I never had any official interaction with Na Fianna Éireann. I was well acquainted with former members, and one former Na Fianna leader; some of those members elevated to senior positions within the IRA and pursued exemplary operational records, the vast majority of which reside in the anonymity of true Fenianism.
The opening chapter in James Durney’s book leaves no doubt as to the importance of the role and contribution Na Fianna has played in the republican struggle. Its members have paid the ultimate sacrifice throughout that conflict from 1916 through to the hunger strikes of 1981.
From its founding in 1906 its potential to the revolutionary movement was quickly realised as Séan MacDiarmada sought to bring it under the control of the IRB, a critical contingent of which was plotting the ground for the 1916 Rising.
Another central premise of its founding gave it a depth of character beyond a mere transition hub from youthful training to adult militarism. Irish cultural identity was pivotal in republican thinking at the time.
As Home Rule was sending the youth of Ireland to the Somme to make itself ‘acceptable’ to an English establishment an Irish counterpoint was deemed essential in promoting a separate and sovereign identity.
The Irish language was seen as the ultimate manifestation of that Irish identity which made its learning a crucial part in the role of Na Fianna. It wasn’t simply a case of ‘Brits Out’ but the realisation and establishment of a culturally aware Republic. Small wonder it found a welcome home in Padraig Pearse’s St Endas.
With an impressive array of significant republican figures at its helm, Liam Mellows, Con Colbert, Bulmer Hobson, Constance Markievicz, Na Fianna quickly developed a national foothold and its impact on the ground was beginning to be felt.
One of its members, Patsy O’Connor, died at the hands of the RIC as it baton charged striking workers during the 1913 Lockout; Na Fianna members playing a supporting role in that bitter industrial dispute.
But perhaps the most indelible memory for most is the photograph of Na Fianna members on Howth Harbour with outstretched arms reaching for smuggled armaments aboard the Asgard; their military credentials confirmed.
But beyond the photographs and historical footnotes there are personalised accounts from those who explained their reasons for joining Na Fianna and outlining their roles in its activities which gives an essential perspective to the times and decades through which Na Fianna Éireann evolved and developed.
The period between 1916 and The War of Independence is competently covered and well researched. And what’s more insightful for the reader is the continuing use of personal narratives to convey a sense of clarity to an oft-times chaotic environment, the product of dissent, countermanding orders and personal loyalties.
But without question that tumultuous week in 1916 would read very different were it not for the involvement of Na Fianna Éireann. The book’s detailed description of their activities, and death and injuries incurred, translates that sentiment into fact.
As with the broader republican struggle it was not the rebellion that sparked growth in its aftermath but rather the British response to it. The executions of the Rising’s leaders proved a powerful fillip for still active commanders to recruit and renew in various regions throughout the country.
As ever in republican circles funerals, commemorations and agitation on prisoners issues became the stock in trade of daily activity and national focus. But there is something missing from the transition from Easter Week to the War of Independence and that is Na Fianna Éireann’s role, if any, in the 1918 General Election.
It was that election result which both democratised and gave full manifestation to the institutions of the proclaimed Republic. But it was also central to the whole question of loyalty, a benchmark of fidelity, which would be challenged when it came to the subsequent negotiations. A salient question to be asked and answered would have been where Na Fianna’s loyalties lay at the time as it applied to Dáil Eireann!
Perhaps an explanation for this apolitical interpretation of Na Fianna stems from a general attitude that IRA members had towards them. Whilst Na Fianna members were highly active in military activity both in the sectarian violence by loyalists in Belfast and from the Black & Tans in Cork and Kerry the author unearths an element of developing tension between, ostensibly, the senior and junior wings of republican armed forces.
The clear reticence of IRA commanders and volunteers to give orders to ‘youngsters’ to engage in direct military confrontation was fairly widespread even leading to a directive that all armaments held by Na Fianna should be given to local IRA Quartermasters. Did this lack of confidence in Na Fianna’s military abilities due to their youth also extend to their abilities to offer political commentary and insights that were worth listening to?
At this juncture in the text the author introduces their own take on developments concerning the Anglo – Irish Treaty which he describes as ‘the best possible compromise at the time.’ Is this the lens of reasoning through which the rest of the text was written?
For Na Fianna both the truce and the Treaty seem to have been addressed from a local perspective, or loyalty to the local IRA Command to which they were seconded. Although their Árd Fheis reiterated allegiance to ‘the Republic’ a neutral stance on emerging divisions and hostilities was adopted.
This however did not insulate them from the escalating violence particularly in Belfast where both the RUC and the Ulster Special Constabulary engaged in widespread attacks on Catholic Communities. The author duly notes that between 1916 and 1923 it was the Civil War period which claimed the higher death toll for Na Fianna members.
But also of note was the high rate of accidental deaths amongst its members from the inexperience use and handling of weapons. In a well sourced note a British officer makes this very same claim as just cause to disarm the organisation.
Nor did Na Fianna escape the bitterness of the Civil War. The text outlines several high profile killings, murders and executions with Na Fianna personnel involved on both sides. The ultimate toll of these internecine actions was the high rate of its members simply calling it a day.
One discernible pattern emerges in that the level of activity of the IRA determines subsequently the level of activity of Na Fianna. This may seem a trite and obvious point to make for although the purpose of the organisation is well established the fact that it has no collective voice of its own is overlooked.
Certainly individual members had their own personal motivations and political viewpoints which are expressed on various events like the Spanish Civil War and the Official/Provisional split, the rejection of Marxism in the latter on patriotic grounds demonstrating a dread of detachment from its proverbial umbilical cord. Prophetically this rejection of ‘new thinking’ in favour of orthodoxy would manifest itself in a future split in its parental organisations.
Fian Gerard McAuley became the first fatal republican casualty when he was shot dead by British soldiers in August 1969. He would not be the last of Na Fianna Éireann to make the ultimate sacrifice, nor indeed the last to sacrifice a future via youthful imprisonment.
As the early years of the 1970’s slowly evaporated from republican claims of being the years of victory the dark realism of attrition and an altered definition of that victory began to prevail.
The activities of Na Fianna in that phase of the struggle are well documented, as they should be, because the final word of history has yet to be written as to how that chapter in the republican struggle came to a close. And although the book terminates at 1986 it is becoming ever clearer that the machinations and infiltrations which led to the Good Friday Agreement were already well established, even in the midst of the 1981 Hunger Strikes.
Alluding to my earlier observation regarding the authors description of the Anglo-Irish Treaty as ‘the best possible compromise at the time’ that niggling suspicion, to my mind, bore fruit with the closing declaration of the book.
Quoting Pearse the author reaches a conclusion which I profoundly disagree with. And it reinforces my contention that having a voice is critical to having a purpose because all silence has to offer are the echoes of a history we profoundly disagree with. And that is the true definition of a war of attrition.
James Durney, 2026, Boyhood's Fire: Na Fianna Éireann at War 1916–1986.


























