Gearóid Ó Loingsigh ☭ writing in Substack on 19-November-2026.

Photo: Buenaventura Port, Colombia (GOL)

In Hollywood films drug traffickers are often seen taking direct charge of drugs when they are not using mules. The drug trafficker, regardless of his rank in the hierarchy sticks his neck out, gets himself dirty and plays a direct active role at all times. The reality of it is quite different. The highest capos do not live in Colombia, they are not even Colombian and the shipment of their merchandise is done in much the same way as many legal products. In the same way that dirty money is laundered through international clean money circuits, drugs are sent alongside normal products and it is the same companies who take charge of getting them from A to B.

Sometimes we see news about seizures of cocaine in commercial shipments, although not always in the main newspapers, nor on the main TV stations and you have to search out for the news item in specialised magazines. According to the Ports Europe magazine, the following seizures occurred in different operations: 1.68 tonnes in Urabá, Colombia going to Antwerp, Belgium; 2.6 tonnes in Valencia, Spain; 300 kg in Nuremberg, Germany; 1.184 tonnes in Alicante, Spain. All of these loads were hidden in banana shipments.

According to figures from EUDA (European Union Drugs Agency), Antwerp and Rotterdam account for most seizures of cocaine in Europe. These two ports taken together account for more than all the other ports together and Antwerp, in turn, more than doubles Rotterdam. Guayaquil in Ecuador is the main port from which cocaine is sent, if we measure it against the number of seizures. More than 80% of the drugs that come into the EU arrive in commercial ships. Let’s leave to one side the myths of mules and the drug trafficker in his four wheel drive. Drugs flow through the same economic circuits as all other commercial products.

In its report the World Customs Organisation analyses various manners in which cocaine is sent to the consumer countries. It has a whole chapter given over to the banana industry and provides figures on the number of cocaine seizures in banana shipments.

Of the 2,252 container-based drug detections in the analysis period, a commodity description was recorded for 1,613 (72%). Of those, 35% (564) had a reported commodity of bananas, although the actual number would be higher due to the large number of ‘unknown commodity’ containers contaminated with cocaine that were shipped from well-known banana exporting countries.[1]

Furthermore, they state that in many cases the cocaine is not simply in banana crates but rather is hidden behind structural concealments of the containers themselves. The report explains various ways of hiding drugs and speculates on what they refer to as infiltration of the export chain or internal conspirators. Without doubt, there are employees in the ports who place drugs in the shipment, but at no stage do they talk about the company’s responsibility or role. In the case of traditional cocaine shipments where the cocaine is hidden in the same banana crates and covered by the fruit the report states that:

no internal conspirator connection could be made or inferred… It is possible but remains unknown if the importing and exporting businesses were complicit in the drug trafficking venture.[2]

The law is usually implacable with lower income people when drugs are found on their properties. Such is the case of the Chingaté Baracaldo family in Fusagasugá, Colombia that rented out a part of its house to a woman. Later when they realised that the tenant was using the space to store and sell marijuana they reported her and the police found 32 grams of drugs in the place. However, the prosecutor proceeded to confiscate the property alleging that the owner had a legal duty to control the use of her property. Following an 18 year battle the family has been unable to recover their house. There are 32,000 other cases in Colombia, some are rich and participate in the drugs trade and others are low income families and are victims of it.[3]

But in the case of import-export companies they are absolved of any responsibility and they concentrate on the individuals arrested in the port, when there are any. The company is not intervened, and its assets are not seized. The companies would have a greater degree of responsibility than the Chingaté Baracaldo family, as the family reported the drug vendors and the maritime and banana companies are not exactly the ones who report the drugs shipments. Quite the opposite. Even so, nothing happens to them. In many countries public records are not even kept on the companies involved and we will not find information that details the maritime and banana companies involved or the amounts of drugs per company in any report. This is the case with the European Union.

In Ecuador there are some records on the companies associated with the drugs trade but “The authorities do not reveal the identity of the owners nor the names of the legally established companies”[4] though the “National Department of Anti-Drugs Investigations formally asked the Ministry of Agriculture to suspend the export licences of recidivist drug trafficking companies.”[5] In 2025, 66 companies were linked to drug trafficking. Amongst the companies are those of the family of the current president Noboa.

In an encrypted chat from February 2021, alleged drug traffickers from the Balkans boasted of having the exclusive rights to traffic cocaine hidden in export banana containers from the family company of the president of Ecuador, Daniel Noboa.[6] 

Despite at least eight shipments of cocaine in containers belonging to his companies, the president does not even appear on the Clinton List and has not been sanctioned by the OFAC (Office of Foreign Assets Control).[7]

The situation is even worse in Colombia where they really don’t acknowledge the companies’ responsibility. Thanks to the work of journalists we can point to two companies, both linked to political sectors in the country. One of them, Banacol, contributed to the election campaign of Federico Gutiérrez and other Colombian politicians[8] and the other company, Banasan, belongs to the brothers of the Minister of Trade, Industry and Tourism in the Santos government.[9] None of these cases had positive outcomes. They were not charged.

As Bloomberg points out in the USA the maritime and banana companies usually negotiate the reduction of any sanction imposed and in Europe, it is very rare that the companies are fined. In one of the most notorious cases investigated by Bloomberg, the Gayane ship that had trafficked 20 tonnes with an calculated value of one billion dollars continues to plough the seas of the world.[10] A clean slate. The governments and authorities are loathe to publish data that indicate which companies are involved, the recidivist rate nor the quantity of drugs seized per company. The law is for the poor and the authorities haven’t the slightest intention of investigating the top executives and owners of the banana and shipping companies. It is implausible that none of the companies is complicit in the drugs trade but no one wants to bring the great business opportunity, that is the banana-drug trafficking industry, to an end.

References

[1] WCO (2025) Infiltration of maritime cargo supply chains. Brussels. WCO p.31 

[2] Ibíd., p.32

[3] See.

[4] El Diario Correo (31/08/2025) 56 exportadoras de banano han estado asociadas con el narcotráfico. 

[5] Ibíd.

[6] OCCRP (04/12/2025) Cocaína y banano: traficantes de los Balcanes usaron cargamentos de fruta de la empresa familiar del presidente de Ecuador para enviar drogas. Stevan Dojčinović et al. 

[7] The list can be consulted.

[8] Vorágine (07/11/2023) Bananera que financió a Fico en la mira por envíos de cocaína a la mafia italiana. https://voragine.co/historias/investigacion/bananera-que-financio-a-fico-en-la-mira-por-envios-de-cocaina-a-la-mafia-italiana/

[9] Vorágine (03/12/2023) Los ‘narcobananos’ que exporta la empresa de los hermanos de un exministro. José Guarnizo y Nicolás Sánchez Arévalo. https://voragine.co/historias/investigacion/los-narcobananos-que-exporta-la-empresa-de-los-hermanos-de-un-exministro/

[10] Bloomberg (16/12/2022) How a Cocaine-Smuggling Cartel Infiltrated the World’s Biggest Shipping Company. Lauren Etter and Michael Riley. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2022-12-16/how-world-s-top-shipping-company-became-hub-for-drug-trafficking


⏩ Gearóid Ó Loingsigh is a political and human rights activist with extensive experience in Latin America.

Exporting Bananas And Cocaine 🪶 A Great Business Opportunity

Dixie Elliot ✊ writing last month about the criminalisation of Irish culture in Maghaberry prison.


At a time when the headlines are dominated by Unionist culture, which is based entirely on sectarian hatred and the Orange Order's determination to walk where they are not wanted, behind the walls of Maghaberry Prison Irish culture is being criminalised.

The silence from Nationalist politicians and the so called media is both shameful and cowardly.
If they have a conscience then they are easing it by telling themselves that Niall Sheerin is a 'Dissident Republican.'

The Derry man has served the original sentence imposed upon him by a British court, but continues to be held after Parole Commissioners, adopting the powers of a court of law, insisted he remain imprisoned several months beyond the usual and expected release date.
A report in the Sunday Life suggested that the decision was based on concerns that he had not been sufficiently depoliticised while behind bars at Maghaberry prison.

What are these so called 'concerns' based on?
 
His love of Irish culture, in particular the Gaelic language and sport. Because of that they have decided that Niall Sheerin has not been 'sufficiently depoliticised'.
 
Do the words of Bobby Sands no longer mean anything, have they become an inconvenient truth which highlights the fact that nothing has been gained by his sacrifice and that of his nine brave comrades?
 
They will not criminalise us, rob us of our true identity, steal our individualism, depoliticise us, churn us out as systemised, institutionalised, decent law-abiding robots. Never will they label our liberation struggle as criminal.

Read this and see how they are criminalising Irish culture inside prison walls.

Thomas Dixie Elliot is a Derry artist and a former H Block Blanketman.
Follow Dixie Elliot on Twitter @IsMise_Dixie

A Tale Of Two Cultures

Christopher Owens 🔖has been delving into . . .  

Photographs & Graphics from the 1980s Anarcho-Punk Underground



Zounds always had a way of articulating the optimism of the anarcho punk scene. Emerging as an alternative to the commercial punk scene, anarcho punk turned a generation into anarchists. And one such person was Chris Low.

Originally from Stirling, Low first discovered punk when he saw Crass at the age of eleven. As a result, he threw himself into the fledging anarcho punk scene with gusto, producing a fanzine called Guilty of What?’as well as drumming for the likes of Political Asylum, The Apostles, Oi Polloi and Part One from the age of 13 onwards, often bunking the train to London to hang out at various squats and anarchist centres.

In light of recent news re. the contradictory positions between wanting to raise the age of consent and lower the voting age, the idea of a young teenager travelling around the country and involving himself with adult activities such as anarchist politics and punk rock seems unfathomable today.

Most of the book are photographs taken by Low throughout the period in question and while they may not be the most sophisticated, they do capture the period and the individuals involved that not only depict their youth, but also a sense of fun and possibility, such as these two photos.


The final segment sees Low going through his archive of flyers, fanzines and propaganda with each one containing a recollection. In an era of Photoshop and AI, these cut and paste affairs hit in a way that modern tech couldn’t conceive: stark yet amateurish, funny but deadly serious and deeply political and artistic.


As a coffee table book, this is a must have for anyone vaguely interested in this period of British history.

Chris Low, 2025, Beyond the Monochrome: Photographs & Graphics from the 1980s Anarcho-Punk Underground, Lowthario Press.

 ⏩ Christopher Owens was a reviewer for Metal Ireland and finds time to study the history and inherent contradictions of Ireland. He is currently the TPQ Friday columnist and is the author of A Vortex of Securocrats and “dethrone god”.

Beyond The Monochrome

Lynx By Ten To The Power Of Two Thousand One Hundred And Fifty Nine

 

Religious Derangement Syndrome @ 25

 

A Morning Thought @ 3330

Kate Yo ✍ Yesterday afternoon we went to see McGurk's Bar Tragedy at the Waterfront Hall.


I'd never been to a play there before. Usually, plays are in the Opera House, with concerts etc in the Waterfront. However the play was obviously put together for that stage. All the characters were on the stage at all times with expert use of lighting highlighting those whose part was on. There was the Gem public house with musicians to one side - this is the venue that the bomb was originally for; McGurk's bar at the front, including the snug; the police station near McGurks; and the army barracks where Kitson trained loyalists in his methods every weekend.

I'd just finished reading Time Bomb, Irish bombs, English Justice and the Guildford Four, so the dirty tricks the army captain got up to came as no surprise. The book however together with the play merged somewhat at the end of the show when Mr McGurk's character mentioned the victims of pub bombings, and the sorrow he had for the perpetrators.

This was a very Belfast play and brought out in the banter of those regulars who frequented the bar. Jokes among the men (for there were few women and those who were allowed in were served in the snug). A group of younger women did come in, in a light hearted skit wanting equal rights but got short shrift when one of their mas turned up. 

McGurk ran a clean bar with a swear box on the counter. His brother in law worked with him and as each character came in McGurk introduced them in a sort of soliloquy, telling their names and a little bit about each of them and their circumstances. This bar was described by one police man as an old man’s pub when querying the army's false version of events. 

The bomb was meant for the Gem bar that was hosting a fund raiser for the hospice on the Somerton Road and was due to be packed that night. It was known as a Sticky bar and when the bomb exploded it was hoped major casualties would be the result and enough anger from it for the Provisionals to be blamed with hope of a bitter feud to ensue. A black op in other words, but there were too many people out front and attention would have been drawn on the bombers, Shankill Road UVF. They dumped it at the nearest bar which was McGurk's. It killed fifteen innocent civilians.

The aftermath of the bombing came after the break, with the stage set up to reflect a collapsed building with survivors telling what happened. At one funeral of a young man whose parents both died he wanted to see inside the coffins, he wanted proof they were his parents. Most of the bodies had arrived at the morgue in plastic bags, and the body in the coffin of the young man's father wasn't his father at all. Some grieving homes were raided. It ended with a reading of names:

Francis Bradley
John Colton
James Francis Cormier
Philip Garry
Kathleen Irvine
Edward Lawrence Kane
Thomas Kane
Edward Keenan
Sarah Keenan
Elizabeth Philomena McGurk
Maria McGurk
Thomas McLoughlin
David Milligan
James Patrick Smith
Robert Charles Spitwood.

The play concluded with a standing ovation.

It has sold out all performances. When it comes out again, go see it!

⏩Kate Yo is a Belfast book lover.

McGurk's Bar Tragedy

Caoimhin O’Muraile ⚽ For six decades I have had many great experiences following Manchester United FC home away and abroad . . . 

. . .  the culture on the terraces, the Magistrates on Monday morning, the Procurator Fiscal in Scotland and later when I had grown out of that phase, the piss ups minus the arrests. 

The memorable games like Barcelona 1984 in the Cup Winners Cup, having gone two goals down at the Nou Camp, which we watched with horror in that huge stadium, to that great come back in the second leg which had Old Trafford rocking as Brian Robson and Frank Stapleton tore the Catalan’s including Maradona apart, winning 3-0. The ground was rocking reminiscent of those European nights back in the sixties which when I first started going in 1969 were folklore at United, passed on and down by older generations. I watched the Holy Trinity of Best, Charlton, and Law, three Balon d Or (European Footballers of the Year) winners in one side, Denis Law 1964, Bobby Charlton 1966, and George Best 1968. Great days and fond memories including meeting the greatest manager Man Utd ever had and arguably the finest to manage in English football ever, Matt Busby. 

What Matt Busby would make of the managerial carnage which is going on now can only be imagined, less than pleased would be an understatement. Matt Busby believed football belonged to the working-class and was fiercely proud of his class upbringing, a former face worker down the pit, always reminding his players the fans ‘in the stands the people paying at the turnstiles are the ones responsible for your wages’ and ‘these guys pay your wages, and are probably more upset at the result than you are’ when the side lost. Back in 1970 he warned against the perils of what has evolved in the game today, the ‘altar of big business’ sacrificial warning. 

In 1948 Busby’s first great side built around Johnny Carey, Jimmy Delaney, Charlie Mitten, Johnny Aston (snr), and Stan Pearson with Jack Crompton in goal, lifted the coveted FA Cup defeating Blackpool by 4-2 including the legendary Stan Mathews and Stan Mortenson. In 1952 United with some youngsters blended with the 48 team still in place won the league as Busby began rebuilding his second great team, the ‘Babes’ were soon to be born. The team which became known as the ‘Busby Babes’ who lifted the First Division in 1955-56, and 1956-57 were cut down in their prime at Munich Airport on 6th February 1958. Matt Busby received the last rites of the Roman Catholic Church not once, but twice, and on his return to football management prophesised, almost to the month, it would ‘take five years’ for United to win a trophy. Five years later in May 1963 Man United defeated Leicester City 3-1 in the FA Cup Final at Wembley, the first to be played under an all-covered stadium. This was the embryo of his third great team which won the league in 1965 and again in 1967 then, the Holy Grail, the illusive European Cup which many felt Matt had been denied by the Munich tragedy. United defeated a great Benfica side which boasted Eusebio, Jaime Graca, with Hose Henrique in goal and Mario Coluna their captain.

Briefly going back to 1945 when he took the job, Matt Busby insisted he would decide on all footballing matters, who would be bought and who would be sold and they ‘would keep out of football matters’, they being the board. The Chairman, J.W. Gibson agreed to Busby’s terms though some directors were not happy. Matt Busby’s immediate success, operating from a garden shed with a bombsite as a ground he soon shut these directors up. He was never questioned again. Busby had laid the blueprint for managing Manchester United which ripped through the pre-war arrangements when the board decided who would be bought and sold, they also picked the team.

In 1977 the ‘Battle of the Giants’ played out the FA Cup Final at Wembley between Manchester United and Liverpool. United, under Tommy Docherty, hammered the scousers 2-1 ending their hopes of winning the then illusive treble. Ironically 22 years later in 1999 it would be Manchester United under the managerial stewardship of Alex Ferguson who would lift the treble consisting of the League, FA Cup, and European Cup. This treble had illuded Bill Shankly, Bob Paisley, Joe Fagan, Kenny Dalglish at Anfield but United’s second great manager, Alex Ferguson, achieved the impossible. Ferguson once vowed to ‘knock Liverpool off their fucking perch’ which in his 26 years as Man Utd Manager he did just that. Ferguson won 13 league titles, 2 European Cups, 5 FA Cups, and 4 League Cups in a total of 1,500 games. 

In 2005 an aggressive takeover took place at Old Trafford when the Glazers, Malcom Glazer, bought a majority of shares using nefarious methods at United. The fans were outraged and that anger is still present today. Ferguson, who should have stood by the fans, unfortunately did not. He told fans; ‘If you don’t like it go and watch Chelsea’, something Busby would never have uttered, Ferguson's stance over the Glazers disappointed many supporters. Ferguson claimed the Glazers were ‘good employers’ who did not ‘interfere’ with the football side. In 2013 Alex Ferguson retired after 26 years as the Manager at Old Trafford. He had just won the league for the 13th time and was going out while at the top. Could it have been, though deserving his retirement, Ferguson knew things were changing and not for the better and he was probably aware that having held back the Glazers since 2005, despite his claims about them being ‘good employers’, he would be unable to do so for ever? They were beginning to encroach on the dressing room and new positions like a Director of Football were being introduced.

It is not necessary to examine every Man Utd Manager/Head Coach since Fergie, there have now been 13 of them, so let me move on to the latest victim, Michael Carrick. Not so long ago, managing Manchester United was the most prestigious job probably in world football and now it has become, thanks to the Glazers and Jim Ratcliffe, a poison chalice. Michael took the reins after the dismissal of Ruben Amorim who lost his job after a 1-1 draw away at Leeds. After the match Amorim raged, rightly so in my view, he was ‘hired as the manager, not just the head coach’ and effectively demanded the scouting department and director of football, Jason Wilcox, ‘do their jobs’. Unfortunately for Ruben he was only the head coach despite his delusions. The last man to hold, at least on paper, the title of ‘Manager’ was Erik ten Hag though effectively he too was merely the head coach. Michael Carrick took the reins on a caretaker basis and the team’s fortunes improved dramatically. In fact if the league had started in January 2026, it would have been Man Utd and not Arsenal who would have won it! United’s first game under Carrick was against Man City in the derby. Against all expectations Man Utd took the spoils and bragging rights defeating the Blues 2-0 at Old Trafford. Then it was away to eventual champions Arsenal and again against the odds United came out victors by 2-3. Like all those since Ferguson who held the job as Man Utd manager or head coach Michael Carrick had none of the powers once held by managers like Matt Busby and Alex Ferguson. Busby had the ultimate power even above that enjoyed by Ferguson who did need the board’s approval regarding transfers because of the money involved, but the board invariably backed Fergie. Carrick had very little say over who the club bought and sold and was handed what Jason Wilcox, Director of Football, and Omar Berrada, Chief Executive Officer, delivered. 

Jason Wilcox did not deliver high-priority targets of Carrick’s: Anthony Gordon, Elliot Anderson, Mateus Fernandes, Sandro Tonali, Aurelien Tchouameni, Alex Scott and other top-class players. Despite this clown failing in his duty to go out and buy players Carrick wanted, it was Michael who got the sack for the disappointing start to the 2026/27 season. This was yet another disgraceful act by the men who run Old Trafford with Wilcox, Berrada, and Ratcliffe who had the final say meeting in Monaco to decide Michael’s fate. The very men who should be allowed nowhere near a football club were deciding the fate of an Old Trafford legend, it’s a fucking disgrace! The results this term have been disappointing but given the conditions and restraints the ‘Head Coach’ had to work under not getting the players he wanted it is difficult to see any other outcome. This is, apparently, the new model of running a football club, no manager, just a head coach with people who know fuck all about football taking charge of buying and selling players. It is akin to a Hospital Administrator carrying out open heart surgery on patients!

All the time Michael Carrick was doing his duties on the training pitch these two snakes, Wilcox and Berrada, were talking to another man about becoming the next head coach. That man now is the head coach, Mauricio Pochettino, who was in charge of the USA national men’s team. United will have to pay £7.5 million to the USA for poaching their man and also £5 million to Michael Carrick who had, and retains, the supporters' backing. The Glazers, still the majority shareholders by some distance, will take this money out of that extracted over the years by them from the club. To them this is loose change and if all goes wrong again, and all indications are not good because the same restraints will be on Pochettino as were on Carrick, they can just sack the new man. This managerial merry go round at Old Trafford has been a standing joke since Alex Ferguson retired back in 2013. Pochettino’s sanity must be called into question because he reportedly said, when offered the post, it is ‘too good an opportunity to miss’. This opportunity which in his eyes was ‘too good’ has seen 5 managers and 2 head coaches sacked in 13 years!! Is he sure?

The real problem at Old Trafford lays with the Glazers and Ratcliffe. When the INEOS boss bought a minority shareholding, 28%, he also took over the football side of the business, itself a minority piece of the overall concern. Recently Avaram Glazer removed any pretence of having the slightest interest in football when he stated; ‘clubs of United’s stature do not depend on success on the pitch to retain their commercial power’. This evidently proves football at Old Trafford is a very minor part of the business and success, once all important, is no longer the primary consideration. Glazers comments reportedly compared Manchester United with the New York Yankees and Dallas Cowboys who appear not to depend on sporting success in order to maintain commercial appeal. Man Utd are not some fucking American Wild West theme show with no other purpose than being a cash cow for the owners. It is the Glazers and Ratcliffe who have to go but how to do it? I don’t really care how they are disposed of, just when they are!!

Caoimhin O’Muraile is Independent Socialist Republican and Marxist.

Man Utd, Another Year, Another Manager ⚽ A Heart Breaking Tragedy

Lynx By Ten To The Power Of Two Thousand One Hundred And Fifty Eight

 

A Morning Thought @ 3329

Jim Duffy ✍ The Taoiseach is spot on in his lashing of Sinn Féin over their endless lies on neutrality in EEC/EC/EU referendums.
 
Years ago I went through every single Sinn Féin newspaper advert for every single referendum on Europe, from 1972 on. In Every one bar the Fiscal Treaty (and even they knew the arguments in that referendum would have made them look ridiculous) they argued the exact same things:
 
1. This will end neutrality.
2. This will bring Ireland into NATO.
3. This will see Ireland join a European Army.
4. If voters vote yes, they will be giving away their right to hold any more referendums on the EEC/EC/EU.
 
In the fifty-four years since that first referendum
 
1. Ireland remains neutral.
2. Ireland is not a member of NATO.
3. Ireland has not joined a European Army, nor does any such thing as a European Army exist.
4. Ireland continues to hold referendums on EU matters. The rules are exactly the same. If a treaty does not change EU competences no amendment to the constitution is needed as those competences have already been included in the constitution, so there is no need for a referendum.
 
If a treaty adds new competences, then a constitutional amendment is automatically required, meaning a referendum in that case is always required, and always will be required.
 
Sinn Féin is now lying by saying that ending the Triple Lock will end neutrality. That is patently absurd. Ireland declared neutrality in September 1939. The Triple Lock first appeared in the Defence Act 1960. For Sinn Fein to be correct, that would mean Ireland wasn't neutral between 1939 and 1960 when there was no triple lock. It couldn't even have existed between 1939 and 1945 as there was no UN Security Council or even a UN.
 
That is nonsensical.
 
All the government is doing is reverting to the status quo ante between 1939 and 1960, with one difference. It is increasing the number of personnel that could be on duty abroad to fifty. That is necessary as no naval vessel could carry out functions abroad under the lower threshold, as the minimum crew needed for a ship would exceed the number laid down in the 1960 Act. It would be unsafe to have a ship with such a tiny crew. The new number simply ensures ships can be safely crewed by having the minimum crew needed.
 
Every single claim made by Sinn Féin is untrue, just as every single claim made by Sinn Féin in European referendums is a lie. They would for example, brazenly trot out the lie every time that if people voted for a referendum they would be surrendering their right to ever vote again, despite the very fact that a referendum was taking place demonstrated that their claim the previous time was 100% untrue.

It is worth pointing out that no other country on the planet, including no other neutral, has a triple lock. Austria and Switzerland have both called the Triple Lock "nuts!" One Austrian politician questioned how a country that gives a veto over the use of its military to the US, Russia, France, the UK and China could even call itself independent. He said it displayed the "mindset of a colony, asking for permission."
 
The British and French vetoes are effectively dead as both stopped using theirs in December 1989. France has no intension of ever using it again as a matter of policy. It wants all vetoes abolished.
 
It is particularly absurd that in 2026 Trump, Putin and Xi have a veto over the use of Irish troops.

Ireland had to pull out of a rescue mission in the Mediterranean when Putin, as part of of his campaign against the UN, vetoed rolling over a resolution. Ireland had to withdraw. Other countries, including neutrals, continued on the mission.
 
In every other country on the planet, exclusive control of the use of the military is controlled by parliaments. Article 15.6.1. of Bunreacht na hÉireann also states that "The right to raise and maintain military or armed forces is vested exclusively in the Oireachtas." Article 28.3.1. also states that "War shall not be declared and the State shall not participate in any war save with the assent of Dáil Éireann."
 
Many constitutional lawyers have long questioned whether the Triple Lock is even constitutional, given that it allows the five veto powers to overrule a decision of the Oireachtas.
 
The sheer absurdity of the Triple Lock can be seen in the fact even if every single Irish citizen, every single member of the Government, and every member of the Oireachtas supported a mission, Donald Trump could override them and veto it. That is an absurdity.

⏩ Jim Duffy is a writer-historian.

Triple Lock 🪶 Sinn Fein Lying

Louth For Ever ★ writing in Medium November-2026.

A friendly reply to our comrade Muiris Ó Súilleabháin — and a case for where the actual votes are sitting.

What the Figures Really Establish

A few weeks ago, Muiris’ article ‘The Fragmentation Of Unionism And The Illusion Of Republican Progress’ did something that has become unfashionable in this debate: it looked beyond the headline statistic to ask what actually sits underneath it. Muiris wrote that unionist fragmentation “has not translated into any sustained increase in support for Irish unity since the signing of the Good Friday Agreement in 1998.” Worth testing against the record, since most of what follows agrees with him. It is correct that polls and elections are not measuring the same thing, and it is also right that no one should be permitted to fuse them into a single number and declare the matter closed. 

Where I part company is in treating that warning as a basis for distrusting the polling itself. LucidTalk (@lucidtalk.bsky.social) pinned the 2022 Assembly election vote shares to within 1.1%, and has predicted every Northern Ireland election since 2015 within a few points, including the EU referendum. Whatever else may be wrong with using a survey as though it were a ballot, “the pollsters are guessing” is not a viable criticism, at least not against that track record.

Still, that record of accuracy cannot resolve the constitutional issue itself, because there has never been an actual vote on that question to compare it against. The pollster has plainly proved dependable on the matter it has been tested against. The issue that really counts remains untested, for the moment, in the only way that would finally settle it. That is something worth pausing on rather than hurrying past.

What the election record does establish, is this. Sinn Féin and the SDLP won 39.6% in 1998. In 2022, they won 38.1%. That’s the 24 years we’re talking about here. In Belfast, unionism shed seven council seats from 2014 to 2023; nationalism added precisely one. The ballot box is changing far more slowly than the polls, and that is not because the polls are mistaken. Elections and referendums pose different questions, and that difference cuts in both directions: a steady nationalist vote share does not show that support for unity has plateaued, just as a declining DUP vote share does not demonstrate that the Union is weakening. I suspect Muiris would be more ready than most to accept that extension of the reasoning.

The Ceiling, in Model Form

None of that undermines the point Muiris made from the outset, and it is the part of his analysis I think will endure longest. Unionism can lose and still preserve the Union. Sinn Féin can win and still fail to deliver unity. This week’s polling, when run through a proper seat model, demonstrates the mechanism his argument was reaching for instead of merely stating it.

The DUP and TUV are level on first preference vote share, and both trail the UUP. Using the same poll, the ‘Salmon Of Data’, Peter Donaghy’s (@peterdonaghy.bsky.social) probability model places the nationalist bloc on 40.9 seats and unionism on 38.5, out of 90, with the remaining 10.5 split between Alliance and the Greens. That is a genuine nationalist seat lead, but only a slight one, and the psephologist’s own warning is important to preserve honestly: many of the DUP-TUV marginals are “impossible to call,” so that exact division could swing either way with a small turnout change.

If you run the median case, Sinn Féin reaches 31 seats, up four, while the DUP falls to 14, down eleven, and TUV climbs to 13, up twelve, close enough to exchange places as the larger unionist party after the next bad week. Now place the formula that actually distributes ministries against that same projected increase. 27 seats versus 31 earns Sinn Féin nothing extra: four ministries out of ten, exactly what it holds now, because d’Hondt reduces a party’s claim according to the number of posts it has already secured, and a party already near the front of the order sees sharply diminishing returns from adding more. A larger mandate. The same executive. That is the ceiling Muiris identified, and it remains in place whether one looks at the trust poll, the vote share, or the seat model.

Donaghy also tested the scenario unionists have been quietly talking about for two years: a single merged unionist party in place of the DUP, UUP and TUV. It would “definitely” be the biggest individual party, at 39.5%. Yet the bloc totals hardly shift: nationalist 40.1 versus combined unionist 40.0, a difference of one tenth of a seat, down from roughly two and a half. A merger fixes the appearance and changes almost nothing about the numbers. If Sinn Féin’s ceiling is this restrictive even while winning, then unionism’s floor is this low even while losing, and even while fully united. Muiris’ instinct that electoral strength and constitutional power have drifted apart turns out to be true on both sides at once, more completely than his own article demonstrated.

What Neither Indicator Settles

Three quarters of unionists say they could not accept a pro-unity outcome, no matter what process produced it. Eight in ten DUP voters say so. Among TUV voters, the figure is closer to nine in ten. That is not a question of preference. It is a statement about consequence, and it means many people on the losing side of this issue have already made clear that a democratic defeat will not settle it for them.

Where the Votes Really Sit

The illusion isn’t that Sinn Féin’s progress is real, it’s that nationalism’s own electorate is where a majority will come from. Here is the argument, and I do not think either of us had fully assembled it before this week.

The republican & nationalist bloc is not expanding. It was 39.6% in 1998 and 38.1% in 2022. Sinn Féin’s growth has come almost entirely from the SDLP rather than from fresh ground, and Donaghy’s own seat model shows the same limit in projected form: four ministries either side of a four seat gain. A border poll fought on the current nationalist coalition does not win. Muiris has already shown that, and I think it is the most important thing either of us has written about this all year.

So the real movement is elsewhere, and the model shows where it is headed. Among voters who have decided, Alliance and Green supporters now back unity over the Union by roughly two to one, and 56% want a border poll within the next decade. Donaghy’s median case has Alliance losing ten of its seventeen seats, the steepest proportional decline of any party in the projection, even greater than the DUP’s. His own unprompted interpretation is that this may be “a post Drumcree effect with the declining centre ground,” with the middle being squeezed as the poles harden. If that is right, then the bloc containing the voters this movement needs is being pulled apart by the same polarisation everyone is watching elsewhere in the DUP, yet almost nobody is discussing it.

I am not asking Alliance to endorse unity. Their neutrality is not hesitation; it is the entire product. Naomi Long has said that sitting out a referendum campaign “might make sense,” cast as a matter of individual conscience rather than party discipline, and that is exactly why the party can draw from both traditions at once. Force a declaration and you do not clarify Alliance; you end it, and you probably drive its soft unionist third back toward the UUP. Nor is that the cause of their recent polling decline. That is incumbency fatigue, a leader whose ratings have softened after another rocky term in office, and the Greens and PBP taking bites out of the left while Drumcree dominated the news cycle. I am not going to invent a better narrative where an accurate one already exists, and Muiris, of all people, is the last person who would thank me for trying.

What I am saying is this: a party whose own voters lean two to one toward unity, while the party officially aligns with neither side and is currently losing seats in both directions at once, is holding a gap it may never close. It does not need to close it. The voters in that gap do not need Alliance’s permission. They are already counted, and Donaghy’s own model is already showing where they are dispersing. The strategic mistake has been to watch DUP collapse and call that the story, when DUP collapse merely redistributes a bloc that was never going to yield a majority on its own. The route to one runs through people who presently vote Alliance, not through squeezing a nationalist vote that peaked before the ‘Millenial’ generation of voters was able to cast one.

I want this poll won the first time it is held. The Agreement permits a second attempt seven years after a loss, which is a mercy and a trap in the same clause, because any movement that can survive defeat will plan for it. There should not need to be a second attempt. The votes for the first one are not waiting inside the nationalist electorate. They sit inside a party that has spent fifty years defining itself by refusing to say where it stands — The Alliance Party — and the model says that party is breaking apart faster than the one everyone has been watching. That is not a reason to leave it alone. It is the reason not to. Muiris’ piece led me to the right numbers. I just think they point somewhere he has not yet named, and I suspect he will arrive there before I do next time.

Sources & References

Muiris Ó Súilleabháin, “The Fragmentation Of Unionism And The Illusion Of Republican Progress,” The Pensive Quill, 31st October 2026.

LucidTalk polling for the Belfast Telegraph, fieldwork 29–31 October 2026, 3,989 respondents — the largest poll held in Northern Ireland to date. Figures on unionist leader trust, party vote share, and attitudes to a pro-unity referendum result are drawn from this release, reported by Suzanne Breen, Belfast Telegraph.

LucidTalk, lucidtalk.co.uk — forecasting accuracy record, including the 2022 Northern Ireland Assembly election vote share forecast (to within 1.1%) and election forecasts since 2015.

Peter Donaghy, Salmon of Data (salmonofdata.com), seat projections and scenario modelling built on the above poll, including the probability range projection, the median scenario seat chart, and the hypothetical combined unionist party scenario. Also shared directly via his Bluesky account, @peterdonaghy.bsky.social.

1998 Northern Ireland Assembly election and 2022 Northern Ireland Assembly election results, Northern Ireland Assembly / ARK.

2014 and 2023 Belfast City Council election results.

Naomi Long MLA, on Alliance’s position regarding a future referendum campaign, reported by the News Letter and the Irish News.

⏩Louth For Ever writes on Irish politics and constitutional change. Follow for analysis of Ireland’s democratic future as it’s constructed by those actually engaged in the work.

The Illusion Isn’t The One Named 🪶 The Nationalist Vote Hasn’t Grown in 24 Years 🪶 Somebody Else’s Has