review (Anti-capitalist Musings, November 6th)
Europe’s sanctions on Russia: Riddled with loopholes (Centre for European Policy Analysis, November 6th)
Could Ukraine have made a deal with Russia in 2022? Former foreign minister Dmytro Kuleba on negotiations (Ukrainska Pravda, November 2nd)
Oil on the water: How Russia avoided accountability for the Black Sea tanker disaster caused by its sanctions evasion efforts (The Insider, November 2nd)
Research of human rights abuses
Russia abducts husband of Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Power Plant employee whom it sentenced to 14.5 years on insane charges (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 5th)
Valentyn Vyhivsky endured torture, years in solitary confinement and is still captive in Russia after his sentence (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 4th)
Ukrainian POW ‘dies’ in Russian prison as Moscow abandons vital convention against torture (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 3rd)
Crimean held incommunicado and beaten for 6 months, then sentenced to 15 years in an afternoon (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, November 2nd)
Statement on the International Day to End Impunity for Crimes against Journalists (Zmina, November 2nd)
International solidarity
Eight French trade union federations speak out in solidarity with Ukraine (USC, November 7th)
Marseille Appeal: Defeat Russian Imperialism, by the Antifascist Platform against Russian Imperialism (Left Renewal, November 4th)
KVPU appeals to the international trade union community over Russia's escalating aggression against Ukraine (KVPU, November 4th)
Also not to be missed
100 years ago Kyiv's young writers sought artistic freedom. Stalin’s purges cut their experiment short. (Kyiv Independent, November 7th)
Trump’s new Ukraine proposal could push Putin to escalate the war (ZN,UA, November 7th)
Trump’s diesel deal with Russia falls apart as tankers change course (ZN,UA, November 5th)
To end war on Ukraine, Washington must revoke its Russian diesel licence and block Novatek’s Alaska gas plans (Razom We Stand, November 5th)
Opinion: Putin’s diesel won't fix Alaska's fuel bill, but it will pay for attacks on Ukraine (Razom We Stand, November 2nd)
Upcoming events
Tuesday10 November, 6.30pm Life Under Russian Occupation: Stories from Ukraine. Meeting with Anhelina Zinovieva (Donetsk), Sofia Naumenko (Mariupol), Daniil Shapovalo (Luhansk). Queen Mary, University of London. Hosted by Ukrainian Society and the Centre for Eurasian, Russian, and East European Studies (CEREES)
Wednesday 11 November 7.00pm. Public meeting: Stand with the people of Ukraine. Meeting with Oleksandr Kyselov (Sotsialnyi Rukh Ukraine). Somers Town Community Hall, 150 Ossulston St, NW1 1EE. Hosted by Anti-Capitalist Resistance
Friday 13 November 6.00pm. Meeting: The US midterms, Ukraine and the fight against fascism. with Tanya Vyhovsky, Vermont State Senator (Progressive / Democratic), and Dylan Burns, journalist, streamer and founder of Track Ukraine. Hosted by Ukraine Solidarity Campaign. Register here
We are also on twitter. Our aim is to circulate information in English that to the best of our knowledge is reliable. If you have something you think we should include, please send it to 2U022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com.
We are now on Facebook and Substack! Please subscribe and tell friends. Better still, people can email us at 2022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com, and we’ll send them the bulletin direct every Monday. The full-scale Russian assault on Ukraine is going into its third year: we’ll keep information and analysis coming, for as long as it takes.The bulletin is also stored on line here.
To receive the bulletin regularly, send your email to:
2022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com.
To stop it, please reply with the word “STOP” in the subject field.
We are also on twitter. Our aim is to circulate information in English that to the best of our knowledge is reliable. If you have something you think we should include, please send it to 2U022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com.
We are now on Facebook and Substack! Please subscribe and tell friends. Better still, people can email us at 2022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com, and we’ll send them the bulletin direct every Monday. The full-scale Russian assault on Ukraine is going into its third year: we’ll keep information and analysis coming, for as long as it takes.
The bulletin is also stored on line here.
To receive the bulletin regularly, send your email to:
2022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com.
To stop it, please reply with the word “STOP” in the subject field.

















