Aide-Memoire Written by Aaron Edwards.

I received a long-winded and rambling email the other day from someone I have crossed paths with on a number of occasions over the years, the documentary film-maker Sean Murray.

Sean was anxious to know whether I knew Clifford Peeples, popularly known to tabloid readers in Northern Ireland as the “pipe bomb pastor“. It seems he’s making another documentary on his muse and wanted to know the nature of my dealings with him.

Like many journalists and academics who have worked on the Northern Ireland conflict, I do indeed know Clifford Peeples.

And he has – like a lot of other people I know back home – ‘a past’.

Peeples’ involvement in loyalist political activism and militancy over several decades is well-known and documented.

Clifford Peeples has featured beneath several front page headlines over the years.
Source: Belfast News Letter, 30 April 1999.

He has always been an unapologetic opponent of the Provisional IRA and the process by which they were brought in from the cold by the British government in the 1990s.

Clifford’s extreme opposition to what he called the “sell out and surrender” of the Good Friday Agreement (1998) led to him being arrested and convicted of possessing two grenades and an pipebomb in suspicious circumstances in late October 1999.

Peeples was sentenced to ten years imprisonment in 2001.

The judge accepted Peeples and his co-accused were transporting the bombs but had no intent to use them.

These days, like a number of rehabilitated ex-political prisoners, Clifford has become an accredited journalist and researcher who has an encyclopaedic knowledge of our troubled past.

He has worked with many other journalists, academics and researchers in Northern Ireland and beyond and shares his contacts and knowledge generously.

That does not mean he is universally popular.

Some journalists dislike him so much they have reportedly engaged in threats and intimidation towards him.

In 2013 Peeples was attacked in Belfast city centre by another journalist.

The veteran Irish Times and Sunday Tribune correspondent Ed Moloney was so incensed by the incident he wrote a piece on his Broken Elbow blog rebuking Clifford’s assailant.

Moloney said he would have no problem entertaining Clifford as a dinner guest, acknowledging, like most of us in the writing profession, that journalism and politics go together ‘like fish and chips’.

I have spent much of my professional life breaking bread or ingesting stronger substances with greater and more mendacious blackguards than he, and while I have never met Mr Peeples, he strikes me from a distance as an honest type – Ed Moloney on Clifford Peeples (2013)

Peeples is also well-known to republicans.

Some see him as a loyalist bogeyman; others, including dissident republicans, regard him as a loyalist hard-liner and, remarkably, have engaged with him.

In August 2020 he was a guest speaker at the Republican Sinn Féin conference at Conway Mill in west Belfast where he joined a panel to talk about Éire Nua.

Clifford Peeples speaking at a Republican Sinn Féin event at Conway Mill in August 2020.
Courtesy of one of the organisers of the event.

According to one of my friends who was involved in the organisation of the conference, Clifford reportedly told the audience how Éire Nua died when the Provos massacred ordinary Protestants during the Troubles.

He reminded them they all shared the same blood and genetic makeup as those they regarded as planters.

It was a bold play considering some in the audience had been in Maghaberry with him in the early 2000s and were painfully reminded of his reputation when they clashed with him in Bann House.

Nevertheless, I’m reliably informed by one of the organisers that all members of the organising committee – bar one – agreed to him speaking and they were genuinely amazed he came along.

Clifford Peeples delivering humanitarian aid to the Ukrainian people in January 2023.

Peeples hit the news headlines in 2023 when it was reported that he went to Ukraine in what he described to journalist Hugh Jordan as a ‘humanitarian aid mission‘.

Peeples was in the news again in 2024 when he was arrested at his home on suspicion of fomenting unrest in the wake of the Southport riots.

Cynically, the arrest took place on the 53rd anniversary of the launch of internment without trial when loyalists and republicans were detained at Her Majesty’s pleasure, some for several years.

On that day in August 2024 it must have seemed to local loyalists like a rerun of that infamous day decades earlier, with some reports saying it took 27 police officers and a dozen land rovers from the PSNI’s Tactical Support Group to take him into custody. He was subsequently released without charge, with the Public Prosecutions Service informing him he had no case to answer.

Peeples told The Times afterwards, he had been questioned for two days “over four social media posts”. He said one related to the Southport attacks “expressed concern for the safety of police officers” and claims that police did not explain how it was incendiary. The one social media post that apparently offended the person who reported him was a YouTube video (now removed) fronted by that well-known purveyor of alternative thinking at the Spectator, Douglas Murray! Intriguingly another post by Peeples expressed his concern for police officers having to deal with the deteriorating situation across the UK.



In July 2025 Peeples’s home was fire-bombed and he was nearly killed. One line of enquiry about the motive was he had angered associates of the Provisional IRA because of his advocacy on behalf of families who had their loved ones murdered by the group during the Troubles.

In true Peeples style he told Hugh Jordan it is this work that has exposed him to danger, not only from those associated with Provo death squads but also ‘elements within loyalism who have become embedded with republicans’.

To say Clifford Peeples is an implacable opponent of the Provisionals and their political wing Sinn Féin is probably an understatement.

I was first introduced to him over a decade ago by my dear friend, the late journalist Lyra McKee. I remember how, at first, I refused to even entertain the notion. It quickly dawned on me how I was once given advice about having to talk to those we do not agree with, so as to get a better understanding of where they were coming from that I agreed.

In a blog post I published last December, I explained how around that time I asked Clifford to assist me with my research into the murder of UVF commander John Bingham on 14 September 1986.

Bingham was killed by a Provisional IRA death squad from Ardoyne.

Clifford had contact with Bingham’s daughter Elizabeth and I helped her to get access to her father’s inquest file.

She then asked him to write a narrative of what happened to her father, subsequently published as The Bingham Report.

It was the first of several reports Clifford would compile on the murder of loyalists that uncovered suspected collusion between the Provos and the British state.

Peeples’ work was – and is – based on a rigorous academic methodology tempered with good old-fashioned investigative journalism. Coincidentally, it even preempted the conclusions reached in the final report of Operation Kenova.

I think it is fair to say Clifford Peeples and I do not share the same politics or views about the peace process. He is on the right of the political spectrum and opposed the Agreement. I am the complete opposite.

Readers of this blog and my work will know that I was an early proponent of the Belfast Agreement and the peace process.

I worked alongside prominent PUP members Billy Mitchell, Billy Hutchinson, Dawn Purvis and David Ervine, among many others, in their attempts to engage the UVF and RHC in dialogue to transform these terror groups beyond violence.

It’s how I cut my teeth in terms of the peace-building work I did in my twenties and, later, when I assisted the PUP in terms of policy development and political education.

I have written unashamedly about my involvement in this work and of my left-leaning politics at the time.

Guilty by Association?

In the course of my peacebuilding and academic work I was introduced to former members of the Official and Provisional IRAs and other republican groups and have maintained good working relations with them over the past 25 years.

Two of my oldest friends were members of the Officials imprisoned in Long Kesh compounds in the 1970s.

The author with Brendan Mackin and Harry Donaghy, former members of the Official IRA,
and others, including respected academic Dr Tony Novosel, in 2008 (c) Aaron Edwards

Among those who I have also interviewed or interacted with in the course of my work are two well-known figures from the (Provisional) Republican Movement, Danny Morrison and Sean ‘Spike’ Murray.

As you can see from the photograph below, taken in 2015, I have occasionally joined them on social occasions.
Winning Friends and Influencing People? The author enjoying a Christmas drink
with a few notable personalities, including Spike Murray in 2015 (c) Aaron Edwards

Spike Murray was convicted on explosives charges in March 1982. His IRA ‘bombing team’ were caught in possession of two beer keg bombs, which was traced back to a massive bomb-making factory containing over two tonnes of explosives. I know from my own historical research that the intelligence agencies were on his trail for several years prior to his arrest.

My sources have confirmed to me over the years that after his release Murray allegedly worked his way up the ranks of the IRA’s Northern Command, serving as Second in Command to Martin McGuinness in the 1990s.

Sean ‘Spike’ Murray was sentenced to 12 years for possession of explosives in the early 1980s.
Source: Belfast Telegraph, 12 March 1982.

Spike later became a key proponent of the Sinn Féin peace strategy and remains a central figure in the Republican Movement to this day.

I remember Spike telling me over a decade ago that the peace process was ‘the only show in town’ when we spoke about community tensions and dynamics.

Although my recollection of our conversation then is a little hazy, he may even have offered to speak to my students to communicate his political views. I’ll leave the reader to judge whether this was said in jest.

What I do know is he was always helpful, for as long as I have known him. The first time I met him was in 2005 when I stepped in for my friend Stephen Bloomer for a few weeks at Interaction Belfast. My job was to act as the lead on a special “research project” for Roisin McGlone and Spike who were attempting to manage issues connected to the Whiterock parade. It was a particularly tense time and the talks collapsed into the worst violence the city had seen in years.

I learned a lot about the failure of conflict mediation when trust is lost.

As a senior academic at the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst for almost twenty years I have continued to build and maintain a wide and diverse range of contacts for my research.

Any casual reader of my work will see I rely on oral testimonies of those involved in paramilitary violence to a considerable extent.

Sometimes that has meant interacting with people who have been involved in some horrendous things.

I know many people reading this will be abhorred that I have no qualms interacting with former gunmen and bombers but sometimes, in order to gain insight into the thoughts and actions of people involved in terrorism and extremism, you have to talk to them.

The author with high-ranking UDA commanders Andy Tyrie and Jackie McDonald
at a conference held in Queen’s University Belfast in 2010 (c) Bobby Hanvey

That doesn’t mean you agree with what they did – or are alleged to have done – it simply means you are unafraid to ‘look them in the whites of their eyes’ to borrow a phrase from my late friend Billy Mitchell, all in the pursuit of the truth.

As I have said on countless occasions in multiple fora, academic researchers do not seek to excuse but explain so that we can get a firmer understanding of radicalisation, extremism and terrorism and take steps to stop it.

The Man Who Knew Too Much

An old friend of mine who was a fairly senior member of the Provisional IRA’s GHQ once jokingly called me “the man who knew too much.” I would qualify this by arguing that I am probably the man who knew too many people!

Readers will be able to see the reality of my ability to access and speak to a wide range of people when they come to read my next book, Enemies Within, a major study of Johnny ‘Mad Dog’ Adair and his infamous C Company paramilitary gang.

It has been said that Adair, who is rarely out of the news headlines, was directly or indirectly responsible for the deaths of dozens of people in the 1980s and 1990s.

Yet, I was able to look at his role from a complete 360 degree perspective.

Deciding I wouldn’t talk to anyone because of who they were or what they were suspected of doing or had done would have meant being unable to answer so many questions for those who lost loved ones at the hands of Adair’s gang.

On the other hand, the book I am currently working on is about the Provisional IRA’s abduction, torture, murder and disappearance of Captain Robert Nairac GC. It has meant accessing a wide range of interviewees, including those from the republican community. They have brought me into their confidence so that I can tell a more rounded story of their experiences of South Armagh in the 1970s.

If a lifetime of interacting with a broad range of people who played a part in our Troubles means I am guilty by association then so be it.

Presumably that also includes Sean’s father?
The author enjoying a pint with an eclectic mix of personalities in 2017, including Sean Murray Jnr and his father, Spike. I’ve a huge array of contacts across the board back home in Belfast.


Why I Write About… Northern Ireland 5 April 2021

It’s Hobson’s Choice Time for Unionism 12 January 2024

Stones Left Unturned: Op Kenova, Collusion and the IRA Assassination of John Bingham 10 December 2025

Aaron Edwards is the author of critically acclaimed books, UVF: Behind the Mask and Agents of Influence: Britain’s Secret Intelligence War Against the IRA. His next book, Enemies Within, on the use of secret agents inside the UDA/UFF, will be published by Merrion Press in 2026.


Guilty By Association?

Ukraine Solidarity Group ✊ A Digest of News from Ukrainian Sources ⚔ 25-May-2026.

In this week’s bulletin

⬤ Kremlin perfect storm.
⬤ The coming bad peace
⬤ More evidence of Russian torture.
⬤ Russia’s use of chemical weapons.
⬤ Repression numbers game.
⬤ The tale of Yermak
⬤ Kremlin trolls on the march.

News from the territories occupied by Russia

Death sentence without witnesses in Russia’s latest conveyor-belt trial of Crimean Tatar political prisoners (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, May 22nd)

Ukrainian sentenced to five years for writing that Russian-occupied territory is part of Ukraine (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, May 21st)

Russia passes life sentence on ‘treason’ charges against Ukrainian accused of acts of resistance (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, May 20th)

Weekly update on the situation in occupied Crimea (Crimea Platform, May 19th)

71-year-old Ukrainian patriot Halyna Dovhopola unbroken after 7 years in Russian captivity, but “won’t survive another such winter” (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, May 19th)

55-year-old Crimean seized at Russian airport and tortured to fabricate treason charges over donations to Ukraine (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, May 18th)

Russia’s fake ‘secret witness’ exposes fabricated charges against five Crimean Tatar political prisoners (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, May 18th)

Suspect in the deportation of children from occupied Kherson region becomes an ombudsperson in Russia (Zmina, May 14th)

News from Ukraine

Mass protests, hundreds of pages of amendments – what comes next? Human rights defenders and media professionals call for revisions to the draft Civil Code (Zmina, May 20th)

The tale of Yermak: How Zelensky’s former right-hand man ended up under arrest on corruption charges (The Insider, May 16th)

“Good customs” vs human rights: ZMINA brought together more than 60 participants to discuss the risks of the new Civil Code (Zmina, May 15th)

War-related news from Russia

“I Don’t Want to Get Used to the War” (Russian Reader, May 23rd)

Russia stages third ‘trial’ of Ukrainian POW, adds 2 years to illegal 18-year sentence for comments about Russian war crimes (Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, May 22nd)

Institute of Philosophy raids target Aristotle translation project (Meduza, 22 May)

Azov Brigade chief medic tortured to death in Russian captivity (Ukrainska Pravda, May 22nd)

Trolls on the March on Kremlin’s Orders (Posle.Media, May 20th)

Inner Emigrants (Russian Reader, May 20th)

Ukrainian ex-prisoners in Russia remain in detention (iStories, 20 May)

The cold shoulder, instead of a “time for heroes”: Russian policy on war veterans (iStories, 19 May)

Political Repression Is a Numbers Game in Russia (Moscow Times, May 18th)

Analysis and comment

The political economy of Ukraine’s war and the politics of a coming bad peace (Europe Solidaire Sans Frontieres, May 21st)

Kyiv says war has reached a pivotal moment (Meduza, 22 May)

The Kremlin’s Perfect Storm (Posle.Media, May 19th)

«Civil Society is the Backbone of Democratic Resilience». Center for Civil Liberties at the OSCE Civil Society Parallel Conference (Centre for Civil Liberties, May 15th)

War in Ukraine: How Has Our Analysis Changed? (September Collective, May 5th)

Research of human rights abuses

Memory that shapes the future: ZMINA joined the “Generation Nika” Award Ceremony in honour of Veronika Kozhushko (Zmina, May 20th)

How Russia Uses Chemical Agents Against Ukrainian Military Personnel (Tribunal for Putin, May 19th)

International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights in Situations of Armed Conflict: human rights defenders made a submission (Zmina, May 18th)

International solidarity

Ukrainian on flotilla now out of Israeli captivity (Facebook, May 20th)

Upcoming events

Tuesday, 26th May, 19.00, Edinburgh. Voices Against Putin's War: An Evening in Solidarity with Ukraine. Lighthouse Bookshop, 43-45 West Nicolson Street, EH8 9DB. More information here.

Wednesday 27 May, 19.00, Glasgow. Voices Against Putin's War at Mount Florida Books, Glasgow. With Simon Pirani & Fellow Readers More details here.

🔴This bulletin is put together by labour movement activists in solidarity with Ukrainian resistance. More information at Ukraine Information Group.

We are also on twitter. Our aim is to circulate information in English that to the best of our knowledge is reliable. If you have something you think we should include, please send it to 2U022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com.


We are now on Facebook and Substack! Please subscribe and tell friends. Better still, people can email us at 2022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com, and we’ll send them the bulletin direct every Monday. The full-scale Russian assault on Ukraine is going into its third year: we’ll keep information and analysis coming, for as long as it takes.

The bulletin is also stored on line here.

To receive the bulletin regularly, send your email to:
2022ukrainesolidarity@gmail.com.
To stop it, please reply with the word “STOP” in the subject field.

News From Ukraine 💣 Bulletin 197

Dixie Elliot ✊Ah. but you do David Cullinane.


You need your leadership to define your politics otherwise you'd be out of Sinn Féin on your ear.

For example, Mary Lou McDonald has said on a number of occasions that she was willing to form a coalition government with either FF or FG, while at the same time she was also saying that they need to end the dominance of both parties in Southern politics.

The reason being is that Sinn Féin just wants to get into government and they are willing to jump into bed with any party to get there.

As for Mary Lou, she just wants to become the first female Taoiseach.

That's all that matters to them, and party members like David Cullinane aren't capable of changing a light bulb without asking the leadership if they can change it, then waiting for them to say go ahead and change the light bulb.

Then they'll sit in the dark wondering where the money is coming from to change the light bulb . . .

Thomas Dixie Elliot is a Derry artist and a former H Block Blanketman.
Follow Dixie Elliot on Twitter @IsMise_Dixie

Daft Davy

Friendly Atheist36 GOP lawmakers cited everything from the Bible to Socialism to oppose a bill preventing minors from getting married.

The good news is that Oklahoma recently became the 17th state (along with Washington, D.C.) to ban child marriage.

The bad news? It wasn’t unanimous. In fact, 36 Republicans in the State House voted against the legislation, reminding everyone that they’re perfectly fine with adults forcing themselves upon children who aren’t legally old enough to make decisions for themselves.

Their excuses were downright embarrassing.

Senate Bill 504 shouldn’t have been controversial. All it did was remove the underage exceptions to the law about how marriage can only occur between legal adults. From now on, it won’t matter if your parents (or other authorities) agree to it or if you’re pregnant. No marriage until you’re 18. Simple. That’s a big deal because children are sometimes pressured by their parents to marry early or they feel forced into marriage because of teenage pregnancy. Plenty of adults enter into marriages that don’t pan out, but it’s perfectly rational to say a decision that important should only be made by adults.

“How Old Was Mary?” 🪶 How Dozens Of Oklahoma Republicans Fought A Bill Banning Child Marriage

Right Wing Watch 👀 Written by Kyle Mantyla.

Last week far-right Christian nationalist pastor and Indiana Lt. Gov. Micah Beckwith appeared on the "FlashPoint" program where he admitted that he is doing his best to give the residents of his state "permission to hate" the religion of Islam.

After fellow Christian nationalist pastor Brian Gibson declared that Islam is "incompatible with a constitutional republic that is built on the word of God" and must be banned, Beckwith readily agreed, saying that the right-wing effort to ban sharia law is vital to saving this nation by "giving people permission to hate again."

"I know that sounds a little harsh at first," Beckwith said:

We've seen this movement to eradicate hate in our culture; that is the worst thing we could do. The Bible talks about how God hates certain things and when we say we want to eradicate hate—think about this—we're actually saying we want to eradicate a characteristic of God. Hate is not the opposite of love; indifference is the opposite of love. So when I talk about this, I say, 'Guys, we need to, in Indiana, we need to hate.' 

Continue @ RWW.

'Permission To Hate' Islam

Lynx By Ten To The Power Of One Thousand Nine Hundred And Eighty Eight

 

Pastords @ 46

 

A Morning Thought @ 3162

Christopher Owens 🎵 with the 63rd in his Predominance series.

“It's a semi-automatic, get in the car/Corrosive heart and frozen heat/We're worlds apart where we could meet/Where the street fold round and the motors start/And the idiot wields the power.” - The Sisters of Mercy

Horns up 

New Horizons


Dwarves – Jenkem

17 albums in from Blag Dahlia’s madmen and they’re still as ferocious as ever. This new album sees them dial back the aggressive pop punk and go back to a more hardcore punk sound. As per usual, most songs are under 90 seconds and will make you want to start a fight on public transport but with a smile on your face. Progress, not perfection.

The album can be purchased here.

Darryl Jenifer – The Weather Channel

Now this came out of the blue: Bad Brains bassist returns to his jazz roots for his second solo album. And what a delight it is to report how great it is. Reinterpreting two Bad Brains classics in this style is a genius move to grab the interest of longtime fans, but the later fusions of dub reggae and metal make this album of the month.

The album can be streamed and purchased here.

BIG|BRAVE - in grief or in hope

Like their contemporaries (and past collaborators) The Body, Big|Brave continue exploring terrain others won’t touch. This release sits somewhere between drone, dark electronic music, doom metal and post rock. It’s a haunting listen that conjures up so much potent imagery in the mind of the listener but what else would you expect from Big|Brave?

The album can be streamed and purchased here.

Earth Motherfucker/Pound Land – Split LP

Reclusive noise punks Earth Mother Fucker have teamed up with prolific noise punks Pound Land to produce an album that is filthier than a junkie’s arsecrack. Melding each band’s interpretation of garage, dub, noise and free jazz, the album is utterly exhilarating as well as being caked in dirt. The perfect record for modern Britain.

The album can be streamed and purchased here.

Golden Oldies


Excel – The Joke’s on You

Although they’ll forever be known as the band Metallica “borrowed heavily from” to create ‘Enter Sandman’, it’s unfair to relegate Excel to this footnote in music history as this LP (containing the aforementioned number) is just as potent and ferocious as anything recorded by their Venice contemporaries Suicidal Tendencies.



The Varukers – Still Bollox But Still Here

Fresh off a reunion tour supporting death metal legends Bolt Thrower, Rat and co. went back into the studio to rerecord some of their eighties oeuvre and what emerged was an astonishingly ferocious record of d-beat punk rock updated for the 1990’s. While the cover isn’t their finest moment, the rest of the LP is. They never topped this release.



Smashing Pumpkins – Gish

Although overshadowed these days by other releases in their discography as well as Billy Corgan’s propensity for cringy behaviour and statements, there is no denying that their debut LP is a gorgeous, dreamlike mix of shoegaze, psychedelia and classic rock. With a fat sounding production from Butch Vig, this album is a joy to dive into.


⏩ Christopher Owens was a reviewer for Metal Ireland and finds time to study the history and inherent contradictions of Ireland. He is currently the TPQ Friday columnist and is the author of A Vortex of Securocrats and “dethrone god”.

Predominance 63

Geordie Morrow 🖌 with a painting from his collection of art work. 

Oil on canvas

🖌 Geordie Morrow is a Belfast artist 🖌

They Think It’s All Over 🖌 Shankill, 1980

The Fenian Way 🔖 One can hardly turn on or tune in to a news or current affairs programme and not fail to hear the mention of the term TUSLA, the State’s Child and Family Agency, and its ongoing travails as public scrutiny of its operation peels back layers of failures across a broad spectrum of its powerful remit.


A quick google on the word itself unearthed; From debate and conjecture, the name Tusla emerged as a fitting logo for the Child and Family Agency. While the word borrows from the Irish words 'tús' + 'lá', Tusla is a completely new word reflecting a shared desire for a new beginning, forging a new identity. A new word, a new way of working.

The same search also leads you to Trustpilot, the highly regarded review site, wherein the vast majority of its contributors (circa 70) are scathing in the extreme. In cold print the acrimony expressed by individuals on their dealings with TUSLA makes for sober reading, but given the nature of the subject matter, State intervention which can remove children from families, a more studied appraisal of the totality of such an issue is warranted.

There are no perfect families, no Waltons or Simpsons as yardsticks to gauge any semblance of functionality. By and large the average family is a work in progress, trudging along with a sense of solidarity within communities who exist along similar lines.

The Irish Constitution recognises families as follows:

The Family Article 41

1° The State recognises the Family as the natural primary and fundamental unit group of Society, and as a moral institution possessing inalienable and imprescriptible rights, antecedent and superior to all positive law.

2° The State, therefore, guarantees to protect the Family in its constitution and authority, as the necessary basis of social order and as indispensable to the welfare of the Nation and the State.

Education Article 42

1 The State acknowledges that the primary and natural educator of the child is the Family and guarantees to respect the inalienable right and duty of parents to provide, according to their means, for the religious and moral, intellectual, physical and social education of their children.

Given this onerous recognition it should stand to reason that any state body charged with powers to intervene in the functionality of families, with powers to remove children if deemed necessary, must itself be subject to rigorous and transparent scrutiny as it goes about its remit. This book shines a light on that basic necessity, and without straining a metaphor, it reflects very dark shadows indeed.

There are families where grave abuses and violent dysfunctions permeate daily life and children exist with physical and psychological harm and whose only recourse is to outside intervention as an immediate and first step to protect them. Such action requires process, which must be evidenced based and open to transparent scrutiny. What is not required is a presumption of guilt founded on some anachronistic view of women and mothers.

The book is a series of interviews with mothers from various regional, ethnic and economic backgrounds who share their experiences with TULSA and the removal of children from them. Each chapter ends with a link and QR code to a podcast discussion on the issues raised which contribute informatively on their cumulative experiences.

The common threads throughout the interviews are defined by the word patterns. The authors carefully construct a narrative based around these unmistakable patterns that is quite damning of almost every strata of the TULSA process. The inherent bias demonstrated towards these mothers is all the more frightening because it appears inherent in other State bodies, Gardai, the Courts and legal system when it comes to dealing with these cases.

And, what is reminiscent of the Catholic Church’s reaction to their sexual abuse scandals, TUSLA’s apparent primary concern was its own self-preservation and deflection from culpability of the many grievous errors its actions permitted.

The book competently outlines the legacy effects which TULSA’s actions have had on families even when error is eventually conceded and children are returned. Both the nature and the longevity of the separation inflicts indelible damage on family relationships. In a lot of cases male partners can become very vindictive, exploiting to the fullest the unwarranted bias against the mothers wherein children themselves are used as pawns resulting in inevitable psychological harm.

Another damning obstacle is the legal system, a bleak house indeed for affected mothers. TULSA and other relevant agencies have solicitors and barristers appointed to them by the state; for mothers seeking urgent redress this invariably proves cost prohibitive. The book cites the opinion of Justice Frank Clarke who recognised ‘the very real problems with access to justice in Ireland’. But like most public institutions in Ireland, reform comes dropping slowly even when it concerns the reality that whether a mother retains custody of their child comes with an actual price tag.

As an addendum to the failings of the legal system is a truly bizarre and frightening insight into the use of ‘psychologists’ in such cases; findings of ‘unfit mothers’ made by individuals unfit to reach such damning conclusions in the first place. Citing a Prime Time undercover investigation one of their reporters obtained an online doctorate from America for the ‘price of a take away’. Armed with a dubious certificate and a brass plaque such individuals are free to offer ‘professional’ opinions on sometimes complex family situations. An unhealthy weight is afforded to these psychological reports in family cases which is astounding when one considers the book's expose of the absence of any regulation for psychologists in Ireland.

The in-camera rule is one of the most powerful forces shaping the lives of mothers who find themselves trapped in the family law system. It determines what can be said, who can speak, what can be challenged, what can be exposed and what must remain hidden from the public.

This opening paragraph of one of the concluding chapters, for me, cuts to the chase; this is Catholic Ireland and its legacy. The complete absence of accountability and transparency being a natural recipe for corruption and abuse.

But worse than the abuses committed are the denials and deflections that any such abuses and dangerous shortcomings actually occurred. It is a vicious self-preserving circle that bequeaths a mindset institutionalised and furtive thinking. It has infested various institutions including the courts, the gardai, state institutions like TULSA and aspects of the medical profession charged with responsibilities in this area of family law. 

For this reviewer the core value of the book is demonstrating the immense chasm between the laudable constitutional recognitions and protections alluded to earlier and those institutions and bodies charged with their implementation and defence. The book’s strength are the testimonies of individual mothers who were so egregiously victimised by a State obliged to protect them. A highly recommended read!

Dr Finbar Markey & Anna Kavanagh MA, 2026. Justice For Birth Mothers: The Fight Against Forced Separation In Modern Ireland. Butterfly Books Publishers Ireland. ISBN-13: ‎978-9699896217

The Fenian Way was a full time activist during the IRA's war against the British.

Justice For Birth Mothers 📚 The Fight Against Forced Separation In Modern Ireland

Lynx By Ten To The Power Of One Thousand Nine Hundred And Eighty Seven