Barry Gilheany ✍The Lessons And Legacy Of The Russell Brand Case (And Maybe Others)

Whatever women wear, wherever they go, indeed whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and to demand justice from the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Russell Brand, act without their consent.

 Those words delivered by Judge Bennathan during the sentencing of this disgraced comic, actor and You Tube presenter have laid down the legal and cultural parameters for any future judgement of celebrities who weaponise their fame and financial and reputational clout to cow the victims of their predatory behaviour. It is the clearest enunciation yet of the cardinal principle fought for by generations of feminists that “No means no” in rape trial proceedings. Not the tautologous meaninglessness that lay behind statements like “Brexit means Brexit;" but a statement of what to to rape victims of the bleeding obvious but not to the generations of reactionary legal counsel like the defence in Brand’s case who would take every opportunity to traduce the victim’s account of their trauma by introducing the factors itemised in Judge Bennathan’s sentencing statement to throw clouds over the understanding of consent. Now surely, it has been established in case law that none of those reasons can ever be admissible as a defence in rape and sexual assault trials. Now is the time to make it a statutory offence to do so. The Bar Council has called for the perpetuation of such “rape myths” by defence counsels to be outlawed.

But not even the conviction of the man with the Charles Manson visage and follicles based on over a thousand evidential items has led to a humble acceptance of his guilt. No, he posted a message on his You Tube channel Sunday Service pleading his innocence through the words of his wife Laura. Bad enough, that the Christ-like demon was able to broadcast a running commentary on this crypto-spiritual channel to his US followers on the trial but to continue to protest his innocence outside of normal legal channels is utterly preposterous and is certainly contrary to prison regulations where such messages cause serious distress to victims. The London Victims Commissioner has stated that such comments would retraumatise his victims As I write this, 10 Downing Street has described this message as “appalling” and is looking at appropriate responses.

It is important to discuss what some commentators hope is Britain’s #MeToo moment[1] as, hot on the heels of Brand conviction, last week the London Metropolitan Police launched investigations into “non-recent” allegations of sexual misconduct by comedian, children’s author, and Britain’s Got Talent (BGT\) judge David Walliams after a three year joint investigation by ITV and the Guardian newspaper into his alleged grooming and sexual assault of teenage girls including at least one 15 year-old who had contacted him for advice as to how to enter the world of comedy. Online speculation has also mushroomed around another prominent entertainer of the noughties era alleged to be guilty of the same sexually predatory crimes as Brand and Walliams and likely a close colleague of both. The laws of libel and the reputation of the TPQ weblog prevent me from naming my suspect candidate, but it is to be hoped that justice will catch up with this generation of celebrity sex offenders as it didn’t with Jimmy Saville or late in life as with Rolf Harris, Stuart Hall and Gary Glitter.

Brand and others were not ensnared by peak #MeToo as, like other cultural phenomena like Black Lives Movement, just did not transfer seamlessly from across the Atlantic to Britain. At Brand’s trial, his defence barrister Ian Winter QC, sought to use #MeToo against the complainants. He questioned why they had not come forward in 2017, the year of the downfall of Harvey Weinstein, when in his lyrical formulation, ‘every woman in the world was examining whether they’d been sexually assaulted by a famous person.”[2] However that line of argument does not take into account what Rosamund Unwin calls the “half-baked” nature of Britain Me Too. Some brave women did come forward but it was politicians who were the main focus – Michael Fallon had resigned as defence secretary after admitting to his behaviour towards female journalists and colleagues had “fallen short” of the required standards, and the late Anthony Lester resigned from the House of Lords following sexual harassment allegations that he denied. The MP for Dover Charlie Elphicke went to prison. Businessmen behaving inappropriately towards staff in public were brought to book. There were also a slew of complaints made against politicians from all the major parties around “touching” and “handsy” behaviour which didn’t lead to high-profile resignations apart from Chris Pincher during the dog days of the Boris Johnson administration. However there has been discussion about toxic working cultures within the Parliamentary estate.[3]

By contrast in the US, the downfall of film mogul Harvey Weinstein triggered full fat #MeToo which swept away Les Moonves, the head of CBS; Matt Lauer, the presenter of NBC’s Today show; the comedian Louis CK; and Charlie Ross, the veteran television interviewer, fired by CBS and PBS. A particularly deserving case was that of the conservative broadcaster the late Roger Ailes, forced to resign from Fox News after multiple allegations of sexual harassment. The case against Bill Cosby, the subject of complaints for years by women, went to trial in 2018 although his conviction was overturned by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in 2021. The convictions of Puff Diddy and RB Kelly are arguably the outcomes of the culture shift set in motion by #MeToo.

Another issue that has to be revisited in the wake of the Brand (and likely other scandals) is the age of consent with calls for a staggered age of consent which would make sexual relationships between adults and teenagers when there are decades in age between then statutory rape while no longer criminalising consensual sex between teenagers even if under the statutory age of 16 as in the UK; 17 in the Republic of Ireland. Such legal flexibility would have definitively placed Russell Brand on the wrong side of the law in relation to the allegation of rape of a 16-year-old when he was 30 and would do for David Walliams should he be charged with the offences he has allegedly carried out against young women. It would legally enshrine Andrew Mountbatten Windsor as the “sweaty nonce” who committed statutory rape against the late Virginia Guiffre in both London and the State of Florida and possibly other minors. Perhaps such a law could be named “Virginia’s Law” but there would have to be the widest possible consultative process before and during a putative legislative process to put in place the appropriate guardrails.

Britain’s notoriously strict libel laws have historically acted as a major deterrent to whistleblowers and investigative journalism in the area of celebrity sexual crime. In 1968, the Sunday Express was poised to publish an expose of the offending record of Jimmy Saville but baulked at it due to the advice of their libel lawyers and so and opportunity to identify of Britain’s most prolific sex offender was missed. It should at least be possible to amend the libel laws to ensure that in the cases of failed attempts at suing newspapers by Walliams, Elphicke et al, the costs are awarded entirely against the complainant.

Lastly on the ‘lad’ culture of the time that Russell Brand operated in. My fellow TPQ columnist Christopher Owens points out rightfully that prevailing cultural maxims and assumptions do not rob people of agency. Yes, it was an era when young women in public spaces like pubs would take no “shit” from leery blokes and would respond to unwanted advances from them with throwing beer at them or maybe even a kick in the nuts (my words). There are anecdotes of how women operating in male dominated environments would display a pair like Karen Brady who as Managing Director of Birmingham City became the first woman ever to hold such a position in professional football and later, on the club’s flotation became the youngest such appointee in the sport, would riposte to players on the team choice who said “I can see your tits” that “Well you won’t see them from Crewe when I have transferred you there!” All fine but hardly, I would suggest, that these vignettes chime with the lived experiences of many, if not most, women. For, in the words of Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett, “the noughties told girls like me was that abuse was normal.”[4]

Rhiannon paints vivid and shocking scenes from the ‘lad culture’ era; personal, such as reading as a 17-year-old a tabloid newspaper column arguing that girls who wore short skirts essentially deserved to be raped, to being attacked by a stranger while walking home after a night out when a common rape myth at the time had it that “I was a car who had left her doors unlocked. She knew girls who met rock stars more than twice their age at festivals who targeted them when they were still in their teens. Girls who were groomed and abused by teachers or preyed upon by older men with a preference for girls still doing their GCSEs. Girls whose boyfriends locked them in their flats. Girls who were assaulted or anally raped like Brand’s victim.[5]

She recalls the prevailing media landscape at the time that she co-authored with Holly Baxter in 2014 a book called The Vagenda which contained a section on rape culture and rape myths and aimed at teenage girls. The gang rape jokes by Jimmy Carr (who I have always found obnoxious). The London Evening Standard having a strip club correspondent. The Daily Telegraph reporting that Gymbox ran a Playboy “bunny bootcamp.” Teenage magazines having a section for readers’ photos entitled “How Sexy Am I?”[6]

The book was trashed by older male reviews and by the women who took money from the women’s magazines it criticised (where was the sisterhood when it was needed again?) To question the post- modern culture in which idea of meta narratives were for the birds; in which everything “went;” in which women were supposedly “liberated” and so feminism was redundant was to invite criticisms for being “uncool,” “prudish,” “neurotic” or, heaven forbid, “politically correct” or what would now be called “woke.” That world may have passed but its legacy is, in the words of Rhiannon, the divided self of women who came of age; “the half that knows it has been violated, and the half walking around in a world that refused to listen.”[7]

References

[1] Rosamund Urwin. Our #MeToo moment? Let us hope that Russell Brand’s conviction marks a watershed for Britain. New Statesman 13-19 November 2026 pp.18-19

[2] Ibid, p.19

[3] Ibid

[4] Rhiannon Lucy Cossldett. The noughties told girls like me that abuse was normal. The Guardian Journal. 12 November 2026 pp.1-2

[5] Ibid

[6] Ibid

[7] Ibid, p.2

⏩Barry Gilheany is a freelance writer, qualified counsellor and aspirant artist resident in Colchester where he took his PhD at the University of Essex. He is also a lifelong Leeds United supporter.

On The Noughties Step

Barry Gilheany ✍The Lessons And Legacy Of The Russell Brand Case (And Maybe Others)

Whatever women wear, wherever they go, indeed whatever they drink, they retain the right to say no and to demand justice from the criminal courts when sexual predators like you, Russell Brand, act without their consent.

 Those words delivered by Judge Bennathan during the sentencing of this disgraced comic, actor and You Tube presenter have laid down the legal and cultural parameters for any future judgement of celebrities who weaponise their fame and financial and reputational clout to cow the victims of their predatory behaviour. It is the clearest enunciation yet of the cardinal principle fought for by generations of feminists that “No means no” in rape trial proceedings. Not the tautologous meaninglessness that lay behind statements like “Brexit means Brexit;" but a statement of what to to rape victims of the bleeding obvious but not to the generations of reactionary legal counsel like the defence in Brand’s case who would take every opportunity to traduce the victim’s account of their trauma by introducing the factors itemised in Judge Bennathan’s sentencing statement to throw clouds over the understanding of consent. Now surely, it has been established in case law that none of those reasons can ever be admissible as a defence in rape and sexual assault trials. Now is the time to make it a statutory offence to do so. The Bar Council has called for the perpetuation of such “rape myths” by defence counsels to be outlawed.

But not even the conviction of the man with the Charles Manson visage and follicles based on over a thousand evidential items has led to a humble acceptance of his guilt. No, he posted a message on his You Tube channel Sunday Service pleading his innocence through the words of his wife Laura. Bad enough, that the Christ-like demon was able to broadcast a running commentary on this crypto-spiritual channel to his US followers on the trial but to continue to protest his innocence outside of normal legal channels is utterly preposterous and is certainly contrary to prison regulations where such messages cause serious distress to victims. The London Victims Commissioner has stated that such comments would retraumatise his victims As I write this, 10 Downing Street has described this message as “appalling” and is looking at appropriate responses.

It is important to discuss what some commentators hope is Britain’s #MeToo moment[1] as, hot on the heels of Brand conviction, last week the London Metropolitan Police launched investigations into “non-recent” allegations of sexual misconduct by comedian, children’s author, and Britain’s Got Talent (BGT\) judge David Walliams after a three year joint investigation by ITV and the Guardian newspaper into his alleged grooming and sexual assault of teenage girls including at least one 15 year-old who had contacted him for advice as to how to enter the world of comedy. Online speculation has also mushroomed around another prominent entertainer of the noughties era alleged to be guilty of the same sexually predatory crimes as Brand and Walliams and likely a close colleague of both. The laws of libel and the reputation of the TPQ weblog prevent me from naming my suspect candidate, but it is to be hoped that justice will catch up with this generation of celebrity sex offenders as it didn’t with Jimmy Saville or late in life as with Rolf Harris, Stuart Hall and Gary Glitter.

Brand and others were not ensnared by peak #MeToo as, like other cultural phenomena like Black Lives Movement, just did not transfer seamlessly from across the Atlantic to Britain. At Brand’s trial, his defence barrister Ian Winter QC, sought to use #MeToo against the complainants. He questioned why they had not come forward in 2017, the year of the downfall of Harvey Weinstein, when in his lyrical formulation, ‘every woman in the world was examining whether they’d been sexually assaulted by a famous person.”[2] However that line of argument does not take into account what Rosamund Unwin calls the “half-baked” nature of Britain Me Too. Some brave women did come forward but it was politicians who were the main focus – Michael Fallon had resigned as defence secretary after admitting to his behaviour towards female journalists and colleagues had “fallen short” of the required standards, and the late Anthony Lester resigned from the House of Lords following sexual harassment allegations that he denied. The MP for Dover Charlie Elphicke went to prison. Businessmen behaving inappropriately towards staff in public were brought to book. There were also a slew of complaints made against politicians from all the major parties around “touching” and “handsy” behaviour which didn’t lead to high-profile resignations apart from Chris Pincher during the dog days of the Boris Johnson administration. However there has been discussion about toxic working cultures within the Parliamentary estate.[3]

By contrast in the US, the downfall of film mogul Harvey Weinstein triggered full fat #MeToo which swept away Les Moonves, the head of CBS; Matt Lauer, the presenter of NBC’s Today show; the comedian Louis CK; and Charlie Ross, the veteran television interviewer, fired by CBS and PBS. A particularly deserving case was that of the conservative broadcaster the late Roger Ailes, forced to resign from Fox News after multiple allegations of sexual harassment. The case against Bill Cosby, the subject of complaints for years by women, went to trial in 2018 although his conviction was overturned by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in 2021. The convictions of Puff Diddy and RB Kelly are arguably the outcomes of the culture shift set in motion by #MeToo.

Another issue that has to be revisited in the wake of the Brand (and likely other scandals) is the age of consent with calls for a staggered age of consent which would make sexual relationships between adults and teenagers when there are decades in age between then statutory rape while no longer criminalising consensual sex between teenagers even if under the statutory age of 16 as in the UK; 17 in the Republic of Ireland. Such legal flexibility would have definitively placed Russell Brand on the wrong side of the law in relation to the allegation of rape of a 16-year-old when he was 30 and would do for David Walliams should he be charged with the offences he has allegedly carried out against young women. It would legally enshrine Andrew Mountbatten Windsor as the “sweaty nonce” who committed statutory rape against the late Virginia Guiffre in both London and the State of Florida and possibly other minors. Perhaps such a law could be named “Virginia’s Law” but there would have to be the widest possible consultative process before and during a putative legislative process to put in place the appropriate guardrails.

Britain’s notoriously strict libel laws have historically acted as a major deterrent to whistleblowers and investigative journalism in the area of celebrity sexual crime. In 1968, the Sunday Express was poised to publish an expose of the offending record of Jimmy Saville but baulked at it due to the advice of their libel lawyers and so and opportunity to identify of Britain’s most prolific sex offender was missed. It should at least be possible to amend the libel laws to ensure that in the cases of failed attempts at suing newspapers by Walliams, Elphicke et al, the costs are awarded entirely against the complainant.

Lastly on the ‘lad’ culture of the time that Russell Brand operated in. My fellow TPQ columnist Christopher Owens points out rightfully that prevailing cultural maxims and assumptions do not rob people of agency. Yes, it was an era when young women in public spaces like pubs would take no “shit” from leery blokes and would respond to unwanted advances from them with throwing beer at them or maybe even a kick in the nuts (my words). There are anecdotes of how women operating in male dominated environments would display a pair like Karen Brady who as Managing Director of Birmingham City became the first woman ever to hold such a position in professional football and later, on the club’s flotation became the youngest such appointee in the sport, would riposte to players on the team choice who said “I can see your tits” that “Well you won’t see them from Crewe when I have transferred you there!” All fine but hardly, I would suggest, that these vignettes chime with the lived experiences of many, if not most, women. For, in the words of Rhiannon Lucy Cosslett, “the noughties told girls like me was that abuse was normal.”[4]

Rhiannon paints vivid and shocking scenes from the ‘lad culture’ era; personal, such as reading as a 17-year-old a tabloid newspaper column arguing that girls who wore short skirts essentially deserved to be raped, to being attacked by a stranger while walking home after a night out when a common rape myth at the time had it that “I was a car who had left her doors unlocked. She knew girls who met rock stars more than twice their age at festivals who targeted them when they were still in their teens. Girls who were groomed and abused by teachers or preyed upon by older men with a preference for girls still doing their GCSEs. Girls whose boyfriends locked them in their flats. Girls who were assaulted or anally raped like Brand’s victim.[5]

She recalls the prevailing media landscape at the time that she co-authored with Holly Baxter in 2014 a book called The Vagenda which contained a section on rape culture and rape myths and aimed at teenage girls. The gang rape jokes by Jimmy Carr (who I have always found obnoxious). The London Evening Standard having a strip club correspondent. The Daily Telegraph reporting that Gymbox ran a Playboy “bunny bootcamp.” Teenage magazines having a section for readers’ photos entitled “How Sexy Am I?”[6]

The book was trashed by older male reviews and by the women who took money from the women’s magazines it criticised (where was the sisterhood when it was needed again?) To question the post- modern culture in which idea of meta narratives were for the birds; in which everything “went;” in which women were supposedly “liberated” and so feminism was redundant was to invite criticisms for being “uncool,” “prudish,” “neurotic” or, heaven forbid, “politically correct” or what would now be called “woke.” That world may have passed but its legacy is, in the words of Rhiannon, the divided self of women who came of age; “the half that knows it has been violated, and the half walking around in a world that refused to listen.”[7]

References

[1] Rosamund Urwin. Our #MeToo moment? Let us hope that Russell Brand’s conviction marks a watershed for Britain. New Statesman 13-19 November 2026 pp.18-19

[2] Ibid, p.19

[3] Ibid

[4] Rhiannon Lucy Cossldett. The noughties told girls like me that abuse was normal. The Guardian Journal. 12 November 2026 pp.1-2

[5] Ibid

[6] Ibid

[7] Ibid, p.2

⏩Barry Gilheany is a freelance writer, qualified counsellor and aspirant artist resident in Colchester where he took his PhD at the University of Essex. He is also a lifelong Leeds United supporter.

1 comment:

  1. Obnoxious as he is he should be allowed to maintain his innocence. That sort of restriction applied to the Birmingham Six and they would still be in jail. It is like denying the Holocaust - it should be permissible to do so and permissible for the rest of us to ridicule the claim.
    And he should be free to communicate his beliefs to his wife, and she in turn to publish them. I thought the statement she put out on his YouTube channel was ridiculous. A load of religious bull. Ridicule rather than repression is a better approach and less societally harmful.

    ReplyDelete