The overthrow of the regime of President Bashar al-Assad and the Assad dynasty which had ruled Syria for 54 years in a manner which requires the redefinition of the words “brutality” and tyranny on the weekend of 7-8 December 2024 happened with such stunning speed as to make the downfall of communism in Eastern Europe in 1989 look like a gradual process.
While the world was focused on the wars in Ukraine and Gaza, nobody apart from seemingly thwarted Syrian revolutionary sympathisers on X had any inkling that the rebel forces led by the Islamist Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) who, after their routing in Aleppo in 2016 by the Syrian and Russian air forces and then their bussing to Idlib province, had quietly regrouped for the last two years and then launched a mini-blitzkrieg that in a space of a week saw the recapture of Aleppo, Hama and Homs leading then to final victory with the liberation of Damascus and the melting away with the regular Syrian Army. Meanwhile, mindful of the fate of other dictators such as Ceausescu, Saddam Hussein and Col Gaddafi who unwisely stayed to fight futile battles against tide and time, Assad and his entourage flew to the lair of his ally, Vladimir Putin, in Moscow.
It is difficult to settle on an appropriate lexicon to describe the feelings and reactions of the Syrians at the moment of their liberation. Joy and ecstasy at the removal of over two generations of cruel and arbitrary dictatorship versus agony at the discovery of the full horrors of the gulag complex that almost 100,000 Syrians disappeared into. At its apex was the Sadanya prison complex which can more accurately be described as a death camp or ‘human slaughterhouse. Constructed with the help of Nazi functionary Alois Brunner who died a fugitive in Syria during the reign of Hafez Al-Assad it is likely that up to 13,000 inmates were tortured and murdered there in the course of the Syrian Civil War. The scenes of bundled up clothing, shoes and other personal effects and the obvious squalor in which prisoners lived recall the optics of Tuol Sleng from Pol Pot’s Cambodia and even Auschwitz. The unimaginable atrocities perpetrated there and the attempted destruction of incriminating paperwork by the guards are reminiscent of similar cover tracking by the retreating SS and Khmer Rouge. And just like those homicidal industrial complexes, it is to be hoped that Sadanya be preserved as a museum to bear witness to another episode in the history of humanity’s inhumanity to humanity.
Or it is hope at a new dawn of freedom, reckoning and reconciliation for the Syrian people versus far at the prospect of another form of tyranny of Islamist vintage. Or fear about the disintegration that visited Iraq and Libya after the overthrow of Saddam and Ghaddafi, respectively. But the formation of an interim administration consisting of representatives from different rebel factions and of technocrats from the old regime which conspicuously did not happen in the aftermath of the fall of the afore mentioned regimes is a very hopeful sign. Also encouraging is the avowal (so far) of HTS leader Abu-Mohammed al-Jolani not to rule as an Islamist. Its evolution from an Al-Queda franchise to a national liberation type movement should be welcomed and the deregistering of HTS as a terrorist entity by western nations such as the UK and US would accelerate this journey.
Syria like most other MENA nations is a mosaic of differing tribes, ethnicities and religious groupings held together at the centre by strong, repressive governments from a single tribe like the Alawite Shia sect from which the Assads hail. They stay in power through a mixture of buying off tribal leaders and repression. Such centrifugal pressures are legacies of their moments of formation; the carving up of the Middle East by Britain and France in the Sykes-Picot agreement in the aftermath of World War and the forced union of tribes into new mandates such as Iraq and Syria. Because of their tortured origin, MENA nations such as Syria also face centripetal or external pressures such as aggrandisement from external actors such as Turkey and Israel and during its Civil War had Iran and its proxies Hezbollah propping up the Assad regime along with Russia.
But above all Syria is a nation in trauma. I write this now having watched an almost half hour feature on Channel 4 News on the sheer dimensions of the atrocities that Bastard al-Assad’s regime inflicted on its country. In one mass grave, it is believed, lie the remains of 100 – 150,000 regime victims. Witnesses who were conscripted to transport the dead recall daily deliveries of up to thirty corpses for any number of weeks. One particularly grotesque cargo consisted of a hundred bodies frozen together who had to be burned by Fire Brigades to separate them. The dead bore the calling cards of Mukhabarat; fingernails ripped out of children, cigarette burns, whipping by cables; blunt instrument trauma to the head. If Syria is to recover and move forward as a nation, then there has to be a full reckoning with its recent and present past. And this reckoning begins with the gathering and collation of the documents to be used in the evidentiary proceedings in future prosecutions of the architects and participants of the 21st century largest charnel house; either in Syria or at the Hague.
And it is not just the Assad crime family, the secret police top brass and those at the top of Air Force Intelligence who must face accountability for their serial crimes against humanity. Those who had the capacity to act but didn’t when the need called need to show humility. First up, the Obama administration who laid down red lines over the use of chemical weapons but who failed to do so after the egregious violation of them in the sarin gas attack on Eastern Gouta on 21st August 2013 which led to 1,440 excruciating deaths. That they didn’t was due in no small measure to the House of Commons vote against sanctioning military action against Assad on 31st August thanks to the then Labour Leader Ed Miliband whipping his MPs into voting No. This was the most shameful episode in Labour’s history since Tony Blair led the UK into backing George W. Bush’s invasion of Iraq a decade previously; the fallout from which being a significant contributory factor in the reluctance to sanction this much more justifiable intervention. The next eleven years of Syrian history were thus to be Russian, Iranian, Turkish, and Israeli history as well.
Next are the assortment of useful idiots and sycophants who provided cover to the Assad regime. Top of the usual suspects are George Galloway and Nick Griffin; for Galloway it was Assad’s opposition to the “Zionist entity” that was his route to sanctification; for the former leader of the BNP, it was that as well as being a supposed a bulwark against Radical Islam that fitted the bill. Galloway has just declared that he has “given up” on the Arab cause in the wake of Assad’s fall at the hands of “Ten Thousand Chinamen” or more accurately Uighurs; this begs the question as to whether he was a beneficiary of Assad’s financial largesse. Then there are the four Irish parliamentarians; Clare Daly, Mick Wallace, Catherine Connolly and Maureen Sullivan who, in the cases of Daly and Wallace frequently shilled against any sanctions against Assad and also Putin for his Ukrainian aggression in the European Parliament, and also along with of Ms Connolly and Ms Sullivan made a number of visits to Syria in 2017-18. They met with Assad and parroted the Assadist line that Syria was at war with “genocidal extremists.” As any investigation into the mass homicidal criminality of the Assad regime progresses, it would be reasonable to question this quadrumvirate as to what pecuniary gain they made and indict them as accessories to war crimes and crimes against humanity.
One particular foul episode concerning Wallace was his role in denigrating the report of the International Convention for the Prohibition of Chemical Weapons (ICPCW) into the sarin gas attack on Douma by the Assad regime in April 2017 and parroting the regime line that it was rebels who were responsible; a lie that was proven to be such by the Open Source investigative body Bellingcat.
In the rogues gallery also are Alt Media sources such as The Gray Zone which parroted the regime line about the use of chemical weapons as well as the slander that the Syrian White Knights - a volunteer civil defence body which rescued people from the rubble caused by regime and Russian air raids - were agents of British intelligence and Al-Queda and used crisis actors to provide fake news. Two prominent members of The Gray Zone are Max Blumenthal, son of the journalist Syndey, and Aaron Mate, son of renowned addiction and trauma specialist, Gabor – both certainly are not pursuing their distinguished parents’ vocations of speaking truth to power.
So, congratulations to the Syrian people for liberating themselves from one of the world’s most cruel and longest lasting tyranny without external intervention. Enjoy the moment. You have shown that where evil exists, retention of the status quo is never an option.
⏩Barry Gilheany is a freelance writer, qualified counsellor and aspirant artist resident in Colchester where he took his PhD at the University of Essex. He is also a lifelong Leeds United supporter.
Until the Islamofascists take over at least.
ReplyDeleteThis is always the fear
DeleteI am moderately confident that will not happen. Initial signs promising.
ReplyDeleteIsrael has no interest in a cohesive Syria. Far better to have their enemies fight among themselves.
DeleteSteve - a rule of thumb: think Israel, think Nazi. Each is motivated by the same weltanschauung: a superior race that has the right to rule over anyone it cares to. Towards that end it pursues lebensraum, genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity, infanticide, torture, rape, colonisation inter alia.
DeleteAM
DeleteThey didn't hang about taking the Golan Heights and attacking Syrian ammo dumps either.
I observed a strong supporter of the Palestinian cause cursing one and all who welcomed the fall of the Syrian tyrant. This seemed to jar with the sentiments expressed by Palestinians many of whom openly celebrated his fall. How many Palestinians went through the Slaughter House? Like Netanyahu, Assad is a monster. The West has a problem in that it makes monsters look good by embracing the monsters it approves and hanging the monsters it disapproves.
ReplyDelete5,000 Palestinians were massacred in Yarmouk refugee camp by Assad's forces. Thousands also died in refugee camps in Lebanon at the hands of Hafaz Assad's troops. The Palestinian Solidarity Campaign is very silent about this.
ReplyDelete'Congratulations to the Syrian people for liberating themselves'...
ReplyDeleteI think it had little to do with them. It appears to be more a move by Turkey (who have been destabising the region for years by facilitating lunatic jihadists) the USA (who have made a grab for the oil in the north) and the zionist entity (who continue their rapacious land grab).
Syria is 'free'. Oh happy day!
That comment represents the imperialism of the Western antiperialist.
DeleteHTS may not be everyone's flavour of the month but they are an indigenous force who cooperated effectively with more secular groups. Once Assad lost the cover of Iran, Russia and Hezbollah the game was up from.
ReplyDeleteA zionist cheerleading an al qaeda affiliate group. You couldn't make it up.
ReplyDeleteFirst of all, I am neither Zionist or anti-Zionist. But more importantly, I oppose tyranny and abuse of human rights wherever it occurs. Can I ask you, The Skin, where you stand on Assad 's crimes?
DeleteBarry - you do no such thing. Your denial of Starmer's support for the war crimes listed in the ICC case against Israel belie any such assertion.
DeleteI have never denied that Starmer made that statement. I have made it plain that I support the ICC indictment against Netanayu and have frequently condemned the conduct of Israel's war in Gaza on my articles and comments.
ReplyDeletewhat you denied was that the statement he made was support for the war crimes identified by the ICC in its issuing of the Netanyahu/Gallant arrest. It is demonstrably in support of those war crimes.
DeleteThere have been claims made from within the Syrian rebels that the US was preparing them weeks in advance. They want Assad overthrown but even oppose the arrest of Netanyahu. Genocide Joe and his gang are a serious threat to world peace.
ReplyDeleteIt was more Iikely that Turkey was the main backer of HTS and it has the main beneficiary of Assad's overthrow. The West did not lift a finger to help the Syrian opposition
DeleteTurkey is up to its neck in it but with whose approval? Who provided the arms with the intention of destabilising the country and which then were then acquired Al-Nusra Front which later changed shape to Hay’at Tahrir al-Sham (HTS)? The West.
DeleteThe West is continuing to insist that Syrians through sanctions be starved for the crimes of the regime - a regime the West used for rendition purposes - on the false pretext of concerns for human rights. Yet it does not insist on similar sanctions against Israel. This racism that drives Western foreign policy is to be abjured. It is predicated on a view that Palestinians are less than human and therefore human rights should not be accessible by them. Starmer never called for water and electricity to be cut off to Israel? Not once has he identified an Israeli war crime although he has accused Russia of many. There is a very simple reason for that - he is a Western racist.
The biggest threat to world peace now is right wing populist nationalism allied to Big Tech Bros and it is coming closer to home than you might think. If Elon Musk attempts to and gets away with funding Reform UK to the tune of £100m, another liberal democratic domino could follow. The era of the US hegemon and the order it upheld is over; yesterday's fish and chip paper. But as always, be careful what you wish for.
ReplyDeleteRight Wing populist nationalism is a threat as can be seen from the genocide in Gaza. This is a Genocide being perpetrated in front of our eyes, armed and supported by the West. Are we to seriously believe that Farage is going to be a more enthusiastic supporter of war crimes than Starmer?
DeleteHe is a potential Quisling to Putin.
ReplyDeleteFagash is an apologist for Putin's genocidal war in Ukraine
ReplyDeleteAny more so than Starmer is to Netanyahu's genocidal war? Is Russia waging genocidal war and Israel is not?
DeleteFarage gave cover to Putin's aggression by spewing out the discredited NATO expansion narrative. He like Trump is a likely asset for Putin just like other far right figures like Le Pen and Orban. Both conflicts are potentially genocidal.
ReplyDeleteBarry - look at the history of NATO. It has been expanding for decades and pushing its influence to the East. Clinto expanded it, Bush did also.
DeleteNATO is an institutional expression of US foreign policy with the US as hegemon. If a NATO member wishes to leave it must report not to the Secretary General of NATO but to the President of the USA.
NATO is about the projection of US military, political and economic power. It is a neoliberal force project. To cite Thomas Meaney:
In just a few short years NATO went from being a primarily defensive organisation to being a brazenly offensive one.
It has sought to exploit genuine concerns of Baltic nations and East European states about Russia for the purposes of turning them into a strategic beachhead in a Europe that has no strategic autonomy. It is best suited by an authoritarian regime in Moscow not a democratic one. If Russia had a democratic regime there would be little for the Baltic states to fear
None of this is about human rights concerns or out of respect for sovereignty - the US has demonstrated as an outlier in international law it does not care about those things. It arms the genocide in Gaza.
While it is a distant likelihood, unlike Genocide Joe, Trump just might stop the genocide in Gaza and the war in Ukraine, Farage backing him can't be judged too harshly in the light of Starmer endorsing war crimes and arming the genocide.
There are plenty off criticisms of Farage that can be levelled and which I share but yours ring empty when you fail to criticise Starmer's support of Israeli aggression. It is clear even to the blind that the aggression in Ukraine is nowhere near as cruel or as intense as that in Gaza.
Anthony, East European nations signed up of their volition to NATO and just recently traditionally neutral Finland and Sweden have joined due precisely to the fact that there is an undemocratic, expansionist regime in Moscow. NATO has actually vetoed the applications of Georgia and Ukraine. Remember that Ukraine gave up its nuclear weapons in 1994, never imagining that there would be a revanchist Russia again on its doorstep. Trump will try to stop the war in Ukraine all right, by rolling over in front of his pal Putin and giving him what he wants and even withdrawing the US from NATO. He is an isolationist after all.
ReplyDeleteThe threats of Trump that "all hell will break loose" if the hostages are not released by 20th January hardly bodes well for an end to the war in Gaza. Nor is his electoral dependence on Christian evangelical dispensationalism with their End Times prophecies for the Holy Land. Nor his his birds of a feather affinity with Netananyu portentous.
Regarding my stance on Gaza. It is a horrible, brutal conflict that is an affront to humanity.It should end now with an unconditional ceasefire and release of the hostages. Starmer should never made those comments about deprivation of food and electricity and I certainly condemn them. But I am not going to be held responsible for them But that was when he was in opposition with no power to influence the conflict. Labour in government does not endorse any breaking of humanitarian law by Israel or anyone else and, judging from online reaction at any rate, supporters of Israel are hacked off by its support for the restoration of funding for UNWRA and the suspension of arms exports licences.
Regarding comparisons between Gaza and Ukraine, the Russians certainly set standards for cruelty by the massacre at Bucha and the siege of Mariupol including the bombing of Mariupol Maternal Hospital and Children's Theatre which led to the deaths of 20,000 mainly civilians. Then there are the filtration camps and the kidnapping and settling of Ukrainian children in Russia. It was Russia who committed the supreme war crime of invasion of another country with the purpose of territorial conquest. Ukraine did not attack Russian territory and commit mass murders of civilians as happened on 7 October and has always abided by international law in treatment of POWs.
Whatever one's objections to US, UK and some EU members support of Israel in its merciless war in Gaza, it should never afford a free pass or get out of jail card for Putin, Trump, Farage and the rest of the modern far right axis of evil.
This is my last comment on this thread. I am not bothered if you disagree.