Anthony McIntyre ๐Ÿ”– In the year that has marked the fiftieth anniversary of the onset of Argentina's Dirty War, waged by the South American country's armed forces, the dark art has again seen its dirty head rise above the parapet.


This is the outworking of a sanitising project by the conservative right, seeking to establish the perspective of the powerful and to discredit a settled and verified narrative holding the country's armed forces to account. 

March-24 is to seventy per cent of Argentina's population what 9/11 is to the United States or Chile. Masses take to the streets to invoke memoria, verdad y justicia. The current president Javier Milei has since his incumbency been seeking to subvert this memory, truth and justice narrative, disparaging the accounts of victims, minimising the number of disappeared and equating state violence with that of Peronist guerrillas and left wing allies who fought the dictatorship. The Milei administration alleges “a biased and vengeful version of history,” his Vice President, Victoria Villarruel - a niece of one of the junta colonels - dismissing as myth the official death and disappeared toll.

Jacobo Timerman was one of the disappeared who experienced a truth that Milei seeks to downplay if not disappear. Once described as "the most famous Argentine political prisoner" of the country's so-called "Dirty War," he emerged from the darkness of the torture chambers, and his account is worth reading even 45 years after its publication, particularly as a foil against Milea's regime of truth.

In the first few pages Timerman resonates deeply with those who journeyed through the squalid bowels of the H Blocks:

The floor of the cell is permanently wet. Somewhere there is a leak. The mattress is also wet. I have a blanket, and to prevent that from getting wet, I keep it on my shoulders constantly.

Jacobo Timerman was kidnapped by Argentinian security forces in April 1977, thirteen months into the reign of the military junta. At the time he was editor of La Opiniรณn and set his mind against the fascism running rampant throughout the land. For many, that carried a death sentence. No one was safe, not even members of the country's mostly conservative clergy. Bishop Enrique Angelelli, one of the few dissenting clerical voices challenging the military died when his car mysteriously crashed. Two military officers were in 2014 found culpable for his death. 

Prior to being hauled off to meet Susan, the name given to the picana - an electric prod used to torture prisoners - Timerman had received death threats from a right wing death squad irked at his call for the right to trial for anyone arrested - rather than being disappeared. The Popular Revolutionary Army of the Left also promised to kill him for accusing them of being fascists and a lunatic left.

Each day of the thirteen months La Opiniรณn managed to function under military rule relatives of those missing would turn up at the paper's offices seeking help to locate their loved ones. It was something also experienced by Bob Cox at the Buenos Aires Herald: the desperate seeking the disappeared. 

Timerman felt he had been kidnapped by an extremist faction within the military, one that 'was also the heart of Nazi operations in Argentina.' Videla, he felt, wanted him spared. He refers to the Nazi regalia and portraits he managed to glimpse during his incarceration when his blindfold was removed. Yet elsewhere in the book he seems to shift position. The Nazi element was no longer the fringe:

The military government that took power in Argentina in March 1976 arrived with an all embracing arsenal of Nazi ideology as part of its structure. 

For Timerman a Zionist Jew, to be in the custody of such monsters, must have been hell on earth. Jewish girls, he claims, were violated twice as often as non Jewish ones. The type of violation he speaks of is described in unspeakable detail by Andrew Graham-Yooll in his own account of the period. While undergoing torture by Susan, Timerman recounts his interrogators screaming Jew, Jew, Jew at him. 

The book is not just an account of his time in a torture centre but also offers many observations on the politics of Argentina. However, because of his misplaced belief that Jorge Videla was some sort of moderate, the narrative is arguably much more reliable when it addresses the matter of detention and torture. 

Now that much more information has come to light about the junta, it seems impossible to describe Videla as a figure who wanted to transform Argentina peacefully but was up against hardliners. That was a US spun myth which allowed Kissinger and company to cosy up to the regime. Videla was a uniformed thug, who had trained at the School of the Americas. He believed he was on a Christian mission to eradicate communism and those who espoused it - just about everybody from trade union leaders, nuns, priests, doctors, academics, journalists, school children protesting for lower bus fares and of course guerrillas.

Timerman survived whereas an estimated thirty thousand others did not. For that he can thank Jimmy Carter who as US President put the junta under considerable pressure, something the previous administration of Ford and Kissinger were averse to. 

A read that is not relaxing.

Jacobo Timerman, 2022. Prisoner Without a Name, Cell Without a Number.
Published by University of Wisconsin Press
ISBN-10: ‎0299182444
ISBN-13: 978-0299182441

⏩Follow on Bluesky

Prisoner Without A Name ๐Ÿ“š Cell Without A Number

Anthony McIntyre ๐Ÿ”– In the year that has marked the fiftieth anniversary of the onset of Argentina's Dirty War, waged by the South American country's armed forces, the dark art has again seen its dirty head rise above the parapet.


This is the outworking of a sanitising project by the conservative right, seeking to establish the perspective of the powerful and to discredit a settled and verified narrative holding the country's armed forces to account. 

March-24 is to seventy per cent of Argentina's population what 9/11 is to the United States or Chile. Masses take to the streets to invoke memoria, verdad y justicia. The current president Javier Milei has since his incumbency been seeking to subvert this memory, truth and justice narrative, disparaging the accounts of victims, minimising the number of disappeared and equating state violence with that of Peronist guerrillas and left wing allies who fought the dictatorship. The Milei administration alleges “a biased and vengeful version of history,” his Vice President, Victoria Villarruel - a niece of one of the junta colonels - dismissing as myth the official death and disappeared toll.

Jacobo Timerman was one of the disappeared who experienced a truth that Milei seeks to downplay if not disappear. Once described as "the most famous Argentine political prisoner" of the country's so-called "Dirty War," he emerged from the darkness of the torture chambers, and his account is worth reading even 45 years after its publication, particularly as a foil against Milea's regime of truth.

In the first few pages Timerman resonates deeply with those who journeyed through the squalid bowels of the H Blocks:

The floor of the cell is permanently wet. Somewhere there is a leak. The mattress is also wet. I have a blanket, and to prevent that from getting wet, I keep it on my shoulders constantly.

Jacobo Timerman was kidnapped by Argentinian security forces in April 1977, thirteen months into the reign of the military junta. At the time he was editor of La Opiniรณn and set his mind against the fascism running rampant throughout the land. For many, that carried a death sentence. No one was safe, not even members of the country's mostly conservative clergy. Bishop Enrique Angelelli, one of the few dissenting clerical voices challenging the military died when his car mysteriously crashed. Two military officers were in 2014 found culpable for his death. 

Prior to being hauled off to meet Susan, the name given to the picana - an electric prod used to torture prisoners - Timerman had received death threats from a right wing death squad irked at his call for the right to trial for anyone arrested - rather than being disappeared. The Popular Revolutionary Army of the Left also promised to kill him for accusing them of being fascists and a lunatic left.

Each day of the thirteen months La Opiniรณn managed to function under military rule relatives of those missing would turn up at the paper's offices seeking help to locate their loved ones. It was something also experienced by Bob Cox at the Buenos Aires Herald: the desperate seeking the disappeared. 

Timerman felt he had been kidnapped by an extremist faction within the military, one that 'was also the heart of Nazi operations in Argentina.' Videla, he felt, wanted him spared. He refers to the Nazi regalia and portraits he managed to glimpse during his incarceration when his blindfold was removed. Yet elsewhere in the book he seems to shift position. The Nazi element was no longer the fringe:

The military government that took power in Argentina in March 1976 arrived with an all embracing arsenal of Nazi ideology as part of its structure. 

For Timerman a Zionist Jew, to be in the custody of such monsters, must have been hell on earth. Jewish girls, he claims, were violated twice as often as non Jewish ones. The type of violation he speaks of is described in unspeakable detail by Andrew Graham-Yooll in his own account of the period. While undergoing torture by Susan, Timerman recounts his interrogators screaming Jew, Jew, Jew at him. 

The book is not just an account of his time in a torture centre but also offers many observations on the politics of Argentina. However, because of his misplaced belief that Jorge Videla was some sort of moderate, the narrative is arguably much more reliable when it addresses the matter of detention and torture. 

Now that much more information has come to light about the junta, it seems impossible to describe Videla as a figure who wanted to transform Argentina peacefully but was up against hardliners. That was a US spun myth which allowed Kissinger and company to cosy up to the regime. Videla was a uniformed thug, who had trained at the School of the Americas. He believed he was on a Christian mission to eradicate communism and those who espoused it - just about everybody from trade union leaders, nuns, priests, doctors, academics, journalists, school children protesting for lower bus fares and of course guerrillas.

Timerman survived whereas an estimated thirty thousand others did not. For that he can thank Jimmy Carter who as US President put the junta under considerable pressure, something the previous administration of Ford and Kissinger were averse to. 

A read that is not relaxing.

Jacobo Timerman, 2022. Prisoner Without a Name, Cell Without a Number.
Published by University of Wisconsin Press
ISBN-10: ‎0299182444
ISBN-13: 978-0299182441

⏩Follow on Bluesky

No comments