Jim Duffy ✍ The Taoiseach is spot on in his lashing of Sinn Féin over their endless lies on neutrality in EEC/EC/EU referendums.
 
Years ago I went through every single Sinn Féin newspaper advert for every single referendum on Europe, from 1972 on. In Every one bar the Fiscal Treaty (and even they knew the arguments in that referendum would have made them look ridiculous) they argued the exact same things:
 
1. This will end neutrality.
2. This will bring Ireland into NATO.
3. This will see Ireland join a European Army.
4. If voters vote yes, they will be giving away their right to hold any more referendums on the EEC/EC/EU.
 
In the fifty-four years since that first referendum
 
1. Ireland remains neutral.
2. Ireland is not a member of NATO.
3. Ireland has not joined a European Army, nor does any such thing as a European Army exist.
4. Ireland continues to hold referendums on EU matters. The rules are exactly the same. If a treaty does not change EU competences no amendment to the constitution is needed as those competences have already been included in the constitution, so there is no need for a referendum.
 
If a treaty adds new competences, then a constitutional amendment is automatically required, meaning a referendum in that case is always required, and always will be required.
 
Sinn Féin is now lying by saying that ending the Triple Lock will end neutrality. That is patently absurd. Ireland declared neutrality in September 1939. The Triple Lock first appeared in the Defence Act 1960. For Sinn Fein to be correct, that would mean Ireland wasn't neutral between 1939 and 1960 when there was no triple lock. It couldn't even have existed between 1939 and 1945 as there was no UN Security Council or even a UN.
 
That is nonsensical.
 
All the government is doing is reverting to the status quo ante between 1939 and 1960, with one difference. It is increasing the number of personnel that could be on duty abroad to fifty. That is necessary as no naval vessel could carry out functions abroad under the lower threshold, as the minimum crew needed for a ship would exceed the number laid down in the 1960 Act. It would be unsafe to have a ship with such a tiny crew. The new number simply ensures ships can be safely crewed by having the minimum crew needed.
 
Every single claim made by Sinn Féin is untrue, just as every single claim made by Sinn Féin in European referendums is a lie. They would for example, brazenly trot out the lie every time that if people voted for a referendum they would be surrendering their right to ever vote again, despite the very fact that a referendum was taking place demonstrated that their claim the previous time was 100% untrue.

It is worth pointing out that no other country on the planet, including no other neutral, has a triple lock. Austria and Switzerland have both called the Triple Lock "nuts!" One Austrian politician questioned how a country that gives a veto over the use of its military to the US, Russia, France, the UK and China could even call itself independent. He said it displayed the "mindset of a colony, asking for permission."
 
The British and French vetoes are effectively dead as both stopped using theirs in December 1989. France has no intension of ever using it again as a matter of policy. It wants all vetoes abolished.
 
It is particularly absurd that in 2026 Trump, Putin and Xi have a veto over the use of Irish troops.

Ireland had to pull out of a rescue mission in the Mediterranean when Putin, as part of of his campaign against the UN, vetoed rolling over a resolution. Ireland had to withdraw. Other countries, including neutrals, continued on the mission.
 
In every other country on the planet, exclusive control of the use of the military is controlled by parliaments. Article 15.6.1. of Bunreacht na hÉireann also states that "The right to raise and maintain military or armed forces is vested exclusively in the Oireachtas." Article 28.3.1. also states that "War shall not be declared and the State shall not participate in any war save with the assent of Dáil Éireann."
 
Many constitutional lawyers have long questioned whether the Triple Lock is even constitutional, given that it allows the five veto powers to overrule a decision of the Oireachtas.
 
The sheer absurdity of the Triple Lock can be seen in the fact even if every single Irish citizen, every single member of the Government, and every member of the Oireachtas supported a mission, Donald Trump could override them and veto it. That is an absurdity.

⏩ Jim Duffy is a writer-historian.

Triple Lock 🪶 Sinn Fein Lying

Jim Duffy ✍ The Taoiseach is spot on in his lashing of Sinn Féin over their endless lies on neutrality in EEC/EC/EU referendums.
 
Years ago I went through every single Sinn Féin newspaper advert for every single referendum on Europe, from 1972 on. In Every one bar the Fiscal Treaty (and even they knew the arguments in that referendum would have made them look ridiculous) they argued the exact same things:
 
1. This will end neutrality.
2. This will bring Ireland into NATO.
3. This will see Ireland join a European Army.
4. If voters vote yes, they will be giving away their right to hold any more referendums on the EEC/EC/EU.
 
In the fifty-four years since that first referendum
 
1. Ireland remains neutral.
2. Ireland is not a member of NATO.
3. Ireland has not joined a European Army, nor does any such thing as a European Army exist.
4. Ireland continues to hold referendums on EU matters. The rules are exactly the same. If a treaty does not change EU competences no amendment to the constitution is needed as those competences have already been included in the constitution, so there is no need for a referendum.
 
If a treaty adds new competences, then a constitutional amendment is automatically required, meaning a referendum in that case is always required, and always will be required.
 
Sinn Féin is now lying by saying that ending the Triple Lock will end neutrality. That is patently absurd. Ireland declared neutrality in September 1939. The Triple Lock first appeared in the Defence Act 1960. For Sinn Fein to be correct, that would mean Ireland wasn't neutral between 1939 and 1960 when there was no triple lock. It couldn't even have existed between 1939 and 1945 as there was no UN Security Council or even a UN.
 
That is nonsensical.
 
All the government is doing is reverting to the status quo ante between 1939 and 1960, with one difference. It is increasing the number of personnel that could be on duty abroad to fifty. That is necessary as no naval vessel could carry out functions abroad under the lower threshold, as the minimum crew needed for a ship would exceed the number laid down in the 1960 Act. It would be unsafe to have a ship with such a tiny crew. The new number simply ensures ships can be safely crewed by having the minimum crew needed.
 
Every single claim made by Sinn Féin is untrue, just as every single claim made by Sinn Féin in European referendums is a lie. They would for example, brazenly trot out the lie every time that if people voted for a referendum they would be surrendering their right to ever vote again, despite the very fact that a referendum was taking place demonstrated that their claim the previous time was 100% untrue.

It is worth pointing out that no other country on the planet, including no other neutral, has a triple lock. Austria and Switzerland have both called the Triple Lock "nuts!" One Austrian politician questioned how a country that gives a veto over the use of its military to the US, Russia, France, the UK and China could even call itself independent. He said it displayed the "mindset of a colony, asking for permission."
 
The British and French vetoes are effectively dead as both stopped using theirs in December 1989. France has no intension of ever using it again as a matter of policy. It wants all vetoes abolished.
 
It is particularly absurd that in 2026 Trump, Putin and Xi have a veto over the use of Irish troops.

Ireland had to pull out of a rescue mission in the Mediterranean when Putin, as part of of his campaign against the UN, vetoed rolling over a resolution. Ireland had to withdraw. Other countries, including neutrals, continued on the mission.
 
In every other country on the planet, exclusive control of the use of the military is controlled by parliaments. Article 15.6.1. of Bunreacht na hÉireann also states that "The right to raise and maintain military or armed forces is vested exclusively in the Oireachtas." Article 28.3.1. also states that "War shall not be declared and the State shall not participate in any war save with the assent of Dáil Éireann."
 
Many constitutional lawyers have long questioned whether the Triple Lock is even constitutional, given that it allows the five veto powers to overrule a decision of the Oireachtas.
 
The sheer absurdity of the Triple Lock can be seen in the fact even if every single Irish citizen, every single member of the Government, and every member of the Oireachtas supported a mission, Donald Trump could override them and veto it. That is an absurdity.

⏩ Jim Duffy is a writer-historian.

No comments